Australian Knife Laws
-
@damiross said:
With all of the knife restrictions and gun laws, I do believe the state and federal governments in Australia have eliminated all violent crimes in Australia.Most of the laws I can live with, although its getting so that even taking a deep breath is a crime in Australia.
But fortunately, the majority of "Authority" figures have at least some semblance of common sense and logic.
For example, the water authority in Australia is called Maritime Authority cops a load of flack from boaters.
But in 99% of cases, its the boaters that dont know the rules and often break them.
Most of these rules are logic based and if ignored can lead to serious accidents and death.
But as a regular boater, I find their occasional review of my "Mandatory" gear polite and informed.
Even the one I had let my life jacket inspection miss by a couple of months, it was only a " better see to that" not a fine.Most general duties cops have been polite and easy to get on with, although there have been exceptions.
I'm putting the whole incident down to "having a bad day" for the cops.
But be aware that the cops in Australia seem to be less tolerant, less obliging and less personable than any I have met in just about every other country I have visited. -
@Valkie said:
Most general duties cops have been polite and easy to get on with, although there have been exceptions.I'm putting the whole incident down to "having a bad day" for the cops.
But be aware that the cops in Australia seem to be less tolerant, less obliging and less personable than any I have met in just about every other country I have visited.I have zero problems with Aussie cops, but admittedly these days I don't give them any reasons to single me out for special attention. The last few decades it has only been random roadside breath tests, and as I don't drink (nor do I look like someone that might take drugs) all my interactions have been very smooth and easy. When I was young and foolish (don't they always seem to go together ?) my speeding did sometimes attract unwanted attention.
-
Here in Norway I think the actual practice has become more restrictive the latter years. There is blanket bans for certain types of knives and the like which are deemed to have no civil purpose, but for the rest it should be enough with a good reason for the carry.
However, while it used to be add-on charges, or used against people who clearly had no sensible cause for carrying a knife (self-defense not being one), these days some police seem to have lost the plot. From the top of my head I can remember reading about people being fined for having a knife in their car, workers not removing their knifes from their tool belts before having lunch in public, and my favourite the man using a multitool in public to slice an apple.
The latter is my favourite as he refused to accept any fine and took it all the way to the court - and he won! So while some police might have lost their way at least some judges still care to use common sense as per premise of the law.
(I'm old enough to remember the time when a fair chunk of the population were issued and stored automatic assault rifles, submachine guns, and some even bigger stuff at home. The world is certainly changing as knives now seem to be the new redline..)
-
Its always interesting to hear about experiences outside of California. I used to think our laws were pretty restrictive here in my city. When I began to carry a dedicated knife I looked into the laws and did/do my best to adhere. My partners son is LEO as well as many friends of mine. I say this because each LEO will bring to the job their personality. That said, I am of the belief courtesy is always our best foot forward in any dealings with LEO. I have never been subject of search nor do I expect I will tho one never knows.
If we know the laws of our jurisdiction and choose to carry contrary to it, we then could face consequences. I'm also of the belief the "fight" is not with the boots on the ground but further up the "ladder". I am trying to stay on the outskirts of a political conversation but y'all know what I am saying.
Any energy spent in my opinion should be spent on rallying for changes where it really matters. I have read about cases here in California where people have chose to challenge those boots on the ground ( by carrying a certain knife ) and then taking on the courts and winning. Thats a cost I cannot afford financially. I applaud those who can. Truth is tho, it made little difference in the law written. Not sure how that works tho?
Whats unfortunate to me are those who vilify the tool rather than the person who uses the tool for bad purposes.
This topic is a hard one for me. As someone who enjoys carrying multiple sharps I'd be saddened if that was taken or strongly restricted.
Thank you all who have posted.
-
@Aloha said:
I'm also of the belief the "fight" is not with the boots on the ground but further up the "ladder".Depends on how the law is formulated. Over here the law requires the boots on the ground to make a judgement call. And I think that judgement has changed over the years. Here the law itself hasn't changed so that can't be the reason for the stricter policy - rather it seems like a wanted reinterpretation of that law by the boots or higher ups. But here that reinterpretation has not been done by the politicians as the law is unchanged. Thus people have to turn to the courts to have them draw the lines for where the room for reinterpretation stops.
@Aloha said:
I have read about cases here in California where people have chose to challenge those boots on the ground ( by carrying a certain knife ) and then taking on the courts and winning. Thats a cost I cannot afford financially. I applaud those who can. Truth is tho, it made little difference in the law written. Not sure how that works tho?When people are winning over the boots on the ground in court that means the people was within their rights and that the boots judgement and interpretation of the law was wrong. Over here at least that should lead to the police adjusting their understanding and policy to be in line with the courts officially given interpretation.
-
Sadly these laws have absolutely nothing to do with public safety or criminal activity, they are 100% to have total and complete control of YOU. I feel sad for yall as an American with rights to bear arms. Honestly if I lived in Australia I'd be getting my passport together to leave and move to America.
I seen what they did to yall a couple years ago.... they never tried that here. Sadly the brits fell down the same path, you cannot give them an inch or they'll take it all and you'll quickly look like Australia.
Nothing against you guys that live there, my empathy is with you.
*Distasteful and politcal comment removed
-
Anymore politcal comments and this thread will be locked.
-
Vidar
. Such a tough conversation to be had without myself stepping over the line. I appreciate your response.I am not above adhering to MTOs no politics talk.
-
@Elevatorman said:
Sadly these laws have absolutely nothing to do with public safety or criminal activity, they are 100% to have total and complete control of YOU. I feel sad for yall as an American with rights to bear arms. Honestly if I lived in Australia I'd be getting my passport together to leave and move to America.I seen what they did to yall a couple years ago.... they never tried that here. Sadly the brits fell down the same path, you cannot give them an inch or they'll take it all and you'll quickly look like Australia.
Nothing against you guys that live there, my empathy is with you.
*Distasteful and politcal comment removed
Ah, but you don't live in Australia though do you, so I don't imagine your opinion on what it is like to live there is worth much 8)
-
@damiross said:
My God! Why do they even allow you in public? :ahhhThey don't have any choice.
I'm still working so If they stop me, I can't work and their taxes are gone.Went into Sydney the other day, on the train.
A guy got on with a large bag that looked quite heavy.
He was stopped at Circular Quay, where I got off, they checked his bag, it was full of tools.
He was allowed to go with no further comment, I recon I could do more damage with his tools than my pocket knife. -
Without getting all political and ranting as I have a proclivity to do.
I'm not a criminal.
I don't want to carry nasty, huge or fighting knives.
I have no need for a weapon to protect myself.
all I want is to be able to carry a useful tool when and where I want .As a boy scout 40 something years ago, we all carried pocket knives.
Dad always had a knife on hand.
As I progressed through Venturers and Rovers, went bush a lot, hunting, hiking and just enjoying camping.
I always had some sort of knife.
It was an accepted practice to have a sharp knife on hand as it is so useful for so many things.
These new Multitools are even better (I wish they had been around 40 years ago)I still carry "openly" my multitool when working for marine rescue, every sensible sailor has a knife.
I have used it many times in helping people and even saving a life
I also "openly" carry at work and also use it daily, more so cutting fruit than anything else lately.
When caravaning I have a multitool tucked away somewhere on me or in my bag, again, most helpful in a situation where a knife, pliers or screwdriver is needed in a hurry.But everywhere else, I just have an empty sheath or nothing, often missing my handy tool.
I heard recently that a multitool even without a knife is now classed as a weapon, I haven't verified that yet, but I do know a screwdriver is.
My walking cane is ok...for now, but how soon before that also becomes a "weapon"?
And what about my wife's 14-pound purse with all its accoutrements...a weapon? I think so, I've been hit with it.
Its getting sad, but that's the way it is, and I can't change it.
Perhaps one day, things will get more sensible.
But as long as we have idiots running around with machete and stabbing people with kitchen knives.
Small harmless pocketknives will alwyas be a soft target. -
@Valkie said:
Its getting sad, but that's the way it is, and I can't change it.
Perhaps one day, things will get more sensible.
But as long as we have idiots running around with machete and stabbing people with kitchen knives.
Small harmless pocketknives will alwyas be a soft target.Unfortunately things have changed a lot from the "old days".
In the past very few people went around carrying a knife as a weapon and not many people were harmed by knives.
These days there is quite a lot of of (mostly younger) people who do carry a knife and are willing to use them as a weapon, so politicians and police have responded to this perceived threat to public order.
Which is where we are nowadays. I don't like it either, but I can't see us going back to how things once were, with police willing and able to apply common sense. -
Laws are used by the police at thier discretion.
I had a few young cops give me a car search the other day, for having resting crim face, they asked if I had any weapons...I was honest and said there was a folder in my pocket, and likely a multitool in my bag....they didn't bat an eye or even ask about it. If you treat or talk about a knife as weapon, they will see it as a weapon and act accordingly. -
@Elasmonut said:
Laws are used by the police at thier discretion.
I had a few young cops give me a car search the other day, for having resting crim face, they asked if I had any weapons...I was honest and said there was a folder in my pocket, and likely a multitool in my bag....they didn't bat an eye or even ask about it. If you treat or talk about a knife as weapon, they will see it as a weapon and act accordingly.I believe, like you, that attitude has a lot to do with how things go.
aggressive is matched with aggressive, and because these guys have guns, "you should never bring a knife to a gunfight"The funny thing is that when wearing my rescue uniform, I wear my multitool openly and very visibly (for ease of access if I need it)
I have worked with police, other rescue personnel and even border and federal police in the course of my duties while being equipped.
The only time my Multitool has been mentioned was when a border officer noted that I had a Victornox multitool , as he had never seen one close up.
We discussed his Leatherman and my Victornox tools at length (while waiting for "something")
We discussed how and what we have used them for, never once was the "weapon" word used.Why cant this level of innocence be assumed by all in our daily lives?
Surprisingly, he also carried an illegal spring-loaded knife, apparently not unusual I was advised.
But then, he also carried several other tools including torches and lighter, even though he didn't smoke.I realise that knife crime is becoming a problem,
I also realise that the grubberment has to be seen to doing something about it.
but the existing laws were adequate, if only they were enforced, rather than making it illegal to carry such a useful tool.England has become more sensible with some relaxation of their carry laws.
Perhaps one day, Australia will too............ -
Australia has had a couple of deranged people wandering around attacking people over the last few weeks.
All of them have been mentally ill or belong to a gang and attacking each other.
You will all be aware of the Bondi attacks, it made the news all over the world.But I stress, this attack and the one on the Christian preacher were done by mentally ill people, not ordinary people.
If they didnt have a knife they would have used something else
And the Bondi attacker was using a huge carving knife, not a multitool or pocket knife.So, the response by the Australian grubberment?
Not to provide better mental health care (sadly lacking and in desperate need)
BOTH ATTACKERS HAD BEEN UNDER YEARS OF MENTAL HEALTH TREATMENT, WHICH WAS OBVIOUSLY NOT WORKING.They are introducing new laws and tightening up their powers to search "ANYONE"., "anywhere", "anytime" without any cause or reason.
Recent "knee Jerk" reaction was to start using metal detectors everywhere and they are having a field day.So, I guess the death knell of carrying even a tiny Victornox classic has been rung.
No Australian may now carry anything without being potentially charged for carrying a "WEAPON".The next stage will be that all food will have to be sold in bite sized pieces and all household knives confiscated, because you will no longer need or be allowed to have them.
Tradesmen will have to register all tools with serial numbers and carry authorization to use them.
All tools will need to be stored in locked cabinets when not being used.Its so sad.
-
Indeed

-
@Valkie said:
Tradesmen will have to register all tools with serial numbers and carry authorization to use them.We actually had a case here some years ago where 2 carpenters got fined for wearing knives in public. They had walked to a nearby cafe for lunch without stripping off the knives from their tool holding clothing. It was recogniced that the knives were for work and that they had the required civil use of the knives, but the lunch break was not considered work. Not sure how that would go down in Australia, but to me that fine was a lack of common sense.
I can only say that under current laws lots of what I and others did when we were younger would be illegal today. And yet, I'm pretty sure there are more stabbings today than back then. There is certainly a problem somewhere, but restricting knife access seems to be going after the sympoms instead of actual underlaying causes.
-
Valkie is a being slightly histrionic with the serialised paint scrapers - but yes broadly australian state governments take big leaps with laws after every incident.
What's more frustrating is the populist methods - a politician will stand in the house of representatives and make a statement along the lines of "There is no reason a lawful person should have a knife on public transport!"
and everyone cheers "here! here!"
but...that's not true is it?
Some people catch the train to work, and they might have a lawful reason for a knife - tradies, chefs, students (who need to eat lunch, but do not have access to a "staff room" at their place of education), backpackers (tourism is one of our major exports....and any sensible traveler has a knife).
There's actually a bunch of lawful reasons why someone could have a knife...
but even that 45 seconds of desktop analysis is not conducted when it comes to driving legislative change in the wake of traumatic news story.
Without getting too into the political weeds - as a sort of "cultural explanation" for interested parties - the Australian States (Less the territories, because they are the "fun states" and generally have the least restrictive laws, not just in terms of knives, but for everything) - basically operate on a "who can be seen to be doing the most policing" platform - so every year they "tighten up" a Law about something or another to ensure they are "delivering safety". Then the other states find out, and "tighten up" their laws to "Bring them into alignment with other states" and so on....
So, obvious Knife Laws is a subject near and dear to the hearts of members here, in context, it might be worth considering that Australian states have on-the-spot fines for loitering, jaywalking, and even swearing.
For your safety.
-
@Vidar said:
We actually had a case here some years ago where 2 carpenters got fined for wearing knives in public. They had walked to a nearby cafe for lunch without stripping off the knives from their tool holding clothing. It was recogniced that the knives were for work and that they had the required civil use of the knives, but the lunch break was not considered work. Not sure how that would go down in Australia, but to me that fine was a lack of common sense.I can only say that under current laws lots of what I and others did when we were younger would be illegal today. And yet, I'm pretty sure there are more stabbings today than back then. There is certainly a problem somewhere, but restricting knife access seems to be going after the sympoms instead of actual underlaying causes.
Exactly my point.
although I was slightly less eloquent about it.Its not the knives that are the problem, its the people that use them and the weak stance against criminals we have.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login