Tools or Toys?
-
I’ve been wanting to post this video before, but I wasn’t sure how to best communicate this without offending anyone. Mods, feel free to take this down if I’ve broken any rules.
https://youtu.be/V9RH-eEifn0?si=y9k8D8vnBjT2-Gdn
But what struck me the most, was that a single MT or SAK would have completed most of the challenges. But instead there was a lot of searching thru their pockets or backpacks for another tool, or improvs.
Some of the improvs were intentional, though at least one was using the pliers all wrong.
Again not trying to single out the folks, in fact I commend them all for trying. But for me at least it’s a reflection of my EDC journey. I started off with a simple SAK or LM with flashlight, progressed to pocket jewelry, realized how useless most of it was and went back to a simple functional carry. The only bling I have won’t kill me. At the most a folder with a super steel but is not my primary knife. When I ran their Prep exercise through my head my MT and flashlight would have finished most of the challenges.
What do you all think?
-
I’m also thinking that a modified SAK would done all of those challenges (except flashlight?) Maybe a Mechanic with plus scales?
-
I like Zac in the Wild. Good Youtube channel.
Yeah, there is a spectrum of utility on one end and feeling good on the other. For me, mostly feeling good. Much of the fun is being prepared, and then on occasion having what you need to make things easier or save the day. I don't really "need" the stuff I carry, but it does make life a little easier. And its a fun "hobby" that you can do pretty much every waking moment.
At a minimum, I want a gun, light, SAK, phone and mini Sharpie on me every day. More stuff, like an MT or Knipex Cobra/Pliers Wrench is another layer of fun, but those things are very rarely used. Still, I carry them often in addition to my core goodies.

Gratuitous pic. -
She’s a Beauty for sure. Nice tool.
Yeah I wish I could carry a gun. Los Angeles, CA has like the most stringent concealed carry process. I gave up long time ago. Enjoy it now!!!
-
I first started with a sak that my grandfather gave me, but I then bought my first multitool in high school, my trade kinda required pliers, and one day I was on my way to the docs and my throttle cable got screwed up, the spring vanished so it stayed open, so of course my engine was not slowing down I had to keep both feet on the break when I got off the highway, then turned the engine off when I got to the docs and rolled it through the parking lot, the engine had to cool down but it was finally cool enough by the time my appointment was over, luckily I had a click pen and used my multitool to bend it to make it work, ever since I always carried a tool, till I got my own vehicle and would carry a full toolbox, but my field of trade kinda required a multitool, so no mater what I would have one and a flashlight, but since I no longer work due to medical I kinda switched things up, I really don’t need pliers so I went back to sak’s, and on the keychain I carry a mini flashlight, let alone a mini roll of duct tape, heck in the wallet I even have a mini first aid kit, all it is is two alcohol wipes along with two diff size bandages, but that’s my minimal, if I’m going to be out besides just shopping, then the mini backpack comes and that has all sorts of stuff, a full size first aid kit, 55gal bags that can be made into ponchos or used with duct tape to make a mini tent, and other junk, but normally I just need my keys and my sak, by my code I don’t leave home without them! As far as tool or toy, it all depends on what you have and have to use it for, something small it’s a tool, but something large then that tool just got made into a “mini tool” which in my book is a toy, but might get the job done in time..
JR -
Cool story! Glad all turned out well.
Yeah, same with me as I have gotten older my needs have simplified. I mostly carry a Cadet as it satisfies most of my needs. But a LM will rotate in once in a while as I do love them.
When I was working in warehouses nothing short of a LM would be carried. Even when I started working in an office I carried an LM when my son was a baby. Now that he is needing me less growing up I carry the Cadet and keep the MT in the car. Less scary to people when I open a package or use the drivers.
You Sir are prepared and will most likely survive their test!
-
Thanks, yet ever since joining the forum I learned other things, I also got my first alox, and found out sak’s can be customized, I originally had a custom alox made with all the tools I wanted and none that I didn’t need, which was perfect, I then took a compact myself and switched out the corkscrew for a Philips, and added a saw layer, which pretty much made the most simple and perfect sak in my book, yet I really liked the alox and when the FarmerX came out it’s been my edc ever since, perfect with a leather sheath with a steel,, and when a sak is perfect it’s more of a tool then a toy,, in my opinion,,
JR -
I have a few thoughts on this, and some are contradictory because that's the way my scattershot brain works.
1- I agree, a good SAK or multitool, paried with an EDC pen and flashlight would have accomplished the whole thing. IN fact, a teeny SAK like the Midnight Manager or Midnight MiniChamp would have accomplished almost all of it without having to go any further than your keychain.

2- Most of these guys are rummaging around in their pockets fro different tools- if you are going to have a dozen different tools on you, why not carry a basic tool kit rather than a collection of relatively ineffective tools? Let's face it, a multitool is a compromise- it is way more convenient to do light duty jobs with a multitool than it is to go to your toolbox in the garage, basement or car, but it won't turn screws as a dedicated screwdriver, it won't cut as well as a dedicated knife, it won't saw as well as a dedicated saw etc. So if you are carrying three multitools and a pair of Knipex pliers, then why not just carry a small, light duty toolkit?
3- One guy stopped at cutting the wire because he didn't have wire cutters and said he didn't want to damage his blade. I may be wrong, but it looked like relatively soft wire, probably copper to me. a thin copper wire shouldn't damage a properly heat treated steel blade. Even if it isn't copper, it still bent easily enough, so I'd try my fancy steel blade on it anyway.
4- There was a #4 but I spent so much time giving a back story that I forgot what the point was. If I recall what I wanted to say I will add it again.

Def
-
That was fun to watch but that one guy telling they broked pry tool on Wave ( that got me really irritated) Wave doesnt have prytool its medium screwdriver. Even if it was prytool its maybe worst prytool ever invented.

Basicly this kit would clean whole table with no real effort and all those would fit easily with me. Pencil because they didnt mentioned that it needed to be ballpoint pen.
Only Tools Matters
-
I think the idea is interesting, and my first thought was “why hasn’t anyone done this before?” Maybe there’s a magazine or catalog article somewhere I’m not aware of.
It looks to me like a challenge designed for a Wave or Arc with bits. And if I was there, with preparedness in mind for traveling, I would likely have my Wave and some bits.
The point of the video is clicks, likes, views, for the sponsors and ads. It’s common MT uses we might find in daily light use (except that large rope I guess unless you’re on boat?). But, if we’re really asking about preparedness… I would’ve liked to see some wire stripping or filing or sawing. What about the can opener? Who of us alway says I’ve used a can opener few times in years?
The dual bolt was an interesting part. A pocketwrench would solve that.
Just my two cents.
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
2- Most of these guys are rummaging around in their pockets fro different tools- if you are going to have a dozen different tools on you, why not carry a basic tool kit rather than a collection of relatively ineffective tools? Let's face it, a multitool is a compromise- it is way more convenient to do light duty jobs with a multitool than it is to go to your toolbox in the garage, basement or car, but it won't turn screws as a dedicated screwdriver, it won't cut as well as a dedicated knife, it won't saw as well as a dedicated saw etc. So if you are carrying three multitools and a pair of Knipex pliers, then why not just carry a small, light duty toolkit?On point 2, exactly! Sometimes I like to test the limit of my MTs but there are surprisingly a lot of times I can get by with one. Earlier this week I had to make a foot for this tower stand thing my kids use to reach the counter. We have extra wood in the garage, and some hand tools and a jig saw, but I wanted an arm workout. It didn’t take that long and it’s rough but does the job. I could’ve done it without the “real” tools. I functioned more or less the same the last 2 years while living in a rental and stuff in storage. Obviously there’s a limit, but I like using my MTs for as much as I can.
@Antti Lammi said:
That was fun to watch but that one guy telling they broked pry tool on Wave ( that got me really irritated) Wave doesnt have prytool its medium screwdriver. Even if it was prytool its maybe worst prytool ever invented.
Basicly this kit would clean whole table with no real effort and all those would fit easily with me. Pencil because they didnt mentioned that it needed to be ballpoint pen.
Only Tools Matters
You would’ve won and not weighed down!
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
1- I agree, a good SAK or multitool, paried with an EDC pen and flashlight would have accomplished the whole thing. IN fact, a teeny SAK like the Midnight Manager or Midnight MiniChamp would have accomplished almost all of it without having to go any further than your keychain.
I had the same thought! Just wasn’t sure as I’ve never had a MM or the MMC.
You all bring in good pragmatic points. It was cool seeing what people carried. Just seemed like it was overly complicated.
-
By the way I watched the other video of Zac’s partner where they did the same test with different people. Same story. I only linked Zac’s cause I do like his content so far. Has not crossed all the way yet to the Dark side of capitalism.
-
@powernoodle said:
I like Zac in the Wild. Good Youtube channel.Yeah, there is a spectrum of utility on one end and feeling good on the other. For me, mostly feeling good. Much of the fun is being prepared, and then on occasion having what you need to make things easier or save the day. I don't really "need" the stuff I carry, but it does make life a little easier. And its a fun "hobby" that you can do pretty much every waking moment.
At a minimum, I want a gun, light, SAK, phone and mini Sharpie on me every day. More stuff, like an MT or Knipex Cobra/Pliers Wrench is another layer of fun, but those things are very rarely used. Still, I carry them often in addition to my core goodies.

Gratuitous pic.

I awlso want a gun in my EDC (we're lucky if we can get away with the SAK & stuff ::))
-
I’ve been meaning to get a .22 rifle. A friend of mine brought his and they are a lot of fun to go plinking around.
-
@Old Boy said:
I’ve been meaning to get a .22 rifle. A friend of mine brought his and they are a lot of fun to go plinking around.Absolutely the best! I got my first when I joined the rifle team, amazingly my uncle who was a sniper found one at a tag sale and gave it to me for a first rifle, it was pretty bad but I sanded the stock and refinished it then blued the rest, it’s a Remington pump action, just simple iron sights but I hit a soda can with every shot at 150ft, I then got a pretty beat up sears which is an automatic with a scope, so I refinished it and also came out like new..sorry couldn’t find any pics and their buried in the attic, but .22’s totally great, quiet, and cheap, ammo..
JR -
I think what got to me was how people were carrying around a lot of "stuff" but not so much that was very useful and more than that, when they did have the right tool how inexperienced they seemed to be with it (like the broken LM pry tool :D ). I try to never discourage someone who is inexperienced and learning but it was a bit eye opening about the "community" as a whole and where many people seem to have their focus. Those tasks seemed quite basic and to have people who are so "into" it struggle to find the right implements was interesting.
For me one of the more interesting parts of carrying handy tools for both known and unexpected situations is learning how to use each tool in creative ways and learning the limits of each bit and thus minimizing what I have to have on me. A tool carries a measure of innate utility on its own but in the hands of a master the same tool can be noticeably more practical. Of course in the video the guys are being filmed and facing unexpected situations which might fluster some.
I carry what I do with a focus on speeding up everyday tasks, lowering the barrier to taking care of tasks that would otherwise be left for the indeterminate "someday" and I suppose there is some factor of just liking different tools and appreciating the engineering behind them. I am definitely a function over form guy when it comes to EDC and I try to keep a balance between not carrying anything that I won't need often and having enough on me to face even some unexpected situations. There have been quite a few times where the small implements of a multitool have been the best tool I have for certain situations because of the size, convenience or lack of a specific full sized tool.
Considering minimizing my carry and maximizing my utility a gun for me would be the thing I would use the least and take up almost the most space on my person - it doesn't come close to being a practical tool in any context for me personally. My edc has changed based on my environment, context, work etc... and changes throughout the seasons so that's just me.
-
@customod said:
I think what got to me was how people were carrying around a lot of "stuff" but not so much that was very useful and more than that, when they did have the right tool how inexperienced they seemed to be with it (like the broken LM pry tool :D ). I try to never discourage someone who is inexperienced and learning but it was a bit eye opening about the "community" as a whole and where many people seem to have their focus. Those tasks seemed quite basic and to have people who are so "into" it struggle to find the right implements was interesting.For me one of the more interesting parts of carrying handy tools for both known and unexpected situations is learning how to use each tool in creative ways and learning the limits of each bit and thus minimizing what I have to have on me. A tool carries a measure of innate utility on its own but in the hands of a master the same tool can be noticeably more practical. Of course in the video the guys are being filmed and facing unexpected situations which might fluster some.
I carry what I do with a focus on speeding up everyday tasks, lowering the barrier to taking care of tasks that would otherwise be left for the indeterminate "someday" and I suppose there is some factor of just liking different tools and appreciating the engineering behind them. I am definitely a function over form guy when it comes to EDC and I try to keep a balance between not carrying anything that I won't need often and having enough on me to face even some unexpected situations. There have been quite a few times where the small implements of a multitool have been the best tool I have for certain situations because of the size, convenience or lack of a specific full sized tool.
Considering minimizing my carry and maximizing my utility a gun for me would be the thing I would use the least and take up almost the most space on my person - it doesn't come close to being a practical tool in any context for me personally. My edc has changed based on my environment, context, work etc... and changes throughout the seasons so that's just me.
Like you said carry really depends on situations, i dont carry home same set im carrying at work or when i go to hiking. Few things might be same but still mainly diffrent.
Only Tools Matters
-
Good thread.
After over a decade of playing the EDC game (and spending lots of money) I realized that a SAK, small flashlight, and a pen covered my edc needs very well. Not to mention, only around $100 (less not many years past), and I didn’t need 26 pockets to carry them.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
I've seen this video a few days ago and thought it was time someone "tested" edc-ers. I thought the tests were fun. PW and MT combo would have crushed these tests. That said, I don't carry a full size MT tho I do carry a PW.
I think the first fella did good minus the pen and light. Which to me shows a MT is more than enough for such tasks. It also reminds me that I carry what I carry NOT to solve EVERYTHING I come across but to help in my day to day when away from my vehicle or far from it.
Cut, light, write, turn, pry, and grab. For me this is accomplished by a Traditional folder, AAA light, pen, PW, and Squirt. If I cannot get by with these then thats ok. I also carry a midnight manager which I tend to forget about since I've carried a manager now for years and years.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




