SAK-A-Like and/or off brand challenge for December?
-
@nate j said:
Day 23The main clip blade is my “clean” blade on this knife, being reserved for cigars, food, and any other tasks where its extra length and or more acute point provide an advantage.
It easily trimmed this cigar.
Enjoying following this one. I have a few "regular" Rough Ryders, and they're decent enough. How much of an upgrade would you say the Reserve line is?
-
Day 21
Merry Christmas! Used the Armbars knife to open presents, got a new screwdriver for my knives and a nifty gadget one.

Sent from my SM-G996U using Tapatalk
-
Day 24
SAK-Alike Challenge
Gerber Armbar CorkSome horseshoe crab shells on the beach today,

-
Nice find!
-
Day 25
Merry Christmas, awl! No uses, as I mostly stayed in and nursed the wife. Still not sick, so maybe there's hope for me.
People were asking about the Swiza, so here we go...

Closed (with tweezers out)
[attach id=0 msg=2455270]Swiza has a much better hand feel. I don't love the Wenger style tweezers (always feel like I'm going to lose a nail when I pull them out). Swiza is, as far as I can tell, an old watch/clock company that Peter Hug (the older Wenger CEO) bought out. We'll see a lot of Wenger style design cues here, and the line has some wacky tools (though we won't see much of them on this one). Mine is a D04, which is roughly comparable with a Highlander/Tinker.
[attach id=1 msg=2455270]
Main blades deployed. The Swiza is sort-of OHO with enough finesse, which is about the same as can be said for the T4 (except Swiza doesn't claim to be) note the longer blade and big Wenger style belly. Blade is unlocked by pressing on the shield, again like Wenger (though you can disengage it manually like a traditional liner lock). I'm pretty sure I got this one fresh from the factory, and the edge is meh (though the T4 needed a touch up too).
[attach id=2 msg=2455270]
All the more or less shared tools. Note the complete waste of a flat side on the back Phillips, which could've been a file.
That tiny awl is very sharp (sharper than the main blade OOTB).[attach id=3 msg=2455270]
And the uniqueish tools. Note Swiza adopting a near Vic style can opener.
I'll see if I can get a couple of actual uses in before the month is out. If not, I'm sure it'll get some pocket time eventually.




-
That looks pretty good. Looks like it might be a solid tool.
-
Maybe you can stay healthy. It's bad when everyone in the house is sick at the same time. I am a little surprised that the Swiza didn't come sharp. Of course, that is easily remedied. I like the orange scales. The awl looks a little flimsy, but you shouldn't pry with one anyway. Sounds like you could use it for light scraping or chamfering since it is so sharp. The blade is long enough to suit my taste anyway. Thanks for the report and excellent pix. Best wishes. G
:) -
<u>Christmas Day</u>
The Voss was busy today. Between sharpening pencils, opening new toys, and cutting up the Christmas ham, it saw no rest. Hope y'all enjoyed your day with your loved ones.


-
@BPRoberts said:
Enjoying following this one. I have a few "regular" Rough Ryders, and they're decent enough. How much of an upgrade would you say the Reserve line is?I have some of the standard RRs as well. I would say the Reserve line is a noticeable step up in F&F from the standard RRs, and you get the upgraded steel (D2) vs. the standard no name stainless/440A/no name carbon steel.
You’re looking at a price point that is considerably higher though: more like $40 - $60 for most RRR models vs. a lot of the standard RR line in the $10 - $20 range.
I see the improvement opportunities for the RRR line as follows:
- There are a number of fairly sharp corners and edges on the knife when closed. Some time spent at the factory smoothing/rounding these out would make the knife more comfortable in both pocket and hand.
- Some of these RRRs are unnecessarily beefy, meaning they are carrying more weight than necessary for no benefit. I was a bit surprised when my scale revealed this RRR stockman (at 4.0 ounces) to be only about 11% heavier than a comparable (right down to the black micarta scales) Case 75 pattern stockman (3.6 ounces). I would have guessed more.
- While I think it is clear that D2 is a step up from RR standard steel, I would love to see some offerings in 154CM, S35VN, or etc.
-
Day 24
The sheepsfoot blade is my “dirty”/general utility blade on this knife. I pretty much use it for everything within its capability that doesn’t require a “clean” blade.
The sheepsfoot blade opened this package of new sticks with no problem, and no fear of adhesive residue.

-
Rocky Patels we're my go-to when I was younger. I've been liking Deadwoods lately and a local blend from the cigar and pipe shop I go to.
-
@AzteCypher said:
Rocky Patels we're my go-to when I was younger. I've been liking Deadwoods lately and a local blend from the cigar and pipe shop I go to.I enjoy trying new ones as well, but it seems like RP, Alec Bradley, and CAO are what I keep coming back to.
-
Day 25
The flat screwdriver on this RRR is just a hair smaller at the tip than the Vic 91 mm version. I have no doubts about its ability to turn any screw it fits.

-
Day 26
Final (for now) thoughts on the Rough Ryder Reserve Common Stock Pattern (stockman):
I think it is a solid buy for $50.
I believe it would complete all tasks that might reasonably be expected of it. It feels stout and reliable in hand.
My main criticism, as detailed in my response to BPR above, is that there are sharp edges and corners on the outside of the closed knife, which make it less comfortable in hand and pocket than it could be if a few extra minutes had been taken at the factory to smooth/round these out.
Because this is a SAK-A-Like challenge and I neglected to do this earlier, here are comparison pics of the blades vs. 91 mm SAK…


-
Day 25
SAK-Alike Challenge
Gerber Armbar CorkSpent the day on the road. Home now, didn't feel like cooking.

-
Day 22
No action today, did get a Chipmunk in the mail today.

Sent from my SM-G996U using Tapatalk
-
Day 26
Opened some oil to make potato coins tonight.

-
<u>Day 26</u>
Late posting as we were traveling to my in-laws this evening. Helping setup my little nephews new ride on train.

-
Day 23
Interesting Roxon SAK-a-like I'm carrying today along with the Armbar


Sent from my SM-G996U using Tapatalk
-
Day 26
SAK-Alike Challenge
Gerber Armbar Cork
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login