AI Vs MTO
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Okay, this one is pretty good, even if it sounds an awful lot like the Gerber article above!I asked it this time to create a FB post to promote MTO and this is what it came up with:
Not too shabby really!
Def
It forgot to mention the challenges

-
AI doesn't face any challenges since it killed John Connor!
Def
-
@Fireman said:
It reads like overzealous ad copy. It's a versatile, ingenious, rugged, reliable, well-crafted, shining, iconic example. Holy adjectives, Batman!
My English professor would have beaten me with a stick.My Direct-reports keep trying to impress me with adjectives in their writing. They're young, they don't remember a world where only real estate agents used that many words to obscure the truth - and they get upset when I tell them to rewrite it with less garbage, because they genuinely believe they are being clever/doing the right thing by filling pages with bullsmurf.
On the upside, since most of the "AI" scours the sorts of websites that use that language (and then as the smurf-factory spits it out, scours its own content to make more....) it becomes reasonably easy to ignore anything (or anyone) that tries to communicate like that.
-
Robots say the nicest things....
Megan asked ChatGPT to write an article about me:
"Unveiling the Versatility: Navigating the Multitool Realm with Grant Lamontagne's Spirit"
In the realm of multitools, where functionality meets innovation, one name shines bright – Grant Lamontagne. An aficionado of utility and a connoisseur of craftsmanship, Lamontagne has etched his mark on the multitool landscape through his platform, multitool.org, with a distinctive style that resonates with enthusiasts worldwide.
Grant Lamontagne's journey into the world of multitools is a testament to the allure of versatile instruments. His exploration of different models, brands, and functionalities mirrors the curiosity that drives multitool enthusiasts to seek the perfect companion for any task life throws their way.
What sets Lamontagne apart is not just his collection of tools but his insightful approach to reviewing and discussing them. His writings on multitool.org embody a passion for practicality, a love for the outdoors, and an appreciation for the fine details that elevate a tool from ordinary to exceptional.
Lamontagne's reviews are not mere evaluations; they're narratives that weave the story of each tool's journey from conception to execution. Whether exploring the intricacies of blade design, the ergonomics of handles, or the durability of materials, his analysis dives deep into the heart of what makes a multitool not just a gadget but an indispensable companion.
One of the key aspects of Lamontagne's style is his ability to translate technical details into relatable experiences. Reading his reviews is like embarking on a journey alongside him, feeling the weight of the tool in hand, experiencing the smoothness of its deployment, and envisioning the scenarios where it truly shines.
Lamontagne's appreciation for craftsmanship extends beyond the mainstream brands. He uncovers hidden gems, applauds innovative features, and encourages a diverse range of tools that cater to various needs. In doing so, he fosters a community that values both the iconic and the undiscovered, shaping the discourse around multitools into a celebration of versatility.
The multitool landscape evolves constantly, with new models emerging, and innovations pushing the boundaries of what's possible. Grant Lamontagne's presence in this dynamic arena serves as a guiding light, steering enthusiasts toward tools that not only meet their requirements but also enhance their everyday experiences.
As we navigate the vast universe of multitools, Grant Lamontagne's spirit remains embedded in the essence of exploration, discovery, and an unyielding passion for the tools that accompany us through life's myriad adventures. His legacy is not just in the tools he reviews, but in the inspiration he imparts to a community that shares his zest for the multifaceted world of multitools.
Awwww shucks.
Def
-
as you know, my recent ventures have been into canoeing - and any new purchase requires reading a lot of reviews (well, it doesn't, but I do it anyway)
and it is tiring how much "content" is either written by AI, or is crap copy by people who may as well be personality-free machines for all they bring to the table.Scouring through the amazon-reviews, sales generated bullsmurf, and "AI" nonsense to find something written by a human who has actually used the product is a tiring chore.
Fortunately, you can generally tell in the first sentence or two - no actual human uses the excessive adjectives found in AI smurf or Real Estate ad style drivel, and you get pretty good at ignoring either fake content, or content written by people you wouldn't be interested in anyway.
I'm still a lurker at MT.O after all these years, because despite some things I don't really agree with, at least I know what I'm reading was written by a real person, somewhere, doing it because they want to, not because they are programmed to, or are being paid to.
-
@Sea Monster said:
as you know, my recent ventures have been into canoeing - and any new purchase requires reading a lot of reviews (well, it doesn't, but I do it anyway)
and it is tiring how much "content" is either written by AI, or is crap copy by people who may as well be personality-free machines for all they bring to the table.Scouring through the amazon-reviews, sales generated bullsmurf, and "AI" nonsense to find something written by a human who has actually used the product is a tiring chore.
Fortunately, you can generally tell in the first sentence or two - no actual human uses the excessive adjectives found in AI smurf or Real Estate ad style drivel, and you get pretty good at ignoring either fake content, or content written by people you wouldn't be interested in anyway.
I'm still a lurker at MT.O after all these years, because despite some things I don't really agree with, at least I know what I'm reading was written by a real person, somewhere, doing it because they want to, not because they are programmed to, or are being paid to.
FILE ERROR.
DOES NOT COMPUTE.Def
-
@Sea Monster said:
My Direct-reports keep trying to impress me with adjectives in their writing. They're young, they don't remember a world where only real estate agents used that many words to obscure the truth - and they get upset when I tell them to rewrite it with less garbage, because they genuinely believe they are being clever/doing the right thing by filling pages with bullsmurf.On the upside, since most of the "AI" scours the sorts of websites that use that language (and then as the smurf-factory spits it out, scours its own content to make more....) it becomes reasonably easy to ignore anything (or anyone) that tries to communicate like that.
I recently finished up a writing program in grad school, and apparently that's what they're teaching now. When I was in undergrad, high school, etc. the rule was to cut what you could, understated was best, etc. Now professors are looking for you to write these long sentences full of pointless details.
-
@Sea Monster said:
as you know, my recent ventures have been into canoeing - and any new purchase requires reading a lot of reviews (well, it doesn't, but I do it anyway)
and it is tiring how much "content" is either written by AI, or is crap copy by people who may as well be personality-free machines for all they bring to the table.Scouring through the amazon-reviews, sales generated bullsmurf, and "AI" nonsense to find something written by a human who has actually used the product is a tiring chore.
Fortunately, you can generally tell in the first sentence or two - no actual human uses the excessive adjectives found in AI smurf or Real Estate ad style drivel, and you get pretty good at ignoring either fake content, or content written by people you wouldn't be interested in anyway.
I'm still a lurker at MT.O after all these years, because despite some things I don't really agree with, at least I know what I'm reading was written by a real person, somewhere, doing it because they want to, not because they are programmed to, or are being paid to.
I wholeheartedly agree, I myself have played around with AI to see if it could help write reviews. It's too vague, lacks any warmth and feels robotic. I initially thought, hey these reviews sound good, but the more I read they generalize and overly sensationalize the product. I know sometimes I can get wordy and overzealous in my writing but you can tell there's a person writing them.
Sent from my SM-G996U using Tapatalk
-
With steel there is a peculiar line drawn at the first nuclear bomb test. Apparently after that it has always been some radioactive waste in the atmosphere, and it has been impossible to make steel without any radioactive inclusions ever since. Thus those who really need that are very fond of steel made before that time.
I wonder if there will be a similar line drawn with AI - only data before a certain time can be said to safe from AI input.
Starting out AI has also been trained on historical texts and actual human input in various forms online. But as more and more online information is written by AI they will end up in this weird loop of trying to train themselves using their own previous output as relevant reference input for training. I imagine this could lead to some rather degenerative feedback loops.
-
Having some fun with ChatGPT this morning, Once again, it's a great tool, and in time I think it will be fantastic. For now though, I think the true life experiences of the folks here at MTO are pretty safe!
At first I asked what the functions of the Victorinox Dual Pro were and this was the response:
The Victorinox Dual Pro is a multi-functional tool designed for various tasks. Its functions typically include:
Knife blade: Typically, the Dual Pro includes a sharp knife blade suitable for cutting tasks.
Screwdriver: It may feature a flat-head screwdriver or a Phillips screwdriver for tightening or loosening screws.
Can opener: This tool usually includes a can opener for opening canned goods.
Bottle opener: It often has a bottle opener for opening bottles with crown caps.
Wire stripper: Some models include a wire stripper for removing the insulation from wires.
Tweezers: A pair of tweezers are often included for picking up small objects or for first aid purposes.
Keyring: The tool may feature a keyring attachment for easy carrying.
These functions make the Victorinox Dual Pro a versatile and handy tool for various everyday tasks and outdoor activities.
Largely correct, but ignores the defining tool of the Dual Pro, namely the second, serrated blade.
Not too bad though- with a small amount of editing, this could be convincing.
So I tried again, asking it a question that has raged here since the inception of MTO- what is better, the SwissTool Spirit or Leatherman Wave? This is the response:
Determining whether the SwissTool Spirit or the Leatherman Wave is "better" depends on your specific needs and preferences. Both tools are highly regarded multi-tools, each with its own strengths.
The SwissTool Spirit, made by Victorinox, is known for its high-quality construction, precise engineering, and sleek design. It offers a variety of tools and functions, including pliers, screwdrivers, blades, and more, all of which are accessible without unfolding the tool. The Spirit is often favored for its durability and precision.
On the other hand, the Leatherman Wave is a popular choice known for its versatility and extensive toolset. It features a wide range of tools accessible from the outside, including pliers, knives, saws, scissors, and more. The Wave is often praised for its ergonomic design, ease of use, and rugged build quality.
To determine which tool is "better" for you, consider factors such as the specific tools and functions you need, your budget, ergonomics, build quality, and any personal preferences you may have. It's also helpful to read reviews and compare specifications to see which tool aligns best with your requirements. Ultimately, both the SwissTool Spirit and the Leatherman Wave are excellent multi-tools, and the "better" choice depends on your individual needs and preferences.
I agree with this pretty well entirely, although I do feel some of the details are off. Bear in mind, that while I prefer the Spirit (and therefore may be a bit biased in my interpretation) I have a massive amount of respect for the Wave as well.
That said however....
The bit about he Wave having a versatile and extensive tool set with a wide range of tools accessible from the outside seems like a bit of a slap in the Spirit's face since it actually has a greater number of functions, many with multiple functions, providing a wider array of versatility, and all of them being accessible from the outside.
And the ergonomics of the Wave being better than the Spirit?
I'm not knocking the Wave, it just seems odd to me that the things that ChatGPT thinks are points the Wave has over the Spirit are actually pints for the Spirit.
If I wanted to compare the two and pint out the favorable points of the Wave, I'd point out the OH opening plain and serrated blades, the jimping on the serrated blade spine for easier identification and the replaceable wire cutters found on the Wave +.
Also, if one really wanted to get into the nitty gritty (something MTO members are excellent at, I may add!) the Wave is better for holding on to in a wet environment as the additional texture offered by all the cutouts makes for a firmer grip than the Spirit, which is well known to be extremely sleek and polished.
But I absolutely agree with ChatGPT's comments regarding the best one being the one that has the toolset that best suits your needs- it must have gotten that tidbit from the wonderful folks here at MTO- while we have never really settled the Wave Vs Spirit debate, that was the conclusion that we came up with years ago!
Def
-
Ok, maybe it’s because I just woke up and can’t see straight, but what the heck’s going on, we’re battling “artificial intelligence”

JR -
I'm not sure "battling" is the right word.
Most websites nowadays, especially those updated frequently (think multiple times per day) feature articles written by AI services like ChatGPT.
We don't do that at MTO nor do I intend to start any time soon, although I do use ChatGPT for other things in my life
This thread is just here for some fun examples of what happens when you use AI to write articles for your site- it can give you the bulk of it, but really misses details, like the ones I have pointed out above.
But, it's a tool, and like any other, it will get better and better until we wonder what we ever did without it. In the meantime, you have my word that MTO reviews, articles, editorials etc will all be done by a living, breathing person who has actually handled and used the product in question
Def
-
Reading this post got me curious.
I asked an AI image generator to make a new "Leatherman style plier based multi tool with a blade and a hook" just to see what it would come up with.
Promising???


-
That is kind of cool looking, although I am a bit confused as to how to use it! :ahhh
Def
-
-
To quote Humorbot 5.0....
SNAPPY COMEBACK NOT FOUNDDef
-
Score another one for MTO.
I fooled the AI. It walked right into this one.
I expect a Terminator any moment now.

Def

-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Score another one for MTO.I fooled the AI. It walked right into this one.
I expect a Terminator any moment now.

Def

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




