Australian Knife Laws
-
I’m generally opposed to governments outlawing much of anything.
But when I see people hauling around 3+ D cell Maglites, or flashlights with “strike bezels”, I do wonder “Who do they think they are fooling?”
-
One Moment Please: An Country where every second Animal trys to kill you bans
? So they get a worst Knive Law than Germany in the End.. -
@Valkie said:
Im an old F#$t and I still remember the old days.Hopefully I'll reach that honorable status too one day, but even without that I can remember getting my first SAK at 10. A Victorinox Fisherman (?) if I remember correctly - something fishy anyway. And of course I brought it to school to show off and compare with whatever other versions others in the class had. These days we would probably have been rounded up and made national news or something.
Of course, back then we also had monthly drills for quickly and organized evacuation into the schools bomb shelter - I guess the politicians were busy with bigger issues.
-
"Okay, just stay calm and nobody gets hurt. Just put the money from the register in a bag and be quick about it. I'm serious here. I have a pair of nail clippers and I'm not afraid to use them. Don't think I'm for real? Here goes. I'm gonna clip off TWO of my fingernails. Right down to the quick. There. Now you see. Get me a bottle of wine off that shelf too. Not that one....the white. I'm having fish tonight."
Best wishes. G

-
@matzesu said:
One Moment Please: An Country where every second Animal trys to kill you bans
? So they get a worst Knive Law than Germany in the End..Most of the things that can kill, don't actually try very hard to do it, unless you go out of your way to annoy them, so it's not a huge issue, day to day.
Also, most of the things that can kill you (and might try) are protected, so you're not actually allowed to kill them anyway, unless they've already started trying to kill you.
Finally, most of the the things that can kill you, if they decide to try, you don't have huge window of opportunity to do anything about it (an irukanji is about the size of a fingernail, and for all practical purposes, invisible)
All in all, the wildlife is a fairly moot point.
-
I did not meant that your Swiss Army Knive should you protect from the dangerous Animal in Austria, only that they are much more dangerous than a guy whit a Pocketknife..
-
I don't know about that.
I would hate to come up against a 10 year old scout with a victornox in his hand.
He might build a shelter around you.
Or construct a hammock.You never know with these dangerous kids.
-
To be fair that there are still schools and areas around where knives are just tools like any other - more so in rural areas though. There are still kindergardens around where the kids use knives as part of their outdoors activities from they are 4-5 years old or so.
More to the point. The law is the law here but how it is interpreted seems to vary wildly depending on region and situational setting. That might be more even in Australia? Having visited Australia a few times I reckon common sense might be more common than this thread give it credit for?
-
@Vidar said:
To be fair that there are still schools and areas around where knives are just tools like any other - more so in rural areas though. There are still kindergardens around where the kids use knives as part of their outdoors activities from they are 4-5 years old or so.More to the point. The law is the law here but how it is interpreted seems to vary wildly depending on region and situational setting. That might be more even in Australia? Having visited Australia a few times I reckon common sense might be more common than this thread give it credit for?
Common sense might be putting it a bit strongly, but....allocation of police resources is a consideration I guess.
In a town with large ice issues for example, you don't tend to find cops pulling people up for jaywalking. It's not just where they want to do their paperwork - they're hip deep in "real crimes" (and domestic violence) issues.
But...look at it this way - given the power to randomly search people for "weapons" - now they can "suspect" people of having weapons...and oh look, we didn't find one, but we did find some drugs. oh-ho-ho.
You might say "Good! Less drugs on the street!" - but...Well, the discussion of application and interpretation of police powers might get too spicy for MT.O.
Suffice to say - I think from now on, lots of people will be removing their classics from their keychain, to save the worry of potential issues.
-
@Sea Monster said:
In a town with large ice issues for example, you don't tend to find cops pulling people up for jaywalking.That is actually a common way to tell locals from tourists in some cities around here. The locals tend to be the ones walking in the street just next to a perfectly fine sidewalk.
Yes, that power will be tempting to abuse, but as you say likely too spicy here. And I agree many or most will just not risk the bother or attracting attention at all. Sad if it comes to that though for actual useful tools.
-
@Sea Monster said:
Suffice to say - I think from now on, lots of people will be removing their classics from their keychain, to save the worry of potential issues.I'll continue to pocket carry my LM Squirt P4 and won't worry too much about it. The next time a cop asks to see what's in my pockets will be the first time, and I've lived in Oz for more than 70 years. Admittedly I rarely do anything to attract Police attention...
-
@gregozedobe said:
I'll continue to pocket carry my LM Squirt P4 and won't worry too much about it. The next time a cop asks to see what's in my pockets will be the first time, and I've lived in Oz for more than 70 years. Admittedly I rarely do anything to attract Police attention...In Queensland the government introduced "Jack's Law", named after a 19yo kid who was stabbed in the city. It allows Police to use a metal detector on anyone they like in a safe night precinct or public transport hub. The police deploy at the transport hubs and wand EVERYONE. Anyone they find with a knife or Multitool they charge - even if they have a valid excuse for carrying one as set out in Queensland's knife laws. It's up to you then, to argue your case in court. In the one case I've read where that has happened, the prosecutor offered a deal of a guilty plea in exchange for a $100 fine and no criminal conviction recorded. I expect most people will take the deal as pleading innocent means spending extra on court fees and no guarantee that the judge will find in your favor. Apparently the father of Jack is going to NSW to try to convince the premier there to implement Jack's law, as it has been so successful in Queensland, based on them seizing 1000's on knives. In Queenslnad, they're also looking at extending the places where they can use Jack's law to shopping centres.
I can't help but feel that this is wrong, that the government is targeting innocent people who are lawfully carrying a knife, just to make it look like they're being "tough on knife crime". It feels almost like a dumb version of Minority report - where they try to arrest you for a crime that you might commit in future, by acting that if you're carrying a knife, you're automatically up to no good. https://mypolice.qld.gov.au/news/2024/03/28/morayfield-commuter-safety-crackdown/
-
@Carthas said:
In Queensland the government introduced "Jack's Law", named after a 19yo kid who was stabbed in the city. It allows Police to use a metal detector on anyone they like in a safe night precinct or public transport hub. The police deploy at the transport hubs and wand EVERYONE. Anyone they find with a knife or Multitool they charge - even if they have a valid excuse for carrying one as set out in Queensland's knife laws. It's up to you then, to argue your case in court. In the one case I've read where that has happened, the prosecutor offered a deal of a guilty plea in exchange for a $100 fine and no criminal conviction recorded. I expect most people will take the deal as pleading innocent means spending extra on court fees and no guarantee that the judge will find in your favor. Apparently the father of Jack is going to NSW to try to convince the premier there to implement Jack's law, as it has been so successful in Queensland, based on them seizing 1000's on knives. In Queenslnad, they're also looking at extending the places where they can use Jack's law to shopping centres.I can't help but feel that this is wrong, that the government is targeting innocent people who are lawfully carrying a knife, just to make it look like they're being "tough on knife crime". It feels almost like a dumb version of Minority report - where they try to arrest you for a crime that you might commit in future, by acting that if you're carrying a knife, you're automatically up to no good. https://mypolice.qld.gov.au/news/2024/03/28/morayfield-commuter-safety-crackdown/
There's versions of this (what I'm about to say, not what you said), in most australian states - if you want the history read up on Garry David - basically in 1990 Australia decided to give itself the power to "detain" people because 'they might do something, somewhere, somehow' - note this is before all the terroism rhetoric that came a decade later.
Here's the title info from the NSW version of the "Community Protection Act"
'An Act to protect the community by providing for the preventive
detention of persons who are, in the opinion of the Supreme Court, more
likely than not to commit serious acts of violence."More or less until that point in time, you had to actually commit a crime before you had business with the police - since then the states have progressively increased the "robust powers" the police have to "find bad guys"
I won't submit an opinion on the ethics of how Australian state policing occurs, just providing a bit of backstory to the last 30 odd years of, let's call it policing culture
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
-
Hopefully bladeless multi's should still be ok. The other option is to leave it in a lunchbox with a piece of fruit.
It is sad that it has come this far. It would be interesting to see which knives have been used. Easy access kitchen knives has been used in most cases as far as I am aware.
Pete
-
@Carthas said:
In Queenslnad, they're also looking at extending the places where they can use Jack's law to shopping centres.Most shopping centres have shops that sells knives in some form or another, so that might be a challenge. Both from view of actual impact and from the view of how to get knives actually bought home..
-
Rainy night in Sydney. A couple run to the door of a house. Then they stop at the front door.
"Hurry Ronald, I'm getting soaked. Oh, you oaf can't you find the key?"
"I'm trying dearest. Really. You think it's easy finding that dratted key in the dark. Let's see....? No that isn't it. I know I have it somewhere....
"Don't you have one of those pocket torches? You used to carry one. Hurry. My shoes are just ruined."
"Can't carry one now. The police call them burglary tools. Can't have them thinking we are breaking and entering or something.... I give up. Give me one of your shoes. I will use it to batter in the glass and reach through to the lock. "

-
@Carthas said:
It feels almost like a dumb version of Minority report - where they try to arrest you for a crime that you might commit in future…This is pretty much the way I feel about the “red flag” laws that have been popping up here in the US.
People can have their rights trampled and their property seized, not because of any crime they have committed, but because they might possibly harm themselves or others at some point in the future.
Even when the laws require a hearing before a judge, the initial hearing on whether or not to issue a confiscation order is generally held ex parte, so the prospective subject of the order doesn’t even have the opportunity to be present at the hearing to present a defense.
Also, while I’m not a lawyer, a casual perusal of the Bill of Rights suggests to my mind that these laws are likely in violation of one or more of the 2nd, 4th, 5th, 6th, and 7th Amendments.
-
@nate j said:
Is that any torch, or just the ones big enough to be used as bludgeons?IDK about anyone else, but my torches are mostly “see where I’m going in the dark so I don’t fall on my smurf tools”.
Dont know.
All I know is that some kids were detained at the local train station because they were carrying torches and the police stated that there were suspicious because they had said torches..Now, I know they can arrest you for carrying other "break and enter tools" such as crowbars, screwdrivers and lock pics, but until then I had never heard of torches..
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login