Musing about a thousand dollar knife
-
It is an intriguing question. Recently I found myself looking at a £650 GBP Ray Mears bushcraft knife. I could not not really see the advantage the extra price garnered over, say, a Casstrom Woodsman at £150 GDP......other than the kudos of being able to tell others that one owns it. I would certainly not wish to use it for fear of damage (which is probably why so many very expensive knives come up for sale "new and unused"). In the end my rational mind kicked in and reminded me that I have a Mora Robust, that cost me a mere £10.95 GBP that would do the same job and my vanity subsided in favour of keeping the money in my pocket. Funny old world innit? :D
-
I would never treat a knife as an investment exactly, but retained value has to come in to it.
AndyAaron above asks why spend thousands for a Rolex or Omega instead of buying a £50 Casio, and part of the answer is that you’re buying an heirloom, something which is likely to increase in value. I bought a Rolex Explorer brand new in 2004 for £1900 and it would sell used for £5000 or more today.
I don’t know how many knives would do the same, but it takes some of the risk away if you could get your money back, or even make a profit.
-
My thinking about this might be too simple perhaps, but I think people spend money based on the perception that they will get the same or more back in value. Few pay more than they think something is worth.
To that there are two further points:
[list type=decimal]
-
Sometimes products or brands promise more than they can deliver and the perceived value paid for just isn' there.
-
The value can come in many shapes or forms, and I think practical utility value is just one of those. Some might think of it as an investment, some might value the design, some for talking points, sentimental value, value as a gift, some because it makes them smile using or looking at it, some because they become all cool and attractive with it (what would I know? ::) ), some due associations with other owners, some due to aspirations of being someone needing such specifications. (200m water proof watches somes to mind..). Most likely a mix of many things, some of which might not even be concious.
People value objects for all kinds of different reasons. As long as that value seem delivered then I think that is all fine and personal. I do have issues with products and brands that overpromise and underdeliver though as in the first point - and there are many of those creating and riding short term hype and marketing.
-
-
You are absolutely correct. For me, I don't see the value in spending $1000 on a knife with fancy materials that don't really improve performance and are just there to try and justify a higher price, made by people that I have never heard of before- and not to toot my own horn, but I have been quite involved in the knife industry since the mid 90's.
Getting back to the Mercedes/Cadillac versus a second hand used car thing that Andy mentioned if I may. Andy is quite correct, you will get from Point A to Point B just as fast in a second hand economy car as you would in a brand new Mercedes, but I think that in these cases, there is well established value in those cars. They have value because they perform better, are more comfortable, are better made, have higher resale and are more reliable.
This fancy knife won't perform better, won't have any better ergonomics, and I can't say the resale on something no one knows about would be any better.
Def
-
@AndyAaron said:
Let me give you different point of view.
The same way you think about expensive knives can be applied to any product.
Why you need expensive Mercedes or Cadillac when you can have second hand car for 10% of the price and it still gets you from point A to point B?
Why to buy Rolex or Omega for thousands of dollars when you can have $50 Casio that keeps more accurate time?
Why to buy headphones for $1000 when you can listen to your music and podcasts using $40 headphones? And I can keep going…- We are collectors. We like to collect things. You get into your hobby, you keep searching for more information about materials, designs, you fall in love with something specific and you just want it into your collection. You may have interest for some collecting and for some not. For example I can imagine me buying 1k knife or 10k watch but not 1.5k brand new cell phone that gets obsolete in two years. But there are plenty of dudes waiting in line for new phones ;)
- Irrational love for something. Handyman can cut everything the same or even better than $1000 knife but when you sit and play with your expensive love it brings you additional happiness;)
- Craftsmanship - today when everything is produced by automation you just appreciate something that is made by hand. When it is made in the US or in the EU the price for it is always much higher than made in Asia.
- Show off - some people just want to show that they have the money to buy things. I don’t like it but there are plenty of them.
- To keep the value. Investment. You don’t loose much money on Sebenza I guess.
- Some manufacturers just trying to raise the prices to see if the customer accepts it or not:)
Anyway, I like the way Live and let live. It doesn’t matter how much it cost if you are happy with it.
Disclaimer: I don’t own any super expensive knives, just two second hand Inkosis. The rest are cheap knives that I am happy about.
I like nice things, I consider myself a connoisseur of the finer things in life...
which is why I have all the things you list as cheap :(
I have a very fine 20 year old Toyota that has been getting me from A to B nicely
I have a very fine 13 year old casio that has been telling me the time nicely,
Headphones/Electronics are a funny one, because there are a lot of cheap electronics that are worth less than nothing - I have sennheisers that have been reasonable for 3 years so far.I don't think the issue is the price tag itself, but the price tag relative to what the thing is or does.
A corvette has a number of technical differences and capabilities that may, or may not, justify the price difference to a toyota starlet.
but there is presumably an upper limit to how much a couple of pieces of metal fashioned in a to knife can ever do, and since no one is offering road-side assist for a folder (break your knife cutting a sandwich? just call 1800-sharp, and we'll be there to cut it for you!) - you might wonder where that price is.
You also might wonder, if you were so inclined, are you paying $1000 for a $200 knife, with the extra $800 just so you can say "Hey, I
am a smurfing rubepaid $1000 for this knife, nice hey?"but then, some people collect baseball cards, so wanted to possess things "just 'cause" is a weird lever in people's brains.
-
I think it is all about finding the perfect balance that fits to the person. I don’t like overpaying for things on the other hand I am done with cheap and crapy stuff. I burnt myself several times looking for cheapest product and found out that it didn’t last or was pain to use. There are several sayings in Czech for this. “I am not that rich to be able to afford cheap things.” and “You pay twice for cheap things.”
On the other hand I don’t want to spend 1k bucks for thing worth 100.
Balance - that’s my motto ;)P.S. I drive 17 years old Ford, use 4 years old phone and have 45 years old wife :)
-
Well, after telling your wife's age on the internet, at least we all know you won't be getting older! :ahhh
We have a similar saying in English- buy quality and only cry once.
Def
-
@AndyAaron said:
I think it is all about finding the perfect balance that fits to the person.
Put another way, a Ferrari will do things a Jeep or a pickup won't do. The opposite is also true. I don't think a Rolex will do anything an analog G-Shock won't do. The $1,000 knife won't do anything an Opinel won't do. I can appreciate the Ferrari, the Rolex, and the $1,000 knife. But the Jeep or pickup, the G-Shock, and the Opinel work better for me.
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
We have a similar saying in English- buy quality and only cry once.Around here it is usually shortened to “Buy once, cry once.”

On the general subject of expensive stuff, I like to think I look for value. I’m generally fine with paying more to get more, but I don’t want to pay more just to pay more.
-
It might be added the value of money itself is different between people. For me USD1000 is real money which I would consider carefully before spending and also consider what else I could get for that. It will be hard to convince me I need a USD1000 knife in my life. For others USD 1000 on non-necessities might be out of reach or will take serious saving if the want is large enough.
Then there are those who have serious money or income, and who can spend USD 1000 like I spend USD 10. I don't think too much about spending USD 10 rather than say USD 2 if I want the more expensive item even if it isn't purely needed. I guess I'm just not in the economic target demography for these Grimsmo knives.

Disregarding the branding exclusive strategy of having some extremely expensive showpieces, to sell more of the just very expensive pieces, I also sometimes wonder if certain items are priced extremely high just to be exclusive. For some people and occasions having something others don't have might provide value in itself. (That said I would expect a USD 1000 knife to be short run or mass production).
-
I agree with all your arguments and I myself think mostly the same. However all I read here are very rational arguments.
As I said in my very first post in this thread you shouldn’t forget about the passion and the heart. The knife can be piece of art or very unique piece.
For example I love my Ontario RAT 1 and consider it best folding knife for it’s price. It hardly beats the $20 Opinel in slicing on the other hand it is way more robust for doing things around the house and garden. If RAT 1 cost $1000 I would be laughing very loud.
On the other hand there are local knife makers that can make very unique folding knife, using way better materials, with specific engraving per customer’s request and it takes them hours to built one. Obviously they ask the relevant price for that. And that is completely fine with me.
Regarding the usage, RAT1 would be definitely more used for cutting, slicing, bushcrafting and doing the heavy stuff. But when I sit down and want to relax and play with the knife there will be much more joy with the hand made one tailored for me ;)
As we are lovers and collectors of knives and we spend whole days chatting and discussing about them there should be no surprise that there is love for cheap ones as well for the expensive ones. -
I think this particular knife issue can be boiled down to Fashion, or if we are being truly honest with ourselves, hubris.
This is a fancy knife, which does look good and has some fancy specs and that is enough for someone to lord it over someone else and make themselves feel special because they have it.
I think it is obvious if we equate it to something like watches, as has been done above, but not really from he right perspective.
A Rolex costs a lot more than Timex and probably doesn't keep time as accurately. This is true, but the Timex isn't hand made, the Timex doesn't have as high quality of materials and there is no art in a Timex. You buy a Rolex for the art, the pedigree, and possibly even for the resale potential, none of which you buy a Timex for.
Timex (or whoever) made decent watches for day to day use, they are inexpensive, not bad looking, highly functional and readily available. They are a good watch, but they aren't a Rolex.
But it gets worse than that.
Megan buys fashion watches- ones with Kate Spade or Michael Kors written on it, and spends good watch money on them- you could get a decent G-Shock for less. They may look nicer and have a fancy name on them than Casio, but they are absolutely the cheapest junk watches on the planet because they are driven by profit. For example, even though she hasn't personally designed anything new in years following a tragic case of death, Kate Spade keeps coming out with new designs.
The name has been sold, the artistry passed with her, and now it's all about profit. Make something in the style of Kate Spade, find the cheapest manufacturer you can find, crank out a few container loads of absolute crap (but with a good name on it) and sell it at a premium. Then buy that second house and drive your new Porsche to it.
It's the same with these kinds of knives. In the absense of a name (Who is Grimsmo?
) they substituted fancy materials and fancier sounding specs and sell it at a premium. No art needed, just insert an overly vain sucker with too much money.Not a bad business plan really- I wish I was smart enough to do it myself. You don't want to know how many emails I get every day from companies in China, Pakistan or other places begging me to stick the MTO name on some of their crap and make a fortune.

Def
-
If you can afford $1000, that's cool too.
I'm not rich by any means, but if I want something, I'll save for it.

-
At these price points I think of it as a question of priorities and passions rather than functionality. I'm not into knives enough for $1000 knives to make sense for me. However, I am also certain I have spent more money on stuff that wouldn't make sense for many other people - and I've been quite happy with most of those purchases and would do them again. So for people into knives I just assume it provides value at some level and make sense to them.
In a corner here I have marble chessboard with gold and silver covered pieces. It's value was never about playing chess with it though - it was bought as a decorative piece. It just so happens to be usable for chess. I wouldn't spend that money on it today, so it also serves as a remainder of years gone by when I had more money than sense! ::) :D Still, it looks good and do its job well - but actually playing chess is just a side note.
-
Horses for courses.
Don't yuck someone's yum.
...but nope for me. $1000 would better used elsewhere in my case.
-
I'm sure a $1000 knife is nice, great materials, a known designer, a conversation piece, and still functional.
At the same time, I cannot justify that much money just for just a knife. For the same amount I can fill a bag with all sorts of gear, and their back-ups. -
I reckon my most expensive knife would be Böker Tirpizt Damascus Gold.
Few others might be in the same price range (I strongly believe in actively forgetting the price as soon as possible) but at least it most certainly is the one where 'do I really need to cut this...?' thought process is most used ;)
Not sure how much hard use the gold plating takes and sharpening might be tricky too..Despite this I do carry it and when I do it gives me pleasuse. Even if I regularly drop a Classic or similar into other pocket, just in case.
My categories with folders and SAKs are 'can it be carried with other items in same trouser pocket or will it ride alone in order not to get marked or dirty?'
Call me vain, but often the 2nd category makes me feel happy whilst with 1st it sometimes is just feeling properly equipped. Of course, saving the day; or the world; with cheap old Spartan or similar is on other level of happiness!
I'm sometimes tempted by William Henry with dinosaur bone handle or similar. But checking the bank balance clears those ideas rather quickly.
Guess what I'm trying to say is that if it gives you pleasure why not?
Lähetetty minun SM-T515 laitteesta Tapatalkilla
-
$1000 is a solid down payment on a bicycle these days. I'd probably go that route than a knife.
Some things are worth the extra price tag. I've worn many Timex watches over the years. While they are solid watches, I wanted something a little nicer so I splurged on a Lorus (subsidiary of Seiko) field watch. You can feel the quality upgrade in this. As the saying goes, buy once cry once..
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



