What fixed blade are you carrying today?
-
I went shopping yesterday, not actually a search intending to buy, but more to complete research.
I acquire a ESEE Ashley Game knife a few weeks ago in S35VN at a bargain $ from knife connection. And have been very pleased with it. Then thought the 1095 would fix an itch. The Grey Micarta specifically but out of inventory at a few haunts. Then the ESEE CR2.5 caught my eye. Out of Stock too! So both item were requests for notification when in stock.
Wednesday the email arrived that both were available. Only ready for one, so I watched some reviews on YouTube.
The CR2.5 is very nice + $20 less than a AGK.
Then a CR2.5 clone review appeared. Expected some trash report, do not buy. Instead it was favorable. $25 bucks, whoa! Found on the River site. Many varieties to, good steel, G10 scales or Micarata.
I am curious, a fix blade, about the size of my Stockman, 1/4 the price. 🤪Put it in the cart. Oh wait what else is in my cart? Yep, a BPS model, actually two. Walnut handles, 1075steel, scandi grind leather sheath. $32. Oh my, both can be here next day. Very curious, two nights for half of one ESEE. Buy!!!!
Arrived this afternoon late. Both are exceptional.
[attach id=0 msg=2490969]
The BPS is model BS1FTSS, I step it to SS. Made in the Ukraine, awl reviews of different models at AAA+++.the leather sheath is top notch. Thick leather and well stitched. Just needs some oil and dry yo fit the handle form.
The CR2.5 clone is a SDOKEDC DC53. Very nice fit and finish and kydex style sheath with a solid belt clip like a TAC4.
Both extremely sharp, dangerously sharp. I kid you not, it appears the paper was seperating befor the blade even touched it.
I included my model 74 stockman and Sod Buster Junior for reference.
This picture includes the sheath for the clone.
[attach id=1 msg=2490969]For now the AGK 1095 is on the back burner.
The CR2.5 is still off interest if the clone size and function works for me. If the clone performs great then I made add on to both vehicles and tackle box. Its blade is very similar to a bird and trout style fix blade knife.PS: I will need to look up other details later and make notes. And expect to carry both in some manner!
After thought, comparison picture of the AGK (top) to the BPS Camp Knife
[attach id=2 msg=2490969]


-
I've heard nothing but positive reviews of the BPS knives. The CR2.5 clone looks well made. It bothers me to buy an exact copy of something because whoever makes the original has put the time and effort into it, but I have bought knives that were not exact clones but close to the design of the original just to see if I could get along with the type. Sort of a proof of concept before spending the money for the original. So, I understand the attraction of the clone, especially when the original is often not available.

-
That is exactly the draw to the clone. Less than 1/3 the price.
The CR2.5 has been on my radar for 3 years, and sells out quickly each time. And, online only, so no retailers near to actually see and feel the real item.
Can now say, my curiosity has been satisfied.
-
So, what do you think of the DC53 (CR2.5 clone)? It's not really to my liking but it does look like a user.

-
Today I'm carrying the Wissahickon Critter. Very ergonomic knife with a great handle. It really would benefit from a lanyard though, because there's barely enough handle sticking out of the sheath to get a thumb and one finger on it.

-
@Alan K. said:
So, what do you think of the DC53 (CR2.5 clone)? It's not really to my liking but it does look like a user.
Well… the Clone, saw enough use yesterday, that I was satisfied with reason of purchase.
The fit in my hand was better than expected. I removed the belt clip from the sheath and carried in front tight pocket without an issue.
The blade style, drop point, is to my liking, similar to a Sod Buster. Longer than a Jr. And, shorter than a full size, minus the belly of the blade.
This blade is similar in length to the common Bird n Trout fix blades in the market, with functional and less traditional handle. Also, not clip point blade which may explain the like factor.
I feather several sticks from my brush pile, soft maple, Locus, Hard Maple, and Cottonwood. A variety of branches that blew into my yard.
It did very well at that task and also cutting notches and spike tips as I would foot tarp stakes if making a lean too.
Did very well, but most noticeable was no hot spots in either hand and easy to control.
I actually enjoyed carrying and using. I then was happy enough to order the ESEE CR2.5 I had originally researched. It should arrive by weeks end. This will be 1095 Steel.
The Clone is fitted with DC53 Steel. And was pleased with its feel. I used in the kitchen, like I would a pairing knife. Not great for tomato slicing, the blade is thick at the spine, blade did its part parting tissue, just could get consistent slices. On a chicken it did great, sliced through joint cartridge and ribs. And even down the middle separating the breasts.
I am not a fan of D2 steel, it feels brittle to me. The DC53, has a harder Rockwell, and edge had some edge feel after my use. Cutting paper, it sounded as if I was cutting cardboard. After 4 strops to each side, it now felt smooth and when I ran it through the same printed paper it was like a whisper, only 4 passes on the leather😗
I felt quilt buying a definite copy of a ESEE design, and yet most surprised by the copy’s quality. Damm YouTuber
-
My bad. I thought DC53 was the name. Didn't realize that was the steel. I'm glad you said there were no hot spots because I would have asked if you hadn't. I'm impressed that you liked it enough to order the original. I hope you enjoy them both for many years.

-
I follow up:
The original arrived this morning. The ESEE CR2.5 (middle)!
It is surprising the difference in your mind interpreting measurements to actual size.
My picture is to reference blade length.
[attach id=0 msg=2491539]
The Case 75 clip = 3-1/4” & 4-1/4” handle.
ESEE CR 2.5 drop = 2-1/2” (duh) & 3-5/8” handle.
Clone = 2-7/8” & 4-1/4” handle.
The Clone is similar, yet larger.
First impressions of the CR 2.5, it is SHARP, the blade is sturdy, the back spine is a flat 90degrees, and I will need a lanyard to improve 4th finger grip. This should compliment my AGK very well. But first, most likely kitchen duty first. Luv the Micarta grips, feel and color. 😉

-
@LoopCutter said:
It is surprising the difference in your mind interpreting measurements to actual size.Yea, you can read all the specs and look at all the pictures, but you never know for sure how a knife is going to work for you until you hold it in your hand.
Congrats on the new acquisition!
-
I like the looks of the CR2.5. Congratulations on a sweet blade!

-
Spartan Enyo

-
Great picture Sherry. Can we see the Sparten out of the scabbard please?!
-
@Alan K. said:
Great picture Sherry. Can we see the Sparten out of the scabbard please?!
-
Nice piece, but I think I prefer your ATK. -
@Alan K. said:
Nice piece, but I think I prefer your ATK.I love the ATK, too. The ATK is a sweet little jack-of-all-trades types of knife. It is usually the one I grab for hiking , but I forgot it and the Enyo was in the car. The Enyo you can tell just by holding is more a defense focus design, yet still very capable of doing general tasks.
-
Buck 113 Ranger.

-
@Blunt Object said:
Grabbed the Granny's Tooth by Roselli, high carbon steel with a wicked bite, to set up bird feed bundles.Here's a more modern iteration of a small carbon steel fb: the JP Peltonen Ranger Cub or "Pikkusissi". Still love the Roselli, but the sheath is not secure, and I like the handle on this one more.
https://www.peltonenknives.com/knives/m23-ranger-cub for steel and size etc.

-
I like that. It looks perfect for EDC. Might have to get one but maybe in one of the other colors.

-
LionSteel H1

-
Been rocking the Peltonen M23 all week. This custom sheath just arrived. There is a place for dangler sheaths, but vertical carry is my carry mode of choice.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login