Leatherman Signal challenge: October 2024
-
@Cypren said:
I will say that doing this challenge has really driven in — no pun intended — how the single most important function for me in a multitool is a good screwdriver. The Signal’s absolutely miserable implementation of the bit driver (seriously, what were they thinking, making the tool unable to close when the driver is out?) has been a nightmare for the last six days and I can’t see myself ever carrying this tool again once the challenge is over.I prefer when a screwdriver can be used when the tool is closed, but after using a Skeletool for a long time, it doesn't bother me so much. What's funny is that after using my ARC so much, what bothers me the most about the Signal bit driver is that I can't open it one-handed.
-
@Farmer X said:
@Sos24: I haven't seen a Food Lion in forever! If memory serves me correctly, there was one in Dahlgren, VA.:Day 6
This is actually from last night...I'm unsure how much hot-spot I'm allotted every month. But the Signal's combo tool is a very effective can opener.
[attach id=0 msg=2499453]
One knock on the Signal is that it can't be completely closed when the combo tool, awl, or bit driver is in use.
I don’t remember for certain if there is a Food Lion in Dahlgren, but know there is one near Wallops and if you went to Dahlgren, you were probably also at Wallops. Food Lions are popular in VA and NC but not sure how much beyond there.
I agree on the frustration that the Signal doesn’t fully close when using the inside tools.
@Juan el Boricua said:
Day 6Made a "platform base" for the floor fan to be easily moved with my box one.

[attach id=0 msg=2499475] [attach id=1 msg=2499475]Nicely done
Yeah, so I am constantly saying how I almost never use a multitool saw. Well, what would you freakin' know - I used the Signal's saw today. I was fixing a broken pipe in my irrigation system that was connected to an anti-siphon valve. For the life of me, I couldn't get the end of the broken pipe out of the valve. My nipple extractor (he he) couldn't get a grip on the broken pipe end, so I used the saw to cut grooves in the pipe. Viola! The pipe came out.

So what do I do immediately after? Well, of course I go through with my plan and replace the saw with a file anyway.


I have to laugh, because reading through this thread would have you believe Leatherman is missing an opportunity to turn their “outdoor tool”. Into an urban tool with just a few minor modifications.
-
Installing a new home security system. The door/window sensors have these little plastic tabs protecting the batteries during shipping; the instructions seem to think you can pull these things out with your fingers, but I sure can’t manage it without a firmer grip.
[attach id=0 msg=2499408]
Good use
Used the blade to remove a package from the bubble wrap envelope.

Then used the blade to cut through the tape security seals in order to remove my new flashlight.

It has been a while since I picked up a Fenix PD35. I am really digging the anodize green.

Nice light and beautiful green. Fenix makes great lights, I just wish they would use more neutral LEDs
-
Day 7
Doing some testing with my Firebox Nano stove.The Signal pliers cam in handy with handling the hot Toaks alcohol stove to pour back excess fuel and with lifting the gas burner out without waiting for it to cool.


-
Day 7:
You'll see that red one most of the month fore sure : it's mine and it's modded to fit my urban needs (still lacking the mod Rich shown the over day) with metal file and scalpel blade.Opened packets today, nothing much interesting, so a pic of it chillin'
[attach id=0 msg=2499569]
-
Day 7
Beauty shot for today. [attach id=0 msg=2499588]

-
@Sos24 said:
I have to laugh, because reading through this thread would have you believe Leatherman is missing an opportunity to turn their “outdoor tool”. Into an urban tool with just a few minor modifications.

Which leads me to...
Day 7
Ok, I replaced the ferro rod, signal whistle, mini sharpener, and saw with something more useful to a non-camper. One last tool remains... the one I hate most on multitools and one that I have never needed - the can opener :ahhh Looking at the can opener's spot, there isn't much room to work with. Maybe I cab fit a mini driver in there


-
@Cypren: I suppose the Signal's bit driver is adequate for light-duty use. But I wouldn't try it out on GM air filter housings (and the Signal is not an "at-work" multi anyway).
@JonesE: I like the topo! But I'm afraid that if I get one, it'll be a safe queen.
@Sos24: what do I miss about Virginia? Sheetz.
@m47mu74nt: I like the red, and it seems that file mods are kinda popular.
@Juan El Boricua: looking good!
@Rich_SD: funny how that works out...a good can opener is a desirable feature for me.
Another great day, y'awl!

Day 7
The carabiner strikes me as a rather odd inclusion. It's too small to ride well on a belt loop. I'd rather see it closed up and used as a generously sized lanyard hole. Or maybe I'm missing the point.
[attach id=0 msg=2499601]

-
Like the orange background Juan.

Would like it if Leatherman would make an orange and black Signal. That would be awesome.
JonesE
-
@Farmer X said:
@Rich_SD: funny how that works out...a good can opener is a desirable feature for me.Another great day, y'awl!

Day 7
The carabiner strikes me as a rather odd inclusion. It's too small to ride well on a belt loop. I'd rather see it closed up and used as a generously sized lanyard hole. Or maybe I'm missing the point.
[attach id=0 msg=2499601]
My wife would knock me to next Tuesday if I brought the multitool I just used to fix our irrigation system (or other random dirty job) into the kitchen to open a can.

Yeah, I hate the multitool can opener, but I salute all of you that make use of that odd tool

Don’t even get me start on multitool corkscrews

For the Signal carabiner, I think we’re supposed to clip that to our backpack strap

-
@Rich_SD said:
Ok, I replaced the ferro rod, signal whistle, mini sharpener, and saw with something more useful to a non-camper. One last tool remains... the one I hate most on multitools and one that I have never needed - the can opener :ahhh Looking at the can opener's spot, there isn't much room to work with. Maybe I cab fit a mini driver in there
Does it still count for the challenge if we just replace every piece of the Signal one at a time until we have a Wave? Asking for a friend.

@Farmer X said:
The carabiner strikes me as a rather odd inclusion. It's too small to ride well on a belt loop. I'd rather see it closed up and used as a generously sized lanyard hole. Or maybe I'm missing the point.You and me both. Especially given how much functionality of the tool was sacrificed for its inclusion. Not just the inability to close the tool with the other handle's attachments extended, but the entire second handle's worth of fold-out tools. The only thing I can figure is that it's a throwaway inclusion because the compromises were already made to prioritize the striker surface, something they may well have considered a must-have for its intended use as a camping tool.
Day 7
I didn't use the tool for a whole lot today other than slicing open packages. (And indirectly, slicing open my thumb when it went skidding across the edge of a heat-sealed package I was cutting through; have I mentioned how much I hate heat-sealed packaging?) New toys in the mail today were mostly specialty electrician's tools for my project of wiring a bunch of new circuits in the basement and the garage over the next week.
[attach id=0 msg=2499617]
The blade on my Signal is getting pretty dinged up and has visible notches in it from what I tend to think of as fairly light use over the past week. Not an auspicious sign, but at least I should get my sharpening tools tomorrow to touch it back up again.
[attach id=1 msg=2499617]


-
@Cypren said:
Does it still count for the challenge if we just replace every piece of the Signal one at a time until we have a Wave? Asking for a friend.
The multitool of Theseus

That's a great point. I like the form factor of the Signal - it's like a jumbo skeletool - so maybe the challenge for me is making it into something useful to myself. Or I'm cheating

-
I'd love to see the Signal-Wave.
Larger Skeletool is exactly how I think of the Signal. Which is why I don't own one. The Skeletool is a clever way to cram a knife, pliers, and driver into a small package. The Signal is... half of a Wave? strapped to a Skeletool, with a couple outdoor goodies tossed in.
-
Day 8:
Pried stapples open, but no real job, so here is my load out as of today:[attach id=0 msg=2499681]

-
Day 8
I'm team pocket-carry, and I'm not liking the Signal's pocket clip. It makes the tool stick out too far.
Here it is compared to my ARC:

Here it is next to my Curl:

...and next to my Skeletool. The thing I like least about the Skeletool is how far it sticks out of my pocket, but it is still not far enough that I don't like carrying it. The Signal feels like it sticks out too far... but maybe I'll get used to it by the end of the month.

-
@Rich_SD: Mrs. FX would have done the same. And I wouldn't have blamed her. As nasty as my ST300 has gotten, its can opener is unlikely to see use. And I don't much like rhe Signal's pocket clip, either.
@Cypren: I hate those damn clamshell packages. And good luck with the wiring!
@BPRoberts: I guess that's a fair enough assessment. The Signal, in my opinion, would benefit greatly if the hammer and carabiner were removed.
@m47mu74nt: I like the red and yellow! Probably I wouldn't go for the X-Acto blade holdermod, though.
Day 8
Anymore, dealing appropriately with a six-pack holder is an infrequent use for me. Rich mentioned that he likes black oxide with a little wear, so the can opener is awlso out in rhe photo (it's been getting a workout lately).
[attach id=0 msg=2499714]

-
Day 8
The coffee maker needed a thorough cleaning; out came Blue. Good as new! (Other than the warmer has now a crinkled finish, ad it is used 3-4 times a day!) [attach id=0 msg=2499721]

-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
