Off-brand October Challenge
-
That brand is decent. Better than most of the other pseduo-MREs I've tried (which isn't a ton, admittedly.) The two big differences I notice between them and the genuine surplus:
-
Lower variety. I've only ever gotten crackers or tortillas in the bread slot, cheese in the spread slot, and I think three things in the snack slot (corn nuts, dried fruit, trail mix).
-
The "goo" slot (protein shake, fruit puree, etc.) doesn't exist. I think the overall calorie count is somewhat lower (not a bad thing, I'm not humping around with 100 pounds of gear) and most of their drinks are sugar sweetened instead of zero cal, so they don't have the calories to "spend" there.
Not as good as the real thing, but passable for a lazy civilian (and I'd certainly be happy to eat it if we got smacked with a blizzard or something and the power was out).
Day 23
Scissors and file helped install a hammer mod on this Skeletool CX. Still not sure how I feel about the Skeletool. I think what I really want is something halfway between the Signal and the Skeletool for office carry. 4" form factor, lose the outdoor gadgets, swap the saw for a file, and I'd be a happy non-camper. I'd call it the Secretary to keep the S theme, and because it'd be like a good secretary. Mostly stays out of the way, but handles 90% of the work around the office.

-
-
There could be a Skeletool in my future. Some of those spiffy color schemes are really eye-catching. If Leatherman added a file and good scissors to a Skeletool without substantially increasing the price, it would probably sell like hotcakes.
-
Day 24
Adjusted the pivot on this CRKT M-16 a bit looser for easier opening with the tab. I don't think I've ever had a knife that was easier to flick open then use the stud.

-
Day 26
Ruike opening a Jarritos.

-
I'm gonna look for that when I make the Saturday Meijer run! -
Day 26
Very busy day for the Storm. Cutting rope, opening packages, bending wire. Closed down the camper for the season, and didn't get a chance to pause for a pic during the work. Here it is with the strop tonight when I touched up the edge a bit.

-
Day 27
Apologies for the pseudo-repeat, but I spent a good chunk of the day working on the M16. In the end I removed the broken/modded LAWKs "washer" replaced it with a "regular" one from the hardware store up the street. I had to dremel out the center a bit wider, but that wasn't too bad. Put it back together a couple different ways and found one that locks up tight and opens and closes smooth. Kind of a pain in the butt, but it's always nice to take something apart and tweak it. Really feels like "my" knife now. Awlso touched up the edge. Looking forward to carrying it.

-
Day 28
Ruike opened up this telescoping lantern/speaker. It's gonna go on the porch to play spooky noises and help the trick or treaters find their way on Thursday.

-
I haven't had trick-or-treaters in probably at least a decade. But it sounds like the lantern could help keep the little sprogs safe.

-
Apparently it's a big deal in our new neighborhood. I guess we'll find out.
Day 29
Peeled an orange with the hook cutter. Gotta test it out if it's going to be an Executive replacement. It sliced well, but the orange was pretty tough. I think that's the fruit's fault, not the knife's.

-
Looks like a webbing/cord cutter or a gut hook. Pretty neat take on the combo tool!

-
Day 30
End of challenge glam shot. It's late here, I'll post my thoughts tomorrow. All in all, I think both tools are passable, but not sure I'd go so far as to recommend either.

-
Alright, thoughts on these tools before I move onto black carry month.
Ruike S31
[attach id=0 msg=2502580]
As I said at the start of the challenge, this has gotten trotted out as a potential Executive replacement ever since Victorinox discontinued them. It is not. It only has like half the tools! That's not to say it's a bad knife. I like the nice deep belly on the main blade. The cutting hook is great for opening packages and oranges both. The screwdriver is a larger head than the Executive, which I think is a small win overall. The scissors are a resounding meh. They jimped handle isn't super comfortable and they're passable cutters. I miss the nail file, T&T, etc. If you don't like the nailfile and want something bigger than a Classic/Rambler, there's a niche there. It's cheaper than the Rambler, which is something. Good construction, holds an edge well. Certainly the best "off brand" knife in this category I've ever used.
Roxon Storm
[attach id=1 msg=2502580]
(Curl for scale)The scissors are really the story here. They're good scissors. Sizable, cut well (maybe not quite as well as the Vic scissors, but the size makes up for a lot), and comfortable to use. But they're big. They push the tool into the size/weight category of something like a ST300 or Swisstool (not Spirit). The size and variety of the other tools isn't up to those kinds of standards, so you're left with a light duty tool in a heavy duty form factor, with a pair of scissors added on. Again, that's not an unreasonable niche, but it is bit niche. The tools all worked well. I admit that the saw issue is probably more because I tried to cut up a pumpkin (it worked great on actual wood) than any fault by Roxon. And they had the best warranty experience I've ever gone through. New tool with minimal fuss in under two weeks, and I got to keep the old one, which I was able to repair with nothing more than a screwdriver.
Both of these are very acceptable tools. At the price point ($25 for the Ruike and $45 for the Storm) they're very strong in their respective categories. If you want something different, a specific toolset, or are looking for something more budget friendly they'll do great. As a basic EDC, I think some of the more established options offer a more well rounded choice.


Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login