Leatherman Signal challenge: October 2024
-
Day 29
[attach id=0 msg=2502319]

-
-
@JonesE: you've been on a roll lately!

@Cypren: organization is awlways a good thing.

@Rich_SD: hope you don't have a huge backlog of laundry. And you may or may not like the post I have planned for tomorrow.

@Juan el Boricua: I agree with the sentiment on your mug!

Day 29
I hadn't tested the hammer yet. Let's get on it.
[attach id=0 msg=2502341]
Most of the damage was done with the first strike. I did about 20 strikes total (split roughly evenly between front and back), which was about 15 too many. The hammer is seriously uncomfortable to use with the hot spots created by the ferro rod and sharpener. For me, that's the worst aspect of the Signal...it's in dire need of a rethink.
[attach id=1 msg=2502341]
To make matters worse, the Signal lost some of its paint with all those strikes. Everything still opens and closes well, though.
.jpg)
.jpg)
-
Day 29
Putting up more pegboard in the garage and starting to get more stuff out of boxes and off the floor and up onto the walls. The Signal did duty as package opener, staple remover and screwdriver throughout the day.
[attach id=0 msg=2502357]

-
I really should have joined this challenge lol. Thanks for all the pictures. Here's part of my Signal collection

-
Day 29:
(Again I fell asleep before I could post the picture..)
Tried to open canned beef without the dedicated key, and without a can opener (because I don't have one on this Signal).
Was an epic fail, the can tore appart very badly: the strip that is meant to peal off broke...
I could eat eventually, but it was a pain to get to it.[attach id=0 msg=2502373]
[attach id=1 msg=2502373]
Conclusion : use dedicated tools as much as possible. Note that it is not against the Signal specifically, would have turned out as bad with any multitool assuming I had also removed the can opener


-
Day 28
I thought I posted yesterday, but I must have not it postOpen some mail containing gifts for the wife.
Day 29
Spent the day out hiking. No use, so glamour shot

-
@Cypren: good to see that things are falling into place!
@grouch: quite the group you have there!
@m47mu74nt: agreed on the proper tool, but your determination is admirable!
@Sos24: looks like a nice place to spend a day!
Now it's time for some thoughts on the Signal. I prefer a plain edge blade, and the flat bit driver isn't the greatest. The pliers, saw, opener, and awl are great. Tools that are specific to the Signal leave a little to a lot to be desired. While the pop-out tools are a little small, they at least lend themselves to customization. Far and away the worst feature is the hammer thing: it's too small and uncomfortable to use effectively, and it eliminates a spot for other, more useful tools. I'd like to see a New Signal with the hammer eliminated, some outdoors-oriented tool that's exclusive to the Signal added, and the sharpener and ferro rod carried in loops on the sheath. Though I enjoyed putting it through its paces, and will keep it in my camping kit, the spiffy colors aren't enough to make me want to buy more of the current iteration.
Day 30
Finishing the challenge with another Signal and coffee photo, this time featuring my new mug.
[attach id=0 msg=2502389]
Rich_SD might not be overly fond of the mug, but I know Sos24 will love it.

[attach id=1 msg=2502389]
It has been great having y'awl along for this challenge. Thanks for making it great, and don't forget to request your badges!
.jpg)
.jpg)
-

I like your new mug!

-
Day 30
Let it be known that even a major medical issue can’t keep me away from a MTO challenge. I didn’t get to use my tool as much as other challenges, but I finished!

For what it is, the Signal is an excellent tool, and I can see why it is so popular with the camping/outdoors niche market. I really like its size, form factor, and the feel in my hand. That said, the Signal is not for me – most of its tools are not useful to me (ferro rod, signal whistle, mini-sharpener, saw, and can opener). I also prefer plain edge blades over partially serrated blades because plain edge is much easier to sharpen.
Modifying my Signal during this challenge has made it perfect for me. Now it has all of the tools I use the most, and none that I don’t need. After a challenge, I normally clean up my knife/tool and store it away in my collection, but my modified Signal has definitely earned a place in my frequently carried pile.

-
Day 30
Thanks for having me along on the challenge. It was a great opportunity to get to use the Signal more frequently than I would have used it. I truly enjoyed everyone’s posts. Especially the discussion about what has worked for them and what hasn’t. I really liked seeing all of the mods that were done to the platform. I limited myself on a few to the printed parts. That helped, but I felt changed the whole aspect of the design. For me, I am more of what you would call an urban carry. I prefer tools that more closely match my lifestyle. The Signal is clearly more focused at the outdoor/camping community. I am glad Leatherman made the tool. Options are great to have.
JonesE
-
Day 30
The Signal is a pretty robust, well-layed out tool but, not an EDC one for me. Although I appreciate having the Rebar's pliers head, sturdy and robust knife, such a compact and easy to work with chassis and "the basics" (I saw the Signal as a Skeletool on steroids), I found that the blade, having the plain edge so far from my hand, and the harsh ergonomics (to my small-mediumish ungloved hand) made whittling and precision cuts difficult; being unable to use the driver without splaying handles or attaching an extension reduced minimalism, and (a BIG surprise to me, as I thought differently before the challenge!) having to pick either a file or saw but not have both, was cumbersome. I still love its form factor and utility, and will still carry them occasionally but, found out that Blue will never replace the Bladed Bladeless MP as my EDC of choice. Thank you Farmer and all participants for a gratifying experience. See you in the threads! [attach id=0 msg=2502449]

-
Day 30:
Found my coyote Signal flirting with a Fox Zero

-
Well the month was pretty fun, Signal was also already my go-to EDC so it wasn't much different, but it did force me to try before reaching for a dedicated tool
-
Thank you again to awl who made this a great challenge!
It was particularly interesting reading everyone's thoughts on the Signal after 30 days. Opinions weren't as polarizing as I thought they might have been. Stay tuned, as I have a little bonus cooking up. 
-
Day 30
Last day with the Signal. It served duty today mostly as a box cutter and wire snips.
After a month of using it, I can't say I'll be sorry to be sending this one back into the depths of the collection cabinet. Maybe, as others have said, it's just that this is a bad fit for me and my "urban carry" lifestyle, but would be great for frequent campers and backpackers, but there are certain decisions they made (like the bit driver) that I'm pretty comfortable just saying are objectively badly designed.
Anyway, here's a sendoff photo of the Signal surrounded by the knives I'll be carrying for next month's challenge and the Arc I'll be relieved to be carrying again for the one-day gap in between.
[attach id=0 msg=2502481]

-
Day 30
Just some box opening and outdoor coffee, but no picture. So you get a picture of the Signal and a notebookIt was a fun challenge but I am glad it is done, because I just prefer my SAKs.
The Signal is a unique tool and has some use, but for outdoors I prefer an Outrider or Farmer X. I find the mods that make it more an urban tool interesting.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

