My 3DC
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Notes for designing things in the future... take more photos of the thing I'm designing a component for, measure a lot more things and take better notes. Also, in a case like this, if the thing is small enough, take it with me for test fitting, if not actual testing, then send the thing along with the new parts.Same experience and conclusion here. If the item can't be taken along then I try to take pictures with the ruler/ caliper/ micrometer and their actual measurements in the picture. Two pictures with one zoomed out if needed. That helps to remove any issues with remembering what the measurements were of.
For certain parts it is easier to use a physical reference. For instance if some parts has been bolted with a freehand holes anywhere technique it is measurement smurf to try and match the hole pattern. Putting some pointy bits in the holes and pressing down a plate or similar will reproduce the positions just fine though. For organic shapes, keys or similar the best solution I've come up with is imprints or castings. Or the profile curve replicator tools carpenters use if the shape is just 2 dimensional.
Anyone tried reasonably priced 3D scanners for such tasks?
-
I have used an app for my phone called Polycam and it seems to work well enough for larger things- like a coworker for example. I have also tried to scan smaller items like a Leatherman Signal and it didn't come out that well.
As I understand it, most iPhones come with but in LIDAR nowadays and so the app will probably work better on that. Why the heck an Phone needs LIDAR I'll never know, but it's nice that they justify the insane prices somehow.

I've also been looking at dedicated scanners and while most are the cost of a small car, there are some that are quite reasonable.
The guys that made my printer (XYZPrinting) used to make a model that was both a 3D scanner and printer in one, and I thought that was pretty freaking sweet. I don't know how well it worked, and given that they have since gone out of business, it probably wasn't great. Still a cool concept though- a 3D photocopier would be a very neat concept.
Def
-
You could try using an Xbox Kinect.
-
@Vidar said:
Anyone tried reasonably priced 3D scanners for such tasks?I've used a few. 3D scanners with prices below five figures are generally not accurate enough to help with CAD and fabrication. The point clouds they generate are simply too coarse, movement mechanisms don't have enough rigidity to prevent artfacting and their scale is inconsistent and almost always has to be manually tweaked using known reference measurements to produce something even vaguely usable.
They're mostly tools for artists who want to bring physical objects into virtual scenes where measurements are arbitrary and precision is unnecessary. Fabricators are almost always going to be much better-served by sinking the money into quality calipers and a micrometer and taking the necessary measurements by hand.
-
@Cypren said:
They're mostly tools for artists who want to bring physical objects into virtual scenes where measurements are arbitrary and precision is unnecessary. Fabricators are almost always going to be much better-served by sinking the money into quality calipers and a micrometer and taking the necessary measurements by hand.That has been my impression too, but as it is a few years since I checked last I had hoped there had been some progress.
Some years ago I tried photogrammetry and some 50+ photos from various angles. The result was visually okish, but again, hardly CAD precision. Structured light might have helped I suppose.
Anyway, thanks for the update.

-
The value of a 3D scanner in my mind, is the ability to (relatively) quickly recreate a design.
In my mind, I see it as being a way to take a broken component that can be fitted back together, scan it quickly and, if possible, fire directly into the printer for a replacement component. If the piece is too broken, take the scan into Fusion or other software and fix it before printing.
Sure the replacement component may not be as strong as the original, but I feel like it is a good fix until an actual replacement can be brought in.
The example I use is a shelf bracket or plastic hinge part for a fridge/freezer. If it breaks, you really can't use the item until a replacement can be obtained.
Sure you can probably get the component on Amazon these days, but it's not likely you can wait two days with no door on the freezer.
So, duct tape the door shut, remove and scan the part, print a new one and repair the hinge. While it's printing, order a proper replacement. When it's done printing, print a second one, just in case.
It doesn't have to be perfect, it doesn't have to match, but it gets you closer than having to do all the measuring yourself.
Def
-
I've developed a new 3D printing rule that probably should have been obvious, but I hadn't encountered until recently.
FRIENDS DON'T LET FRIENDS USE CHEAP FILAMENT.
It's easier said than done though, as I wasn't aware I was using lower quality filament until it was done. I will absolutely be making a note of this brand and ensuring that they never get any money from me again.
These are two identical parts, both printed with PLA filament, which is the only kind my printer will use. I don't think I need to tell you which one is the crappy one, even if you don't know a thing about 3D printing. It's pretty obvious that the layer adhesion is severely lacking resulting in gaps, cracks and an overall crappy product.
Using good filament however, produces a beautiful product that you can be proud of!
With some filaments, like the iridescent stuff I used on the Juice sheath, I kind of expect it to be less than ideal because it has other qualities that are of interest.
The bright green filament doesn't even have that going for it. The color may be nice, but it's nothing special and the super crappy finish means you don't even see the color anyways.
Maybe after some sanding and polishing it would look okay, but with all the gaps it isn't going to function very well.
The olive colored one on the other hand, was done in the same machine, from the same file, with all the same settings and looks absolutely perfect, straight out of the printer.
Def



-
That green does look ready for recycling.. I guess it is chance it needed drying or other settings, but no need for the grief and work when you already have other great stuff.
As for 3D scanners I guess it is a matter of needed geometric precision whether the result can be used for the intended purpose - and then the value of that purpose. Over time I expect precision to increase and costs to decrease until it gets interesting for me. (There are certainly very precise scanners available today, so the technology is there already, but the costs are not worth it for my sporadic use).
-
Yeah, I have done a few models with it and been disappointed each time. I kept thinking that it was something I'd done wrong, like maybe stored it at an improper humidity or temperature, had the settings wrong in the machine, had too cheap a machine etc. In the end it seems that the filament, or at least my usage of it, is no good. I hate to blame my tools (or materials), especially when it's something I am still relatively new to, but I think it's safe to say that this material just isn't much good.
I also have some high gloss black material that seems only good for making spaghetti monsters, but I'm not ready to call that one just yet. I am getting close though...

Oh, and a roll of white stuff that seems uninterested in doing what it's supposed to, but again, I'm not ready to call that one just yet either.
But, half the fun of this kind of thing is figuring stuff out, and I've probably got or used a dozen rolls of different colors and types, and so far I've only had a few that didn't work as intended. Some better than others for sure, but this green is the only actual fail so far.
But, if I am being honest, it does work well enough in that if I needed to make something out of it, it would probably work out. It wouldn't be the best quality, it wouldn't be the nicest finish, but I could manage something out of it.
Def
-
Just for reference, what brand is it?
I always print a temp tower with each new color/brand that I buy to see what temp it prints best at just to be safe. This has saved me from several headaches.
-
It was XYZPrinting brand, the same brand as the machine I have.
In fact, now that I have checked, the other colors that I have been having a problem with (white and black mentioned above) are also XYZPrinting, and so I think it's safe to say that you should probably avoid that brand entirely. That should be pretty easy, as I believe they have gone out of business.
That having been said, I had a number of spools of their filament and they weren't all bad. None stand out as particularly great, but I had initially bought them as I figured the best choice for this machine would be the same brand- aka the recommended filament. XYZPrinting even went so far as to put a chip in the rolls of filament to ensure that you use their stuff- the machine won't print without a chipped spool on it. And, since each spool is chipped, the software also measures how much is used. When a spool is empty, the chip is no longer valid.
If you want to use aftermarket filament you have to buy their generic spool chip, which I did.
I also found that many brands of spools won't fit on their chip bracket and spool holder, so I just leave an empty spool with the chip in the hanger and feed the machine from another spool hung behind it.

It's kind of an annoying and inefficient setup, but it works.
Def
-
This particular use of a 3D printer never occurred to me. I guess I just have different priorities!
Def

-
Hm. Wonder if I can print some extrusion forms for pasta? Seeing as I'm not smoking ribs I mean.
SAK cake forms? Should go great with layers...

-
As long as you are baking the cakes at less than 150 C you should be okay! :ahhh
I also printed a bumper for my new DJI Neo. I don't believe it needs it, but all the cool kids are putting them on so I figured I might as well do it too.
I used the lightest of these ones figuring this is just an extra bumper on top of the existing factory bumpers. If it gets destroyed I may try a heavier version.
Def
-
Oops, forgot the pic.
Def

-
@Vidar said:
Flexible rubber version? Bend and bounce instead of breaking. Foam or 3D strusses?As I said, my printer doesn't support fancy materials for that kind of thing so I have just printed it in regular, hard PLA.
It should protect the camera somewhat, although to be honest I really don't feel like it needs it. I watched a video where a guy flew it repeatedly into trees, brick walls, concrete seawalls etc at speeds of around 45kph and the drone stood up to it. And, if the Neo does get damaged, I have the insurance and can replace it for about $20. I was more interested in seeing how well it printed, and it's got a few flaws. For example I think there was some of the other green blobbed in the head that came out because there were a few layers that didn't look right. I must have missed that the last time I cleaned the head?
I printed one for my father's Neo as well, and it came out much better. :D
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
It should protect the camera somewhat, although to be honest I really don't feel like it needs it. I watched a video where a guy flew it repeatedly into trees, brick walls, concrete seawalls etc at speeds of around 45kph and the drone stood up to it.Sounds like a drone adapted to my skill level! :ahhh
-
This one, oddly enough is well adapted to every skill level as it bypasses the weakest link. It eliminates the silly component between the remote and the ground.
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
