locks,do we need them on edc?
-
IMO, for most edc tasks you don't need a lock, but it's a nice added bonus. If the law wasn't like it was here I would carry a locking folder all the time as IMO there would be no reason not too.
-
As it's already been said, it's not necessary but it is something that you would want if you had to do a tough job with your EDC knife/tool.
-
@heavy handed said:
i only ask this as i have tried all of my daily edc tasks with a crkt lake laredo and my non-locking vix solo and my solo has never closed in use, even after using it to cut a plastic bucket to get under a sink to catch a leak.i suppose im trying to justify the uk laws in my own head.

These days I'd always choose to carry a lockback like the Laredo over a similar one blade slippy like the Solo.
There's really no good reason to give up that extra margin of safety provided by a locking blade.
There is no justification for the UK knife laws, which IMO are a sign of creeping fascism in the UK. At best the laws were promulgated by well intentioned incompetents. At worst by politicians hungry for ever greater power over the people of the UK.
.
-
I've managed to slice my hands on slippies, but I still carry them and mostly do just fine, if you use it how it is supposed to be used, then there's no worries.
NEVERTHELESS
Lots of people feel they don't need seat belts, and most of them don't end up being thrown through their windscreens into woodchippers*, and yet you can't buy a car without a seatbelt?
I don't want locks to be required on my knives, certainly, but it takes a jackass (or, apparently, the Queen) to actually BAN a safety feature.
*Or maybe they do? I don't subscribe to WoodChipper Deaths Monthly, so I could be missing out on a whole heap of statistics here.
(I was going to go with a less extreme example than seatbelts, eg. gel cushioned shoe inserts? Not necessary, but added comfort!)
-
My issue is not the locks, but the people using them. Gone are the days when a man taught his son how to use a slipjoint pocketknife, taught him what to do and what not to do, taught him HOW to use a knife safely.
Well, maybe not gone, it seems to be getting there.
I have seen countless examples of young men, and even teens, really leaning into a knife to cut something big, and when I question them, they say "So what? It's got a lock on it, doesn't it?" This complacency is what hurts us because there seems to be no awareness of the lock's limitations. It seems to run parallel with the rest of society, though. People have grown complacent in ALL aspects of life, totally depending on others to live their lives for them and more then that, EXPECTING other to do so. If they get hurt, it's someone else's fault. If they cause harm to someone, it's someone else's fault. If the knife closes on their hands, it wasn't that they were doing something wrong, it's that the lock was loose, or it was a Chinese piece of crap knife, or.....! We here at MT.O are a different breed. For the most part, we are all handy tinkerers who use our noggin a little more then the average man and can figure out how to use a tool the right way. Sure, we mess up on occassion, but from what I've read on here, 9 times out of 10, we blame our selves for the injury. However, most are not like that. THAT'S why i feel locking knives should NOT be given to youths. Let them learn, first and foremost, HOW to use a knife safely. Let them learn all the little things that make a huge difference. Never cut towards you, cut away. Never apply too much pressure in the wrong direction or the blade will close on you. Try not to thrust and stab too hard. Little things, you know? Only THEN should they be "rewarded" with a locking blade, if they even consider that a reward. Some, like myself, don't like locking knives. A slipjoint will do whatever I need it to. Once they have the basics mastered, it's up to them to choose what they want to carry.
Sorry for the rant. Just needed to get that off my chest. -
My issue is not the locks, but the people using them. Gone are the days when a man taught his son how to use a slipjoint pocketknife, taught him what to do and what not to do, taught him HOW to use a knife safely.
Well, maybe not gone, it seems to be getting there.
I have seen countless examples of young men, and even teens, really leaning into a knife to cut something big, and when I question them, they say "So what? It's got a lock on it, doesn't it?" This complacency is what hurts us because there seems to be no awareness of the lock's limitations. It seems to run parallel with the rest of society, though. People have grown complacent in ALL aspects of life, totally depending on others to live their lives for them and more then that, EXPECTING other to do so. If they get hurt, it's someone else's fault. If they cause harm to someone, it's someone else's fault. If the knife closes on their hands, it wasn't that they were doing something wrong, it's that the lock was loose, or it was a Chinese piece of crap knife, or.....! We here at MT.O are a different breed. For the most part, we are all handy tinkerers who use our noggin a little more then the average man and can figure out how to use a tool the right way. Sure, we mess up on occassion, but from what I've read on here, 9 times out of 10, we blame our selves for the injury. However, most are not like that. THAT'S why i feel locking knives should NOT be given to youths. Let them learn, first and foremost, HOW to use a knife safely. Let them learn all the little things that make a huge difference. Never cut towards you, cut away. Never apply too much pressure in the wrong direction or the blade will close on you. Try not to thrust and stab too hard. Little things, you know? Only THEN should they be "rewarded" with a locking blade, if they even consider that a reward. Some, like myself, don't like locking knives. A slipjoint will do whatever I need it to. Once they have the basics mastered, it's up to them to choose what they want to carry.Off topic rant for a moment here-
Is it just me, or is all this nostalgia a bunch of rabbit pellets?
I don't know how they do things in Texas or Saskatchewan, but being competent and intelligent has nothing to do with sitting on grand-pappies knee and learning to whittle.(I also rather imagine that most people are sensible, but "Man enjoys knife sensibly, a good time had by all" is fairly bland news. Try to remember for every one self-decapitation, a thousand people manage to not get their nuts stuck in a lawnmower every day.)
Anyway, not trying to pick a fight, I agree with your conclusions, if not the path taken to reach them.
(I am a little curious about my recent trend towards landscaping equipment fatalities? Maybe I should mention that one to the head-doctor)
-
Competence and intelligence are illusion. They are taught. It's like common sense. It is taught. Who teaches it to us? it SHOULD be our parents. Parents came before us. Thus, nostalgia.
I don't know how they do things in Texas or Saskachewan either, but that's usually the order of things. Grandpa teaches it to dad, dad teaches it to son, son teaches it HIS son, etc. Pellets? Sounds like the law of nature to me.
Just saying. -
Competence and intelligence are illusion.
.....
I am not high enough for that conversation.
People have grown complacent in ALL aspects of life, totally depending on others to live their lives for them and more then that, EXPECTING other to do so.
on others...people?
How many people do we have to work with here?
See, this is why "isms" are great. Instead of trying to indeterminately say "people" and "people" we can say "those damn whitey crackers are getting lazy and making the blackfellas do all the work"
or "if it weren't for women, the country wouldn't be in a financial crisis"
You've got to blame specific groups! (above statements given as examples only, keep your shirts on and your anti-nomad sign waving wives at home, where they should be, cooking and getting you a beer)
I know some prize winning imbeciles, and I guess it's those sorts of people that Laws are in place to protect (or to protect us from?)
but some people can't be helped, and they can't be helped any better when they're 50 than they can be when they're 15.I'm not going to blame a religion, I'm not going to blame a gender, or even people between 4' 9" & 5' 6" (even if they are the cause of all wars), and I'm not going to blame parents, society, or youth.
It's up to any person (and I know countries disagree on when a child becomes a real person, with personalities and rights and toilet training and whathaveyou) to learn for themselves, and that responsibility is on them.
I might not be coherent, it's past 1am here :P
Also I'm aware I'm slightly bitter, since I was never a boyscout, I never had a "coach", and I never passed anything at school. I am, for all intents and purposes, an ignorant, uneducated man - and yet, I take responsibility for my actions*, and I like to think I learn from them every day.
*With the possible exception of abusing people on online forums, for which I use a nome de plume, and try to only pick on people too far away to do anything about it :D
To return to the topic, I reiterate my statement that I do not think Locks are strictly necessary, but there's not too many reasons NOT to have them.
You know it makes sense.
-
Competence and intelligence are illusion.
.....
I am not high enough for that conversation.
People have grown complacent in ALL aspects of life, totally depending on others to live their lives for them and more then that, EXPECTING other to do so.
on others...people?
How many people do we have to work with here?
See, this is why "isms" are great. Instead of trying to indeterminately say "people" and "people" we can say "those damn whitey crackers are getting lazy and making the blackfellas do all the work"
or "if it weren't for women, the country wouldn't be in a financial crisis"
You've got to blame specific groups! (above statements given as examples only, keep your shirts on and your anti-nomad sign waving wives at home, where they should be, cooking and getting you a beer)
I know some prize winning imbeciles, and I guess it's those sorts of people that Laws are in place to protect (or to protect us from?)
but some people can't be helped, and they can't be helped any better when they're 50 than they can be when they're 15.I'm not going to blame a religion, I'm not going to blame a gender, or even people between 4' 9" & 5' 6" (even if they are the cause of all wars), and I'm not going to blame parents, society, or youth.
It's up to any person (and I know countries disagree on when a child becomes a real person, with personalities and rights and toilet training and whathaveyou) to learn for themselves, and that responsibility is on them.
I might not be coherent, it's past 1am here :P
Also I'm aware I'm slightly bitter, since I was never a boyscout, I never had a "coach", and I never passed anything at school. I am, for all intents and purposes, an ignorant, uneducated man - and yet, I take responsibility for my actions*, and I like to think I learn from them every day.
*With the possible exception of abusing people on online forums, for which I use a nome de plume, and try to only pick on people too far away to do anything about it :D
To return to the topic, I reiterate my statement that I do not think Locks are strictly necessary, but there's not too many reasons NOT to have them.
You know it makes sense.
Others. What else could others mean in that particular sentence? I mean, it couldn't POSSIBLY be anything else. You can dig for further meaning, but others is self explanitory in that situation. I know it helps with a reply to tear a post apart, but this time..... not so much. If I had put people, you would have said "What people?" If I had put adults, whites, blacks, latinos, martians, etc, you would have questioned it.
Simple sentence. Simple messege. Will not elaborate because it can't be simplified more then it is.Also, easy on the "White crackers making the blackfellas" and "If it were women..." comments. Racism and sexism are not tolerated on this site, nor should they. What people? I only know of ONE people in this world, unless there is a type of eight headed, tail having, winged humans, then people are people, ALL subject to the same actions, mistakes, and misunderstandings. Blame specific groups? There's only one group, and you're a part of it.
If you learn anything today, learn that.
And don't cut towards you either. LOL. -
Cor blimey :o
I like a lock, don't need a lock, can't really carry a lock. Moot point in the UK!
My EDC is usually a SAK or non-locking MT along with a UKPK. I blame myself 100% whenever I have drawn my own blood.... just like I did last week on holiday with a very sharp axe :D
I don't think kids should carry anything which locks at all - they need to learn not to be idiots with sharps.
-
I like a lock, don't need a lock, can't really carry a lock. Moot point in the UK!
My EDC is usually a SAK or non-locking MT along with a UKPK. I blame myself 100% whenever I have drawn my own blood.... just like I did last week on holiday with a very sharp axe :D
I don't think kids should carry anything which locks at all - they need to learn not to be idiots with sharps.
What does "cor blimey" mean? Is that like "holy sh*t"?
-
Yes, kinda :D
It's a very east London thing, which is where I was born.
-
I was talking to a female colleague today about how locking knives are regarded under UK law. She could not understand how a locker would be illegal since the lock was obviously there in order to make the knife safer to use. The female perspective here is pure logic

-
@Magic Bus said:
I was talking to a female colleague today about how locking knives are regarded under UK law. She could not understand how a locker would be illegal since the lock was obviously there in order to make the knife safer to use. The female perspective here is pure logic
It's a shame it's not shared by our ''better's'' ::)
-
@LatinoHeat said:
Competence and intelligence are illusion. They are taught. It's like common sense. It is taught. Who teaches it to us? it SHOULD be our parents. Parents came before us. Thus, nostalgia.no offence LatinoHeat but competence and intelligence are not taught. they can be incouraged but stupid is stupid. average intelligence is the ability to understand what is going on. to be intelligent is to understand why it is going on. i of course have neither of these atributes.
most peole learn from their mistakes... smart people learn from the mistakes of others. one could suggest that neither of these behaviors are taught by anyone but self or even personality traits.
most of my life i've carried slip joint knives. as much b/c that's what i saw others carry and use. there was no teaching really... that's all i knew.
now i have come to carry a locking knife. not b/c others do but exactly b/c i think it offers more usefulness and safety to me. it's also lighter, stronger, thinner, and quicker.
you don't need to EDC a locking blade but for me a locking knife is common sense. -
Hate to disagree with you, sappy, but intelligence is not understanding why something is going on. Someone has to teach you why something is going on. A child knows it is hot out. He doesn't understand why. You put someone in a room their whole life, teach them nothing, and then release them into the world, they won't even know what grass is, much less know why. It is taught. Again, like common sense. Intelligence is potential, more then anything. Potential to learn, potential to understand. Capacity, if you will, to know all. However, in order to understand and know, one must be taught. Life taught me not to cut the wrong way. A painful lesson, yes, but I had to be taught. If there is no lesson, there is no understanding. However, that's just me. Like I've said before, I explain myself and my thought process, but I in no way push this on anyone. Different strokes for different folks. In the end, all that matters is not whether there is a lock on our knives, but if we can use it as a bottle opener so we can all have a drink together!!!

-
Locks are not necessary until your folder slips and folds on your fingers :D
-
Others. What else could others mean in that particular sentence? I mean, it couldn't POSSIBLY be anything else. You can dig for further meaning, but others is self explanitory in that situation. I know it helps with a reply to tear a post apart, but this time..... not so much. If I had put people, you would have said "What people?" If I had put adults, whites, blacks, latinos, martians, etc, you would have questioned it.
Simple sentence. Simple messege. Will not elaborate because it can't be simplified more then it is.Heh, don't worry, it was a semantics thing, and it was enough of a passing fancy not to try to say it again :P
MOVING RIGHT ALONG:
Okay, so of you Pro-Lockers out there, where's the line between "Locks are good!" & "Carrying a Fixed blade"? (laws notwithstanding)
-
Yes we need locks, otherwise things get stolen.....wait....what?! :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login