Australian Knife Laws
-
Looks like I'll go bladeless sooner than I thought.

-
@Huntsman said:
There are exceptions…ceremonial reasons (eg a Scotsman with a kilt on and a dirk in his sock)…I think I could get used to a kilt and a sgian dubh on the daily if that were the only way I could go about with a knife unmolested.
Maybe something like this…
https://claymoreimports.com/the-officer-multi-tool-sgian-dubh-with-badge/ -
- I can't wait to see the pictures -
@nate j said:
I think I could get used to a kilt and a sgian dubh on the daily if that were the only way I could go about with a knife unmolested.Maybe something like this…
https://claymoreimports.com/the-officer-multi-tool-sgian-dubh-with-badge/In Australia, that would be a concealed weapon and get you gaol time, no problem.
They have lost the plot.
But anyone can carry a weapon if they truly want one, and the "authorities" are powerless to stop them.I carry a Cogach with me whenever I travel to places where I feel there may be opportunity for trouble.
I'm 66 years old and even though I have been a black belt for over 30 years, self defense would be, at best, difficult for an old fart like me with my back issues.The Cogach is a traditional English staff, longer than a cane and generally a little more sturdy.
Importantly used in hilly or uneven ground to keep ones balance (but was also known to be used as a weapon when required).I have been stopped by "authorities" for carrying this cane, but they back down when I get antsy about impinging on my disability (I have damaged vertebrae and several blown discs).
I also occasionally carry one of several other "walking sticks" Shillelagh made out of tree roots and small trees, probably better described as lacquered clubs, but with rubber bumpers on the base magically transforming them into "walking sticks".And of course there are my standard brass/ solid silver headed walking sticks, my current favorite being my brass skull mounted on a blackthorn shaft. Not something to get within range of I would suggest.
Would I ever use a knife for self defense?
Not a bloody chance in Hell.
far too permanent and with my training, almost guaranteed nasty for any I used it on.Canes, clubs and staff can be used with more precision to disinterest, injure or disable attackers as required.
With far less chance of terminal results.
My father was attacked by three thugs on a train station when he was 80.
These cowards beat him and threw him down a flight of stairs.
It was all caught on CCTV, but they somehow managed to get off any serious time.
My father was laid up for two months and was afraid to go out as often as he used to after that.I will not be afraid.
I will be the one standing over the attackers laughing as they did my father.
But never with a knife, a knife is a tool.
to me at least. -
My comment was mostly tongue-in-cheek.
I too find it puzzling that a Vic Classic will get confiscated as a weapon, but a stout hickory cane goes through as a mobility aid.
I also carry knives as tools, not weapons. I’m fortunate to live in a place where I can carry virtually any knife I want; even automatics are legal here now.
Would I ever use a knife for self-defense? Ultimately, if I ever had to fight for my life, I would use whatever was to hand to the best of my ability. I also feel fortunate that, while there are a few places that are off limits, I am mostly free to legally go about my state with a pistol in my pocket if/when I choose.
-
@nate j said:
My comment was mostly tongue-in-cheek.I too find it puzzling that a Vic Classic will get confiscated as a weapon, but a stout hickory cane goes through as a mobility aid.
I also carry knives as tools, not weapons. I’m fortunate to live in a place where I can carry virtually any knife I want; even automatics are legal here now.
Would I ever use a knife for self-defense? Ultimately, if I ever had to fight for my life, I would use whatever was to hand to the best of my ability. I also feel fortunate that, while there are a few places that are off limits, I am mostly free to legally go about my state with a pistol in my pocket if/when I choose.
Guns were the first thing the Australian Grubberment banned, and small handguns frighten them so bad that they slap maximum penalties on anyone carrying them.
Now, the only people who have guns are cops and criminals, which possibly could be considered the same demographic in some states.
Even carrying rounds is prohibited and will land you in gaol.
And don't even think of wearing a ballistic vest or even owning one, that is also a gaolable offence.Then there are "illegal" weapons, the ownership of which (even at home) is prohibited.
Butterfly knives, Nun chucks, spears, daggers, "zombie" knives, assisted deployment knives and throwing stars, to name a few.The Victornox Classic is also considered a "dangerous weapon" by our courts.
Although few cops would bother you unless you were being an smurfhole.And, as I stated, at my place of employment, knives are no longer allowed to be carried at all.
Only "Safety knives" are used to open packages.
When did Australians get so pathetic?
Imagine Crocodile Dundee if it was made today, "Thats not a knife, but I cant show you what one looks like because I'm not allowed to carry one"I also find it somewhat hypocritical that the police, border force and detectives carry knives.
Every officer has a Leatherman on his belt, and border force officers I know carry knives as do some detectives.
These aren't weapons, but tools.Sadly, I cannot see a day when draconian law enforcement in Australia will get any better.
Hell, our idiot prime minister wanted to implement Disinformation laws preventing people spreading what they saw as misinformation (by their definition, by a collection of public servants with uncontrolled power).
The only people not mandated under these laws would have been the Grubberment and their media cronies.
Hello thought police 1984.They will eventually get what they want, they always do.
They are working on it through the back door now with "safety laws" and media control for children.
But to use the media, you will have to prove you aren't a child, so you will have to hand over your identification, and we all know why, its so they know who to come after if you bag out the grubberment.You can still buy knives in Australia, for now, but in time ..............
-
@Valkie said:
Imagine Crocodile Dundee if it was made today, "Thats not a knife, but I cant show you what one looks like because I'm not allowed to carry one"
but also 
Yea, the whole mis/disinformation thing is pretty wild. I’m hopeful that, after some very high profile “misses”, it has been discredited throughly enough that we won’t have to hear any more about it. Open debate is healthy and the lifeblood of democracies.
Some examples:
-
The theory that COVID-19 was created in a lab in China and then (probably accidentally) released was once flagged as mis/disinformation. Based on reports and data available today, it seems this is at least a plausible theory, if not the most likely explanation.
-
The Hunter Biden laptop story was similarly flagged as fabricated/planted. Except, that, oops, it turned out to be totally true.
-
-
@Valkie said:
In Australia, that would be a concealed weapon and get you gaol time, no problem.I reckon you could get away with the Skean dubh
Here's the law ....
(3) A reasonable excuse includes the person having the knife in the person’s custody—
(a) because it is reasonably necessary for—
(i) the lawful pursuit of the person’s occupation, education or training, or
(ii) the preparation or consumption of food or drink, or
(iii) participation in a lawful entertainment, recreation or sport, or
(iv) the exhibition of knives for retail or other trade purposes, or
(v) an organised exhibition by knife collectors, or
(vi) the wearing of an official uniform, or
(vii) genuine religious purposes, orWould full highland dress count as (vi) or (vii)? ???

Or I guess I could claim (v) as in:
*It's an official MTo Meet-up and I am going to meet ReamerPunch and Echotech to show them my latest multitool purchases !!
:D
* -
Surely, we ought to have an official Swiss Army Knights uniform that includes at least one SAK.

-
@Huntsman said:
I reckon you could get away with the Skean dubhHere's the law ....
Would full highland dress count as (vi) or (vii)? ???
Or I guess I could claim (v) as in:
*It's an official MTo Meet-up and I am going to meet ReamerPunch and Echotech to show them my latest multitool purchases !!
:D
*
ReferenceThe truth be known, these "Knife laws" serve more than one purpose.
It gives the police the right to search "Anyone" without any real reason to do so that they have never had before.Everyone carries keys, a phone and sometimes something else made of metal that would set off their wands.
This then gives them the "authority" to search the person with more intent.this has been recognized and they smile and say, "well, if you are carrying something deemed illegal that's your own fault"
Soon these powers will spread until you are forced to carry an ID or if you belong to any identified group, or wandering outside you allotted area. You may end up having to wear a star, crucifix or something to identify you as from another area outside your allotted space. or simply to identify you as a potential threat to society based on their perceptions or the flavor of the month for these numpties.This is an extract of news item recently.....
*Have they worked elsewhere?
Queensland Police statistics showed 641 weapons were confiscated as a result of more than 66,000 scans carried out in a 14 month period.That means weapons were found in about one in every 100 scans.
Is that a success?
Margo van Felius was part of a team that reviewed Queensland's initial trial of the laws.
The detective-turned-Griffith University criminology lecturer said every knife taken off the streets was a good thing, and that feelings of community safety increased as a result of the trial.
"But … we couldn't find whether that was because of the wanding, or whether that was because there were more police officers on the beat," Dr van Felius said.
So are they a good idea?
There's no definitive answer because, as the Griffith University team reported, there is an inherent tension in laws like this."There is just two sides of the coin here. One side is searching people without reasonable suspicion, which impacts on human rights," Dr van Felius said.
"The other side of the coin is ... wanding does allow police a greater detection of knives.
"But you're only going to find these knives on that person if you are, obviously, wanding that person."
The Griffith review also noted "net widening" as a concern when people are wanded.
"They might have keys in their pocket so then they were asked to empty their pockets," Dr van Felius said.
"They then also might have a little bag of cannabis or some other drugs."
It means where police would normally need to meet certain criteria to search someone for drugs, they were able to conduct a type of search without meeting those thresholds.*
Every inch is an inch closer to total control
-
@Valkie said:
Queensland Police statistics showed 641 weapons were confiscatedI’m curious how many of these were run-of-the-mill pocket knives.
@Valkie said:
The detective-turned-Griffith University criminology lecturer said every knife taken off the streets was a good thing.If we give this sort of vapid nonsense the standing of a logical argument, nearly anything can be justified.

-
@nate j said:
I’m curious how many of these were run-of-the-mill pocket knives.If we give this sort of vapid nonsense the standing of a logical argument, nearly anything can be justified.

It would be interesting to know this information, and what the person carrying them actually planned to use them for.
As a boy scout in the 60-70s we always carried a small folding knife on our belt.
We used them for many things, but I can never remember them ever being used as a weapon.
My father, a gentleman and a gentle man, always carried a small knife.
He had few teeth and loved fruit, so he used it to cut up his fruit.
there is no way on earth he would consider using it as a weapon.But its the same with "speeding" in Australia.
They go on and on about speed kills etc.
But a few years ago they were forced to admit that over 90% of speeding fines were for less than 10kph over the limit.
(Truth be known, the greater portion were under 5kph)So they have changed tactics now.
We are now advised that even 1 kph over some "out of the hat" speed limit is dangerous.
They advertise this as "Casual Speeding" and we are blanketed about how this is a dreadful killer.
In reality, they are using it to justify their draconian speed enforcement, but the road toll is still rising because of the pathetic roads we are expected to drive on rather than speed.Knife laws were originally introduced as a "control" of people who may use knives as weapons.
Mostly from newcomers to Australia, most born and bread Aussies would never use a knife in a fight, they just use their fists.
But, and I stress this strongly, all knife crime that I am aware of has been committed by people who have used huge fixed bladed knives, machete or swords.
I'll bet, ten bob to a trade bit, that no multitool has ever been used as a weapon, they just aren't suited to it, either ergonomically or intimidatory enough.When I was younger, I used to hunt feral pigs.
One of the professional hunters never carried a knife larger than a small 4 inch fixed blade.
He used a 12 inch sharpened screwdriver to dispatch any pigs that were still kicking.
In his words
"Easier to use, easier to penetrate the flesh and got good and deep to the heart"
There was also less blood and mess.We are stuck with knife laws in Australia, draconian as they are.
I will still carry a multitool (when I think I can legally justify it)
But its sad to think that because the grubberment won't punish TRUE knife crime properly, they will make everyone a criminal.
It won't stop knife crime, the same as draconian gun laws haven't stopped shootings.
It just changes the profitability of it, gives them more power and makes it look like they are doing something.First comes wands, then you will need to carry your "papers", then you will need a star or some other visual representation of who or what you are.
THEN THE REAL PERSICUTION WILL START -
@Valkie said:
First comes wands, then you will need to carry your "papers", then you will need a star or some other visual representation of who or what you are.
THEN THE REAL PERSICUTION WILL STARTThis thread is veering into the political and basically a rant against the government. The forum is not the place for this type of thing.
-
@Valkie said:
But its the same with "speeding" in Australia.
They go on and on about speed kills etc.
But a few years ago they were forced to admit that over 90% of speeding fines were for less than 10kph over the limit.
(Truth be known, the greater portion were under 5kph)So they have changed tactics now.
We are now advised that even 1 kph over some "out of the hat" speed limit is dangerous.
They advertise this as "Casual Speeding" and we are blanketed about how this is a dreadful killer.
In reality, they are using it to justify their draconian speed enforcement, but the road toll is still rising because of the pathetic roads we are expected to drive on rather than speed.That’s wild. I feel like, even if one uses the cruise control, speed is going to vary by 3-5 mph / 5-8 kph.
Generally speaking around here, one needs to be going at least 15 mph / 24 kph over the speed limit to get pulled over.
-
@nate j said:
That’s wild. I feel like, even if one uses the cruise control, speed is going to vary by 3-5 mph / 5-8 kph.Generally speaking around here, one needs to be going at least 15 mph / 24 kph over the speed limit to get pulled over.
In Victoria, even 1 kph over the limit will get you a fine.
-
@nate j said:
I’m curious how many of these were run-of-the-mill pocket knives.If we give this sort of vapid nonsense the standing of a logical argument, nearly anything can be justified.

Interesting you say that.
Recently a young "Disturbed" boy, took a large kitchen knife off the shelf in a Coles supermarket and proceeded to stab a worker in the back multiple times.
She survived.
The boy was arrested.
Coles has now taken the sale of ALL knives out of their stores.Wandind didn't help here at all.
The nutcase that went on the rampage some time ago also used a large kitchen knife and when the weapon was knocked from his hand, he ran into another store and grabbed another one.
Police have had to resort to terminal force several times in the last few years to stop a knife wielding attacker, always large kitchen knives.
The common theme here isnt that they were all using a specific type of knife, although large kitchen knives seem to be the weapon of choice, but that all the offenders had a mental problem.
More and more draconian laws around knives isnt cutting it, no pun intended.
Better mental health help would be more effective.
As would more effective punishment for knife crime.**The whole intent of this OP was to point out that we, as knife owners and users of knives, could eventually see the removal of these very useful tools for no good reason.
**
Knives have been carried since man first learned to chip away at a stone and make a sharp tool.
Then he put a handle on it to make it even more useful.
these first "knives" weren't weapons, they were tools, use as a weapon came later.
But there has been an evolution of "knives" over the last 40 to 50 years.
They have become very useful and multifaceted tools that can do everything from sawing through wood to doing up screws.
Unfortunately, some people use them as weapons, but there needs to be a clear distinction between "tools" and "weapons".I see, as the laws become more and more draconian, we will lose the ability to carry anything even vaguely resembling a knife.
And even taking knives from Australians for use anywhere, even in the home.
I note now that many meat packaging offerings these days are already cut up.
How long before ALL meat products are pre-cut so a knife isn't necessary.
And then Banned from use.Sounds far fetched?
look back a few years at just what is now illegal in every country.
Look at how things that were considered normal are now banned.
There are new laws being introduced every day, something like 1 new law every week, every week of the year.
Can we ever understand and be aware of all these laws?
remember "ignorance of the law is no excuse" in every country.
So its quite possible that ALL of us are unknowingly breaking some laws that we are not even aware exist.And it starts in one country and eventually spreads.
I have gone on too long.
Knives to me are tools. Multitools doubly so.
But wea re relinquishing our rights to have tools for reasons that make no real sense.End of rant.
-
Would something like the Roxon Flex work on the Australian Knife Law? : You carry the Tool whitouth the Blade attached outside and when you are on the place where you need the Blade you can just attache it again, or would this not work as the Blade itself is also forbidden even if its not attached to an Handle?
I plan this for the German Knife Law, lets see how this works ..
Sure the Roxons are not that High Quality than Leatherman or Victorinox, but they also work fine ..
It is a bit like in Germany: Most Crimes are made whit Knifes that are not touched by the Law: Big Kitchen Knifes ..
-
@matzesu said:
Would something like the Roxon Flex work on the Australian Knife Law? : You carry the Tool whitouth the Blade attached outside and when you are on the place where you need the Blade you can just attache it again, or would this not work as the Blade itself is also forbidden even if its not attached to an Handle?I plan this for the German Knife Law, lets see how this works ..
Sure the Roxons are not that High Quality than Leatherman or Victorinox, but they also work fine ..
It is a bit like in Germany: Most Crimes are made whit Knifes that are not touched by the Law: Big Kitchen Knifes ..
From what I can make out, and have seen enforced in Australian airports.
ANY tool is considered a weapon.Nail clippers are confiscated as weapons and you are chastised and threatened with arrest.
A small pair of pliers/ screwdrivers as a keyring was confiscated at the airport from me just two years ago. (see picture)Screwdrivers, nail files and even some belt buckles are NO GO.
So its not just bladed knives/ tools that are considered a weapon.
I dont want to carry a weapon, I just want to have a handy tool available, when I need it.

-
@Valkie said:
But wea re relinquishing our rights to have tools for reasons that make no real sense.I believe the ones introducing stricter laws and regulations do it because they think it will help reduce knife related crime. Whether it does, and whether they draw the right distinctions between different kinds of knives and users, are certainly up for discussion.
Even if it does work to some extent that possible gain should be balanced against the lost utility for ordinary law obeying knife users. I think too many argue against knives without any regard for this latter bit. For some the logic seems to be any knife removed, from anyone at any cost, is somehow reducing knife issues. But taking the knife away from a normal user is not reducing any crime. Thus I think life is more complex than that single minded argument, and that the discussion should reflect that.
As an extreme parallel lets take traffic: Every year hundreds of thousands of people are killed every year worldwide in traffic. Many times more are maimed or affected as family and friends. Then there are pollution and other effects as well. Yet, we as a society does not work to ban traffic or cars as such. Like many areas in life we accept there is a risk, and as a society the utility vs loss has been deemed to be at an acceptable balance despite the human losses. And utility here includes just driving around without a cause if you want too - the freedom to do so having some worth in itself for people.
It might not be the best example, and might hit too close to home for many (sorry), but I do miss some of that balanced utility/ loss/ restrictions discussion when it comes to the freedom to carry knives and other tools. (As a side note, if we didn't already have traffic does anyone think it could be introduced today?)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login