AI Vs MTO
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Its interesting that it picked up on the sustainable genetics things but didn't include any of the other stuff I have asked it, like how many potatoes it would take to charge a Tesla Model 3, or how l many times I'd need to rub my feet on the carpet. Or that time I asked whether a small potato or cherry tomato would make a better prosthetic eye and it suggested I use a cocktail onion instead.So without knowing the exact wording of your questions, it's hard to make any confident predictions about why that might be the case. But I can tell you that when I asked it "what do you know about me?", the reason it talked about my laptop was that it's one of the very rare occasions where I started off a question telling it something declarative: "I have a laptop with...", as opposed to asking an abstract question: "if a person has a laptop with...". It's very likely designed to intentionally preserve and retain declarative statements you make about yourself for future use to improve the answers it gives you, while hypotheticals and general questions are limited to the scope of the current conversation that you're having with it. Because every interaction with the system is following a series of predictive decisions, retaining and using any information about you progressively increases the cost of every future interaction you have with it, meaning that they're going to want to be selective about what things are retained between conversations to keep the cost of your future conversations manageable.
Yeah, I ask it a lot of silly things to keep Skynet from getting a proper read on humanity. I want it to underestimate us from time to time, just in case....
I'm guessing this was tongue-in-cheek, but you can be assured that modern large language models like GPT-4 are not a feasible path to Skynet. They have no concept or comprehension of the meaning of what they're outputting, and it's not being done with a human-like reasoning chain that can pursue objectives.
With that said, there are models in development that use neural networks to execute logical reasoning and could potentially be the path forward to AGI (artificial general intelligence), which is what people think of as "AI" in popular concept: a self-aware machine that can reason and creatively pursue both short and long-term objectives and use its successes and failures to self-improve like humans do.
The first model of this type that's become publicly available is GPT-o1, which was debuted to the public 11 days ago. Despite the "GPT" name, it has very little in common with previous GPT models (OpenAI just sucks at naming things) and operates through completely different mechanisms. At the moment, it is slow, clunky, and unbelievably expensive to operate. But what makes it unique is that it's capable of pursuing objectives and self-correcting: in my mapping example, if GPT-4 tells you to drive off a cliff, it's going to happily keep giving you instructions for how to escape a burning car, get through effective physical therapy and continue your trip after you get out of the hospital. GPT-o1 is capable of determining that maybe this isn't a good way to get to your destination and discarding the whole chain of reasoning. What particularly makes this unique is that GPT-o1 is the first model that can produce better answers by throwing more computing power at it. If you give them more processors, GPT-4 and similar models will just give you answers with the same errors, but faster. GPT-o1 will actually give you improved answer quality the more resources it's given, because additional processors mean more possible chains of reasoning it can evaluate and prune down to find one that works.
We're living at a fascinating inflection point in history, honestly: machine reasoning has the potential to transform society to a greater extent than maybe anything since the steam engine if -- and this is a big "if" -- the cost of that reasoning can be brought down to be competitive with human brains, something which we are very far away from at the moment. As impressive as GPT-o1 is, we're still talking about something that can solve a very simple 7x7 crossword puzzle, taking two to three times longer than an average person, and will get totally lost on the average New York Times daily puzzle. And it needs enough electricity to power an average household for a month to solve that simple puzzle. It remains to be seen whether or not these costs can be brought down; at the moment, it's a cool project, but definitely not going to be threatening anyone's job.
-
ChatGPT at the moment undoubtedly can do some pretty cool stuffs
I used it to help me summarize or explain some concepts to me in a simple ways. However, not everything it said is true and I still need to double-check things later on, but it definitely helps me getting a quick look at stuffs. Even its citations is not always trustworthy though. Sometimes I ask it to give me the scientific paper names it used to gain some of the information it said but turned out that the names it gave does not exist, but were generated. -
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Until Boston Dynamics develops a robot capable of handling a folding set of pliers or flip out a can opener from a Champion, I'm not that worried.When you want REAL info from people who actually USE things, MTo may be the last bastion of hope!
Def
Boston Dynamics needn't develop a robot that can handle a set of folding plyers or a can opener any more than the Cylon Raider ships in the original Battlestar Galactica ever needed humanoid robots to sit in and pilot them. The ship itself could have contained the computer brain in the robot heads and the hand controls themselves were not necessary if that was the case
Boston Dynamics can simply create robots that have those tools on appendages natively.
I agree that MTO has much more real world use case analytics than almost anywhere else. But how will the average John Q. Public ever know that?
-
@friendliestdoggo said:
Even its citations is not always trustworthy though. Sometimes I ask it to give me the scientific paper names it used to gain some of the information it said but turned out that the names it gave does not exist, but were generated.Instruct it to give you citations with links: that makes it very quick to check whether or not they’re real. It also forcibly engages the feature of the tool that causes it to make actual web searches to formulate its answer, which significantly reduces the chance of hallucinations. It’s not foolproof — you do still need to check the links it gives you — but it will give much better results on average.
-
@ThundahBeagle said:
Boston Dynamics needn't develop a robot that can handle a set of folding plyers or a can opener any more than the Cylon Raider ships in the original Battlestar Galactica ever needed humanoid robots to sit in and pilot them. The ship itself could have contained the computer brain in the robot heads and the hand controls themselves were not necessary if that was the caseBoston Dynamics can simply create robots that have those tools on appendages natively.
I agree that MTO has much more real world use case analytics than almost anywhere else. But how will the average John Q. Public ever know that?
I'll know.
If I can't have a site I'm proud of, I'll shut it down in a heartbeat.
Def
-
Just for the fun of it, I asked AI to write a review of the XEN-OAL knife I recently reviewed from OKnife. I wanted to see if I was wasting my time hacking out reviews the old fashioned way. Here is what ChatGPT wrote:
The XEN-OAL knife from OKnife is a striking addition to the competitive world of everyday carry (EDC) tools, showcasing a blend of modern aesthetics, high-quality materials, and precise functionality. OKnife, a subsidiary of Olight, has built a solid reputation for producing reliable knives that appeal to enthusiasts and professionals alike. The XEN-OAL continues this legacy with a design that balances practicality and sophistication.
Design and Build Quality
The XEN-OAL immediately stands out due to its sleek and minimalist design. Its clean lines and ergonomic contours not only make it visually appealing but also ensure a comfortable grip. The knife features a handle crafted from durable G10 scales or, in some versions, titanium. Both options provide excellent durability and a premium feel, catering to users who appreciate both aesthetics and performance. The handle is slightly textured, offering a secure grip even in wet or slippery conditions.The blade itself is made from D2 tool steel, a popular choice for EDC knives due to its excellent edge retention and wear resistance. The blade profile is versatile, with a drop-point design that excels in a variety of tasks, from cutting and slicing to light prying. OKnife's attention to detail is evident in the precision-ground edges and the smooth satin finish, which enhances the knife’s overall appeal.
Performance
In terms of performance, the XEN-OAL is a reliable workhorse. The D2 blade retains its sharpness exceptionally well, requiring minimal maintenance even with frequent use. It slices cleanly through various materials, including cardboard, rope, and fabric, making it ideal for both outdoor adventures and urban EDC needs. The blade deployment is smooth and satisfying, thanks to the ball-bearing pivot system. The flipper tab is well-positioned for quick, one-handed opening, and the knife locks securely into place with its liner lock mechanism.One aspect that stands out is the knife's weight and balance. The XEN-OAL is light enough to carry comfortably in a pocket yet feels substantial enough in hand to inspire confidence during use. The pocket clip is robust and allows for deep carry, keeping the knife secure and discreetly tucked away.
Value for Money
The XEN-OAL is reasonably priced for the materials and performance it offers. While it may not compete with high-end custom knives in terms of exclusivity, it provides excellent value for those looking for a functional and stylish EDC knife without breaking the bank. OKnife's commitment to quality control is evident, as the knife arrives razor-sharp and well-tuned out of the box.Drawbacks
While the XEN-OAL excels in many areas, there are a few minor drawbacks to note. The D2 steel, while durable, is not stainless, which means it is prone to corrosion if not properly maintained. Regular cleaning and oiling are essential, especially in humid or wet environments. Additionally, the flipper tab might feel slightly stiff for some users initially, though it loosens up with use.Conclusion
The OKnife XEN-OAL is a solid choice for anyone seeking a dependable and stylish EDC knife. Its combination of robust materials, thoughtful design, and practical performance makes it a standout in its price range. With proper care, the XEN-OAL is sure to become a trusted companion for daily tasks and adventures alike.Here is what I wrote:
https://multitool.org/knives/oknife-xen-oal
A few comments from the AI generated review really got to me- for example, the option of titanium or G-10 handles is absolute proof why a hand written review is much better than than AI generated stuff you are seeing everywhere. The XEN-OAL knife has their new, proprietary aluminum alloy handle they call OAL, which s where the OAL part of the name comes from.
Next up, it's not D2 steel, its a CPM blade, which if I'm honest, I prefer to D2. But then I have been following CPM steels since (I think?) the 90's when it first came out. It was a fascinating concept then and still is today, especially with the recent news about Crucible.
Last but not least, I'd think that mentioning that world famous knife designer Ken Onion would have been mentioned in there somewhere.
Sorry Skynet, no world domination for you today! MTO is going to continue to be operated by people.
Def
-
The problem (as I see it) with all this AI generated "content" both verbal and imagery is that it (the AI of choice) is just regurgitating what it has been trained on or has scraped from the internet.
It has no way of verifying the accuracy of the information other than comparing it to the data it's trained on, a self confirming loop.This can result in it producing truth, fiction or outright lies as its output, with any option put forward with the same enthusiasm/sincerity.
It's as simple as "Garbage in -> Garbage out, and there is inadequate garbage filtering on the input of many, if not most, AIs.At the risk of sounding like an evangelical artist... All it can do is plagiarise, not create.
-
@PTRSAK said:
The problem (as I see it) with all this AI generated "content" both verbal and imagery is that it (the AI of choice) is just regurgitating what it has been trained on or has scraped from the internet.
It has no way of verifying the accuracy of the information other than comparing it to the data it's trained on, a self confirming loop.This can result in it producing truth, fiction or outright lies as its output, with any option put forward with the same enthusiasm/sincerity.
It's as simple as "Garbage in -> Garbage out, and there is inadequate garbage filtering on the input of many, if not most, AIs.At the risk of sounding like an evangelical artist... All it can do is plagiarise, not create.
One might add to that as more and more of the internet AI training digests consists of AI made content the level of "truth" it is being trained on is getting diluted too.
That said I do believe AI can come up with original creations - or at least as original as most new designs in this world. Currently many AI models operate with a concept of "latent space" which holds the AIs perceived essential characteristics and or features of a given subject or relation. It can be somewhat likened to our memory of a book after reading it - we can reiterate the main content, storylines and characters but not the exact text.
Such a latent space might for instance codify the requirements for a functional chair and limits given by say economical production and materials. Within that envelope of possibilities it can then be asked to output a chair design. To the degree it has also been trained on other existing chair designs it can further be asked to avoid those (to an adjustable degree) and still be within the design envelope of possible chairs. That will yield original designs - some likely more original than most human original chair designers do today.
-
Another AI masterpiece that I just had to share!
Def

-
See, that is original! :D

-
I literally cannot stop laughing at this photo!
Def
-
Maybe AI thinked that tent needs heater
-
I guess it makes sense to keep your firewood dry!
Def
-
The shoelaces are just amazing too.
One can suspect the creator prompt to have been something like "put a bonfire inside a tent" - which would be inspired indeed! :D
-
Yes, don’t believe everything you read on the internet. And that goes double if it was written by AI…
In defense (sort of) of the poor AI, there was in fact a blog post stating this, though to any adult of at least average intelligence it was obvious that the blog post was an April Fools joke.

-
Sixty inches seems like a reasonable restriction to me.

Def
-
I just asked Bing a question about the new 60 inch blade rule. They confirmed it. It must be true. Makers will be scrambling to make 59 inch blades from now on, I would suspect. Best wishes. G

-
You know what they say, let 'em take an inch and they'll take a yard.
-
I think they will push it to 59 inches and 15/16ths.
You know what they are like.
Give them sixty inches and they will take five feet, eleven and fifteen sixteenths.
Def
-
I have been having fun with the latest AI trend of getting the various AI's to create action figures based on your image and input.
Out of the three I have generated, two are actually good, and one is probably more accurate, but not overly flattering! :ahhh
This is the latest- which looks nothing like me but I asked for it to include a drone and a multitool as an accessory and this is what it came up with!
Def

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




