SAK demographics.
-
@nate j said:
As the father of four kids currently in Scouts, I’m pleased to report that (at least in the US) Scouting is still teaching kids safe knife use beginning about age eight, and they can carry pocket knives at Scout functions essentially from that point forward as long as they use them safely and responsibly.I’ve heard that a lot of troops don’t allow knives, or knives of certain types (fixed blade, locking, etc). I assume each troop has latitude on what they allow. And I guess local laws play a role too.
-
@gustophersmob said:
I’ve heard that a lot of troops don’t allow knives, or knives of certain types (fixed blade, locking, etc). I assume each troop has latitude on what they allow. And I guess local laws play a role too.It has been a while since I was a Leader for my son’s pack and troops.
The Cub level skills yet provide a Knife requirement of skills. Part of the Wolf badge.
Today, current knife manufactures have Scout license goods, BUCK, CASE, VICTORINOX and others pay fees to use the Scouts stamp, both boys and girl varieties.
The link you provided details se real items, and when I was a leader this was a source for obtaining AWARDS to present to young people for there accomplishments.
A good slip joint was always my go to for introduction to a tool with a blade and did discourage fix blades until Boy Scout levels with experience and longer duration adventures requiring hiking, foraging and survival experiences.
I always encouraged parental involvement, even if a single parent household. Their home there RULES.
SO, I did have a bin with troop/pack tools we utilized for skills levels. Never handed out a tool to take home or presented a sharp style award unless it was OK’d by parent. This was back in the 1980s. -
@gustophersmob said:
I’ve heard that a lot of troops don’t allow knives, or knives of certain types (fixed blade, locking, etc). I assume each troop has latitude on what they allow. And I guess local laws play a role too.I personally have not heard of a unit banning pocket knives (though individually Scouts can certainly lose the privilege if they behave irresponsibly). But I have seen some units/councils that frowned upon the carrying of fixed blades.
The newest Cub Scout curriculum has requirements for pocket knives beginning at the Bear level (3rd grade), and for kitchen knives beginning at the Webelos level (4th grade).
@LoopCutter said:
A good slip joint was always my go to for introduction to a tool with a bladeI used to think that was the best option as well. When my oldest son was starting out, however, the strength of the back spring was a bit of an obstacle, and he ended up being more comfortable with a small lock back. After some thought, I’ve decided to try the Opinel No. 07 Outdoor Junior as a first knife for my twins, so we’ll see how that goes…
-
@nate j said:
~~
I used to think that was the best option as well. When my oldest son was starting out, however, the strength of the back spring was a bit of an obstacle, and he ended up being more comfortable with a small lock back. After some thought, I’ve decided to try the Opinel No. 07 Outdoor Junior as a first knife for my twins, so we’ll see how that goes…My experience with youngsters were in the mid 80s through early 90s!
Internet not even imagined by Al Gore!Opinel is a great option, for a folder with locking blade.
As was Mora knives for a fixed blade.I remember the local stores had Schrade, Buck, and a couple SAK offerings. And, not one person I knew ever worried about back spring pull, or rated. 5 or 6 likely the strongest.
It is amazing how much the world has changed with www connection. Back then it was word of mouth and shared experiences.
👍
-
@LoopCutter said:
My experience with youngsters were in the mid 80s through early 90s!
Internet not even imagined by Al Gore!Opinel is a great option, for a folder with locking blade.
As was Mora knives for a fixed blade.I remember the local stores had Schrade, Buck, and a couple SAK offerings. And, not one person I knew ever worried about back spring pull, or rated. 5 or 6 likely the strongest.
It is amazing how much the world has changed with www connection. Back then it was word of mouth and shared experiences.
👍
Yes, the Opines a great knife for young fingers, IF...IF... they remember to twist the locking ring! Being a strait friction folder with a lock ring added as an after thought in 1955, I'd worry a bit about that. The Opinel is a knife that is sometimes a lockblade, and sometimes not, depending on how you use it. With a slip joint, I know beyond a shadow of doubt, that it will bite me if I act stupidly. But...again that little three letter word, the lock blade will bite me if I put enough stress on the blade to overcome the pounds force of the lock spring, or a mechanical failure, or my lack of keeping it clean and pocket lint clogs up the locking notch. I've seen that happen with a friend na this beloved Gerber LST. He got abad cut on his right index finger when the blade folded because it was half jammed up with pocket lint.
In general, I applaud the scouts being made to use and get to know slip joints. It will tech basic knife safety that may carry over. I've seen two bad accidents with locks, one a young guy over using to the point of abuse of a Buck 110, and when told to 'knock it off', his smart a$$ reply was "Its a Buck knife, it'll take it." Well it didn't, and just after lunch a blood curdling scream echoed up the hall from the sheet metal shop, and there was the kids right index finger laying on the floor with blood squirting out of a neat stump at his second joint of the finger. If he had been taught age knife handling with a slip joint, wound he have done what he did?
When I was in the scouts, it was all about us being taught self reliance. Our scoutmaster, an old retired Marine with both WW2 experience and Korea, showed us how to actually fix stuff using our scout knives. In the 1950's, Phillips screws were starting to become common, and he showed us how to use the inner corner of the flat screw driver to use as a flat Phillips driver. The awl was sharpened on the inner chisel edge so it served as a cable stripper and zip tie buster. The sharp tip of the old style Camillus can open served multiple uses as knot untangler, staple puller, scribe, and hook to lift a pot off the campfire tripod. It was all about multiple uses for the one tool. Maybe another reason I never liked the single blade locker like the Buck 110 and others. I had Opinels in the 1980's and 90's, but they faded away with most of my knife nut obsession. When I carried a Opinel, I had to have my SAK in another pocket because the Opinel was just too limited. If I carry a second pocket knife these days, I'd rather a second SAK for a wider selection of tool set. Like my 58mm with a 93mm. Or 58mm with a 91mm. My classic and Wenger SI make a fine team, as does the classic and cadet.
I think tools should be stressed with the Boy Scouts. Being able to fix something while out in the middle of nowhere, may just be a life saving skill under some conditions. There must be a good reason their motto is "Be Prepared".
-
@ThisAlarm7 said:
As others have said, very robust and VERY concealable pocket gun. Love mine (seen here with 84mm Tinker for scale).LOVE THOSE GRIPS!!!!!!!!!!
What are they and where can I get them?????
-
@cbl51 said:
LOVE THOSE GRIPS!!!!!!!!!!What are they and where can I get them?????
They work SO WELL....it originally shipped with the folding grips with the pocket clip but no matter what I did they were so loose and made for a weird pocket carry. I got these on Ebay for cheap and they come in lots of other colors. $18.99 plus shipping from user Aerolayer.
-
@ThisAlarm7 said:
They work SO WELL....it originally shipped with the folding grips with the pocket clip but no matter what I did they were so loose and made for a weird pocket carry. I got these on Ebay for cheap and they come in lots of other colors. $18.99 plus shipping from user Aerolayer.

Got a pair on the way now. The grips that came on my Black Widow were fine, but the smaller frame .22LR were just too hard to get a good grip on for fast firing. Looking forward to practice!
-
@nate j said:
I still love my US-made knives and tools.But just as an example, the Vic Spartan is still available here in the US for under $25 NIB. Who else is offering a comparable level of capability and quality at that price point? No one; that’s who.
Even in Canada the Spartan goes on sale regularly. Last time I picked up three at $20 CAD each! At that price they're nearly disposable and not a heartbreaker to leave in the car, should someone break in to the car and steal stuff.
Though not a tool, I picked up a Buck folder for $10 as well. I wish I could remember the model but it's such a great little knife too. Buck +Spartan = $30 - do a lot.
-
@gustophersmob said:
https://www.scoutshop.org/outdoors/tools-accessories/knives.htmlDo they only ship in the U.S., or am I missing something on their site?
-
I just found this thread. Here goes...
I am currently in my early 50s, and living just north of the UP of Michigan on the Canadian border (city of 75,000ish). That places me in North Eastern Ontario amongst the Great Lakes. I am a High School teacher. My usual classes center around general science, geography, history, careers/civics, and special education. I get a not boring mix of subjects that differ from year to year which is great in combating boredom. I like a variety.
I found MT.O in 2008 and joined up in 2009 because I decided to h0nour my Dad's memory after finding 20 something multi-tools in his bedroom. I only started collecting SAKs after noticing a vibrant subforum here. I made the mistake of "only getting a few" for my collection. Yeah, once embarked, I couldn't get off the collection train. Oddly enough, I haven't used SAKs much because of work restrictions...but I did use a Leatherman knifeless Fuse happily for over a decade.
I have plenty of hobbies that keep me going. I have been doing something with a camera from the age of 8 when my father lent me his Kodak Retinette 1A rangefinder to keep me out of trouble. I am a collector of lots of things such as: swords, machetes, one piece hunting knives/daggers, multi-tools, SAKs, stamps, coins/trade tokens, survival gear, cameras, etc.
-
Some interesting biographies. G

-
Well in the rural US
Mid 30s
College Educated
Veteran
Patrol Sergeant
I have a small homestead (42 acres) but work in law enforcement and carry a SAK daily, and have never felt "underknifed"I do understand what you mean by the tactical community being very judgemental, but what I've learned is for practicality nothing beats a SAK. There are plenty of great knives to carry i own Benchmades and Spydercos but time and again I reach for the SAK, cause sometimes u need more than a blade.
-
I’m approaching 57 in a couple of weeks.
I grew up in the big city but I live in a rural mountainous area on acreage now.
I’m one of those guys who’s always been chasing more knowledge and I get bored and completely sick of stuff after a couple of years.
I’m a journeyman in several trades (motorcycle mechanic, marine mechanic, millwright). I also volunteer as Captain in local fire department and specialize as a “Human Tracker” in a busy Search & Rescue group. I’ve done those for decades. I’m definitely a type “A” sort of person.
I’m also a certified electronic technician and Amateur Radio operator.ADHD much you think?
I was given my first knife as a kid in the mid 70s. A Logger with no scale tools and the standard cap lifter not the combination tool. I still have it somewhere in one of my many packs/bags of gear that all have the required tools for the job what ever that is meant to be. It’s likely a backup knife in either my summer or winter SAR backpacks I’m guessing. It’s simply not enough to be a primary tool that I’d be wearing in the field. That opens a topic no one here wants to know about. I’m firmly in the camp of 2 is 1 and 1 is none. Yes, I’m also that guy.
I’ve been retired for years from conventional jobs. I build then sell traditional pre war Hotrods built only with the parts that were available to a guy in the late 40s/early 50’s. Not modern catalog stuff. Yes clearly OCD too.
My path out of high school was going to college to be a Fisheries/Conservation officer but after the first summer of required work experience training I realized it wasn’t a good fit. My problem with authority and all. So I’ve done all the law enforcement firearms training. I did the handgun and long gun hobby thing for a few years but after a while that got boring and just expensive. I ticked that box and moved on.
I think for me aside from the collecting side of SAKs I value more of an urban compact EDC knife now. 2 to 4 layers. I find even the large SAKs are just too much of a compromise for me to be more than just a backup in the bush. Please understand that’s just for me and what I expect and what I need. I’m not making judgements on someone who goes camping a few times a year. That makes total sense to me. See if I get a SAR call I may be hiking through dense forest for hours then be forced to overnight or make an Emergency camp with what I have on me to support someone too injured to move until more resources arrive. I can’t mess around.
In my day to day now I need to be able to cut a rope that a horse got tangled in, tighten some screw just enough so I don’t lose it before I get home, open a package, pull/dig out a splinter, sign my name on something, cut the tag on my shirt that’s making me mental. That kind of stuff.
What was the question again? 🤪
-
@29roadie said:
See if I get a SAR call I may be hiking through dense forest for hours then be forced to overnight or make an Emergency camp with what I have on me to support someone too injured to move until more resources arrive. I can’t mess around.I’m curious what all you’re packing on these excursions?
-
I have a bunch of old gear I use. Nothing fancy. Probably first generation stuff too. Never felt the need to upgrade.
Being light weight without compromising quality or strength is number one. Remember my pack was full of stuff but most of it is first aid stuff, lightweight fleece clothes for people I may find, fire starter stuff, fruit bars and water, lightweight tarp and multiple heavy style space blankets. The ones that are silver on one side and orange on the other. Flagging tape to mark the route. Other stuff too but you get the idea. It’s only a 40L pack most of the time.-
Gerber hatchet probably 14 or 15”. Fits nice strapped to the side of my pack upside down to keep the weight low. I got it when they first came out because of how light they were and with all the weight on the head they work awesome. A few years later I started seeing a Fiskers branded one but it didn’t have the heavy corduroy head cover.
-
Something called a Can Saw. I see a lot of them around but they are kind of cheap and flimsy now. A buddy of mine picked up one of those new ones and being a little ackward with it he allowed the blade to flip over and put a pinch in the chain. It’s garbage after that. I got this from the original guy who started the company 30+ years ago. I have used it a tonne. If you get a person on each side of it you can cut through massive logs. Keep a small piece of cloth soaked in gun oil in the bottom on the tin as it seems to stop any rust. Clean it after use too of course. Make a couple of short wooden handles and drill a hole for some short loops of rope to go through. Makes all the difference in the world. T handles. Sometimes I pack an old school bow saw. You know the old red metal ones you see at garage sales? Maybe 16 or 18”. A saw like that is the best tool probably. You don’t get tired using it like you do an axe or hatchet
-
Trauma scissors are probably my number one cutting tool by a long shot. I just get super cheap ones so I can just chuck them out if they get gross or damaged.
-
For a knife it’s another old one. I think’s called a Gerber LST Ultralight. It’s not huge by any means. I’m not a Gerber fan boy either but in the late 80s early 90s they were about the best/newest technology I came across. Lightweight/weather resistant/tough. Remember this is pre internet. It was a different world. If you didn’t see it infront of you it didn’t exsist. I have probably 2 backups stashed on me or my pack too.
I’m not scared of being in the bush. So many people are. Even professionals. I don’t worry about protection. I’m in bear country and not just the black ones. Lots of cougars too. I Just go with it and whatever. I do take precautions maybe pepper spray, etc but I make lots of noise usually. Yell someone’s name if I’m looking for someone maybe blow and Fox 40 whistle once in a while and listen for a response.
I have lots of lights and headlamps too. But I’ve freaked out a lot of SAR people many times over the years because I walk through the bush without a light a lot of times if there’s a trail. Not thinking I just walk up to people and because they’ve ruined their night vision looking at each other with headlamps on they don’t see me till the last second. Big guys screaming like little 8 year old girls. It’s kind of funny though, I’m not going to lie. 🤣 I’ve probably contributed to their nightmares a little I’m sure. -
-
Interesting, thanks for sharing!
-
Oh ya you bet. Probably more than anyone really wanted to know. 😆🤪

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


