SAK-A-Like / Off Brand Challenge - September
-
Day 28:
Sears Craftsman 9560. Has the remnants of the pre-'60s logo. I'm guessing late '50s due to celluloid handles.
Best I can tell, this is an Ulster-produced example.
Note: repurposed an old photo since the original Day 28 photo was terrible.
[attach id=0 msg=2545598]
.jpg)
-
Day 29:
Zippo Pocket Knife
HS was my Granddad's initials, so I bought this knife for him originally, and I later inherited it after his passing.
H&S Machine is a fairly small operation (10 employees) in Lawrence, MA. They were founded in 1948, so it means the knife was made in 1973 going by the "25th Anniversary" marking. No connection to it, but I liked the tools on the handle when I bought it for my Granddad. I also have one for American LaFrance.
[attach id=0 msg=2545601]

-
Day 30:
I have no idea. It has an unintelligible logo ("P" in a diamond) and "STAINLESS JAPAN" as a tang stamp. Tools--pen blade and file/screwdriver/bottle opener (seems like a common tool on many small Japanese knives of the era!).
One of the few advertising knives from my own backyard, this one was a giveaway from Richlands National Bank in the '70s. I bought it for like $2 at an antique store by my house about a year ago. I think they were bought and sold a couple of times, and the location, I think now houses a Wells Fargo. My folks never banked with them.
Enameled gold-tone logo. Probably brass. I'd really be curious if it was gold...
[attach id=0 msg=2545602]
I used it to tighten up my old desk scissors--1930s Shapleigh Hardware 7-inch, chrome-plated.
[attach id=1 msg=2545602]
Gotta admit, this 30 day challenge included some I either never used in the first one (could swore I've done two of these...), or never had. Gotta admit, good quality, inexpensive secondhand knives are something I NEVER pass on.


-
@cody6268 said:
How's the quality? Been looking at cheaper rigging knives, as I need the spike often--but the vast majority of my "spikes" are military antiques (mostly Canadian and English) or high-end (Myerchin). I want something fairly inexpensive to throw in my toolboxes.Rough Ryder Marlin Spike Knives are pretty decent for under $20 each.
Or, for about $25 a piece you can get the solid one-piece stainless steel Myerchin spikes, and they will probably outlive you.
-
Day 30
Fun fact, for the price of the JOTS you could outfit yourself with a Pioneer, a Classic SD, and a Wave+ and have about 10 bucks left over to get a Jarritos (or other glass bottle soda of your choice) and at least a rice and beans plate. Oh, sorry, that's at the retail price, which is almost impossible to get. If you pay Ebay prices you could probably upgrade yourself to a Farmer X and a Minichamp. Or dinner for two.
I think this is a beautiful knife. I know a lot of people complain about the Delrin on a premium knife, but I think it's the right style. The hex wrench is cool, even if I didn't use it. But at the end of the day the Pioneer is more practical (with the awl and extra screwdriver), cheaper, and awlso cool (you can even get your BYSAK if you want). I don't regret buying it and I've got no complaints about the function, but it's not a knife I'm ever likely to recommend to anyone other than a niche collector.
Cleaning it up and putting it back in the drawer for next time I need a "designer" knife to show off somewhere.
Thanks for hosting, AC. Hopefully I'll see some of you over in fixie land tomorrow.

-
Day 30
Final thoughts.
The Gerber Armbar was both too much and not enough for me.
On the one hand, the blade worked well and had the advantage over a SAK of having a lock that’s easily disengaged and a blade that can be safely opened without worrying about the backspring. The scissors did the job, and theyre a must for me.
But the lack of a screwdriver and openers was a negative.
So if this was a dedicated folder like a slipjoint the blade would have been fine, but the bottle opener that was included seemed to be lacking in utility without a screwdriver tip. It seemed extraneous for the most part. Meanwhile it didn’t have more useful implements.
I don’t think I will be carrying this much unless I am just looking for a utilitarian blade, for cutting cardboard or something.
Congratulations to awl for another successful challenge.

-
Day 29
Fox Vulpis

-
Day 30
These weren’t the only tools I carried for this challenge, but found myself falling into a pattern by the end.
From left to right:
Work - LionSteel Jack 2 - High quality, unobtrusive appearance, and ease of carry made it a favorite here. The only real negative is the limited toolset.
Football practices and games - LM Free T2 - In previous posts, I’ve detailed what I feel are a number of questionable design choices on the T2. However, having sturdy, locking flathead and 3D Phillips drivers that I wasn’t afraid to torque with my full strength (and a comfortable enough handle that I could do this without inflicting pain on my hand) made it a good choice for this application.
Scouts & weekends - MKM Malga 6 - In spite of the questionable utility of some implements (blunt awl; tiny fork), the M390 blade cuts like a laser. Textured orange G10 scales meant a good grip even when wet, and would have made it easier to find if dropped or lost. I also made use of the flathead screwdriver a few times. Though I didn’t use the can opener or corkscrew during this challenge, I felt better prepared for having them along.
Thanks to awl for a fun challenge, and a special thank you to AC for hosting!


-
<u>Day 30</u>
Thanks to awl for joining me on this fun challenge. I like this challenge because I put into rotation knives that I sometimes forget I have. There are definitely some badly designed/executed SAK-A-Likes (I'm looking at you Quirky Switch multitool) and others that with a bit more work could've been better/less frustrating (Gerber Bear Grylls). But there are some good classic and contemporary ones out there.
These were my favorite ones to carry though I don't think I carried the Colonial Scout knife now that I think about it. Each have their strength and weaknesses but they awl served their intended purposes well.

If you don't have the badge yet, don't forget to request it. It's on page 5 of the available awards pages, towards the bottom of the page.

Looking forward to seeing some of y'awl on the Fixed Blade Challenge tomorrow!

-
Day 30
Ruike M31 opened some hot sauce.Of all my SAK-a-Likes , I really like the Ruike, with the Boker being very similar if not identical.
The one that I found myself enjoying more than expected was the Ruike S31. The blade, scissor, bottle opener all work as expected. I was uncertain about how useful the hook cutter was, until I started experimenting with it. It actually works well for cutting open chips or other packaging , even poly and bubble wrap.

-
As far as metal slab built slipjoints go the Meyerco Sailor is a pretty solid work knife.
The sheapsfoot blade cuts well, the can opener works, the springs aren't too tight, and the shackle key exists....but the spike is its special trick and it is solid with a sharp tip..jpg)

.jpg)
-
Morning awl,
Thanks again for participating. And now for our GAW. After consulting the Magic 8-ball and spinning the wheel of misfortune, it looks like our winner is.....


Congrats LoopCutter!! PM me your address and I'll get your Rough Ryder out to you this week.
-
A WHAT

had no idea,
or recollection of a GAW within this excellent fellowship of crazy folk!Thank you, I am feeling so undeserving.


-
Congrats to a well-deserving member of the challenge. And regards to friend Aztec for the kind gift. Now friend Gordon can put a RR in a left pocket and a right for better balance. I would caution use of the freaky can opener/finger mangler. Best wishes G
-
Congratulations, LC!
-

There was a GAW? Missed that
]Congrats LC

-
Yup, posted about it right here. It's where I show that the can opener bit me. I've never had a can opener bite me before.

-
Congrats LoopCutter. Guess you'll have to get a fall camping trip in to test it.
-
@AzteCypher said:
Morning awl,Thanks again for participating. And now for our GAW. After consulting the Magic 8-ball and spinning the wheel of misfortune, it looks like our winner is.....


Congrats LoopCutter!! PM me your address and I'll get your Rough Ryder out to you this week.
And as reported by AzteCypher, the gift which he selected has arrived.
It was delivered in SATURDAY’s mail, and oddly the carrier had a bandage on his right hand🥹So care was demonstrated last night and again this morning! A broken nail did occur, as the springs on this are very much a 6.5 on the blade side and a definite 7 on the driver/cap lifter.
[attach id=0 msg=2547315]
A beautiful tool, and I love a Rough Rider that was made when the brand used the ‘I’ before changing to the ‘Y’ !!!
A CAMP KNIFE, that I will cherish, and I will place on display alongside the RED LEAP, from FOLDERBEHOLDER, in the display case.
[attach id=1 msg=2547315]
Thank you for an enjoyable month, shared with a fantastic bunch of like minded MTo family. ☺️


Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login