New locking SAKs coming?
-
@gustophersmob said:
Around here it’s safe to call a spade a spade and a coke spoon a coke spoon.
-
Wow - This is interesting - The Synergies
And Vic are going in the opposite direction, compared to the Companions, regarding knife carrying laws, as locking blades are not allowed in many countries. ..... fascinatingBut it seems to me they are listening to their customers as there are always requests for pocket clips / locking blades
AT first I thought the skeletonised scales and specifically the red inserts in the holes, were the locking release mechanism (top photo)
But I can see this is not the case as there is a dedicated button like on the 111mm models.
But I quite like them - Can see it making too much difference strenght wise as all the strength is still between the pivots.
Although if you dropped it and it landed right on the end of a scale - That could bend the end and stop the screwdriver / small blade opening -
@Huntsman said:
Wow - This is interesting - The Synergies
And Vic are going in the opposite direction, compared to the Companions, regarding knife carrying laws, as locking blades are not allowed in many countries. ..... fascinatingBut it seems to me they are listening to their customers as there are always requests for pocket clips / locking blades
AT first I thought the skeletonised scales and specifically the red inserts in the holes, were the locking release mechanism (top photo)
But I can see this is not the case as there is a dedicated button like on the 111mm models.
But I quite like them - Can see it making too much difference strenght wise as all the strength is still between the pivots.
Although if you dropped it and it landed right on the end of a scale - That could bend the end and stop the screwdriver / small blade openingLooks like its targeted at Urban American customers, office workers and people living in cities look like the target customers based on the tools included and the feature set
-
Saw today an Blue Synergy Alox X and I think I will get it as an Companion to my Swisstool Spirit, the Backtools are also on the Spirit (although I have to use the Detachable Corkscrew, but when do I really need it? , the Scale Tools are on my Minichamp, ..
-
I say a big no to a pocket clip.
If they're going to do away with the can opener they should at least put a combo tool in place of the bottle opener. -
on both counts. I wouldn't have given the package opener such a chilly reception if it was paired with a combo tool. -
@PitCarver said:
I say a big no to a pocket clip.
If they're going to do away with the can opener they should at least put a combo tool in place of the bottle opener.The pocket clip looks pretty small and unobtrusive, shouldn't get in the way
Also I expect they did a lot of research and surveys to find that most people just don't need a can opener on a multitool these days, its nice to have but by no means is it necessary
-
@Richard Zheng said:
The pocket clip looks pretty small and unobtrusive, shouldn't get in the way
@Richard Zheng said:
Also I expect they did a lot of research and surveys to find that most people just don't need a can opener on a multitool these days, its nice to have but by no means is it necessaryHow does getting rid of a tool that is “nice to have but not necessary” square with putting a package opener on a tool that already has a knife blade?

-
Eh.... I don't know. I agree with those that say the skeleton-ized scales look like a real pocket-schmoo magnet...
As far as locking blades go, I can take them or leave them. I don't know... I was never aware that I "needed" a locking blade in a pocket knife until the internet came along and told me I did. As long as I'm following the principles that earned me my Totin' Chit in Scouts, a slip joint is perfectly safe. And when a slip joint won't do the job, I don't know that I trust a locking blade either. Locks do fail. In a situation like that I should either be using a fixed blade... or a knife of any kind simply isn't the right tool for the job.
But innovation is always nice to see. And there's something about innovation that we should all keep in mind - failure is part of the process! If we want Victorinox to innovate, we have to be prepared to accept products that are less-than-ideal as they figure things out. We can and should offer constructive criticism, of course! But it's not particularly fair for us to complain that the company hasn't been innovating.... and then complain when they do it!
I'm saying all of that to myself as much as anyone else. There are some things I like about this idea too.
-
@nate j said:
How does getting rid of a tool that is “nice to have but not necessary” square with putting a package opener on a tool that already has a knife blade?

Well, if it comes to cutting packages that have adhesive tape, I prefer to avoid using my main blade for that as I don't want to get it gunked up with adhesive that is a pain to clean off. Mostly because I sometimes use main blade for food prep. On a regular Alox knife I'd use the awl, which works fine for this, but of course we aren't getting the awl

-
@fullbreakfast said:
On a regular Alox knife I'd use the awl, which works fine for this, but of course we aren't getting the awl
For package opening I also prefer the awl to the new package opening tool. I think it works better, and the glue and gunk is easier to clean off of the awl.
-
@fullbreakfast said:
Well, if it comes to cutting packages that have adhesive tape, I prefer to avoid using my main blade for that as I don't want to get it gunked up with adhesive that is a pain to clean off. Mostly because I sometimes use main blade for food prep. On a regular Alox knife I'd use the awl, which works fine for this, but of course we aren't getting the awl
I’m also a fan of the 93mm awl.
My point, however, was that if you don’t have a package opener but you have a knife blade, you can still open packages. In contrast, if you have a can (no pull tab) but no can opener, you’re pretty smurfed, Youtube videos about opening cans on concrete notwithstanding.
-
@marlowe221 said:
But innovation is always nice to see. And there's something about innovation that we should all keep in mind - failure is part of the process! If we want Victorinox to innovate, we have to be prepared to accept products that are less-than-ideal as they figure things out. We can and should offer constructive criticism, of course! But it's not particularly fair for us to complain that the company hasn't been innovating.... and then complain when they do it!This is a very good point. And even if the Synergy line isn’t really my thing, they’re certainly no auto tool (what I consider an innovative failure from Vic).
-
@nate j said:
I’m also a fan of the 93mm awl.My point, however, was that if you don’t have a package opener but you have a knife blade, you can still open packages. In contrast, if you have a can (no pull tab) but no can opener, you’re pretty smurfed, Youtube videos about opening cans on concrete notwithstanding.
Yeah, it's a valid point. Those cans are getting pretty rare here (UK) but they do still exist.
-
@fullbreakfast said:
If it comes to cutting packages that have adhesive tape, I prefer to avoid using my main blade for that as I don't want to get it gunked up with adhesive that is a pain to clean off. Mostly because I sometimes use main blade for food prep.I endeavor to clean the tape remnants off my blades as soon as possible, and I use 91% isopropyl alcohol for that job. These days it's rare to see me using SAKs for food prep. That's a job I leave almost wholly to my Carbone Opinel No. 12 and CV Case 3137.
@nate j said:
If you don’t have a package opener but you have a knife blade, you can still open packages. In contrast, if you have a can (no pull tab) but no can opener, you’re pretty smurfed.Infinite +1s for that post. As long as you have a Swiss Army Knife, you have a package opener...even if it's a Swiss Army 1. Obviously others feel differently, but I regard the package opener as a net loss where utility is concerned.
-
And how do you sharpen all those teeny little serrations on the package opener? Sooner or later it's gonna need it.
And...what do you do when the pull tab on the can breaks off? I can't believe that I'm the only guy that's ever happened to.
-
@marlowe221 said:
Eh.... I don't know. I agree with those that say the skeleton-ized scales look like a real pocket-schmoo magnet...As far as locking blades go, I can take them or leave them. I don't know... I was never aware that I "needed" a locking blade in a pocket knife until the internet came along and told me I did. As long as I'm following the principles that earned me my Totin' Chit in Scouts, a slip joint is perfectly safe. And when a slip joint won't do the job, I don't know that I trust a locking blade either. Locks do fail. In a situation like that I should either be using a fixed blade... or a knife of any kind simply isn't the right tool for the job.
(Snip, with apologies!)
YES!!!!!!!!!!!!
I've witnessed two very bad failures of a lock. One, a very foolish young man neatly amputated his right index finger at the second joint when his Buck 110 failed under abuse. He was typical of the new generation of young knife nut idiots who are totally ignorant of what came before, and had very sloppy knife handling habits born of never having a slip joint knife. When the shop lead man told him to knock it off and go get the right tool, his smart a$$ reply was "Its a Buck knife, it'll take it."
Well it didn't and just after lunch a blood curdling scream echoed up from th sheet metal shop and his finger was laying on the floor while a pulsating jet of bright red blood was squirting all over.
The second was a few years later, I had to have some surgery on my left thumb for trigger finger. It was done at a hand clinic, and while I was there for the follow up and getting stitches out, there was a young man in the waiting room sitting by me, with his mother. His right hand was very bandaged up, and in conversation it came out that he was a young knife nut with a new super tactical ninja killer knife, and he was practicing stabbing a tree. The lock failed under impact, and he was having surgery trying to get some use back in his right index finger and thumb that was useless from all the severed nerves and tendons. He had sliced right down through the web of his hand between thumb and index finger and both were now non functional. I don't know the outcome. Yet another young knife guy who never learned proper knife handling with a slip joint.
SAK's need a lock like George Soros needs more money. If a slip joint SAk won't handle it use a fixed blade. The only real honest reason for a lock on a folding knife is, you plan on stabbing something. All other reasons are bull hockey.
-
I rarely use a pocketknife of any sort for food. My pockets have all sorts of grit, mung, and icky in them. I sometimes have to use a SAK for a can opener. I try to wipe and off and hope for the best.
I hear our friends in UK and Aussie saying that non-pull tops are rare there. I will accept their word for it. It is different here. I did a little inventory this morning of my canned stuff. Most recently bought cans tallied like this: 5 cans with pull tops and 12 cans without. Canned food items only. No drinks. Occasionally a pull ring detaches, and you have to resort to plan B.
I open packages with a knife blade. Package opener, or knife blade has to be cleaned off afterward. I would rather clean a knife blade than the package opener with all the little crevices and teeth. I use WD40 or rubbing alcohol. The slick blade is easy to clean. I wouldn't put an uncleaned package opener equipped SAK in my pocket to start with. Grit, dirt, etc, remember?
I have used the package opener on a Leatherman. It worked. Claw can opener looks like it would work as a package opener. I haven't tried it yet.
Best wishes,
G

-
Objection, argumentative! :) The function of the folder is to fold, and the only reason to have a knife (not a multitool, not a SAK with different tools) that is not one solid piece of sharpened metal with a handle attached is to save space (ease of carry) and to be concealable (in order not to attract unwanted attention by general population or the law). That goes for legitimate users as well as criminals.
I would LOVE to carry a belt knife openly and everywhere for cases where a SAK just won't "cut" it. Well, I can't. I don't even want a locking small SAK, I have about twenty locking one hand EDC capable folders to fill the need.
I do, however, accept the fact that folders are NOT made for hard use, as in shop work or chopping wood. They will fail. So just pick up the right tool for the right job. If your employer won't equip you with the right tools, quit. But you use what you have in an emergency. Then it's better to have a locking than non-locking knife.
I've carried for about fifty years, got a locking Buck knockoff in 1983 IIRC. The backlock opened my world to whole new possibilities for knife use, and the thought of stabbing has never crossed my mind.
-
@cbl51 said:
And how do you sharpen all those teeny little serrations on the package opener? Sooner or later it's gonna need it.And...what do you do when the pull tab on the can breaks off? I can't believe that I'm the only guy that's ever happened to.
I assume a diamond rod sharpener would work on the package opener, and as for pull tabs on cans, you are probably SOL
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login