Fixed Blade Challenge October
-
Day 20
The Garberg took its turn with the card stock today.
[attach id=0 msg=2548584]
The first cut was a clean, fast, and complete slice. A second cut had to be made for an action shot. Overall, I'm pretty happy with the Garberg.
[attach id=1 msg=2548584]
.jpg)
.jpg)
-
Day 20
We've reached the 2/3rds mark in this October challenge and we still haven't seen anyone carving a pumpkin, gourd, turnip, or other vegetables. If you haven't already got it, the Jack-o-lantern badge is one of the few you can claim during another challenge and it's only available before Halloween.
Today I'm carrying the ESEE JG3 with a SOG Powerpint, but that doesn't seem quite right. The JG3 is all business and feels like it should be paired with a more serious multitool such as the Surge.


-
Day 19
Esse PR4 and some more Glock magazines. When I bought my 43x MOS the guy behind the counter handed me a weighty Glock box after paperwork and purchase. I opened it before leaving to make sure numbers matched paperwork. Inside the box was a Glock 34. I bought the 43x at 419. Guy handed me a 650-700 dollar at the time double stack big Glock. Slight error. :ahhh
Sir, I think there is a problem.


-
Day 20
I think I may order some liners to make the handle slightly thicker. Esse PR4
Used the PR4 to open some tractor oil today and pop the lid on Mexican mineral water Topo


-
Day 20
I often see Mora's recommended as first knives. Cheap, durable, and a fixed blade is easier to handle in some ways than a folder. This Scout is the "official" kid friendly Mora, available with both pointy and safety tip. I know 10 year old BPRoberts would've thought that cross guard was really cool, because 36 year old BPRoberts still likes it.

-
Day 19
@Farmer X said:
I like that one! It would be interesting to compare it side-by-side with a Garberg.Ask and ye shall receive!
Both are straight, Scandi-inspired blades. I say Scandi-inspired because they are both really flat saber grinds with secondary bevels, not true Scandi grinds.
The Garberg features 14C28N steel, while this version of the Fieldcraft uses 154CM. The Fieldcraft’s blade is longer, wider, and thicker than the Garberg’s. The Fieldcraft also has thumb jimping on the spine, while the Garberg has none.
The Garberg has a polymer handle, while this version of the Fieldcraft features red & black G10 slabs.
The Garberg weighs in at a relatively svelte 6.1 oz (7.1 oz with sheath). The Fieldcraft comes in at a beefy 10.7 oz (13.6 oz with sheath).
The Garberg’s sheath isn’t awful, but is pretty basic. I would be hesitant to carry it without the retention strap. As FX noted, it is ambidextrous.
The Fieldcraft sheath is very well done. The kydex locks the knife in firmly with zero rattle, and it easily passes the shake test without any sort of secondary retention. However, the knife remains relatively easy to draw, thanks in part to a small thumb ramp on the sheath. The strong spring steel clip is large enough to accommodate up to a 2” belt or pack strap, and rotates to allow the knife to be carried at any angle. This sheath also features a firesteel loop, and in fact the knife came with a small firesteel & whistle. Sadly for you lefties, this sheath is designed for RH only.
As of this writing, the Garberg seems to be going for about $90 while the Fieldcraft is around $240.
So, which do I think is better? I have to admit a preference for the Fieldcraft, thanks to a more comfortable handle and the aforementioned excellent sheath. But if you’re on a budget and or looking to save weight, the Garberg won’t let you down.




-
Day 20
I opened a bale of alfalfa for my goats.
[attach id=0 msg=2548631]

-
Narf.
-
-
@Pacu said:
I think I may order some liners to make the handle slightly thicker.Good idea. Those scales do look a little on the thin side.
@nate j said:
Ask and ye shall receive!
I'd be interested in the BOB Fieldcraft, even though the sheath would have to be modified or (more likely) replaced.Any chance of seeing some photos of the goats?
Day 21
For the last third of the challenge, I'm switching to the ESEE Izula II. This is my favorite fixed blade thus far...and not solely because it was gifted to me by LoopCutter.
It can't be of much help when the task at hand is consuming beer, though.[attach id=0 msg=2548707]

-
Day 21
The ESEE Izula II is probably the best all-around production EDC fixed blade for most users. It is a good size, and they are built to be pretty much bullet proof. My shot for today is just a glamor shot of the ESEE JG3 stuck in a tree.

-
MMMmmmmmm... Blue Moon!

-
Day 21
Say what you will about neck carry, I think boot carry might be the least practical way of carrying a knife. Smith and Wesson HRT boot knife.

-
Here you go Farmer X!
[attach id=0 msg=2548748]
Some of my Mini Nubians. Nubians bred with Nigerian Dwarves. A fairly recent breed.

-
Day 21
I used my mini P to open a box that came today. Another CS Roach Belly. This one has the older style cloth sheath.
[attach id=0 msg=2548750]

-
Day 21
Esse 5 , the perfect neck knife. ::) ::) ::)
Just kidding. Just a bit heavy for that. Used the Esse today to "tap" a valve open on a water line.

-
@Alan K. said:
The ESEE Izula II is probably the best all-around production EDC fixed blade for most users.@BPRoberts said:
I think boot carry might be the least practical way of carrying a knife.I agree with both of those assertions.
And the Roach Belly is kinda making me wish I hadn't gotten rid of my Super Edge. That little thing carried nicely from about the neck and was wickedly sharp. -
@BPRoberts said:
I think boot carry might be the least practical way of carrying a knife.The intent of boot knives/boot carry is the same as ankle holsters: a last ditch defensive weapon.
I agree it makes no sense as a carry location for one’s general utility blade.
-
Day 20
Kizer Ursa Major
This version features Nitro-V steel and micarta slabs.
The taco-style kydex sheath passes the shake test with minimal rattle. The knife is still easy to draw thanks to the thumb ramp.
The provided belt clip is on the narrow side, only accommodating belts up to 1 1/4” wide. I may have to see if I can modify it to accept something wider, or replace it altogether.
I haven’t had a chance to use this one much yet, but overall I’m pretty pleased for the $80 spent. And at that price, I won’t feel bad about beating on it either.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

