December 2025 Tool Box Challenge
-
I'm in for this one.

The first one was a milestone in my edc and MTO life. It made me appreciate multi-tools and SAKs, but also opened my eyes to mini dedicated tools, and was what inspired the ratchet review thread, and my collection of stubby bit drivers. And it hasn't been attempted since, as far as I'm aware.
Plus, since last time, there are many more options to choose from. More mini ratchets, more folding knives, more tiny pliers, more flashlights, more ratcheting stubby screwdrivers. And of course, any dedicated tool counts. Dedicated tweezers, scissors, Bic lighter, toothpicks, folders, screwdrivers, pliers. There are tons of things that you could carry.- AzteCypher
- IMR4198
- ReamerPunch


-
Is the Toolbox Challenge going to be hard? It might be. A month without coffee or tea, tobacco, TV, walking in the sunshine, the company of pets, a smile from a spouse, driving to work, sleep. All that would really be hard.
On the contrary a month long Chocolate Challenge, or Pizza Every Day Challenge wouldn't be much of a challenge at all. Everyone lived for years and coped with everyday issues long before Tim and his tool. Many a new fur coat for the beautiful Ooog was provided by slaying and skinning some beast at the strong hand of her faithful mate Korg. With an assist by an occasional prehisterical mammal providing the fabric. Sharpened rocks and sticks did the trick. And provided a meal.
A SAK or plier based tool can be replaced by an ordinary knife and pocket friendly pliers and/or screwdriver. Suppose you need to grip something while you use a screwdriver. A multi can't do that. It was a necessity to cut some barbed wire from around a fallen tree. I had a tool to do that. Using a multi would have been an enormous fail. Likewise, I had to dissect another tree that fell across my driveway. Multi-tool? No. It needed a saw and some lopping shears to cut some of the other briars and things that the tree brought down.
Everyone can do without a multi for a month. The question is who wants to give up the multis and take the challenge? There weren't very many when our friend Reamer ran the first one. Might be fewer now? We will see. Still plenty of time. Holiday travel and events will likely be a difficulty in many cases as well. Noted.
It is good to see RP is in for the challenge. He can help show us the way. We have been in several challenges together. I don't remember any of them as being boring with members like RP and AzteCypher along.
Best wishes. Gary

-
-
@IMR4198 said:
Only seven members hold the badge. Why is that?Only seven of us were dumb enough to volunteer?

The first time around I went minimalist IIRC. Now I routinely use small pliers, dykes, and various drivers at work. They have the stuff, but it's a PITA to search for stuff when others leave them in the wrong place. I could do this one again...

-
I didn't volunteer. I hosted it. >:D
-
Like ET, I’ll be traveling some in December. And that’s a time when I’ll need maximum capability with minimal footprint.
-
It looks like travel will be a reason for some not to join in the challenge. Generally speaking, members mention that they can't carry things while traveling.
Some members like to join challenges as an excuse to buy something. Actually, you could complete the challenge by carrying a Sharpie and a box cutter. It could get a little annoying to make a photo of those items every single day. "Today I cut open some boxes at work and a co-worker borrowed my Sharpie to make a temporary tattoo of a spider on his hand. Guessing how often he washes his hand it could be considered semi-permanent. "
Someone suggested replacing the tools on his L-Man with single use equivalents. Carry a knife (or two), a ratchet set, pliers, maybe throw in a Zippo and a mechanical pencil. That could work. Some evidently don't have to change anything except for taking a SAK and a multi out of their little (or not so little) pouches. That would work also.
I don't have any travel plans. I carry some sort of knife every day and always have since my age was in the single digits. Usually I don't carry any other tool except for a one-piece screwdriver key fob. I will have to whisper this last part, since it is a heresy. Get close. I could actually get by without either of them. Regular voice now. The key thing doesn't take up any space and I like pocky knives. I like them so I carry one. I will likely carry some other items that I don't usually carry for the challenge. Winter time. Big pockets on the coats won't be a problem to slide some things in.
We will see how things progress. Best wishes. Gary (IMR)

-
No travel plans for me, either. These days, going to Meijer (less than 12 miles round-trip) is a long journey for me. What the hell; I'm in.
- AzteCypher
- IMR4198
- ReamerPunch
- Farmer X
-
The fun quotient just jumped up 25%. Welcome. Best wishes. Gary

-
Interesting concept. A multitool is a compromise, so why compromise? Single purpose tools are superior, no question about it. But. Instead of a MT with ten functions and one handle, you would carry ten tools with ten handles, and still only use one of them at a time. You would have to work a tool roll, tool belt, or one of those enormous Maxpedition "EDC" pouches into your daily system. A proof of concept is not necessary because that is what every craftsman or handyman did before multitools.
I think I will throw together a set of tools just to see how it would work out. Just for fun. The challenge is definitely out, for health, family, travel and other reasons. Time is not right, ever, it seems.
I would be very interested to read what you choose as your starting sets and if you can stick to it.
-
That is correct, I never used my MT as primary tool, would used dedicated tools for the job.
But, I did find myself always wearing a ST300 or REBAR ON MY BELT, just because.
Doing so saved me many steps back to the truck when rebus site or doing walk through inspections.
Yes, this will be interesting!
-
Of course, replacing the multi-tool's functions with individual single use tools is possible. It isn't a requirement of the challenge. Someone will likely do just that.
The last things I did with a L-Man pliers was to wreck the pins holding a watch strap on. Then I adjusted the trip lever on a couple of moose traps. I live in a drafty old farmhouse and when the weather gets cold, I have to deal with mooses in the hoose. Then I assembled a latch on some suspenders with a L-Man plier. I think I used the phillips driver on a multi for something or other. That's about it for multi usage for me over the last 6 months or so. If I had carried a L-Man every day of that time you could figure I had 2160 hours of carry (at 12 hours a day) for about 15 minutes of use. Never have used a slot driver on an L-Man.
I use a knife every day. Generally, in the kitchen. Rarely a pocket knife blade. I use files, and clamps, and screwdriver bits in a magnetic handle. Dremel moto tool now and then.
Will I carry an expedition type pouch? Don't have one. Will I show exactly what I will carry on day one and try to stick to it? No. Not required. I don't feel any withdrawal tremors when I leave the house without a pocket pry bar (never used one), flashlight, anything made of titanium (likewise not available), ferro stick, or Zippo. Don't have either of those. Don't carry a pen, pencil, or mechanical pencil. I have tools in my vehicles, but don't carry them. The four wheeled beast carries them in its belly.
You are quite welcome to post a photo or two of what you put together for a single use EDC if you like. We do love photos. Best wishes. Gary

-
I'm already making a mental list of the small tools I have that would work for this challenge. 😈
-
@Farmer X said:
I have a spring bar tool. Perhaps I'll work that into the challenge.One of those tools that is specially designed to help you fire a spring bar across the room, never to be seen again? Yeah, I got one of them too.
It’s not coincidental that they are made by the same people that make the spring bars, y’know.
-
Request for rules clarification please!
@IMR4198 said:
Multi-blade knives are fine as long as there are just blades.@IMR4198 said:
A non multi-tool SAK is legal. Alox model with just scissors is fine. So is something like an Evoke, or a horticultural single blade for instance. Leatherman newest single blade fixed and folding knives are fine. GIs a folding knife with more than one blade good, as long as they are just blades and nothing else...? The single blade references in the latter post made me wonder if things were being tightened up in this regard.
-
My interpretation is that any knife that includes additional implements as cap lifters, can openers, saw, screw drivers, Phillips, spoon & fork, awl, scissors, etc are not included as they are a multitool.
A knife pattern like a Stockman, Canoe, Trapper, Doctor, Whittler, etc, in which you have only blades with sharp edges, are good to go.
A Victorinox Pocket Pal is good, only a spear point blade and a pen blade. The new Compact with only scissors appears to be accepted. Also Vic’s floral blades (100mm line) are good.
A Scout pattern or hobo knife is a no, the SAK Classic is a no, the Recruit is a no, etc, even the traditions with a cap lifter are a no.
If I spoke out of turn Gary, stomp my fingers and then correct me.
-
Sounds good to me. You can go outside and play with the other children now, Gordon. I think you wrote, "I must not pass notes in class" enough times already.
Nothing has changed in the rules. So far. I used to have Wenger horticultural knives. One blade, one gold looking blade that has no edge for lifting bark on a graft. That wouldn't be legal. One or two blades are fine. A six bladed stockman would be fine. Something like a Old Timer with just blades but with scale tools would not be legal.
Carrying a multi-tool on your person as a backup is a fail. Nobody can control what you have in your house or desk. You don't have to bury your multi tools in the back yard or put them in a box on the sidewalk marked "Free". I would expect anyone who uses a multi or SAK during the challenge to bow out. This is a challenge, and a challenge should be challenging.
Best wishes. Gary

-
@IMR4198 said:
Sounds good to me. You can go outside and play with the other children now, Gordon. I think you wrote, "I must not pass notes in class" enough times already.
Nothing has changed in the rules. So far. I used to have Wenger horticultural knives. One blade, one gold looking blade that has no edge for lifting bark on a graft. That wouldn't be legal. One or two blades are fine. A six bladed stockman would be fine. Something like a Old Timer with just blades but with scale tools would not be legal.
Carrying a multi-tool on your person as a backup is a fail. Nobody can control what you have in your house or desk. You don't have to bury your multi tools in the back yard or put them in a box on the sidewalk marked "Free". I would expect anyone who uses a multi or SAK during the challenge to bow out. This is a challenge, and a challenge should be challenging.
Best wishes. Gary

Thanks, very clear!
I initially felt like I couldn’t possibly do this - the idea of going out without a proper SAK on my person is like leaving the house with no trousers on. But the difficulty of it makes it interesting, like you say. I have been pondering how it could be done. I think I can do it, and will give it a shot.
- AzteCypher
- IMR4198
- ReamerPunch
- Farmer X
- fullbreakfast
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login