December 2025 Tool Box Challenge
-
@IMR4198 said:
I look at those Klein scissors as a single purpose electrician's tool. Pliers were allowed in the last challenge with gripping and wire cutting features built in. That is just the way they have always been. Cut the wire. Twist connections, etc.
If friend ReamerPunch would like to voice his opinion on the scissors, it would be welcome. In fact if he were to say no, I would defer to his judgment in the matter.
Whether or not you use a feature on a tool doesn't really matter as far as eligibility. One couldn't use just the pliers on a SOG for instance and not use the other tools. Not allowed.
So, I will say allowed pending possible agreement or objection. Not a final judgment, as I might change my mind.
Best wishes. G

Not that my opinion signifies, but it would be an awfully strange world if I was allowed to carry my Knipex combi pliers - with their needle nose, nail hole, gripping section and wire cutters - and those scissors were not allowed.
-
@IMR4198 said:
If friend ReamerPunch would like to voice his opinion on the scissors, it would be welcome. In fact if he were to say no, I would defer to his judgment in the matter.I would allow it. I have the exact same model, and the additional features are afterthoughts, at least on my unit.
You do not have to defer to my judgement for anything, though. You are hosting this now, so the rules are up to you, as long as they make sense regarding the badge. You could be extremely strict, and not allow pliers because they also have wire-cutters. I was ok with a Skeletool KXB knife even though the pocket clip is also a bottle opener, because everything is a bottle opener. I was not that strict, because it was the first time the challenge was being done and the badge was not in the list, so I wanted as many people to join as possible. But the awesome mods allowed the badge despite low numbers.

I am more than happy to offer my opinions but if something is in the gray, we can decide together if it qualifies or not.

-
I welcome your input on the question, RP. I respect your thoughts and know there wouldn't even be a badge if you hadn't taken it in hand to create one and run the original challenge.
There has always been a tendency to dilute challenges here. There is no way (nor should there be) to figure out if someone is keeping to the rules. That has always been a question of agreement to follow the rules of the challenge. These things can be entertaining, or they can be meaningless. Depends on the individual.
It is pretty easy to guess which individuals are actually keeping up with the challenge and interacting with the other members. The personal connections and 'playing along' are 98% of the fun in any challenge. The badges are a pretty decoration but shouldn't be the reason for joining in on a challenge.
I ran a challenge where two members had no connection to anyone else there. Obviously never read any of the posts. Never answered anything they were asked. Zero conversation or comments with anyone else. Didn't pitch in on a single one of the weekly mini-challenges and probably never realized there was such a thing. Posted the same photos they did on another challenge 100% of the time. They got a meaningless badge anyway. Nothing contributed, nothing gained. Just wasted their self-centered time for a month.
We have a pretty good bunch here this time. I think. I haven't had a lot of interaction with everyone. I have no problem with making judgment calls but have no desire to be a dictator either. I like to think that I am open to at least hearing (and considering) input. I like to hear from MTO members who didn't or couldn't join in the challenge and listen to what they say as well.
Best wishes. Gary (IMR)

-
Just to chime in on the scissor’s question!
Yes, it should be allowed! It is a single purpose tool even with the stripping notches.
The scissors are very practical and if I had mine, they would part of my kit.
Unfortunately, they part of my tool grip when started my construction gig. That kit was stolen when my truck was broken into, and ran sacked by some cowardly thieves.
The scissors are single function built to make life easier for communication (phone) techs working with 22 - 24 size wire on punch down boards and D-Marks.
I really should look for a replacement pair. Best darn scissors I ever used.
And, that’s my opinion 🫣
-
I have those scissors as well. No stripping notches on mine, but it is easy to cut and strip wire with them anyway. I use mine for all sorts of little household chores. Best wishes. Gary
[attach id=0 msg=2553760]
-
In the short time you took to reply, I skipped over and searched the auction site.
😱. The prices? My lord!
Oh I like those Gary! Watch them closely, hate to see a Raccoon sneak away with them.
-
-
The scissors I keep in my tool bag are these ones:


which are what I'd call heavy duty. More than I need for the everyday, and too thick and heavy to be part of my kit for the challenge. But you can really put some pressure on these without hurting your fingers, if you need to. They will cut some things that I wouldn't have thought they could.
-
Thanks for everyone's input on the scissors!
I would have been fine with choosing something different, but I'm happy that these are ok because they are awesome EDC scissors; in fact I carried them every day for years. I bought an old Chevy truck in the late '90s and these were in the glovebox. The truck eventually got stolen, but at least I still have the scissors! 
-
@WECSOG said:
I bought an old Chevy truck in the late '90s...Veering off-topic a little: how old was the truck at the time?
I posted a photo in the SOG Sunday thread that sorta-kinda shows an item that should be seen early on in this challenge. -
@Farmer X said:
Veering off-topic a little: how old was the truck at the time?
I posted a photo in the SOG Sunday thread that sorta-kinda shows an item that should be seen early on in this challenge.1967 Chevy 3/4 ton 4x4 with the original 327 and a granny low 4 speed. That was a new body style in '67 and was built through 1972. But the '67 was kind of transitional in that it still used a 327 engine and Muncie 420 (going all the way back to 1947) transmission and also had a small rear window. 1968 and later had larger rear glass, 350 engine and Muncie 465 transmission.
Btw I have one of those SOG multitools but I have no idea where it is. -
@WECSOG said:
Thanks for everyone's input on the scissors!
I would have been fine with choosing something different, but I'm happy that these are ok because they are awesome EDC scissors; in fact I carried them every day for years. I bought an old Chevy truck in the late '90s and these were in the glovebox. The truck eventually got stolen, but at least I still have the scissors! 
And, because of your request about the scissors, I had very deeply surpressed feeling that surfaced.
I found a pair on the River site
, should arrive Friday.The MTo WAY!

-
Now look what you did. Ever since you took a broken Wave out of the surprise box, I find myself wondering what it would be like to have a broken Wave. I had to go out twice and bonk my head on the tool shed until the feeling went away.
Don't anybody say anything to friend LoopCutter about a Swiss Champ. Ever since he saw mine, the evil urge has been germinating in his gourd. He doesn't need one. Although actually everyone needs one. Especially not one of the Silver kind. Nobody. Mum's the word. Don't do it. Best wishes. Gary (IMR)
:ahhh
[attach id=0 msg=2553950]
How the smurf did that photo get there? Must have been that AI thing here.
-
Ha ha.

A SWISS CHAMP huh

I thought it was an EXPLORER!!! SilverTech
Ain’t going bigger, no do not need anything, any bigger!
Even if it gots SilverTech scales…

-
And, I am truly coming to terms with my separation anxiety as it concerns my obsession with LM MTs and the variety of functional SAKs that are in the world.
I will be able to carry any traditional I have and formulate a schedule to work out my pocket rotational schedule. A expect I will reduce my morning selection period from 2 hours down to maybe 45 minutes or less.
A simple kit is ready, it will be relocated to my carry pack as I venture out and about.
I have a home kit in one tool bag, and another bag outfitted similarly for the SUV.
The picks up truck already is outfitted with tools in the bed under the cover.
EDC a pocket knife, a dependable slip joint!☺️
-
You got this, Gordon. Keep taking your meds. Get lots of fresh air and rest. Keep saying to yourself, "Every day and in every way I'm getting better and better." We're right there with you, Swisschamp. I mean champ. Best wishes. Gary

Just for informational purpose an Explorer is only 4 layers. The Swisschamp is 8 layers of polished swiss masterpiece. And currently on sale in see through red or blue for 31% off on Amazon. Don't even think about it. You don't need one. G
-
Ha ha

-
@IMR4198 said:
You got this, Gordon.
Just for informational purpose an Explorer is only 4 layers. The Swisschamp is 8 layers of polished swiss masterpiece. And currently on sale in see through red or blue for 31% off on Amazon. Don't even think about it. You don't need one. GOnly the BLUE IS AT 31% OFF !!!
The Ruby is 115. Red is 115 too, but 8% off.
Black is 22% off to 89.99
Oh my that blue

Can catch a ride on the same truck delivering my scissors…
Damn good thing not EMARLD or SILVERtech
-
I am thinking strongly about joining the challenge. Though I already have the badge and have had a poor track record with finishing challenges the past two years, I think this will be a good way to get back into MTo activities. It is an interesting challenge and the listed participants are a great group of people to interact with.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login