Orange you glad we have a May Challenge?
-
Day 5
Ozark Trail (Walmart) sharpener.

-
Lots of similar comments, so here's my initial thoughts.
- The Vulpis has (thus far) held up to everything I've asked of it. That's not to say I've tortured tested it, but it's driven a bunch of different screws, opened packages, etc. without me ever wishing it was bigger. I think it's worth remembering that it's about the same size as the venerable Executive, which tons of people have carried as their main or only knife for years (see our yearly Chuck Yaeger challenge). In fact, it's a bit "deeper" so you get a similar length, but more belly.
I have not used the saw yet, but I'm inclined to agree that it's probably not going to be worth it as a saw. I am wondering if it's worth it simply as a "rough" blade to muscle open stuff like cardboard, and leave the main blade clean and sharp for food. Will report back over the course of the month.
Overall, I think the 2 or 3 layer versions will probably show very competently as keychain knives. A bit bigger than 58s, and some tools you don't usually see at this size. The 58mm bottle opener is iffy, and the 74s don't have one at all (the orange peeler will do in a pinch.) Likewise, no can opener (though I haven't tested it yet). The 4 layer is a bit bulky for that, but worth considering for anyone who likes the 74, 84, or 85 frames. I will have to see how it crams into the 5th pocket on a pair of jeans. With Wenger gone and Vic cutting a ton of their line in those ranges, I'm glad to see someone filling the gap. My wife has a couple 91s and 93s, and says they're all to big for EDC. She grabs them if we're going camping, working on stuff around the house, etc. but not for a regular day at the office. She's happy enough with a 58. I a Vulpis could be a nice upgrade for someone with a similar use case. (But she'll probably carry her 58 until it literally falls apart, since it's got our wedding date engraved.) As awlways, I do miss the scale tools, but that's not a dealbreaker for most people. Price is higher, but if it can be "buy once, cry once" I think it's acceptable.
- The Phillips on the Workman is pretty tiny. I will try to measure it (or at least compare with my bit set) at home and see if I can get a precise size. I'm going to guess #1. It did do fine on the stool, but I don't think you'd get anywhere on anything much larger. Definitely a "nice to have, but wouldn't want to rely on" tool.
-
@BPRoberts said:
The Vulpis has (thus far) held up to everything I've asked of it. That's not to say I've tortured tested it, but it's driven a bunch of different screws, opened packages, etc. without me ever wishing it was bigger. I think it's worth remembering that it's about the same size as the venerable Executive, which tons of people have carried as their main or only knife for years (see our yearly Chuck Yaeger challenge). In fact, it's a bit "deeper" so you get a similar length, but more belly.I have not used the saw yet, but I'm inclined to agree that it's probably not going to be worth it as a saw. I am wondering if it's worth it simply as a "rough" blade to muscle open stuff like cardboard, and leave the main blade clean and sharp for food. Will report back over the course of the month.
Overall, I think the 2 or 3 layer versions will probably show very competently as keychain knives. A bit bigger than 58s, and some tools you don't usually see at this size. The 58mm bottle opener is iffy, and the 74s don't have one at all (the orange peeler will do in a pinch.) Likewise, no can opener (though I haven't tested it yet). The 4 layer is a bit bulky for that, but worth considering for anyone who likes the 74, 84, or 85 frames. I will have to see how it crams into the 5th pocket on a pair of jeans. With Wenger gone and Vic cutting a ton of their line in those ranges, I'm glad to see someone filling the gap. My wife has a couple 91s and 93s, and says they're all to big for EDC. She grabs them if we're going camping, working on stuff around the house, etc. but not for a regular day at the office. She's happy enough with a 58. I a Vulpis could be a nice upgrade for someone with a similar use case. (But she'll probably carry her 58 until it literally falls apart, since it's got our wedding date engraved.) As awlways, I do miss the scale tools, but that's not a dealbreaker for most people. Price is higher, but if it can be "buy once, cry once" I think it's a acceptable.
Good write-up!

I have the four-layer version, and like you, initially thought one of the thinner versions might be a good keychain knife. YMMV, but as I considered it further, I realized the following:
The #1 reason I carry a key chain knife/tool is for the scissors, and the Vulpis scissors aren’t on par with Vic scissors.
If the saw and scissors on the Vulpis aren’t worth having, then we’re down to the two-layer version. But how does that compare to, say, a Vic Cadet? The Cadet provides more tools at a lower price point.
In fact, I would say the only clear advantage for the Vulpis over the Cadet is the blade steel. But then again, I don’t do much cutting with my key chain knife blade; I’m pretty much always carrying a larger knife as my main cutter.
-
Day 5
Of course, the main selling point of the Malga 6 vs. Vic SAKs is the M390 main blade. And it does not disappoint; the blade alone is worth the price of admission.
Shown with a Vic Cybertool M for scale…

-
I am surprised by all these decent 'SAKalikes' in this thread - as opposed to the CAKs.
Looks like they are pretty reasonable ..... and it's always good to keep Vic on their toes!!
-
Day 5
Pretty happy w/ the scissors so far.

-
<u>Day 5</u>
Speaking of SAK-A-Likes, I'm breaking out the Gerber Armbar Drive to do mail call and package duty today.

-
Day 6
One of my favorite flannel shirts.

-
Day 6
No name snap-off. If only it was a snap-on.

-
Day 6
Garant:

Mostly blue, but I think it’s the orange accents that really make it, aesthetically speaking. This is one of the few SAKs I have bought just because I wanted to have it in my collection, without any thought of using it. And I haven’t.
One of the odd features of this knife is that the tweezers have a 30mm ruler scale on them, which is just about visible in the picture. More of a curiosity than being of much practical use, I’d say.
-
@LoopCutter said:
Oh my! I like the 58mm!Me too .... a lot!!! :D - I guess it is the so-called 'Fire Opal' from the 2021 Classic Colours Collection? ???
-
Day 4
Almost done with the deck! But I'm working a couple of night shifts so there will be a small delay and hopefully we will get it done Friday evening. Got this classic SD for my birthday a couple of years ago. Don't use it much, I'm more of a rambler guy and have been thinking about moving the scales
[attach id=0 msg=2572227]

-
@nate j said:
Good write-up!

]I have the four-layer version, and like you, initially thought one of the thinner versions might be a good keychain knife. YMMV, but as I considered it further, I realized the following:
The #1 reason I carry a key chain knife/tool is for the scissors, and the Vulpis scissors aren’t on par with Vic scissors.
If the saw and scissors on the Vulpis aren’t worth having, then we’re down to the two-layer version. But how does that compare to, say, a Vic Cadet? The Cadet provides more tools at a lower price point.
In fact, I would say the only clear advantage for the Vulpis over the Cadet is the blade steel. But then again, I don’t do much cutting with my key chain knife blade; I’m pretty much always carrying a larger knife as my main cutter.
I've used the scissors a few times, and thus far they've proven more than adequete. The Vic scissors are world class, of course, but the Vulpis has opened a bag, trimmed a bunch of threads, and all those sorts of things perfectly well. I'd rate them above most of the Leatherman scissors, and on par with (or maybe slightly better than) the "good" Gerber ones (the old rounder ones they used to put on the MP400).
In my mind, there's a line between the 58, 65, and 74mm lines and the 84s. The Vulpis is more matched up against the former (like you said, a keychain knife). In which case (for tool options) you're deciding between a nailfile and scale tools vs a can opener (pending forming an opinion on the iffy saw). For the other tools, I think Fox is marginally ahead. They get an advantage on the blade, bottle opener, and drivers in most cases, but Vic the scissors and drivers if you need tiny ones for electronics and the like. I guess it comes down to use case, but I'll take the bigger drivers and blade in exchange for good-but-not-great scissors. If the old 74 line still existed, it'd be much stiffer competetion (I'm happy carrying it for the month, but I don't see it bumping the Executive off my keychain), but against the Classic SD/Rambler/Manager I think it's an upgrade in most cases.
I've tried it a few times, but the Cadet has awlways been too big for me on a keychain. As a dedicated pocket carry, it's a little more complicated. Since you can't get scissors under 91mm anymore, that's a much bigger jump for people who want scissors w/ the traditional blade and opener set (and/or want something bigger than the 58, but not jumping all the way). That's the wife/office worker catagory from yesterday. I need to check, but I think the Vulpis is also (per layer) thinner than the 84s (closer to the 58s), which factors into the bulk as well.
-
Day 6. Orange you glad!
[attach id=0 msg=2572241]
My very first CASE, a trapper with G10 scales! I found at a consignment shop. (At a very low price)
Orange Ozark mug for back ground.I guess when your birthday is on HALLOWEEN you either are drawn to things that are orange or black! Or maybe both. Weird! Right?

-
@BPRoberts said:
I've used the scissors a few times, and thus far they've proven more than adequete. The Vic scissors are world class, of course, but the Vulpis has opened a bag, trimmed a bunch of threads, and all those sorts of things perfectly well. I'd rate them above most of the Leatherman scissors, and on par with (or maybe slightly better than) the "good" Gerber ones (the old rounder ones they used to put on the MP400).In my mind, there's a line between the 58, 65, and 74mm lines and the 84s. The Vulpis is more matched up against the former (like you said, a keychain knife). In which case (for tool options) you're deciding between a nailfile and scale tools vs a can opener (pending forming an opinion on the iffy saw). For the other tools, I think Fox is marginally ahead. They get an advantage on the blade, bottle opener, and drivers in most cases, but Vic the scissors and drivers if you need tiny ones for electronics and the like. I guess it comes down to use case, but I'll take the bigger drivers and blade in exchange for good-but-not-great scissors. If the old 74 line still existed, it'd be much stiffer competetion (I'm happy carrying it for the month, but I don't see it bumping the Executive off my keychain), but against the Classic SD/Rambler/Manager I think it's an upgrade in most cases.
I've tried it a few times, but the Cadet has awlways been too big for me on a keychain. As a dedicated pocket carry, it's a little more complicated. Since you can't get scissors under 91mm anymore, that's a much bigger jump for people who want scissors w/ the traditional blade and opener set (and/or want something bigger than the 58, but not jumping all the way). That's the wife/office worker catagory from yesterday. I need to check, but I think the Vulpis is also (per layer) thinner than the 84s (closer to the 58s), which factors into the bulk as well.
I’m working with a sample size of one, so possible I just got a bad one. There are materials that the Vulpis scissors cut just fine. But when they painfully pulled (and failed to cut) my mustache hairs, that put them cleanly below Vic scissors and into the “not worth having” category.
I agree that the Vulpis knife blade is a clear improvement over any comparably sized Vic. Would love to see Vic offer some models with upgraded steel.
I suppose the real question is, “What do you want from your key chain knife/MT?”
If your keychain tool is your primary or only tool, AND you don’t mind not having scissors (or having marginal scissors), AND you don’t want to step up to 84mm, then there is a solid argument for a 2- (or 3-) layer Vulpis.
If your keychain tool is a complement/backup to a larger knife/MT (pretty much always the case for me), then a 58mm Vic is probably a better option…
As a keychain Rambler carrier, I don’t see the Vulpis replacing the Rambler on my keychain, for a number of reasons:
Scissors - Beating a dead horse at this point, but the Rambler scissors are far superior to the Vulpis scissors.
Knife Blade - Vulpis knife blade is better than the Rambler knife blade, hands down. But because I’m always carrying a larger knife or MT as my primary cutter, this isn’t as critical for me.
Nail File - Rambler wins by default, since the Vulpis doesn’t have one. I do appreciate having a nail file; it comes in handy from time to time.
Bottle Opener - Both work fine. I’ll call this a tie.
Can Opener - Vulpis wins by default, since the Rambler doesn’t have one. But, I don’t consider a can opener a must-have on a keychain tool.
Drivers - Vulpis has two flat drivers, that are actually kind of close in size. Their ability to reach recessed screws is limited by their design. Rambler has the flat SD on the end of the file, plus the outstanding 3D Philips on the combo tool. Their designs are such that they can generally reach even recessed screws. Clear win for Vic.
Scale Tools - Rambler wins by default, since Vulpis doesn’t have these. However, they aren’t too important to me; I would gladly switch to an Alox Rambler for improved durability if such a thing were available.
-
Day 6
MKM Malga 6 on cigar duty

-
Day 6
Bottle opener did not catch on the first try, but pulled it right off on the second. Not sure if it's the knife, or operator error.
(Love that distortion effect through the glass. Didn't notice it when I first took the pic.)

-
@BPRoberts said:
Bottle opener did not catch on the first try, but pulled it right off on the second. Not sure if it's the knife, or operator error.IIRC, the bottle opener on mine was slightly finicky about getting on the bottle cap at just the proper angle, but once this was accomplished, it would remove the cap with one pull.
I believe further testing may be in order.

-
<u>Day 6</u>
Just needed to do a quick touch up on the Gerber.

-
Day 7
An old friend from the toolbox:

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login