20th Anniversary Challenge
-
Hmmmm Buck or GEC badge

Either way should be a good 'un

-
I'll probably carry my Swisschamp for the SAK Stack badge.
-
@WECSOG said:
I'll probably carry my Swisschamp for the SAK Stack badge.@Echotech said:
Hmmmm Buck or GEC badge
Either way should be a good 'un

I am pretty certain doing the 20th Anniversary Challenge, which is a daily post type challenge will get you the 20th Anniversary Badge only.
You can do a separate challenge as well to get another badge utilizing another theme.
As the Dean MEMORIAL Challenge is featuring a EDC CARRY, traditional. Fix, friction, basically any knife except a SAK or Swiss clone type multi or aNY MULTITOOL. NO THUMB STUDS OR ONE HAND FLIPPERS IF I recall.
However, if you have done the MEMORIAL PREVIOUSLY, you can take that challenge and honor DEAN’s love of trads and use only CASE knives, BUCK TRADS, GEC, or any other trad that a badge currently exists.
That is a a challenge within a challenge.
-
He can get the Stack badge while posting on the 20th Anniversary Challenge. Using a SAK is legal for the Anniversary. He already has the green regular Anniversary badge. If he doesn't want the 20th Anniversary badge, he can certainly get a Stack badge.
First time I did (hosted) the Anniversary challenge I applied for the green Anniversary badge. Got it. Next year during the Anniversary challenge, I carried an Opinel every day and applied for the Opinel badge and got it.
There is an alternative. If friend WECSOG wants to host a SAK Stack challenge later in the summer or fall, I would be happy to join in. Friend Barry Rowland and I have already been talking about wanting a SAK Stack challenge. Barry could host, or me, or WECSOG as far as I am concerned. I would just as soon step aside and let someone else host. Probably get 10 people. There is already a badge, so anyone completing the SAK Stack could apply regardless of the number of challengers.
Best wishes. G
:ahhh -
I'd be in for a SAK Stack challenge.

-
@IMR4198 said:
He can get the Stack badge while posting on the 20th Anniversary Challenge. Using a SAK is legal for the Anniversary. He already has the green regular Anniversary badge. If he doesn't want the 20th Anniversary badge, he can certainly get a Stack badge.
First time I did (hosted) the Anniversary challenge I applied for the green Anniversary badge. Got it. Next year during the Anniversary challenge, I carried an Opinel every day and applied for the Opinel badge and got it.
There is an alternative. If friend WECSOG wants to host a SAK Stack challenge later in the summer or fall, I would be happy to join in. Friend Barry Rowland and I have already been talking about wanting a SAK Stack challenge. Barry could host, or me, or WECSOG as far as I am concerned. I would just as soon step aside and let someone else host. Probably get 10 people. There is already a badge, so anyone completing the SAK Stack could apply regardless of the number of challengers.
Best wishes. G
:ahhhI'll probably do that. You guys let me know what month you want to do it in.
I misunderstood; thought the Anniversary Challenge was the one I could incorporate a second challenge in and get both badges. I definitely want the 20th badge.
-
Naturally I can't speak for our friend Barry, but he was interested earlier this year in doing the SAK Stack. That makes four interested already and it hasn't even been announced yet. Our friend Aztec is interested in starting a Barlow challenge. That is the only other challenge that might be scheduled so far except for the August Marlin Spike event.
If you want to run this thing, I would suggest you and friend Aztec come to a meeting of the minds and pick two different months. Looks like September, October, or November. Right now there is a clear field, with no other challenges announced. That will change if others jump in to fill the gap and you might get squeezed out. December isn't the best month for a challenge in my opinion. Too many holiday and family things to deal with. I have hosted a challenge in December, but it is harder.
Our friend Barry might want to co-host the SAK Stack event. I'm just as happy to let someone else host it instead of me. Bear in mind there are two SAK Stack challenges. Like the Soldier Challenge, there is a 30 and a 60 day badge. I would be in for a 30. I don't know about anyone else. Either way, I won't be able to join in on a Barlow challenge, since I don't have anything of that nature. Best wishes. G

-
@IMR4198 said:
Naturally I can't speak for our friend Barry, but he was interested earlier this year in doing the SAK Stack. That makes four interested already and it hasn't even been announced yet. Our friend Aztec is interested in starting a Barlow challenge. That is the only other challenge that might be scheduled so far except for the August Marlin Spike event.
If you want to run this thing, I would suggest you and friend Aztec come to a meeting of the minds and pick two different months. Looks like September, October, or November. Right now there is a clear field, with no other challenges announced. That will change if others jump in to fill the gap and you might get squeezed out. December isn't the best month for a challenge in my opinion. Too many holiday and family things to deal with. I have hosted a challenge in December, but it is harder.
Our friend Barry might want to co-host the SAK Stack event. I'm just as happy to let someone else host it instead of me. Bear in mind there are two SAK Stack challenges. Like the Soldier Challenge, there is a 30 and a 60 day badge. I would be in for a 30. I don't know about anyone else. Either way, I won't be able to join in on a Barlow challenge, since I don't have anything of that nature. Best wishes. G

I'll start with a suggestion for September, although I'm good with October as well. Maybe even November. Possibly even two of those months, because if anyone is interested in the 60 day challenge I might be up for that.
But, I'll wait for input from Aztec and Barry, and anyone else who is interested. -
@WECSOG said:
I'll probably do that. You guys let me know what month you want to do it in.I misunderstood; thought the Anniversary Challenge was the one I could incorporate a second challenge in and get both badges. I definitely want the 20th badge.
Me too

Ok now I’m really confused

I thought the idea was we could get the 20th anniversary badge AND another badge if related to the Dean 51 challenge
I’m definitely wanting the 20th anniversary badge the most so will just stick with that then

-
[quote author=WECSOG link=topic=95062.msg2577128#msg2577128 date=1782251390
I'll start with a suggestion for September, although I'm good with October as well. Maybe even November. Possibly even two of those months, because if anyone is interested in the 60 day challenge I might be up for that.
But, I'll wait for input from Aztec and Barry, and anyone else who is interested.
[/quote]I am traveling October and November, do not think I can carry a STACK SAK on broad. And, I prefer light weight, plus considering carryon only. That does depend on weather forecast for Europe near travel dates.
-
Ok now I’m really confused

I thought the idea was we could get the 20th anniversary badge AND another badge if related to the Dean 51 challenge
I’m definitely wanting the 20th anniversary badge the most so will just stick with that then

You are correct. You can do the 20th, but you can not post using the same tool in the 20th and apply for two badges
You can also do the DEAN Memorial for your second badge (a seperate challenge), and instead of the Dean badge if you have you can get a CASE, BUCK, GEC, Opinel, fix blade. Etc for the 2nd badge.
-
@LoopCutter said:
You are correct. You can do the 20th, but you can not post using the same tool in the 20th and apply for two badgesYou can also do the DEAN Memorial for your second badge (a seperate challenge), and instead of the Dean badge if you have you can get a CASE, BUCK, GEC, Opinel, fix blade. Etc for the 2nd badge.
Got it
thanks LC 
I’ll just stick with the 20th in that case (or should that be buck
)
-
I'm not really involved in this thing, but that never stopped me from making a suggestion. Perhaps friend Aztec could make his Barlow Challenge begin in September. That would allow some of the members who wanted to be in the Marlin Spike challenge the ability to do the Barlow challenge as well.
That would leave October and November open for friend WECSOG. If there turned out to be sufficient interest in a 60 day event, then that would work. If most people wanted to do just a 30 day challenge, then the SAK Stack could end on October 30.
Whether it went 30 days or 60 days, our friend Aztec wouldn't be left hanging trying to figure out whether to schedule the Barlow challenge at the end of 30 days or wait another month. Events would dictate whether 30 days or 60 days were needed and the Barlow challenge could have a fixed and final date. So that way the SAK Stack have an open end to resolve that problem of one month or two. Without straying into Santa Claus territory.
Suggestions only. Do as you please.
Best wishes. G

-
@Echotech said:
Got it
thanks LC 
I’ll just stick with the 20th in that case (or should that be buck
)
While I am passing out free suggestions, I might as well make one to everyone who is planning to double up on the challenges as well. There were a couple of members who did both the Dean Traditional and Anniversary challenge. What they did was post the exact same photo every boring day to both challenges. Obviously never made any contact with any other member. Just 30 photos largely without comment to two challenges. Didn't acknowledge any mini challenges. Never played along, just posted their same photo in two places every mind-numbing day.
I should hope that anyone who decides to do the 20th Anniversary and the Dean Traditional takes the effort to keep things interesting. Post your photo of whatever CASE or Buck or whatever on the Dean. Feel free to post some photos of your traditional knife on the 20th as well, but mix it up some too. Nobody wants to follow the challenges and see the same photos twice. Lots of latitude on the 20th challenge. Post watches, SAKs, chainsaws, hand tools, swords, Legos, PBMTs, or anything else that is part of MTo.
This wasn't really a cautionary tale to anyone. It is more to state that you should make the effort to keep things fun for everyone and enjoy yourself as well. Taking advantage of the rules and re-using photos every day just to get a colored blotch on your award rack doesn't seem worth it.
Best wishes, G

-
We could definitely host a SAK Stack Challenge. I've found they vest work in cooker months because the Champs don't carry as well in shorts

@WECSOG said:
I'll probably do that. You guys let me know what month you want to do it in.I misunderstood; thought the Anniversary Challenge was the one I could incorporate a second challenge in and get both badges. I definitely want the 20th badge.
-
Did you mean best work in cooler months? Best wishes. G

-
@IMR4198 said:
While I am passing out free suggestions, I might as well make one to everyone who is planning to double up on the challenges as well. There were a couple of members who did both the Dean Traditional and Anniversary challenge. What they did was post the exact same photo every boring day to both challenges. Obviously never made any contact with any other member. Just 30 photos largely without comment to two challenges. Didn't acknowledge any mini challenges. Never played along, just posted their same photo in two places every mind-numbing day.
I should hope that anyone who decides to do the 20th Anniversary and the Dean Traditional takes the effort to keep things interesting. Post your photo of whatever CASE or Buck or whatever on the Dean. Feel free to post some photos of your traditional knife on the 20th as well, but mix it up some too. Nobody wants to follow the challenges and see the same photos twice. Lots of latitude on the 20th challenge. Post watches, SAKs, chainsaws, hand tools, swords, Legos, PBMTs, or anything else that is part of MTo.
This wasn't really a cautionary tale to anyone. It is more to state that you should make the effort to keep things fun for everyone and enjoy yourself as well. Taking advantage of the rules and re-using photos every day just to get a colored blotch on your award rack doesn't seem worth it.
Best wishes, G

Guilty as charged, my friend. I got so wrapped up in multiple challenges that I took the fun out of it (for me). I'll be doing the 20th Anniversary only. However, I will have a fun challenge within the challenge. It will be arduous, dangerous, complex, and illegal in fifteen states and several countries. There will be a prize, or prizes, for the survivor...eh, winner.

Make that two minis. One sort of serious and one fun.
-
You weren't even one of the people I was thinking about. If you want to plea however, you can have 6 months deferred sentencing, a personal recognizance bond and court costs. We can talk about setting a date for your mini-challenge. Likely to be scheduled every Friday. Send me a PM after the challenge gets cranked up.
I have re-used a photo a few times. Sometimes because it was something I liked. Sometimes for expedience. The posts I referred to weren't actually breaking the letter of the rules by posting the same photo on two challenges the same day. It was just an abuse of the spirit of doing a challenge. A challenge should take a little effort and thought. I think challenges are the best thing that we do here at MTo. Great chance for social interaction. Talking with friends. Showing off your stuff. Might not be able to do that at home ("What came in the mail, Kevin? Another knife? You're kidding, right? Mother said it would be this way.")
I told some friends about MTo. The badge idea and challenges were something they had never heard of. Then I mentioned the Sos Mystery Box and how many people had sent me things through the years. I'm not really sure they believed me. I didn't even say anything about how everyone gets along without quarreling and picking fights. I know they wouldn't have believed that.
Best wishes, Gary

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login