Barlow Knife Challenge Sept 2026
-
You can carry a Barlow during next month's Dean Memorial Challenge which covers traditional pocketknives, but if you wanted to get a separate challenge going I'd be in.

-
I like the advice you are getting. There is nothing scheduled after the August Marlin Spike deal. There isn't one single thing to stop you from picking a month and announcing it. Lots of Barlow fans here. There won't be a badge unless you get some people to sign up. I seem to remember that you made some nice looking badges yourself in the past. You could make your own as long as you do enough behind the scenes work to get it accepted.
One of our members who doesn't post much now tried to generate some interest in a Cold Steel challenge. It fell with a thud. I think you already have generated more interest than the abortive CS event. Some people would join in even with no badge, but the idea of getting a badge is a very big plus. I'm not sure if the month makes so much difference, as long as it doesn't conflict with some other challenge.
Naturally you could carry a Barlow for the Dean's Traditional as was mentioned. Seems like you said you wanted to carry Opinels for that one? I wonder if Opinel is considered a traditional? Certainly a traditional knife in France. Realistically, they are a lot different than something like a stockman or Barlow for that matter. When I was a puppy, not one person in my town would have known what an Opinel was. All of them would instantly recognize all the stuff made by CASE, Boker, Camillus, KaBar, etc. I never knew they existed until about 1970 when I saw a wholesale dealer with them in a trade paper. The importer had to explain what they actually were. I never actually handled one until decades later. All the hardware stores in town sold traditional knives. Even gas stations and country stores had them along with Colonial and Imperial low cost traditionals. No Opinels at all. Somebody will argue that they are traditional. Others will say they are not. Doesn't confront me any either way.
Did I get off the topic? I hate it when that happens. Best wishes. G

-
I didn't know about Opinels until I was much older. I thought they were fine but I didn't really start liking them until I had one in my hand. They were better than I was expecting. I thought they were considered traditional but I'm double checking regardless.
@IMR4198 said:
Did I get off the topic? I hate it when that happens. Best wishes. G

Off topics are what make the conversations interesting. :D
I'll throw up a quick poll between Sept, Oct, and Nov just to see if we have enough traction.
-
Are you thinking only classic, traditional barlows, or would various sizes and modern barlows be included as well?
-
Ah good question.
To me a Barlow, in it's simplest form, is represented by ***its stretched teardrop handle, a large metal bolster at the pivot end (which is approximately 1/3 the length of the blade) , and one or two blades. ***
That being said, I personally think there's room for both traditional and modern in this challenge. The GEC #78 Bullet End's bolster might not be long enough for my tastes but it's still a nice looking one. I also like the Boker Plus Modern Barlow but I'd probably remove the clip from it.
I prefer the more traditional look myself but I like some of the modern renditions that are out there as well. My small Barlow collection below.

-
The Kershaw Culpepper is called a Barlow by Kershaw, and it is a really nice knife, but the bolster is a bit short causing this community to declare it a Jack knife for challenge purposes.

-
The Culpeppers are well-known locals. Knife shop about 5 miles from me and another business nearby that sells salvaged ship parts. Want a porthole or a Japanese fishing float? That's the place. Culpepper Sr. was THE man for abalone at one time. He did contract work for Frank Buster (Solingen) years ago. Junior sells knives made and branded for their shop from Moki. I wouldn't be surprised if you couldn't buy a Culpepper Barlow from a Culpepper. Good folks.
I'm a Pepper,
He's a Pepper,
She's a Pepper,
All Culpeppers,
Buy a Pepper,
From a Pepper too.
G
:D -
@Alan K. said:
The Kershaw Culpepper is called a Barlow by Kershaw, and it is a really nice knife, but the bolster is a bit short causing this community to declare it a Jack knife for challenge purposes.

The Culpeper looks like a Jack to me as well. All Barlow's are Jackknives, but not all Jacks are Barlow's 😉
There are a few so called "Barlow's" that certainly aren't what would be considered a traditional Barlow pattern. I include the GEC Bullet end being one of those. A. Wright & Son are guilty of this as well.
-
I have some classic barlows, as well as some modern barlows, and some that might be considered Granddaddy barlows.
-
Has MTo sported a monthly challenge for a knife PATTERN?
Trapper. Stockman, Canoe, etc
Or a knife blade shape? Clip, Spear, Sheepfoot, Wharncliff, etc
Just thinking out loud.
I also
Would yield to Steve any rulings as to a if a JACK is a BARLOW or not.I know some old timers rule against a BARLOW, if it sports a SHIELD or EMBLEM on the scales.
I recall my grandma having a few in her kitchen drawer, wrapped in wax paper, a premium tucked inside a five or ten pound bag of flour.
-
Since our friend Steve is running the Traditional Challenge, I would be curious to know if he considers an Opinel as a traditional knife. For purposes of the challenge anyway. Best wishes. Gary

Late edit: I just looked over some of the entries for the Traditional and saw some Opinel knives. Evidently they are okay for the Dean challenge, or were at the time. G

-
Opinels are indeed very traditional.
-
Awlright gentle folks, and not so gentle (looks in the mirror... and winks), after consulting with the knife oracles, a decent amount of google-fu, and an overabundance of shenanigans, how bout we make these the definition of Barlow:
-
Long metal bolster (the metal cap at the pivot end) which typically measures about 1/3 the length of the handle.
-
No end cap, or butt bolster, or end bolster.
-
One or two blades.
That's it. That'll define a Barlow for the purposes of this challenge.
- "What about blade design?", you ask. - Doesn't matter.
- "But mine has a clip!" - That's ok too.
- "What about that funny looking shield there....!" - No biggie.
Let's just enjoy it. And it looks like Sept is a popular vote so let's go with that.
Who'd like to join me in Sept? No worries, I won't take offense if you have better things to do. But I better see you on the next challenge.

Let's try for 10 to make it official.
- AzteCypher
-
-
I have forgotten what I have left that may qualify as a BARLOW!
A few CASE, and maybe same number of RR brand.
And a CULPEPPER which resembles a Barlow.
But right now I must prep for JULY’s commitment.
-
I hope you decide to post a photo of your Culpepper on the 20th Anniversary event. Best wishes. G

-
@AzteCypher said:
Awlright gentle folks, and not so gentle (looks in the mirror... and winks), after consulting with the knife oracles, a decent amount of google-fu, and an overabundance of shenanigans, how bout we make these the definition of Barlow:- Long metal bolster (the metal cap at the pivot end) which typically measures about 1/3 the length of the handle.
- No end cap, or butt bolster, or end bolster.
- One or two blades.
That's it. That'll define a Barlow for the purposes of this challenge.
- "What about blade design?", you ask. - Doesn't matter.
- "But mine has a clip!" - That's ok too.
- "What about that funny looking shield there....!" - No biggie.
Let's just enjoy it. And it looks like Sept is a popular vote so let's go with that.
Who'd like to join me in Sept? No worries, I won't take offense if you have better things to do. But I better see you on the next challenge.

Let's try for 10 to make it official.
- AzteCypher
- BPRoberts
A fine definition in my book. You have my Barlow. Or several. I think I own 3 or 4.
[attach id=0 msg=2577322]
This one is an old Irish Imperial that I carried during the Country of Origin challenge a few years back. Great little knife.

-
Outstanding! Glad to have you along. That's a fine example you have there.

-
I’m sure I have at least a couple knives that will qualify…
- AzteCypher
- BPRoberts
- nate j
-
Love Barlow's and have a bunch of them. I'll have to see how I feel getting closer to September. Certainly has my attention 👍
-
You're always welcome to come have fun.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login