The Great Barlow thread!
-
so pretty much.....if there WAS a collectable barlow on ebay the past few months, I've bought it.
Top left down:
Yellow trucking colonial, some rust
plain white colonial
Paymaster Seeds, some use and rust
colonial electricians style but 2 blade, 2 snap, from "Rapps Variety's Store, 1948"
new made from china, but a nice collectable Ram Horn grip from Marbles
baby barlow "America 250"Right side, down
nice little red baby barlow, 2 snap, Imperial
heavily sharpened and pitted Boker
less sharpened but quite some patina Boker. I'm going to clean that one up
Remington branded, 2 snap, some light rust that I'll clean up
Schrade "tractor up", supposedly made in 1990
solid 2 snap Western, light patina.The red baby and Western are now in a carry rotation, even though I still carry my SAK much more.
Not pictured is another Imperial branded with "new holland" tractors logo
and also not pictured, BECAUSE IT WAS LOST BY THE POST OFFICE.......a VERY nice single blade Russel, got it for around $82, and just disappeared into the ether after being scanned in at my local PO. So somewhere between the PO and the truck, it just disappeared. Yes I filed a claim and got a check for of course less than I paid....but I want the knife. You obviously can't just buy another one like that. I'm thoroughly pissed about it. -
@Swinger said:
so pretty much.....if there WAS a collectable barlow on ebay the past few months, I've bought it.Top left down:
Yellow trucking colonial, some rust
plain white colonial
Paymaster Seeds, some use and rust
colonial electricians style but 2 blade, 2 snap, from "Rapps Variety's Store, 1948"
new made from china, but a nice collectable Ram Horn grip from Marbles
baby barlow "America 250"Right side, down
nice little red baby barlow, 2 snap, Imperial
heavily sharpened and pitted Boker
less sharpened but quite some patina Boker. I'm going to clean that one up
Remington branded, 2 snap, some light rust that I'll clean up
Schrade "tractor up", supposedly made in 1990
solid 2 snap Western, light patina.The red baby and Western are now in a carry rotation, even though I still carry my SAK much more.
Not pictured is another Imperial branded with "new holland" tractors logo
and also not pictured, BECAUSE IT WAS LOST BY THE POST OFFICE.......a VERY nice single blade Russel, got it for around $82, and just disappeared into the ether after being scanned in at my local PO. So somewhere between the PO and the truck, it just disappeared. Yes I filed a claim and got a check for of course less than I paid....but I want the knife. You obviously can't just buy another one like that. I'm thoroughly pissed about it.Nice collection; looks like the barlow bug bit hard!
It’s a shame about the one the PO lost…
-
-
With the recent interest in the Barlow challenge I thought I would bump this thread.
Queen #23

-
[attach id=0 msg=2579844]
SMkW Queen 440C

-
I just realized that I don't have a Queen in my Barlow collection. Let the hunt begin!
Meanwhile, here is one of my recent acquisitions. It's a RR with a simulated tortoise shell. I'm not usually a tortoise shell fan but this one caught my eye.


-
One of two Barlows I have is a Case 65316 bone stag.
Courtesy @Sparta19 a few years back.
Today I was handling it and went to close it the way I close my Spyderco Native 5. Sort of using my thumb to push the spine of the blade while the handle is cradled on the callous of my palm...
Woops...
I believe the cut on the medial side of the ring finger of my right hand went to the bone as I feel like it "skipped" over the solid bone at some point. I sprayed chlorhexidine and benzalkonium, but it kept bleeding until I poured BleedStop on it and wrapped a couple band aids on it.
Nice and sharp, I will say that. And pretty while it's at it.
-
^ without picture evidence, did it really occur? -
I wonder from time to time if I'm doing a good job at sharpening, until I accidentally get nicked by one of my freshly sharpened knives or it happens to catch me as it's closing.


-
@ThundahBeagle said:
One of two Barlows I have is a Case 65316 bone stag.Courtesy @Sparta19 a few years back.
Today I was handling it and went to close it the way I close my Spyderco Native 5. Sort of using my thumb to push the spine of the blade while the handle is cradled on the callous of my palm...
Woops...
I believe the cut on the medial side of the ring finger of my right hand went to the bone as I feel like it "skipped" over the solid bone at some point. I sprayed chlorhexidine and benzalkonium, but it kept bleeding until I poured BleedStop on it and wrapped a couple band aids on it.
Nice and sharp, I will say that. And pretty while it's at it.

-
@LoopCutter said:
^ without picture evidence, did it really occur?Ha ha. My issues posting pics here is documented sir. They snap at 3 and 4 mp. Otherwise there would have been a picture of a sink with paper towels, gauze, bottles of antiseptic, coagulation powder and a Barlow...seemingly without any blood on it at all.
Once I taped my finger shut, I cleaned it off anyway of course. Then put my work gloves on and went back to the garden tractor to finish cutting the grass.
-
And, with that you quell my blood lust🤔
Here I thought I am the only one who complains about a knife bite, after you hone a blade so nicely fine, that when it strikes, there is no pain, only red fluid flowing freely from the point of separation.
😳😳😋
-
@ThundahBeagle said:
Ha ha. My issues posting pics here is documented sir. They snap at 3 and 4 mp. Otherwise there would have been a picture of a sink with paper towels, gauze, bottles of antiseptic, coagulation powder and a Barlow...seemingly without any blood on it at all.Once I taped my finger shut, I cleaned it off anyway of course. Then put my work gloves on and went back to the garden tractor to finish cutting the grass.
Hopefully it will heal quickly being a clean cut. Been there done that a few times myself

-
I just remembered that my Imperial (Prov) made Diamond Edge advertising Barlow has not appeared in this thread before.


-
@SteveC said:
Hopefully it will heal quickly being a clean cut. Been there done that a few times myself
They say beware the rancher who owns only one rifle, he knows that gun and can do anything with it.
I don't have a lot, but enough where muscle memory for a totally different knife took over and it sure told me it was not being handled appropriately.
Had a better look at it today when I changed the dressing. That hard part that the blade skipped over was evidently that part of the nail that's not visible, but under the skin. Still pretty deep just after that, and it's a nice clean slice almost half the circumference. That Case is nice and sharp
-
[attach id=0 msg=2580350]

-
I concur! Very nice SteveC!
I hope WECSOG doesn't mind but, I have a question for those smarter than me, which are A LOT by the way. If a Barlow has a lockback, is it still a Barlow? Everything else being what make a Barlow a Barlow of course. Please see posting by WECSOG here.
I'm inclined to say yes, and here is why:
-
A Barlow knife is a traditional <u>slip-joint</u> pocket knife distinguished by an elongated teardrop handle, an oversized front bolster, and one or two blades designed for everyday use.
-
The lockback's blade locking mechanism is <u>a refinement of the slipjoint design</u>; both use a strong backspring located along the back of the knife handle.
The above being stated, one could argue that a lockback Barlow is a refinement of the original slipjoint design.
Thoughts or counter discussions?
-
-
@AzteCypher said:
I concur! Very nice SteveC!I hope WECSOG doesn't mind but, I have a question for those smarter than me, which are A LOT by the way. If a Barlow has a lockback, is it still a Barlow? Everything else being what make a Barlow a Barlow of course. Please see posting by WECSOG here.
I'm inclined to say yes, and here is why:
- A Barlow knife is a traditional <u>slip-joint</u> pocket knife distinguished by an elongated teardrop handle, an oversized front bolster, and one or two blades designed for everyday use.
- The lockback's blade locking mechanism is <u>a refinement of the slipjoint design</u>; both use a strong backspring located along the back of the knife handle.
The above being stated, one could argue that a lockback Barlow is a refinement of the original slipjoint design.
Thoughts or counter discussions?

I asked AI, and it said yes. It mentioned the AG Russell lockback Barlow as an example.
The reason I asked is, AzteCypher is hosting a Barlow Challenge here: /topic/95205
and I wanted to make sure before I go blithely posting photos of my Boker single blade, lockback Barlow. -
@AzteCypher said:
I concur! Very nice SteveC!I hope WECSOG doesn't mind but, I have a question for those smarter than me, which are A LOT by the way. If a Barlow has a lockback, is it still a Barlow? Everything else being what make a Barlow a Barlow of course. Please see posting by WECSOG here.
I'm inclined to say yes, and here is why:
- A Barlow knife is a traditional <u>slip-joint</u> pocket knife distinguished by an elongated teardrop handle, an oversized front bolster, and one or two blades designed for everyday use.
- The lockback's blade locking mechanism is <u>a refinement of the slipjoint design</u>; both use a strong backspring located along the back of the knife handle.
The above being stated, one could argue that a lockback Barlow is a refinement of the original slipjoint design.
Thoughts or counter discussions?
I don't think a lockback would disqualify it from being a Barlow when it has all the other features associated with the Barlow design.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

