Barlow Knife Challenge Sept 2026
-
@LoopCutter said:
I forgot in which thread GARY was talking about the CULPEPPER 😳Steve called it out as a good JACK KNIFE.
I agree, as the proportions to a BARLOW, just feel out of the mix.[attach id=0 msg=2578615]
Kershaw CULPEPPER (China) in G10!
Barlow is a QUEEN (China) Winterbottom scales and 440C.
I'm no expert and I defer to Steve but for some reason, in our parlance as kids in the 70's, I feel like a "jack knife" had more than one blade, including at least one out of the opposite ends of the handle.
Of course, I might be all wet on that
-
I think I have a Colonel Coon and a Case Barlow, both courtesy of @Spartan19
-
@ThundahBeagle said:
I'm no expert and I defer to Steve but for some reason, in our parlance as kids in the 70's, I feel like a "jack knife" had more than one blade, including at least one out of the opposite ends of the handle.Of course, I might be all wet on that
A Jack two blades on the same end, although one blade knives can be considered a Jackknife these days as well.
-
I have been seeing some nice Barlows on the Anniversary challenge. Sherry had a couple of nice Cripple Creek knives. I didn't know the maker after I saw the first one, so I did a search for knives with a buffalo emblem on the handle. Results came back that it was a Frost with buffalo horn handles. I refined the search a little and got results that indicated it was a knife company called American Buffalo. Two strikes. Finally, I figured out Cripple Creek. Nice knives but not cheap. Best wishes. G
:ahhh -
Being that the Barlow is my all time favorite pattern,,, I will have to participate in this challenge!

- AzteCypher
- BPRoberts
- nate j
- WECSOG
- PitCarver
- GA1dad
-
Alright!!

-
- AzteCypher
- BPRoberts
- nate j
- WECSOG
- PitCarver
- GA1dad
- IMR4198
I have to help friend Aztec get to the 10 challenger threshold. Even if I have to enter it with my Garlow. Something could turn up between now and then. Who knows? Best wishes, G
-
I'm in

- AzteCypher
- BPRoberts
- nate j
- WECSOG
- PitCarver
- GA1dad
- IMR4198
- SteveC
-
I just scored another Barlow! Looking forward to this one.

Unfortunately I withdrew from the August marlinspike challenge. Too much other stuff going on in August, and I seriously doubt I will get out on the water. But after a 30 day rest from challenges, I expect to be ready to go again.

-
I can understand challenge fatigue. I think it was our friend Fireman who told me he did 8 in a row once. Then he did a few more here and there and burned out a little. One in a row is enough for me, actually. I signed up for September and October. We will see if I can last through those. Even if I had a marlin spike, I wouldn't do four in a row.
I tried to explain the challenge game that we do to a friend via email. I'm not sure that he really got a feel for what I was talking about. To me, the challenge games are more fun than anything else we do here. I try to encourage new members to try one. Every now and then one of them does. Sometimes one signs up and never posts a single time. It takes some discipline to do it, but it can be entertaining.
Best wishes, G

-
@IMR4198 said:
I can understand challenge fatigue. I think it was our friend Fireman who told me he did 8 in a row once. Then he did a few more here and there and burned out a little. One in a row is enough for me, actually. I signed up for September and October. We will see if I can last through those. Even if I had a marlin spike, I wouldn't do four in a row.
I tried to explain the challenge game that we do to a friend via email. I'm not sure that he really got a feel for what I was talking about. To me, the challenge games are more fun than anything else we do here. I try to encourage new members to try one. Every now and then one of them does. Sometimes one signs up and never posts a single time. It takes some discipline to do it, but it can be entertaining.
Best wishes, G

I think this month makes 9 months in a row for me. If I didn't sit out the Marlinspike Challenge it would add up to 13 months straight, if I'm counting right. But I've gotta do the Barlow Challenge since I've now bought two additional Barlows specifically for it! :ahhh
And I'm playing host for two months of SAK Stack!
I'm certainly not complaining, though. I've enjoyed it thoroughly. And I agree; the challenges are the most fun activity on the forum.
-
I’ve gotten challenge fatigue before, and taken challenge breaks.
And some months, there just isn’t a challenge I’m interested in participating in.
Overall though, they’re a lot of fun!

-
I know I've experienced that fatigue as well. When I do a challenge, I look forward to reading people's posts and checking out knives I've never seen before. I learn something new every time I do a challenge. And some of those challenges make my wallet lighter by the end of the challenge.

-
@AzteCypher said:
I know I've experienced that fatigue as well. When I do a challenge, I look forward to reading people's posts and checking out knives I've never seen before. I learn something new every time I do a challenge. And some of those challenges make my wallet lighter by the end of the challenge.

This one has already made my wallet lighter, and we're still over a month away from the beginning of the challenge!

-
@IMR4198 said:
I can understand challenge fatigue. I think it was our friend Fireman who told me he did 8 in a row once. Then he did a few more here and there and burned out a little. One in a row is enough for me, actually. I signed up for September and October. We will see if I can last through those. Even if I had a marlin spike, I wouldn't do four in a row.
I tried to explain the challenge game that we do to a friend via email. I'm not sure that he really got a feel for what I was talking about. To me, the challenge games are more fun than anything else we do here. I try to encourage new members to try one. Every now and then one of them does. Sometimes one signs up and never posts a single time. It takes some discipline to do it, but it can be entertaining.
Best wishes, G

This will only be 3 in a row, for me.
And that's enough for this old guy. -
I burned out on Challenges a long time ago. But I'm doing two at the moment. Will probably do the Barlow Challenge but haven't made a final decision yet 🤔
-
I’ve lost track of how many in a row I’ve done at this point.
I’m also already signed up for the marlin spike challenge in August and this barlow challenge in September. And I’ll probably join the SAK Stack challenge for October.
As long as people keep proposing interesting challenges and I keep enjoying it, I’ll keep going.
-
@IMR4198 said:
I can understand challenge fatigue. I think it was our friend Fireman who told me he did 8 in a row once. Then he did a few more here and there and burned out a little. One in a row is enough for me, actually. I signed up for September and October. We will see if I can last through those. Even if I had a marlin spike, I wouldn't do four in a row.
I tried to explain the challenge game that we do to a friend via email. I'm not sure that he really got a feel for what I was talking about. To me, the challenge games are more fun than anything else we do here. I try to encourage new members to try one. Every now and then one of them does. Sometimes one signs up and never posts a single time. It takes some discipline to do it, but it can be entertaining.
Best wishes, G

You can do it, G. I have two Barlows, but I'm willing to look for more. I had so much fun with the anniversary, I think I can hack this and the stack in Oct.
The fireman is in!
- AzteCypher
- BPRoberts
- nate j
- WECSOG
- PitCarver
- GA1dad
- IMR4198
- SteveC
- Fireman
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login