Huntsman, Ranger, or something else?
-
I know, it's tricky! I kinda told him that SAKs are never "One and done" in my experience. You still need the right (multi)tool for each job, and a "do-it-all" like a SwissChamp comes with the cost of carrying the dang thing.
A Camper plus a Classic might be perfect for backpacking. I've always thought the Classic is kinda... boring? Bested by its cousins? But a Rambler doesn't add a lot to your overall capabilities if you're carrying a second tool.
I still think a Huntsman might be about perfect for an EDC for him. I think he'd use each of the tools pretty often, and he's never too far away from a truck if he needs something else. And he could bring it for short backpacking trips without too much thought, as Huntsman said.
I'll take a look at the weights and thicknesses when I get back home (I'm traveling at the moment) and maybe make some kind of table for myself. It's always a tricky balance.
-
@mathmitch7 said:
~A Camper plus a Classic might be perfect for backpacking. I've always thought the Classic is kinda... boring?
I still think a Huntsman might be about perfect for an EDC for him. I think he'd use each of the tools pretty often, and he's never too far away from a truck if he needs something else. And he could bring it for short backpacking trips without too much thought, as Huntsman said.
~The CLASSIC does not have to be boring, it is offered with so many scale options.
Trash Panda, Christmas themes, Smokey the Bear. Sasquatch flavors and one of my favorites
[attach id=0 msg=2584901]
The CIGAR, a RED HILL CULTERY exclusive.
It is flanked by an Alligator on the right and a Dragon scale on the left.
Not BORING!
As for the 93mm, Alox Pioneer X, it will heavier, as the blade and other implements are thicker than the standard VICTORINOX UTENSILS. They are also referred to as HD tools. Disadvantage for hiking is no scale tools, toothpick and tweezers are handy. But paired with a Classic, problem solved.

-
@LoopCutter said:
The CLASSIC does not have to be boring, it is offered with so many scale options.Trash Panda, Christmas themes, Smokey the Bear. Sasquatch flavors and one of my favorites
[attach id=0 msg=2584901]
The CIGAR, a RED HILL CULTERY exclusive.
It is flanked by an Alligator on the right and a Dragon scale on the left.
Not BORING!
As for the 93mm, Alox Pioneer X, it will heavier, as the blade and other implements are thicker than the standard VICTORINOX UTENSILS. They are also referred to as HD tools. Disadvantage for hiking is no scale tools, toothpick and tweezers are handy. But paired with a Classic, problem solved.
Great points all around!
-
Fun quest you have before you @mathmitch7.
In my opinion 3 to 4 layers is a sweet spot for EDC which is where I will focus my thoughts. Just from experience, I EDC items daily, but camp not so often.
My first SAK was a 3 layer Camper, I still like the 3 layer format. I didn't use the wood saw much at all though.
If I were looking to have a 1st SAK right now it would be the Compact. A Compact with a wood saw would be the bees knees, but they don't make one. A Compact with metal file does exist in the discontinued TrailGuide.
Scissors come in handy quite often on the daily and the added bonus of a pen in the scales comes in handy.
The tool I use the most in a SAK is the blade.
The conundrum is which to get, a SAK that has minimal tools that will have him thinking about which tools he'd want to add, or get him a Huntsman (a promising contender) and have him possibly not carry it.
Is there anyway you could take him to a store that carries them and have him choose? Unsure if he's local to you.
-
Questions, questions - Decisions, decisions
Sometimes I wish it were like the old days (decades ago) - When I only had a ***single SAK ***- My trusty Huntsman
It went everywhere with me and did everything I needed it to :ahhh-
I did not have this massive (shelf queen) collection

-
I did not have a difficult decision to make every day on which SAK to EDC - from the EDC group ???
-
I vaguely knew there were various other SAKs out there as I had seen them in the shop, but did not pay too much attention to them * >:D
-
I was much richer, having not spent all my money on buying SAKs

-
Life was just so much simpler and easier

-
.... Note: This was a real shop where I could pick them all up - I still have the image in my brain
- I do remember noticing the SwissChamp at that time and thinking it was ridiculous(ly too big!).
EDIT: PS - I am awaiting the pressing of the Big Ban Button on me for sacrilege.
-
-
It can certainly be a challenge to try to narrow it down to one SAK, given the array of options available.
I’d suggest starting with picking a length. Sounds like you/he are pretty set on 91mm. I think this is a solid choice, as they’re big enough to handle all but the most challenging tasks, and offer the widest range of tools and models.
The next question is, “Corkscrew or back-side Phillips?” An easy call, IMO, as the corkscrew is far more versatile. Some make the mistake of thinking they have no use for a corkscrew if they don’t drink wine, but this couldn’t be further from the truth. It’s a great little marlin spike, as long as the diameter of the cord is less than the distance between turns of the corkscrew. It also stores the handy mini-screwdriver.
Then I would ask, “How many layers?”
There are no single-layer 91mm knives currently manufactured, so that’s pretty much out. Personally, I find 4 layers to be about the maximum for comfortable pocket carry. So, we’re looking for 2-4 layers.For 2 layers with corkscrew, you’re looking at Spartan or Compact. I carried a Spartan for a number of years, and it’s a solid but minimalist option. Still, better a Spartan (or Compact) in the pocket than a larger SAK left in a drawer or glovebox because it was too heavy. I carried a Compact for a while as well, but the lack of an efficient way to handle Phillips screws put me off of it.
If willing to move up to 3 layers, the question becomes, “What is the next most useful tool to have?”
My answer would be scissors. Vic scissors are the best in the business, and come in handy for personal grooming, loose threads, moleskin, etc.
Options then are the Climber or the Companion. I’d suggest a second blade is more useful than a nail file on the job site or camp site. I’ve also had the can opener save the day once or twice when car camping, and wouldn’t want to trade it for a package opener. I carried a Climber for years as well; it’s a fantastic SAK and I rarely felt under-equipped with it in my pocket.If willing to move up to 4 layers, “What is the next most useful layer to add to the Climber configuration?”
I would NOT say the wood saw. I carried one in my hiking pack (if not my pocket) for years, but can’t ever recall actually using it. I believe this comes down to the fact that anything small enough to be cut with the 91mm wood saw and dry enough to burn can be more quickly broken by hand.
There are arguments, in my view, for the following:Pliers - This would be the (sadly discontinued) Deluxe Climber. Though smaller than most PBMT pliers, the 91mm Vic pliers punch above their weight. They’ll handle virtually anything that will fit in their jaws, while the tips are so finely machined that they can grasp a single human hair. Used Deluxe Climbers still pop up on the ‘bay, or can be modded from commonly available parts.
Phillips Screwdriver & Mag Glass - Explorer. If one deals with a lot of Phillips screws, especially recessed Phillips screws, the 3D end-mounted Phillips is worth the weight; it’s also far superior to the back-mounted Phillips. I find the mag glass more and more useful as I approach middle age.
Metal Saw/File - Mountaineer - In addition to doing what the name says, it works fine for fingernails.
P.S. The 91mm models are tougher than they look. Read about the legendary Vicky here:
/topic/46255 -
Part of this is to introduce him to the Victorinox Swiss Army Knife. That's the key part you mention. He may take it backpacking and hiking, he may use it at work
Huntsman is a most excellent introduction to SAKs:
.iconic red cellidor handle - check!
.the basic tools of a most basic Spartan - check!
.saw AND scissors for optimum usefulness both in and outdoors - check!I'm not a "backpacker" per se but I do a fair bit of hiking and camping. I carry the Huntsman. The scissors for bandages and the saw for wood is worth the minimal weight penalty in my book.
Next best would be Farmer X, because of the metal Alox, even though it lacks scale and back tools. The metal scales more than make up for that, as they don't shatter when dropped on concrete or stone
-
@FolderBeholder said:
Fun quest you have before you @mathmitch7.In my opinion 3 to 4 layers is a sweet spot for EDC which is where I will focus my thoughts. Just from experience, I EDC items daily, but camp not so often.
My first SAK was a 3 layer Camper, I still like the 3 layer format. I didn't use the wood saw much at all though.
If I were looking to have a 1st SAK right now it would be the Compact. A Compact with a wood saw would be the bees knees, but they don't make one. A Compact with metal file does exist in the discontinued TrailGuide.
Scissors come in handy quite often on the daily and the added bonus of a pen in the scales comes in handy.
The tool I use the most in a SAK is the blade.
The conundrum is which to get, a SAK that has minimal tools that will have him thinking about which tools he'd want to add, or get him a Huntsman (a promising contender) and have him possibly not carry it.
Is there anyway you could take him to a store that carries them and have him choose? Unsure if he's local to you.

-
Thank you all again, this has been a fantastic discussion so far.
@FolderBeholder said:
Is there anyway you could take him to a store that carries them and have him choose? Unsure if he's local to you.Not really an option, sadly. He's out in Colorado, I'm in New York. I see him maybe once or twice a year.
@nate j said:
It can certainly be a challenge to try to narrow it down to one SAK, given the array of options available.P.S. The 91mm models are tougher than they look. Read about the legendary Vicky here:
/topic/46255Thank you for the thoughts! I love seeing different people's thought processes. Awesome considerations. Personally, I think I'd prefer a wood saw to the pliers, but I've actually never used the pliers and won't have a good perspective on it until I do (and a new (old) SwissChamp is on the way!). I had never seen the Saga of Vicky before, but it was a fantastic read. Thank you for sharing that too!
@ThundahBeagle said:
Part of this is to introduce him to the Victorinox Swiss Army Knife. That's the key part you mention. He may take it backpacking and hiking, he may use it at work.Another fantastic consideration. If this is his one and only (the horror!), it's important it covers the big bases.
-
I gave him the Rambler I had with me to hold him over until I can get him "Something more substantial." I'm sure I'll never see that little red guy again, but that's OK! My BIL deserves it.
-
Yep, you can kiss that Rambler good-bye, they are great little tools.

A Camper/Rambler combo could cover a lot of tasks, just saying.
-
@FolderBeholder said:
Yep, you can kiss that Rambler good-bye, they are great little tools.
A Camper/Rambler combo could cover a lot of tasks, just saying.
If he has the RAMBLER you gifted him, then yes the CAMPER in best 91mm compliment.
On AMAZON the CAMPER is about $30. That is less than a RAMBLER. SHUCKS grab two.
Pairing up two models of VICTORINOX models is a real solution, much better than finding a one has awl solution.
-
@FolderBeholder said:
Yep, you can kiss that Rambler good-bye, they are great little tools.
A Camper/Rambler combo could cover a lot of tasks, just saying.

-
@mathmitch7 said:
Thank you for the thoughts! I love seeing different people's thought processes. Awesome considerations. Personally, I think I'd prefer a wood saw to the pliers, but I've actually never used the pliers and won't have a good perspective on it until I do (and a new (old) SwissChamp is on the way!). I had never seen the Saga of Vicky before, but it was a fantastic read. Thank you for sharing that too!
YMMV, but for me, the wood saw was one of those tools I thought would come in handy, but it never did.
I’ll be interested in your thoughts on the pliers once you’ve had a chance to use them.
I think everyone, at some point, should do their own personal Swisschamp challenge. Carry the Swisschamp for a month or even just a week. See what tools they actually use, when they have nearly all available.
-
@nate j said:

YMMV, but for me, the wood saw was one of those tools I thought would come in handy, but it never did.
I’ll be interested in your thoughts on the pliers once you’ve had a chance to use them.
I think everyone, at some point, should do their own personal Swisschamp challenge. Carry the Swisschamp for a month or even just a week. See what tools they actually use, when they have nearly all available.
Good suggestion. Try it all. Drop what you don't need. When it comes to these though, for some reason I tend to stay lean and buy what I need or think I need
True, the saw is something I always think I may use out camping, but rarely have I started my campfire with a true and proportional "log cabin". I just break the sticks, although it would maybe be nice to saw some old deadwood off the lower part of a tree.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login