Hello Sailor! Marlin Spike/Rigging Knife Challenge - August 2026
-
@mathmitch7 said:
I'm Not Appearing In This Challenge but at the state fair (in the "museum" section about hand-tools) I saw this...Thanks for sharing. That is quite an assortment of boat building tools. Makes you appreciate the effort and skill that went into the craft.

JonesE
-
Three cameos to get to 30. I thought I had one more somewhere, so it might make a last minute guest appearance tomorrow. I will awlso, hopefully, post a pic for the final mini challenge.
Day 28
This Myerchin is actually one of my wife's favorite multis. The claw/plier handle is clever.
[attach id=0 msg=2586337]
Day 29
It says Sheffield, but I've always felt this one felt pretty knockoff-ish. Got it second hand, so hard to know for sure.
[attach id=1 msg=2586337]
Day 30
This one is definitely Chinese, but I have an older Italian version somewhere. Love the giant can opener.
[attach id=2 msg=2586337]
My opinion on the Marlin Spike is much like the similarly water-related fish-scaler, it's great to have a poking tool on a knife. The only issue is, unlike the scaler, it's pretty limited in what you can get it on. Vic and co rarely include them until you get to the chunky models, and most of the rigging knife style multis I carried this month were awkward, stiff, etc. Someday, I'll get one of the 93mms with the spike/needle, and maybe I'll feel better about those.
Thanks for everyone who sailed along with us this month. Hosting a challenge when I was gone for awlmost two weeks was not my best move, and I'm sorry I wasn't a more active host. Barlows next month, and I'm looking forward to carrying something smaller.



-
Day 30
The Myerchin Gen2 Ti Captain has really proven itself a capable all-around option, checking many of the boxes I prefer in a pocketknife. The marlin spike is a useful bonus.
I haven’t developed quite the same level of fondness for the Crew. I prefer the larger handle and larger blade of the Captain, the Captain is easier to flip OHO, and empirical observations suggest that the edge geometry may be better on the Captain. The Crew still has its place, however, when pocket space or pack weight is at a premium.
Thanks for a fun challenge, all, and special thanks to BPR for hosting!

-
I enjoyed this challenge. Thanks to BP for hosting and awl who participated. Of all the knives I've seen in this challenge I think I'd like to pick up a titanium Captain TF300, but it is way down the list right now. Everything is. Between plumbing and HVAC issues, I've spent a grand in the last 3 weeks and money for knives and tools is going to take a while.

-
D29
Another day, another boxBut let's talk about the least useful feature of the Myerco (and many others)..... the extended double liner.
What function does it serve? None that I can tell, except blocking the bottom 1/16in of the shackle key.
The origonal British Army knives had an extended liner, but only one, and it was thick enough to be used as a screwdriver.
So aside from looks I cant find a reason for these 2 paper things extentions.(1).jpg)
-
Day 30
30 days with some old BAKs and it was fun but confirmed my long held opinion that these aren’t EDC but built for a job. They’re basically indestructible but also pretty basic
As a kid I carried one just like BP’s black scaled Chinese model and loved that knife but once I got a SAK I knew it’d be easier to carry and suit my needs better
Thanks to BP and you all for a very enjoyable challenge


-
<u>Day 30</u>
I really liked the Myerchin since the first time I saw nate J post about them. The Crew did not disappoint. I really liked that it was pocketable for me and it's a good looking knife. Could it handle the job of being on a boat? Maybe though I'm sure the Captain would do a better job. The Camillus was definitely bigger and I feel that one could definitely handle boat life.

Thanks to BPRoberts for hosting this challenge!

See y'awl in the Barlow Challenge!
-
@Alan K. said:
Of all the knives I've seen in this challenge I think I'd like to pick up a titanium Captain TF300, but it is way down the list right now. Everything is. Between plumbing and HVAC issues, I've spent a grand in the last 3 weeks and money for knives and tools is going to take a while.

Hopefully the unexpected expenses stop.
The Ti Captain is worth snagging IMO. The only things I can think of that might be off putting to some:
-
Mine weighs in at 4.8 ounces on my scale. This is well within my comfort zone, but maybe heavier than some folks would like to carry.
-
The Ti handles really show scratches etc. Some people like this, some don’t, some are ambivalent.
-
The price for a new one has gotten a bit crazy. (Like the price of everything else though, I suppose.). Myerchin lists them at $155; looks like a new one might be had around $110; used maybe less obviously. I’m sure I paid under $100 for mine NIB.
-
-
@Noa Isumi said:
D29
Another day, another boxBut let's talk about the least useful feature of the Myerco (and many others)..... the extended double liner.
What function does it serve? None that I can tell, except blocking the bottom 1/16in of the shackle key.
The origonal British Army knives had an extended liner, but only one, and it was thick enough to be used as a screwdriver.
So aside from looks I cant find a reason for these 2 paper things extentions.I think you’re correct that the original purpose of the stout extended liner was to serve as a flat screwdriver/small pry tool.
Unfortunately (and this is one of the problems with knock-offs), it seems like folks who tried to copy the design later either did not understand or did not care about its purpose. So, they ended up with something cosmetically similar but functionally useless.
-
@AzteCypher said:
I really liked the Myerchin since the first time I saw nate J post about them. The Crew did not disappoint. I really liked that it was pocketable for me and it's a good looking knife. Could it handle the job of being on a boat? Maybe though I'm sure the Captain would do a better job. The Camillus was definitely bigger and I feel that one could definitely handle boat life.
AC!So, when is your Captain supposed to arrive?

-
Day 31
The transition picture.
Did we get a Marlin spike badge made up yet?
-
@Noa Isumi said:
D29
Another day, another boxBut let's talk about the least useful feature of the Myerco (and many others)..... the extended double liner.
What function does it serve? None that I can tell, except blocking the bottom 1/16in of the shackle key.
The origonal British Army knives had an extended liner, but only one, and it was thick enough to be used as a screwdriver.
So aside from looks I cant find a reason for these 2 paper things extentions.I was very confused the first time I saw the "double driver" on one of my knock offs.
I know my dad used to tell a story about a Soviet knock off of an American plane that had a door in a weird spot since they tried to exactly copy it. I've never been able to verify that exact version, but we see similar cases all the time.
Free carry day, so I slipped the Huntsman in my pocket. Barlows will be fun, but it's awlways a pain when I have to drop off the multi for just a folder.
-
Day 30
I started the challenge with the Camillus Marlinspike 2.0. I ended the challenge with three knives in total after adding the two SOGs. I really like the Camillus. I just wish it carried a bit slimmer in the pocket. The SOGs helped with pocket carry but lacked a locking blade. One observation from the challenge is how useful the Marlinspike was outside of rope and chord work. I used it for aligning holes, scraping debris, probing for rust and corrosion, and as a scratch awl to layout cut marks.
Thanks to BPRoberts for hosting the challenge and for the mini challenges. Also, a big shout out to those who participated. It was a lot of fun seeing how each of you went about the challenge.
JonesE
-
@nate j said:
AC!So, when is your Captain supposed to arrive?


I never took a picture of this and I never mentioned it but, JonesE's post reminded me that the marlin spike makes a very good drift pin. I have a adjustable spud wrench that I use for that purpose but the marlin spike on my Camillus came in handy for that.
-
Ok, I know that the challenge officially ended yesterday, but I don't like to waste a perfectly good day.
There was a big argument here, last night, about what to do. The spike wanted to finish and the Barlow wanted to start.[attach id=0 msg=2586424]
I made the tie breaking decision that they could both be in for today. The spike got to tighten up the last knot, while the Barlow got to trim the ends of the paracord.
[attach id=1 msg=2586424]
I do believe that this is my best one yet.


-
Another great looking lanyard PC!

JonesE
-
Day 31, Final Mini-Challenge
Using the spike on the KABAR to open the strands on some ol' fashioned manila rope (this stuff sucks, but it felt appropriate for the challenge)
[attach id=1 msg=2586473]
To make an eye splice.
[attach id=0 msg=2586473]
And a short splice.
No tot for me, but anyone who made it to 30, don't forget your badge.



-
It was a fun challenge.
Thanks for hosting. -
Very cool BP. I tried my hand at it a bit but mine was definitely not presentable. I'd need to try a few more times before it'd be presentable.
Your lanyard looks really good PC!
<u>Day 31</u>
Had to open up a bag of sweets for the family.

I admit it... I ate two of them.

-
D30
The Skipper is back in the case
It was fun even though I skipped most of the mini-challanges. I am happy to be back to my Trekker though, missed the one hand open.I also used this as an opportunity to slim down my edc of stuff I dont use that often.
So here's a pic of what's left.
Not pictured: wallet, phone, keys, bandanas, watch, and a knockoff 'Tread'
In this lineup the Micra really only gives decent scissors and an eyeglass driver, so it may get swapped for something else..jpg)

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
