Barlow Knife Challenge Sept 2026
-
Might as well start the month out right by using my Barlow to part my cigar.
The knife that I got for this challenge is a Rough Rider, old style Barlow, in white smooth bone. No fancy half stops and the pen blade on the back side. I like the white smooth bone scales because of the ability to take on color with age, (or by artificial means).
-
Day 1
Today I am carrying this beautiful Camco 551 that I got for like $5 on ebay. So far today, I've only used it to open (what else?) my mail, which contained (what else??) more knives.
I love the patina on the blades of this knife, and it cleaned up and sharpened pretty good.

-
@mathmitch7 said:
Day 1Today I am carrying this beautiful Camco 551 that I got for like $5 on ebay. So far today, I've only used it to open (what else?) my mail, which contained (what else??) more knives.
I love the patina on the blades of this knife, and it cleaned up and sharpened pretty good.

I've always like Camco Barlow's 👍 🤠
-
-
Day 1
We've seen some nice old Case Barlows. Here's my relatively young gun. Carried so easy today I had to move it out of my normal knife pocket (a 5th "security" pocket in my slacks) into the back one.

-
Beautiful collection so far all! I really like the mix of modern and vintage knives. I'm glad some brands are still making them, and not just Rough Ryder + Old Timer + Case + no-names.
-
Great start awl. There are some beauties already making an appearance.
Day 1

-
@mathmitch7 said:
I think this shape is called a Lanny's Clip, or Pruner? I say it's close enough for a day, but I'm no expert. Cool knife, regardless!I’d call that blade a sheepsfoot. Straight edge, with spine parallel to edge before dropping to meet edge.
Lanny’s Clip, originally designed by the late great Tony Bose (and later copied by others), is a type of clip point blade (hence the second half of the name) with a distinctive handle. Example: Case Bose Locking Lanny’s Clip
https://caseknives.com/blogs/news/case-x-tony-bose-locking-lannys-clip-collection-announced-at-shot-showA pruner blade has a concave edge and a downward-facing point. Example: Second blade on the Vic Swiss Army 7
https://www.victorinox.com/en-US/Products/Swiss-Army-Knife™-and-Tools/Gardening/Swiss-Army-7-Alox/p/0.8150.26IIRC, it was decided that, at least for purposes of this challenge, at least one elongated bolster would be the defining criterion for a barlow. So by that definition, I have to agree with Steve that it’s a nice looking knife, but not a barlow.

-
@David Bowen said:
Thought it was, blade shape and handle with the one bolster gave me that impression. I've got more in my arsenal thankfully.
**Barlow **- Long metal bolster (the metal cap at the pivot end) which typically measures about 1/3 the length of the handle.
No end cap, or butt bolster, or end bolster.
One or two blades. -
Day 02
Used my Diamond Edge Barlow to open a new hot sauce. This one has smoked habaneros, peaches and loquats.


-
Great looking Barlows up there!
Finally making time to post after a long day.

<u>Day 1</u>
Didn't get to do anything fun with mine so here's a glamour shot of my Hammer Brand Barlow.

-
New production Imperial Barlow. Stainless steel. Lifetime warranty. Low cost. Came sharp out of the box. Blades have good snap with no wobble. Best wishes. G[attach id=0 msg=2586500]
Your comments apply to mine as well. Including the super pointy blades.
Day 2
New production Imperial. I posted it somewhere on the site, right after I got it. IIRC it was $5.99, added to an existing order so shipping was free.
I really like my better quality, collectable Barlows. But to me, this epitomizes what a Barlow is all about. I remember when small country stores had displays of cheap pocket knives near the register. Maybe a dollar for an Imperial Barlow. You didn't expect top grade steel. It was a cheap knife that worked fine for the typical things you would use a pocket knife for, and if you lost it while baling hay or whatever, you just bought another one. At least you didn't lose your nice Case, because you left that one home during jobs like this.This 6 dollar Barlow fits with that, exactly. I like my Case Barlow, but it's a collectable and I treat it as such. This one, if I lost or broke it, no big deal.

-
Day 2
[attach id=0 msg=2586621]
I noticed that the new production Imperial Barlow was stamped with the number 278 on the back of the main blade. That is the same number that the original Imperial Barlows used. About 1960 the 2 blade Imperial models were called Bowie Barlow knives. Two tone handles. Brown over a lighter color base.
Number 278 stood for the clip point two blade model. The sheepfoot was number 279. Number 280 was a spear point. The knives came packed a dozen to a hanging card that was pre-printed with the price of $1. Number 281 was an assortment with 4 each of the three main blade styles.
Cost for any of the Bowie Barlows was $5.40 a dozen. A minimum order was for 12 dozen. This was a straight from the factory jobber price. A dime store or gas station probably wouldn't want that many of one type. They would have gotten a card or two from their wholesaler. Imperial made a lot of different sorts of knives at one time. A retailer doesn't really want to buy enough of any one thing to last for years. Got his money tied up. Storage problems, etc. Terms for sale FOB Providence, RI were 1% in 10 days with balance due in 30.
All a different world now.
Best wishes, G
-
Day 2
Proper Barlow today is a AG Russell one I've had forever with G10 handles. I think it's got a 154CM blade but could be wrong. Also how do you guys carry your knife? loose? or use some sort of pocket pouch? I often carry other things as well so a good organizer is usually in my pocket.
[attach id=0 msg=2586636]
[attach id=1 msg=2586636]
![ResizedImage_2026-09-02_07-56-39_2797[2].jpg](/assets/uploads/_imported_attachments/migrated/605917_ResizedImage_2026-09-02_07-56-39_2797%5B2%5D.jpg)
![ResizedImage_2026-09-02_07-56-39_8020[1].jpg](/assets/uploads/_imported_attachments/migrated/605918_ResizedImage_2026-09-02_07-56-39_8020%5B1%5D.jpg)
-
Front pocket carry for me. Don't ever use a clip, even if the knife has one. Same carry with a Leatherman. Don't carry two knives, or a knife plus a multi. Never have.
That's a nice looking Barlow, David.
Best wishes, G

-
Day 02 🤠

-
Proper Barlow today is a AG Russell one I've had forever with G10 handles. I think it's got a 154CM blade but could be wrong. Also how do you guys carry your knife? loose? or use some sort of pocket pouch? I often carry other things as well so a good organizer is usually in my pocket.
[attach id=0 msg=2586636]
[attach id=1 msg=2586636]
Nice one ! I carry in my front right pocket, either in the watch pocket or loose depending on which other knife I'm carrying with it.
-
Day 2
Cattaraugus 2139

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login