Barlow Knife Challenge Sept 2026
-
My work slacks have a "security pocket" in the front right. Supposed to put your wallet in their if you're in the rough part of town or whatever. Knife lives there so it's by itself, but can't fall out. Wallet and phone go in the main pocket.
I occasionally carry back right, with my bandana, if it's a smaller one like the barlow. Too hard to fish it out of half way down my thigh. Awlso where I sometimes put a small "just a knife" if I'm doing a challenge with a pocket anchor that I don't want to deal with if I'm just opening a box.
I awlso rarely clip. Don't want it showing at work, and I think a sheath is a bigger upgrade when I don't mind it being visible when cambing or whatever. If I do, it's usually on the right side near where the tool would be otherwise.
There's usually a SAK on my keys-- front left pocket.
Off of work, I'm usually in cargos or cargo shorts. The knife goes in the regular front right pocket and wallet and stuff goes in the cargo pocket (they're more long and flat, so the pocket shape matches).
So: Main tool front right, keychain SAK front left, optional/backup back right. Sheath maybe (usually right side); clip probably not.
-
Mail call duty for my Barlow. Should not be any more parcel openings for the rest of the month because I don't have anything else on order.

-
Cattaraugus 2139
Love the Catt! They made some great knives.
My usual carry is a bigger knife in a belt pouch, and a smaller in my strongside front pocket. The pouch knife is usually my Swisschamp, but sometimes an Uncle Henry LB7 or similar. I prefer that the front pocket knife have a lanyard, since I also carry a Ruger LCR in a pocket holster.
As a general rule I don't like pocket clips, but I found that my Boker Kalashnikov XXL works well for clip carry. With a smaller knife the clip gets in the way. But strangely enough, with that huge Boker, the clip holds it out of the way; allowing me to slide the revolver out past it where a smaller clipped knife would snag. -
Day 2
GEC 141122
Small BARLOW
[attach id=0 msg=2586675]
The Queen included for size reference.
For carry a BARLOW rides right front pocket naked.
Exception is this GEC, it rides in a slip, otherwise it is small enough to hide in a pocket corner.
-
I've been contemplating a pocket organizer for my right front pocket as that one usually carries my pocket knife, my folding reading glasses, my pen, my mustache wax, and mustache comb. The only knife I'll carry with a clip is my Kershaw Leek. If I'm carrying a SAK, I'll carry it in my Vic belt holster. My "pretty" knives will get carried in sleeve or their respective holster. Always have a Minichamp on my keychain in my left front pocket.
Love that Cattaraugus Steve.
Awesome Barlows y'awl. I suspect that I may need to go on a hunt for one or two during this challenge.

-
<u>Day 2</u>
Enjoying my coffee during the morning.

-
Thanks !
@AzteCypher said:
Love that Cattaraugus Steve.Awesome Barlows y'awl. I suspect that I may need to go on a hunt for one or two during this challenge.

Thanks, I just picked up another this morning
Should be here in a few days. -
You see that cracked ice Barlow in Aztec's picture don't you Steve. There's the exception to your rule. Sometimes Barlows do have butt bolsters. :D
-
That's a very good point.

I'll need to get a different pic this evening then. :D
-
@WECSOG said:
Your comments apply to mine as well. Including the super pointy blades.Day 2
New production Imperial. I posted it somewhere on the site, right after I got it. IIRC it was $5.99, added to an existing order so shipping was free.
I really like my better quality, collectable Barlows. But to me, this epitomizes what a Barlow is all about. I remember when small country stores had displays of cheap pocket knives near the register. Maybe a dollar for an Imperial Barlow. You didn't expect top grade steel. It was a cheap knife that worked fine for the typical things you would use a pocket knife for, and if you lost it while baling hay or whatever, you just bought another one. At least you didn't lose your nice Case, because you left that one home during jobs like this.This 6 dollar Barlow fits with that, exactly. I like my Case Barlow, but it's a collectable and I treat it as such. This one, if I lost or broke it, no big deal.
Your comments about the knife case and small country stores is so true. I remember seeing a few. But what I think is funny is that nowadays many independent convenience stores, including one in my neighborhood, will have a small knife case of large modern folders right next to the smoke/vape items.
-
@nate j said:
I’d call that blade a sheepsfoot. Straight edge, with spine parallel to edge before dropping to meet edge.Lanny’s Clip, originally designed by the late great Tony Bose (and later copied by others), is a type of clip point blade (hence the second half of the name) with a distinctive handle. Example: Case Bose Locking Lanny’s Clip
https://caseknives.com/blogs/news/case-x-tony-bose-locking-lannys-clip-collection-announced-at-shot-showA pruner blade has a concave edge and a downward-facing point. Example: Second blade on the Vic Swiss Army 7
https://www.victorinox.com/en-US/Products/Swiss-Army-Knife™-and-Tools/Gardening/Swiss-Army-7-Alox/p/0.8150.26IIRC, it was decided that, at least for purposes of this challenge, at least one elongated bolster would be the defining criterion for a barlow. So by that definition, I have to agree with Steve that it’s a nice looking knife, but not a barlow.

Ah, I meant Lanny's Clip and Pruner as shapes for the pocket knife itself, not the blade shape. The blade in the picture is a sheepsfoot, I definitely agree. I was more thinking about handle shapes and bolsters.
-
Proper Barlow today is a AG Russell one I've had forever with G10 handles. I think it's got a 154CM blade but could be wrong. Also how do you guys carry your knife? loose? or use some sort of pocket pouch? I often carry other things as well so a good organizer is usually in my pocket.
[attach id=0 msg=2586636]
[attach id=1 msg=2586636]
I frequently carry a small pocket organizer, but also will sometimes carry an item in the small coin/watch pocket by itself.
That is a beauty.
-
@Alan K. said:
You see that cracked ice Barlow in Aztec's picture don't you Steve. There's the exception to your rule. Sometimes Barlows do have butt bolsters. :DHis rule


@AzteCypher said:
Awlright gentle folks, and not so gentle (looks in the mirror... and winks), after consulting with the knife oracles, a decent amount of google-fu, and an overabundance of shenanigans, how bout we make these the definition of Barlow:- Long metal bolster (the metal cap at the pivot end) which typically measures about 1/3 the length of the handle.
- No end cap, or butt bolster, or end bolster.
- One or two blades.
That's it. That'll define a Barlow for the purposes of this challenge.
- "What about blade design?", you ask. - Doesn't matter.
- "But mine has a clip!" - That's ok too.
- "What about that funny looking shield there....!" - No biggie.
Let's just enjoy it. And it looks like Sept is a popular vote so let's go with that.
Who'd like to join me in Sept? No worries, I won't take offense if you have better things to do. But I better see you on the next challenge.

Let's try for 10 to make it official.
- AzteCypher
-
Day 2

Colonial (Providence RI) Barlow today. It has Snap-on Tools branding, and the name and phone of some regional distributor/sales guy from Long Island (judging by the phone number).
It's a bit faded but the logo was once stamped, so maybe I could restore it with some red ink? I've already done a good bit of work on this knife, it was downright grody when I got it, the back scales are cracked, the blade was awful, and the scales were loose. It's already a LOT better, so what's a little paint between friends?
I have a growing sub-collection of Snap-on branded knives and multis, so I took this day as an opportunity to take a "family picture." I'd love to get more, eventually!
-
You did notice that friend Aztec didn't outlaw the Garlow. Must be legit with no indications to the contrary. Now if I could just find where I put mine........
Best wishes. G

-
@mathmitch7 said:
Day 2
Colonial (Providence RI) Barlow today. It has Snap-on Tools branding, and the name and phone of some regional distributor/sales guy from Long Island (judging by the number).
It's a bit faded but the logo was once stamped, so maybe I could restore it with some red ink? I've already done a good bit of work on this knife, it was downright grody when I got it, the back scales are cracked, the blade was awful, and the scales were loose. It's already a LOT better, so what's a little paint between friends?
I have a growing sub-collection of Snap-on branded knives and multis, so I took this day as an opportunity to take a "family picture." I'd love to get more, eventually!
That Colonial has been carried A LOT! That's a lot of service out of a giveaway promo knife. Bravo. Best wishes. G

-
Day 2
I've had mixed results with Boker, but I like this Barlow (from their Traditional 2.0 series). Great snap, decent steel, and the texture on the handle looks good and gives it some grip. Price is probably a little high at MSRP, but I think I got this one around half off.

-
@IMR4198 said:
That Colonial has been carried A LOT! That's a lot of service out of a giveaway promo knife. Bravo. Best wishes. G

Having worked on a farm that's been in operation a long long time, I can tell you that farmers use this kind of thing until they break. Someone gives them a halfway decent promotional item, and they'll be using it forever.
I have a mini metal clipboard I found in the barn that has the contact info for a local roofer, that lists a four-digit phone number. It's a somewhat rural area, so my guess is that it's probably pre-1970s.
-
Barlow Challenge
Day 2 of 30
Western Brand BarlowIt got near real warm here in SC today,,, popsicle was quite refreshing.
[attach id=0 msg=2586722]
.jpg)
-
@David Bowen said:
Also how do you guys carry your knife? loose? or use some sort of pocket pouch? I often carry other things as well so a good organizer is usually in my pocket.Depends…
Primary knife/tool without pocket clip - loose in RF pocket with wallet. I find the wallet often helps hold the knife in a consistent position, and sometimes helps prevent it from falling out.
Primary knife/tool with pocket clip - Clipped to RF mag pocket (preferred, if pants so equipped), or to RF pocket if no RF mag pocket
Supporting SAK #1: Vic Rambler - on key ring
Supporting SAK #2: Vic Alox Bantam - in wallet
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login