Barlow Knife Challenge Sept 2026
-
Other people w/ the Bear/Queen Barlows, how's your snap? Most of mine are rather weak. I have a few others of the Nü Queens (Stockmans and such) and they're more reasonable.
-
Day 9
Nate mentioned the longer secondary blade on the Case Barlow. I've noticed another thing I like about my Case. On most standard Barlows, holding it like I do to open it, the pen blade is in front of and partially obscuring the main blade so my thumbnail has to slide across it to reach the nail nick of the main blade. It works, but there's a better way. My Case has the pen blade behind the main blade, with its nail nick on the other side. That way both nail nicks are unobstructed. I like that. It's one of the little things that make up a premium tool.

-
@BPRoberts said:
Other people w/ the Bear/Queen Barlows, how's your snap? Most of mine are rather weak. I have a few others of the Nü Queens (Stockmans and such) and they're more reasonable.I have only the one Bear & Sin Barlow, pictured today.
The pull is a solid 6.3, takes a firm grip to pull open by pinching the blade, yet is doable. Via the nail Nick easier, but do not allow a finger near the drop zone if your nail my slip, the down snap will slice a finger tip cleaning with out slowing.
A definite snap when closing.I do not believe I have any other B&S made BARLOWS or SMKW/B&S made knifes.
The other QUEEN tagged BARLOWS from SMKW are I suspect another knife maker. They are solid built units, yet believe more attention was given forward fit and finish, display pieces. 1095 steel, did not arrive hair cutting sharp. But a little effort corrected.
The China made SMKW QUEENS WITH 440C, and I have several were real good knife examples. A notch better than RR and MARBLES. For the price, they each were solid values.
-
Day 9
Been super busy today and almost forgot to take a pic
[attach id=0 msg=2587454]

-
Day 9
New acquisition is an Ulster from late 1940's-early 50's
Great condition

[attach id=0 msg=2587458]
[attach id=1 msg=2587458]
[attach id=2 msg=2587458]
[attach id=3 msg=2587458]




-
Nate mentioned the longer secondary blade on the Case Barlow. I've noticed another thing I like about my Case. On most standard Barlows, holding it like I do to open it, the pen blade is in front of and partially obscuring the main blade so my thumbnail has to slide across it to reach the nail nick of the main blade. It works, but there's a better way. My Case has the pen blade behind the main blade, with its nail nick on the other side. That way both nail nicks are unobstructed. I like that. It's one of the little things that make up a premium tool.
Makes me wonder, is the blade placement and nail Nick by design or by accident?
I can just imagine an apprentice on his second day is given a task to repeat from previous day. Run a second batch on pen blades just like yesterday’s, align in the jig, cut the nick and then stamp the blade tangs. Need 500 blades before you leave today. And supervisor walks off.
The apprentice scratches his head, just like yesterday.
He runs a few, yep I hit this and goes to work. Completed the batch, rolls the bin of 500 pen blades to assembly.
Next morning assembly sets up the materials snd goes to work, about five blades in an inspector, checked the knife frames, wow stop, these pen blades have no nail Nick!!!
The assembler, say no they do look. A crowd gather around and look at the batch in the bin. Yep. Inspector opens main blade, oops the nick is ground on the wrong side. Alarms goes off, production stops.
They drag the apprentice into the room and begin to berate him. Shame shame!!!Then a young lad, a floor sweeper looks at the knife, nothing really wrong here, just put the blades inside the frame with pen blade first, the the main base. Nicks are both accessible.
The factory goes silent, A couple inspectors look again, says to the sweeper, say that again…
And, that is rest of the story!!!
-
I'm not sure how the bolsters are made on the new production Imperial Barlow knives. Looks like something stamped out maybe. I wonder if it isn't some variation of the old shell construction? I could pry the thing off to take a look, but that likely would result in making the patient in this operation unable to continue. Curiosity has killed quite a few cats around here. My cat lady neighbor had about 24 curious cats. I assume their curiosity led them into the digestive tracts of the resident coyote packs. Temps have cooled here and it is beginning to feel a little like fall. Werecoyote Trail got a (expensive) face lift last week. Some of it got some (expensive) gravel. All of it got graded. It is unclear how the naked sections will 'winter'. I will no longer be able to play the "What Track is This" game or be able to take photos of critter tracks. The critters will still be there, but gravel doesn't leave a permanent track. I hope the little cuties don't hoit their preshuss little tootsies on the rocks.Best wishes. G
[attach id=0 msg=2587395]Maybe you can make some smaller on property small game tracks to keep the cure visitors coming around.
@LoopCutter said:
Day 9Hazy morning, contrast with a WAVE of orange and wood present.
[attach id=0 msg=2587403]
The large handle fits my hands so nicely.
Hat wood is real nice.
That Case has some nice character
@nate j said:
Day 8One of the things I like about the way Case does a Barlow is that the secondary pen blade (while not as long as the main clip blade), is still a reasonable and serviceable size.
Contrast with some other manufacturers, whose secondary pen blades seem almost vestigial, or like they are competing to see who can make the smallest secondary pen blade.
I understand that, some pen blades look like they cae off a 58mm SAK.
New acquisition is an Ulster from late 1940's-early 50's
Great condition

[attach id=0 msg=2587458]
Sweet
-
@LoopCutter said:
Makes me wonder, is the blade placement and nail Nick by design or by accident?I can just imagine an apprentice on his second day is given a task to repeat from previous day. Run a second batch on pen blades just like yesterday’s, align in the jig, cut the nick and then stamp the blade tangs. Need 500 blades before you leave today. And supervisor walks off.
The apprentice scratches his head, just like yesterday.
He runs a few, yep I hit this and goes to work. Completed the batch, rolls the bin of 500 pen blades to assembly.
Next morning assembly sets up the materials snd goes to work, about five blades in an inspector, checked the knife frames, wow stop, these pen blades have no nail Nick!!!
The assembler, say no they do look. A crowd gather around and look at the batch in the bin. Yep. Inspector opens main blade, oops the nick is ground on the wrong side. Alarms goes off, production stops.
They drag the apprentice into the room and begin to berate him. Shame shame!!!Then a young lad, a floor sweeper looks at the knife, nothing really wrong here, just put the blades inside the frame with pen blade first, the the main base. Nicks are both accessible.
The factory goes silent, A couple inspectors look again, says to the sweeper, say that again…
And, that is rest of the story!!!

-
Day 09
I checked the archive. There is no mention whatsoever of Walmart's Swiss Tech Doppelt Barlow anywhere on this site. Zero, nada, zilch. So, I've decided to use the opportunity of the Barlow challenge to be the sacrificial lamb, or Guinnea pig. I'm your huckleberry. I recently saw a couple of videos where the You Tubers mentioned that the Doppelt was still showing at the full price of $34.99 if you looked at Walmart's website, but you might get it close to half off if you went to the store. I bought this one, new in the box, on E-bay for $16 plus shipping and tax so I think I got a pretty good deal. Doppelt apparently means double in Swiss, and they call it that because the 2 blades are the same length. They're about as sharp as you get out of the box with a cheap knife which is not very. I may have to work on that. The clip point blade is very pointy. More likely to poke oneself than cut oneself. I think I would have liked it better if the sheepsfoot blade were serrated for cutting fibrous materials. So far, I like the F&F. It is easy to open with a pinch grip or using the nail nicks which run the full length of both blades more like a fuller. Not really a half stop, but the blade reaches a point where you do have to push harder to close it the rest of the way. I like it and will try to get more use out of it over the next few days.



-
-
@Alan K. said:
Day 09I checked the archive. There is no mention whatsoever of Walmart's Swiss Tech Doppelt Barlow anywhere on this site. Zero, nada, zilch. So, I've decided to use the opportunity of the Barlow challenge to be the sacrificial lamb, or Guinnea pig. I'm your huckleberry. I recently saw a couple of videos where the You Tubers mentioned that the Doppelt was still showing at the full price of $34.99 if you looked at Walmart's website, but you might get it close to half off if you went to the store. I bought this one, new in the box, on E-bay for $16 plus shipping and tax so I think I got a pretty good deal. Doppelt apparently means double in Swiss, and they call it that because the 2 blades are the same length. They're about as sharp as you get out of the box with a cheap knife which is not very. I may have to work on that. The clip point blade is very pointy. More likely to poke oneself than cut oneself. I think I would have liked it better if the sheepsfoot blade were serrated for cutting fibrous materials. So far, I like the F&F. It is easy to open with a pinch grip or using the nail nicks which run the full length of both blades more like a fuller. Not really a half stop, but the blade reaches a point where you do have to push harder to close it the rest of the way. I like it and will try to get more use out of it over the next few days.

Looks like a lot of knife for $16. I like the two long blades. Best wishes. G

-
Has anyone had their hands on the new Bear Piranha? Pen blade and some sources are reporting spear point, others sheepsfoot, with a lockback. Looks kinda nice. Not Barlow shaped, but maybe a distant cousin.
@Alan K. said:
Day 09I checked the archive. There is no mention whatsoever of Walmart's Swiss Tech Doppelt Barlow anywhere on this site. Zero, nada, zilch. So, I've decided to use the opportunity of the Barlow challenge to be the sacrificial lamb, or Guinnea pig. I'm your huckleberry. I recently saw a couple of videos where the You Tubers mentioned that the Doppelt was still showing at the full price of $34.99 if you looked at Walmart's website, but you might get it close to half off if you went to the store. I bought this one, new in the box, on E-bay for $16 plus shipping and tax so I think I got a pretty good deal. Doppelt apparently means double in Swiss, and they call it that because the 2 blades are the same length. They're about as sharp as you get out of the box with a cheap knife which is not very. I may have to work on that. The clip point blade is very pointy. More likely to poke oneself than cut oneself. I think I would have liked it better if the sheepsfoot blade were serrated for cutting fibrous materials. So far, I like the F&F. It is easy to open with a pinch grip or using the nail nicks which run the full length of both blades more like a fuller. Not really a half stop, but the blade reaches a point where you do have to push harder to close it the rest of the way. I like it and will try to get more use out of it over the next few days.

When a Trapper and a Barlow love each other very much... It is a nice blade combo (though I agree with your point on serrations), might try to find one if you give it the okay.
Day 9
Beer Tender helped with an orange; blade to score it and lifter to peel it. I am pondering doing a slight mod to the cap lifter to make it usable as a screwdriver or something, but unsure. Open to suggestions/advice if anyone has tried something similar.
[attach id=0 msg=2587479]

-
Day 9

The no-name from Pakistan accompanied me today, helped out with a very exciting mail call (oodles of SAKs) that I'll share here eventually!
-
@SteveC - Nice Ulster!
@LoopCutter - I'll bet that's exactly how it happened!

@Alan K - That's not a bad looking Swiss Tech. I see they have a green one too.
<u>Day 9</u>
It was a long day.... Fought with my work laptop several times as it rebooted twice throughout the day while I was in the middle of something. This this generator fought me for a good hour until it finally cooperated. Didn't get to use the Case but it was standing at the ready to give me a hand.

-
@Alan K. said:
Day 09I checked the archive. There is no mention whatsoever of Walmart's Swiss Tech Doppelt Barlow anywhere on this site. Zero, nada, zilch. So, I've decided to use the opportunity of the Barlow challenge to be the sacrificial lamb, or Guinnea pig. I'm your huckleberry. I recently saw a couple of videos where the You Tubers mentioned that the Doppelt was still showing at the full price of $34.99 if you looked at Walmart's website, but you might get it close to half off if you went to the store. I bought this one, new in the box, on E-bay for $16 plus shipping and tax so I think I got a pretty good deal. Doppelt apparently means double in Swiss, and they call it that because the 2 blades are the same length. They're about as sharp as you get out of the box with a cheap knife which is not very. I may have to work on that. The clip point blade is very pointy. More likely to poke oneself than cut oneself. I think I would have liked it better if the sheepsfoot blade were serrated for cutting fibrous materials. So far, I like the F&F. It is easy to open with a pinch grip or using the nail nicks which run the full length of both blades more like a fuller. Not really a half stop, but the blade reaches a point where you do have to push harder to close it the rest of the way. I like it and will try to get more use out of it over the next few days.

I recalled a knife influencer, Thrifyy Kaniffy review this a couple years ago, and found his video on YOU Tube.
Was favorable for a $34 item and steel is Aus08.I recalled looking a couple time but never saw at my Wally Stores.
-
@BPRoberts said:
Other people w/ the Bear/Queen Barlows, how's your snap? Most of mine are rather weak. I have a few others of the Nü Queens (Stockmans and such) and they're more reasonable.I only have the one Bear & Sons. The snap on mine is week.
Something else that I have also realized is the main blade nail nick is partially blocked by the bottle opening blade.
@BPRoberts said:
Day 9Beer Tender helped with an orange; blade to score it and lifter to peel it. I am pondering doing a slight mod to the cap lifter to make it usable as a screwdriver or something, but unsure. Open to suggestions/advice if anyone has tried something similar.
[attach id=0 msg=2587479]
I had the same thought on the cap lifter. I thought of grinding it to be a useful driver. I also thought of sharpening the edge/corner so it could work as package opener. Or if you have talent make it like the SAK Executive orange peeler.

-
Day 9
The Cripple Creek helped clear a circle for my alcohol stove to make some coffee. I use the blade to cut the roots of some weeds. It was a little overkill, but goal accomplished with a good cup of coffee.

-
Day 9
Case has had some questionable quality years, but the F&F on this Case Barlow is as good or better than any other knife I own.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login