QC issues?
-
I’ve been wanting to try a cellidor companion since they came out with the standard red version. I’ve now ordered 3 companions over the past 9-10 months or so, two from Amazon and one directly from victorinox. All three had pretty significant side to side play on the backside tools, most notable on the corkscrew. Also noticed side play on the package opener on at least one of them, maybe two.
I also noticed the same back tool play on an explorer I got on sale at Walmart back in December of last year.
Any one else noticed this? I’ll be honest I was quite surprised by this, as I’ve rarely encountered a QC issue from victorinox. I know they’re will always be a few that get through, it’s just I’ve now had several with the same issue, so I wonder if something is up.
-
I have two red cellidor COMPANIONS. Both purchased in 2025.
Main tools are tight, no issues.
Back side cork screw and AWL/Punch, a slight
Side to side but Hook is snug.Yet, in comparison to my SPARTAN, COMPACT and CLIMBERs within reach, the CORKSCREW does have a slight side to side matching the same on the COMPANION.
I am by no means a SAK expert, more a novice, but I must say this Side 2 Side observation is a non issue.
In fact, I believe it may be attributed to the outside liner that flex’s.I have used the CORKSCREW a few times on my COMPANION, and no trouble extracting natural or plastic corks. On non cork styles, I do start a pilot hole with the AWL to make it easier on myself.
-
Interesting. Maybe I’m over thinking it. I know side to side play on knifes is much overblown, especially since there should be minimal twisting action.
However, on a driver or corkscrew, I would think side to side play could be a problem, particularly on the weaker backside pin/liner joint.
-
You may not be overthinking.
I just checked my SWISSCHAMP (x3), a EXPLORER, and my CHAMPION.
THE BACKSIDE, AWL/Holepunch and CORKSCREW on these models are tight, no side to side and my feel is a stronger backspring as well.
It is also my opinion the outer liners on these four tools are a minuscule thicker. Eye sight only, as I do not wish to take the knives apart and use a micrometer and measure.
I was actually surprised how sturdy the two backside tools felt when I checked.
-
Thanks for the comparison, that’s good data. My experience with non-alox SAKs is limited, so I wasn’t sure if I was just imagining it.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login