Barlow Knife Challenge Sept 2026
-
Day 15
It's a real nice knife for $16. Sheepsfoot and Clippoint is a great blade combo. My sheep came nice and sharp, and the clip sharpened easily. A couple drops of oil in the pivot and the action is decent. I'm not sure I'd be convinced at $30 or $35, but (for my limited use so far) it's a winner at clearance.

-
-
Day 16
RR “Long Rifle” Grandaddy Barlow
F&F is excellent, especially for a $20 knife. It’s a looker too.
But, unfortunately, instead of the story of an outstanding $20 knife, this is the story of how one bad design decision turned what could have been a good $20 knife into a paperweight.
It’s hard to tell from the pic, but the nail nick is quite shallow. Easily observable in the pic is that the nail nick is located fairly close to the tang, given the length of the blade. Not observable in the pic (because the knife is half open) is how little of the blade sticks up above the handle when closed. Observable in the pic, if you look closely, is a swedge that runs all the way through the nail nick.
All of the above facts combine to make this knife very difficult to open (in spite of fairly modest spring pressure) especially with hands that are wet, greasy, etc.
One of the main reasons for carrying a pocket knife is convenience, so when a knife is unduly hard to open (or close), it really hurts the convenience factor.
I’d like to carry this one some, but unless I discover some special trick to get it open quickly and reliably, I’m not going to.

-
Day 17
RRR Granddaddy Barlow
Deeper nail nick and (probably most importantly) no swedge on the section of blade with the nail nick make this one much more reasonable to open.
Going to carry it some and see, but I’ve been mostly pleased with RRR knives in the past.

-
Day 17

This Camco is quickly becoming my fave Barlow to carry. It's just... solid. Lightweight. Good.
Hope everyone's having a great week!
-
That's a shame on that Long Rifle Nate. It's a good looking one.
<u>Day 17</u>
Planting some corn late in the season. I think we should have enough warm weather that it'll make through before the first frost.

-
Day 17
Cut open some hot dogs for dinner
-
Day 18
Another Colonial photo. Best wishes. G
:D
[attach id=0 msg=2588216]
-
Day 18 🤠

-
Day 18
Green is very often the last color I will choose!
But, today this green bone BARLOW, labeled Queen #22 tempted me.
[attach id=0 msg=2588220]
It will ride the pocket.
I have to admit, the BARLOW pattern fits well in the pocket. And I favor the CLIP POINT Blade over the other options. To me it is just complete, maybe cause of my Stockman tendency.
Enjoy FRIDAY!

-
You too, Gordon. I think the greenie Queenie looks keenie. Best wishes. G

-
I prefer the clip point variants as well, LC. I believe that the one that my grandpa carried had a Sheepsfoot.
Anywho, today I got a message that my new spectacles were ready for me. Other than going along for the ride, baby Barlow had nothing to do.

-
@BPRoberts said:
Day 15It's a real nice knife for $16. Sheepsfoot and Clippoint is a great blade combo. My sheep came nice and sharp, and the clip sharpened easily. A couple drops of oil in the pivot and the action is decent. I'm not sure I'd be convinced at $30 or $35, but (for my limited use so far) it's a winner at clearance.
That was exactly how I looked at it. Nice enough knife to try it at $16 but I'd have passed on it at the full retail of $35. Having carried it for much of the last 2 weeks I have decided that it is a great carry and I'm enjoying using it. I'm glad you found one.

-
Day 17 and Day 18
Besides the unrelenting rain, I have been dealing with excruciating sciatic nerve pain that has made it difficult for me to do anything for the last 3 days. Missed yesterday's picture because I couldn't get to the computer. Here's my catch-up picture and today's picture.
The 9-17 picture was the Swiss Tech Doppelt with a single cell AAA flashlight, and the 9-18 picture is the Colonial Barlow Electrician with my morning coffee.

-
@Alan K. said:
That was exactly how I looked at it. Nice enough knife to try it at $16 but I'd have passed on it at the full retail of $35. Having carried it for much of the last 2 weeks I have decided that it is a great carry and I'm enjoying using it. I'm glad you found one.
My local WM had a good half a dozen in the case. If anyone is having trouble scaring one up, shoot me a PM. Happy to stop in and try to grab another.
-
@Alan K. said:
Day 17 and Day 18
Besides the unrelenting rain, I have been dealing with excruciating sciatic nerve pain that has made it difficult for me to do anything for the last 3 days. Missed yesterday's picture because I couldn't get to the computer. Here's my catch-up picture and today's picture.
The 9-17 picture was the Swiss Tech Doppelt with a single cell AAA flashlight, and the 9-18 picture is the Colonial Barlow Electrician with my morning coffee.I hope you get some relief soon. I have that as well but not as bad as you.

-
Day 18
Camco Sheepsfoot

-
<u>Day 18</u>
Monthly coffee delivery... at least I think it's monthly. Perhaps it's best I don't check to see how often we buy coffee.....


Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



