The Great Roxon Flex Test Experiments
-
My only Roxon (so far) is the Mini Flex Companion. Sadly, the blade was the first thing to go, but having said that its served me well so far
.jpg)
-
Comparisons Part I: Saws
I use a saw quite frequently. It is not the most used tool but it is an important implement for me on a multitool. Flex Immler and others have some great saw comparison videos on YouTube. These tests are fun and highlight the strengths of different types of saws. I’m going to rate each tool out of 10 following a basic rubric of 10: exceptional, 9: very good 8: good, 7: OK could complete task with additional effort/strategy, 6: needs improvement but partially performed task (~50% min completion), 5: needs much improvement with attempted task but could not continue (~25-50% completion), 4: unsatisfactory could not attempt task (<10-25% completion). 3: unsatisfactory with contempt
implement could not begin task, 2: tool failure at start of task, and 1: tool failure at deployment.The Flex saw fits somewhere between the Vic and LM saws in my experience. I prefer the push/pull Vic saw to the sorta push mostly pull LM. For some reason, which is probably mostly my fault, I just can’t figure out if the Flex saw is push/pull or primarily one. I think given the teeth pattern it’s push/pull like a Vic saw.
[attach id=0 msg=2589883]
For this comparison I took the Flex and Spirit into the yard for some tree clearing. I’ve been slowly removing nearly 100 samplings and young maple trees that have over grown in between the bushes and along the property line over the years before we bought the house. Most of the trunks are 4cm diameter or smaller (a special appearance from the Flex ruler on my Companion!). The Vic saw, particularly on the Workchamp, makes quick work of the trees I can’t snip. I also end up trimming a branch or two here and there while on the lawn tractor.
[attach id=1 msg=2589883]
The Flex saw just did not cut as well as the Spirit saw. The actual cutting into the wood requires more force than the Spirit to get going and I could not saw as quickly. Neither push nor pull primary or push/pull in a straight back/forth, angled, or even trying rocking seemed to facilitate the work. The Spirit saw cleanly cuts through at any angle. I awlso found the Flex saw had more lateral flex
than the Spirit saw on the larger 4cm trees. I was getting quite a bit of flex leading the saw to become stuck. This is not something I have experienced with Vic saws. The Wave saw will flex some, but it has a much thinner spine (which I do like compared to the Vic saws.While walking around the garage I found the squirrels nesting in the eaves had chewed through in spots. These boards need replaced anyways, but that’s a project for another month probably. So, I made a quick plywood cover after clearing the nests, laying some wire mesh down, and sprinkling cayenne pepper.
As you might imagine, neither the Flex nor Spirit saw are great for cutting plywood. I made an initial cut with each and finished both pieces with the jigsaw. The Flex saw cut through just like the maple trees. At a certain point it just about chewed through instead of cutting. The Spirit cut cleaner.
[attach id=2 msg=2589883]
The frame size on the Flex yields a better grip while sawing. It is not as comfortable as the Spirit in the long term. I tried taking out the scissors and file which protrude a bit out of the frame and it didn’t appear the hot spots were causing the discomfort. The bulk was more than my liking. Larger hands may fair better.
Here’s my verdict: the Flex saw is OK. It’s not great but it’s not bad by any means. It does the job and just takes a bit more patience. The teeth still feel sharp, but the Spirit saw teeth still seem to work better after several years of consistent and fairly heavy use. The Spirit doesn’t perform as well as a brand new Vic saw yet still better than the Flex.
Flex saw: 7/10
Spirit saw (new): 9/10 and old I’d still give it an 8/10.


-
I feel like I just saw a podcast about this.... :D
Oh yeah, here it is!
/topic/95521:D
Seriously, I am very much looking forward to following this project.

Def
-
Comparisons Part II: Pliers, Chisel, & Awl
Last Saturday as I compared the saw, I awlso took some time to test out the Flex awl a bit more than I had previously used. The Flex awl is wider and ground to a sharper edge with wider bevel than the Spirit. It is more similar to a Leatherman Rebar style awl coming to a sharp tip. The Spirit awl works fine, but the Flex awl does stand out. While cutting the temporary plywood pieces for my garage eves, I used the awl to trace my pencil marking on the rough shape for each piece. The Flex awl very easily scored deep into the plywood, while the Spirit awl left a much more shallow trace. The Flex awl was easier to maintain a consistent vector over my pencil line compared with the Spirit.
I awlso tested boring a whole in one of the cut down >4cm trees I crudely hacked down with a hatchet. I will pile the trees/branches and cut notches or bore through a hole to attach some steel wire through the whole to the lawn tractor and drag the whole pile back to the burn pile with the largest tree/branch on bottom acting as a sled. It did not take much effort to get through this piece. However, there is quite a bit of flex
in the handles when heavy torque is applied. The Spirit does not flex as much and it is well suited to open one handle to make one longer handle. The Flex spring loaded pliers made the same on the Flex difficult. The awl itself as an implement is 9/10, but the handles create a bit of an issue bringing the overall score to a 7/10.[attach id=0 msg=2590521]
Pliers are a likely obvious comparison and there are several videos out there from folks comparing size, teeth, etc. I wanted to take the Flex pliers to similar task I typically use my Spirit. The Flex needle nose pliers teeth are more comparable to LM in cut depth and this is one area where the Spirit could improve. The larger teeth are similar between the Flex and Spirit and I didn’t notice any real performance differences between.
[attach id=1 msg=2590521]
The Flex pliers are decent overall. Grabbed ahold of a stripped screw to turn, pulled a nail, cut and bent steel mesh fencing, grabbed a hook screw for leverage to turn. Nothing fancy. I’ll have to find a more strenuous task for them to update here. So far I’d give them an 8/10.
[attach id=2 msg=2590521]
The chisel on the Spirit is a necessity and is easily my favorite and most used tool. The Flex chisel came razor sharp. It is wider than the Spirit chisel and is ground at a slightly larger angle it appears. Testing it out on some paint to strip it worked beautifully. It did not however stand the test of time. The Flex chisel so far stands at stark contrast to the Spirit. It is no where near as good over time. For one, the chisel dulled very quick. Trying to remove large chunks of old paint slightly dulled the tip as expected. The primary issue occurred when scraping ceiling paint and plaster. I was expecting the plaster dull the chisel as it did on my spirit. I was not expecting it to completely reshape it so quickly. The underside formed a bevel after the plaster scraping. It’s rather hard to describe how difficult it is to sharpen now. I have sharpened my Spirit chisel countless times and even on the plaster it retained its shape and regained a sharp edge. The Flex edge dulls now so easily and just after a few passes today trying to remove some old dried on painters tape it would slide right over the tape. It’s unfortunate as I had high hopes to give it a 6/10.
[attach id=3 msg=2590521]




-
Comparisons Part III: Drivers
The Phillips and large flat head/pry bar/bottle opener are two very used implements for me on any PBMT or SAK. I may be a bit less forgiving here on the driver comparison than other tools.
The 3D Phillips driver on my Spirit and Explorer have seen quite a bit of heavy use over the years. I really wanted the Flex Phillips implement to be as good as the Vic or Leatherman, but sadly it does not completely match up. In terms of quality, it is fine. I applied quite a bit of torque working some old screws out of a wood post. The driver held up even with a lot of cam out. The issue I have with the Phillips is that it is tapered from what I think is supposed to be #2 to #1, but it’s really a #1 to a #0. I could not get enough purchase on a standard wood screw for which a #2 bit had no problem. I also even had trouble with camming on the screws removing a cross bar in the closet that didn’t require much torque to remove. I am impressed though that the steel did not deform the driver tip.
I should also mention that the modular system did not cause any issue. No flex on the Flex this time! However, I should ALSO mention that like my attempt with the awl, you cannot extend the handle without closing the pliers with your palm. Otherwise, the spring mechanism pushes open the jaw in a way that creates a hot spot. The Phillips shank length does provide a small amount of extended reach, but the extended handle is quite helpful when using the driver handles closed is too wide or awkward for reaching a screw. I attempted to demonstrate with a door handle (although mine are fine for closed or open I’ve used them on door knobs where closed handle is in the way).
[attach id=0 msg=2591150]
The flat head combo tool saw some use the other day during our painting project. It works just fine to pry away a roofing nail (that was used for some reason to secure Tyvek wrap), open paint cans, and fit into a #3 screw head where the Phillips was just too small. I did notice that with both the Phillips and the flat head the frame does flex quite a bit even while holding at the pliers end. I don’t believe the tool itself will deform or fail unless an entirely inappropriate amount of force is applied.
[attach id=1 msg=2591150]
Overall, I give the Phillips a 8/10 for length and durability, but end up with a 7/10 for the driver size. The Spirit bit head has the wider flange to better fit #2 and can still manage down to #0 with a delicate touch. I give the flat head driver a 9/10.


-
GB, just for confirmation, how much did the Flex cost at retail, did you customise the tool load, and if so, what was the cost at retail?
I'm just curious as a I'd a look a while back at getting a Flex, but to set it up the way I wanted pushed the cost into 'proper' tool levels
-
@kirk13 said:
GB, just for confirmation, how much did the Flex cost at retail, did you customise the tool load, and if so, what was the cost at retail?I'm just curious as a I'd a look a while back at getting a Flex, but to set it up the way I wanted pushed the cost into 'proper' tool levels
I got it in a trade from David, so priceless

The preloaded tool is now 88 USD. To get my current load out you’d need to add the file, saw, and serrated blade for an additional $18 ($6 each). Or the blank Flex is $44 and adding thr Spirit implements is about $55 extra. Considering one can typically find a used Spirit in great condition for $100 or less, it’s better to just get the Spirit if that’s the ideal loadout.
I will post more about cost and loadouts in the future. At the rate I’m posting you’d be able to save enough for 2 Flex systems putting away a just few pounds a month. :ahhh
-
@Grand_Banana said:
I got it in a trade from David, so priceless
The preloaded tool is now 88 USD. To get my current load out you’d need to add the file, saw, and serrated blade for an additional $18 ($6 each). Or the blank Flex is $44 and adding thr Spirit implements is about $55 extra. Considering one can typically find a used Spirit in great condition for $100 or less, it’s better to just get the Spirit if that’s the ideal loadout.
I will post more about cost and loadouts in the future. At the rate I’m posting you’d be able to save enough for 2 Flex systems putting away a just few pounds a month. :ahhh
Cheers Nate, so same either side of the pond on the cost side
-
Comparisons Part IV: Wire Strippers and Cutters
I value the wire strippers and scraper on the Spirit as a very useful tool. I use these components on the chisel combo tool frequently. Most of my use involves small circuits in the lab, but I have also done a fair amount of electrical work on a couple houses with the Spirit or the Alox Electrician. Small jobs that it is nice to have on me, or in the lab where it may be necessary to quickly fix a low voltage wired connection.
The Flex chisel combo tool wire stripper and scraper are excellent. Very quickly cut through romex sheath and insulation. There is something to be said about too sharp, however, as it was very easy to knick the wire. It’s wicked sharp just like the chisel before extended use. I have not had much opportunity to use the Flex on projects so I recreated a few things for this comparison. The first I did use it, I did make a small indent in the copper, and on the do-over feel like I found the sweet spot for pressure. I recreated it on my pictures here.
[attach id=0 msg=2591274]
A special appearance here from the dedicated wire stripper implement. It is also wicked sharp. I have properly used it and when testing here I found it similar to real wire strippers. It’s possible to knick the copper if not careful but not nearly as easily done as on the combo tool. I applied a little bit more lateral movement with them and clearly cut into the wire. It demonstrates the sharpness and for anyone using them to take care to avoid creating a potential danger.
[attach id=1 msg=2591274]
The pliers wire cutters are interesting. The soft wire section is similar to Leatherman in length. Worked well on the mesh fencing in my earlier post. Snips paper clips fine. Works as intended. The hard wire section did not work as well as the Spirit. I had trouble cutting through 14 AWG wires with insulation while a stripped wire cut fine.
[attach id=2 msg=2591274]
I have also cut many finishing nails with my Spirit. The Flex hard wire cutters required so much more force than the Spirit to cut through a nail. I felt like I needed that special stomp stand Tim Leatherman used years ago to demonstrate his cutters. That said, the wire cutters themselves withstood the force and did not deform. Very impressed by that.
[attach id=3 msg=2591274]
Overall, I give both the combo tool wire stripper/scraper a 10/10 and the wire stripper implement a 10/10. Roxon did a great job with these. The wire cutters I give an 8/10. Hopefully they hold up in the long term.




-
Fun update: Fire
The really awesome thing about the Flex system is the modular components. I don’t think anyone will argue that point. The fact that I can swap out the serrated blade for the plain edge is amazing. I did that for a little bit of fire making this evening.
I only used the saw to trim through a few of the small tree trunks I cut down a few weeks ago for shaving and then to strike the ferro rod.
[attach id=0 msg=2591355]
The plain edge blade bevel is great for shavings and feather sticks. It’s no different in use than a Vic blade. I compared it to my Spirit X plain edge and only noticed one difference. The Roxon blade grind is a bit coarse and I could feel it when shaving through the wood. It was a little weird feeling but did not affect the blade utility. It is also very sharp and did not dull after stripping bark and shaving several branches and small trunks.
[attach id=1 msg=2591355]
Overall I give the plain edge blade a 10/10 only subtracting 1 from the implement to 9/10 if the Flex handles bother you. The locking mechanism slide buttons did create a bit of a hot spot, but that may just be my preference.
[attach id=2 msg=2591355]



-
Thanks for the thorough comparisons of the different tools.
Your results are probably about what I would expect. It isn’t as good as a top tier multitool but the flexibility aspect is what attracts people and they are willing to pat for.
I know the flexibility is what attracted my to Flex Companion and Mini Companion. I also like the easy open of the Companion and Mini as compared to nailing knicks and backspring tools.
-
@Sos24 said:
Thanks for the thorough comparisons of the different tools.Your results are probably about what I would expect. It isn’t as good as a top tier multitool but the flexibility aspect is what attracts people and they are willing to pat for.
I know the flexibility is what attracted my to Flex Companion and Mini Companion. I also like the easy open of the Companion and Mini as compared to nailing knicks and backspring tools.
Cheers, thanks Sos

The modular system and the easy open are awesome. I haven’t taken most of the tools through much or any work yet but some of the unique implements like the wirestripper are well done. Keeping those types of tools handy for a Companion paired with a Spirit would make a great kit. I’m not sure how much grime or dirt your Companions get as I’ve found the tool release and locks get gummed up quick. Saw dust and metal shavings have made for some annoyance. Once you get the tool release tab open it’s a quick easy clean out and back to work.
-
Comparisons Part V: File and Scissors
The Spirit file is one of my most used tools. I can safely say that because it’s quite worn down. Compared to a new Spirit file it is clearly not as aggressive, however, it still works well. I was very hopeful and excited to try the regular file on the Flex. It’s obvious from my initial observation and a few tasks it wasn’t going to be a fair comparison. To put it plainly: the Flex file is at best good for rounding off corners or flat filing soft woods, like the end of a dowel. It is not a metal saw by any stretch. Hell, it’s not even as good a back stretcher as a Vic or LM file.
This far I have used the file to attempt several small jobs and I’ve decided to rank it based on 2 basic categories. 1) wood file, 2) metal saw/file, and 3) sharpening.
As a wood file it is fine on soft woods. I cut (with the saw) a 1” dowel to fit a hanger rod in the closet. Used the file to file down the cut surface. Worked fine. That said, a Vic file can also cut through a 1/4 dowel with no problem. That was not the case for the Flex file. It does do a nice job on popsicle sticks! My son hurt his finger and to help him avoid bumping it I fashioned a make shift splint out of popsicle stick size applicators (which are the same thickness and width as a popsicle stick), filed down the broken edge, and secured with some medical tape to wear while sleeping. Thankfully he didn’t need a real splint.
As a metal file it’s OK and as a metal saw it’s rubbish. It’s very easy to file down aluminum. It barely works to file steel, like a finishing nail. Because I’ve used the Spirit file to cut larger gauge nails I gave it a shot with the Flex and it took a lot to just get through half a nail. Something the Spirit file does quite quickly. The Flex metal saw teeth may have significantly dulled, but I can’t be sure.
[attach id=0 msg=2592722]
As a file to sharpen, it just does not work. I thought I’d be able to at least smooth out some marks on my hatchet and pruning shears. It basically just glides over the metal. I’ve used my Spirit file to reprofile lawn tractor blades after hitting some large rocks and I don’t think the Flex file would do a darn thing. I will touch up those blades the end of the month and will report back if I remember to.
I did take the diamond file for a test drive on the hatchet and shears. It works rather well. Got back a very nice edge on both. I did notice a fine dust over the blades while sharpening and it might be the diamond embedding rubbing off.
[attach id=1 msg=2592722]
The scissors are decent/good scissors. They are actually quite good at cutting through plastics, cardboard and string easily. The lever action is comfortable for both thumb and forefinger use and they’re wicked sharp. I do not like the unfold storage position, however, as it is awkward to deploy and isn’t very one hand friendly.
[attach id=2 msg=2592722]
I give the file overall a 6/10 and break it down as 7/10 wood file, 6/10 metal saw, and 4/10 sharpening.
The diamond file an 8/10 for now.
And the scissors are an 8/10.



-
I forgot to post the comparison with the Spirit scissors for part V.
The Flex scissors are a standard set of shears similar to the LM Sidekick style. While I like these scissors for snipping plastic, they do require a bit more force and bite to get through zip ties. I believe they may work better than the Vic 91mm scissors on zip ties and similar plastics. I do prefer the Spirit snips but I wouldn’t say they are better. I give the Spirit snips an 8/10 because of how well they cut just about anything. If they were longer and opened wider those snips would be a 10/10.
[attach id=0 msg=2592792]

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

It's a fun project for sure!