AI generated sentiment analysis of MTO
-
I know, I know, I'm doing way too much AI stuff these days, but it was still interesting.
Performing a formal sentiment analysis on Multitool.org reveals a community-driven landscape defined by high levels of technical engagement, nostalgia, and brand loyalty.
Because Multitool.org operates primarily as a specialized enthusiast hub rather than a traditional consumer storefront, the "sentiment" here is less about standard customer satisfaction and more about community consensus, functional validation, and collective expertise.Sentiment Analysis Overview: Multitool.org
Sentiment Category Estimated Sentiment Primary Drivers Product Utility Highly Positive Focus on real-world testing, durability, and practical application. Brand Loyalty Strong/Nostalgic Deep appreciation for legacy designs (Victorinox, vintage Leatherman) and "classic" build quality. Innovation/New Gear Nuanced/Critical Excitement for new materials (e.g., MagnaCut) balanced against skepticism toward "predictable" or "bland" industry trends. Community Tone Collaborative Knowledge-sharing, DIY modifications, and mutual problem-solving (e.g., the "Think Tank" section). Key Thematic Insights
- The "User-First" Standard: Much of the site's content acts as a functional filter. Sentiment is rarely binary (good/bad); it is typically evaluative. A product is deemed "good" if it serves a specific niche or solves a real-world problem. Disappointment is usually voiced when a tool is perceived as sacrificing function for aesthetics or quality for cost-cutting.
- Expertise-Driven Discourse: The community values technical specifications (steels, lock mechanisms, machining) over marketing hype. When an article or forum post reviews a product, positive sentiment is earned through "time in pocket" and objective performance, not just brand name recognition.
- Constructive Criticism: Negative sentiment is almost never "toxic." When a design is criticized—such as a shift in manufacturing location leading to lower quality—it is framed as a loss of a previously great standard, often accompanied by community-led discussions on how to repair, restore, or modify the tool to regain its utility.
.
Def
-
AI is pretty clever at times - Eh? I !!
It's spotted our great community and value!
-
Interesting that you bring this up right now.

Following the successful (ish) AI aided construction of GearFeed, I now have started down a more ambitious path that I think we will all appreciate, but you especially.
I have started to rebuild the SAKSelector.
I have a long history with SAKSelector. Many moons ago in the old SOSAK Forum I started working with a member named Bob Quinlan (and others) to create a database of tools, models, sizes, options etc. The idea was, if you had a SAK you couldn't identify, you could pop in the tools, size etc and it would spit out what model it was.
Bob operated that long after by himself, and when it got to be too much trouble and effort, he passed it along to me.
We hosted it on SwissArmyKnights.com for a while after SOSAKOnline died, but it never really worked again properly, no one was maintaining it, updating it, or really doing anything at all with it.
Now I am.
And the AI and I are working to make it better than it ever was, because rather than maintaining it's own SAK database that would need constant updating with each new model, it will pull info from and link back to SAKWiki.com.
It will have it's own domain and be it's own site, but will lead to SAKWiki and also the Swiss Army Knights forum. It shouldn't adversely affect SAKWiki in any way- from the SAKWiki side it won't even be noticed, but it will be a tool that helps people identify their knives and lead them to where they can learn more.
I had intended to wait until I had something a bit more solid to announce it, and I am hoping to have it up and running, at least in a trial stage before the end of the month because I think it would be a great thing to announce during our anniversary celebration.
Just one more value added service that places MTO dead center of this particular niche universe.

Def
-
Wow - Sounds amazing and ..... 'Just what I (ie we) always needed'
And v impressive ... and a ***massive ***timesaver if it can work off the SAKWiki data -
@Huntsman said:
Wow - Sounds amazing and ..... 'Just what I (ie we) always needed'
And v impressive ... and a ***massive ***timesaver if it can work off the SAKWiki dataIt is intended to work on a few levels:
1- it can draw traffic to SAKWiki.
2- SAKWiki will link back to it to provide more/better service to users
3- No additional database to worry about updating whenever new models come out. A s long as SAKWiki gets updated, so does SAKSelector.As an added bonus, it will scrape info and cache it daily so if SAKWiki goes offline, SAKSelector will still function, just in a limited capacity. If SAKWiki doesn't come back online in time, SAKSelector will maintain that cache until such time as SAKWiki returns, so it should always be up to date and ready to go.
Def
-
Even more amazing!!
As it’s AI l/natural language model - I guess it can cope with our horribly inconsistent naming?
Eg see this post from Little Tinker where he found 17 different ways we listed the can opener
/post/1332138
-
It will do it's best.
I'm not a coder and I'm building this from scratch in Python. I'm sure there will be a lot of modifications needed to make it useful, and able to deal with the curveballs.
It won't be perfect, but I'm hoping it will be functional enough for most things.
Def
-
I am back on this for a bit- hopefully I will have something to show soon.
Def
-
Not bad work this evening... This is what I started with and what I have now.
I'm still working, but I think it's coming along nicely. Feel free to check it out at SAKSelector.org.
Apparently I was closer to being done than I thought I was when I stopped working on it last month.

Def


-
Nice! Glad you were almost finished with it and didnt know
Hopefully it won't have to be tweaked to much and works well from the start without problems

-
The issue is that every editor has done things slightly differently over the years and so while it looks fairly standardized on the front end there isn't a reliable, 100 percent "find photo here" setting for each page.
I'm having to cast a pretty wide net to get photos from each page and it's pulling in all kinds of weird images that aren't related to the specific knife.
Also, I sent the letter no to my contact at Victorinox to have a look at. He likes it quite a bit and has suggested some features he would like to see. I will take those under advisement, as I would any of your suggestions.
What is interesting is that he has told me "BTW I used AI to extract all mentioned Tools and Functions from SAKwiki once."
It would be an easy way to recreate SAKWiki under their own banner if they felt like taking another shot at it. After all, I haven't added any of the info from SAKWiki to SAKSelector- the software I am building isn't AI, but it crawls SAKWiki to update its database, and there is no back end secret plug in required to "steal" all of the info.
There really isn't much that we can do about it either, which is one of the reasons I am rebuilding the SAKSelector- try to be one step ahead of everyone else.
Def
-
Be nice is Vic would play better with MTO since they definetly use everything as a resource. At least they agreed to make a special run of SAKs
better than nothing though :ahhh -
As more and more time goes by and I speak more to them it sounds like they just happened to be in the mood to experiment with something, and we just happened to hit them at the right time. I don't think they did it for us so much as they were looking for something to do and we gave them a direction.
Almost like they had just enough inlay material left and didn't want to waste it or something.
Def
-
Ah, gotcha

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login