Buck X-Tract
-
i would say the freestyle or skeletool is a multi more and the tool logic plier and meyerco paradox are more knifes. the extract is in the middle. I definitely think it has a nicer knife than plier.
-
To be honest I think it functions poorly at both. Too bulky to be a good useful blade, not functional enough to be a good MT.
-
@cgk said:
To be honest I think it functions poorly at both. Too bulky to be a good useful blade, not functional enough to be a good MT.BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!! SSSSSSSSSSSssssssssssssssssss!!!!!!!!! :D I think it is a superb tool. Nothing else has the great blade and one handed access to everything like the X-tract does.
Definitely a MT in my book.
-
I agree with Benner.
It is an MT of a unique design that excels at one handed operations.
-
I believe if it's a tool designed with multiple functions it's a multi-tool. The Extract is a multi-tool, the SAK is a multi-tool and a PST is a multi-tool. Granted they all have different configurations but they are ALL a "tool" designed with "multi"ple functions. But who looks at words anyways. 8)
-
@ducktapehero said:
I believe if it's a tool designed with multiple functions it's a multi-tool. The Extract is a multi-tool, the SAK is a multi-tool and a PST is a multi-tool. Granted they all have different configurations but they are ALL a "tool" designed with "multi"ple functions. But who looks at words anyways. 8)See I classify SAK's on their own. :D In fact I classify as the following;
Multitools; Anything that does more than one function (except SAK's). This includes Leathermans, Gerbers, Atwoods etc.
SAK's; Anything Victorinox or Wenger in any of the size variations.
Folders; Any folding knife that has 1 job - cutting. This can be a OH knife or a slippy.
Fixed blades, anything with a cutting edge and fixed. This includes knives, Axes, Kukris etc.
-
See I classify SAK's on their own. Grin In fact I classify as the following;
Multitools; Anything that does more than one function (except SAK's). This includes Leathermans, Gerbers, Atwoods etc.
SAK's; Anything Victorinox or Wenger in any of the size variations.
The flaw in this thinking is when you consider OTHER knives similar to the SAK. Like the standard "scout knife" that almost everyone has made. According to your theory it can't be a multi-tool since it's so similar to a SAK but it is NOT a SAK so what is it?
-
See I classify SAK's on their own. Grin In fact I classify as the following;
Multitools; Anything that does more than one function (except SAK's). This includes Leathermans, Gerbers, Atwoods etc.
SAK's; Anything Victorinox or Wenger in any of the size variations.
The flaw in this thinking is when you consider OTHER knives similar to the SAK. Like the standard "scout knife" that almost everyone has made. According to your theory it can't be a multi-tool since it's so similar to a SAK but it is NOT a SAK so what is it?
No, I classify SAK's as only Vics and Wengers so I would call those MT's.
-
No, I classify SAK's as only Vics and Wengers so I would call those MT's.
That's a bit illogical isn't it? In essence they're about the same thing yet they wind up in different categories? Whachu smoking man? And how much to send me some? :D
-
No, I classify SAK's as only Vics and Wengers so I would call those MT's.
That's a bit illogical isn't it? In essence they're about the same thing yet they wind up in different categories? Whachu smoking man? And how much to send me some? :D
Nope, some are made by the companies that provided for the swiss army and some weren't. Those that are are SAK's and those that weren't are MT's. When we have threads such as "Show us your SAK's" you don't get any MT's or Scout knives do you? They are all Vics and Wengers and so I classify them as SAK's in their own catergory.
-
I'd call it a knife, because it's based on frame of a knife. If it's based on a non-knife tool's frame then it's a multitool.
-
No, I classify SAK's as only Vics and Wengers so I would call those MT's.
That's a bit illogical isn't it? In essence they're about the same thing yet they wind up in different categories? Whachu smoking man? And how much to send me some? :D
Nope, some are made by the companies that provided for the swiss army and some weren't. Those that are are SAK's and those that weren't are MT's. When we have threads such as "Show us your SAK's" you don't get any MT's or Scout knives do you? They are all Vics and Wengers and so I classify them as SAK's in their own catergory.
Interesting logic, can't say that I category them the same but it's nothing worth thinking too hard over. It makes my brain hurt. BTW, is that a NO on the stuff you're smoking? :o :o
-
No, I classify SAK's as only Vics and Wengers so I would call those MT's.
That's a bit illogical isn't it? In essence they're about the same thing yet they wind up in different categories? Whachu smoking man? And how much to send me some? :D
Nope, some are made by the companies that provided for the swiss army and some weren't. Those that are are SAK's and those that weren't are MT's. When we have threads such as "Show us your SAK's" you don't get any MT's or Scout knives do you? They are all Vics and Wengers and so I classify them as SAK's in their own catergory.
Interesting logic, can't say that I category them the same but it's nothing worth thinking too hard over. It makes my brain hurt. BTW, is that a NO on the stuff you're smoking? :o :o
Unless you want some Drum tobacco, you will be very disappointed! :D
-
If it makes my brain think like yours it might be interesting. :ahhh
-
@ducktapehero said:
If it makes my brain think like yours it might be interesting. :ahhhIt also gives you hair like mine. :D
-
I could use some hair.
-
@ducktapehero said:
I could use some hair.Like mine though?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login