Famous Five
-
Not many Gerbers mentioned thus far. A couple, but Leatherman and Victorinox are (as you might expect I suppose) getting the most mentions.
No votes for the Sport Ratchet or the Flair yet I don't think!
-
[quote author=DaveK link=topic=13986.msg264350#msg264350 date=1253569466]
Not many Gerbers mentioned thus far. A couple, but Leatherman and Victorinox are (as you might expect I suppose) getting the most mentions.No votes for the Sport Ratchet or the Flair yet I don't think!
I thought Sog where getting a fair mention too
-
Yep - quite a few SOG references!
-
Utility: Spirit , everything I need , nothing I don't need .
Aesthetics: Spirit , great build quality , and F/F
Ease of carry : the charge family , nice pocket clip , sheath -pretty crappy
Innovation : the Skeletool , fresh concept , but doesn't work for me .
X factor: Spirit
Honorable mention for carry - traditional SAK's
Good thread BTW !
Chris
-
Oh boy...
1. Utility: Surge. Even though mine is modded and doomed to receive even more hacking. Weight is the price but function and size are a balancing payoff.
2. Aesthetically Pleasing: Vic Rescuetool. It's yellow, nicely styled, and beautiful despite its capability. Form followed function, but sexy nevertheless. Like a voluptuous long-haired brunette in a size 12 dress. I want to hold one. The knife, I mean.
3. Ease of carry: Leatherman "Radio Shack" 9-in-1 Precision Tool. It's on my keyring on my wallet chain, and it's so unobtrusive I sometimes forget I have it. Until I need to strip wires - or perform a small multitool task in a sheeple environment without ripping a velcro flap open and deploying the massive Surge.
4. Innovation: Gerber Nautilus. [you there, quit snickering ... we can hear that all the way up front.] A small LED that shines directly on the thing being worked on. It beats my current Fenix-in-the teeth and Surge-in-the-hand. (for taste and dental bills, mostly) A rubberized grip that didn't hold up well, but felt confident when your hands were soaked in oil and/or sweat. Under a car by the highway at 2am trimming the rotted end off a broken fuel hose, for instance. It carries well, had an awesome set of scissors (Thanks, Fiskars) and the basic assortment of tools. A phillips head blade that puts most SAK and even the Surge to shame, especially with larger screws. Modern scout knife, but missed the mark and now fairly shunned amongst our peers. Still, real genius in innovation -- somebody was thinking.
5. X-Factor: In my dreams. A Surge with a corkscrew, tweezers, toothpick, better phillips driver, exotic steel main blade, high-tech coated handles, titanium or unobtanium to reduce weight, built-in 5 or 10 lumen LED task illumination, non-security mainscrews that hold tension better, impregnated bronze pivot bearings, replaceable carbide cutters, Crunch-style locking pliers, small liquid-filled compass, laser pointer, 1 gig USB flash drive, small digital display for a basic AC/DC VOM, and a magnifier capable of starting a fire in good sunlight. I'm willing to pay $300 for such a beast. More for my choice of colors...
:ahhh
-steve
-
Ok, because I'm a complete goober I went through this thread and wrote everything down. I was curious what was winning what. But I have a question: do you count specific tools or the series? For instance, some people put down Charge for an answer to some questions and some people were specific saying Charge TTi...you count that as two different tools or just one tool? What do you all think? Same thing with Swisstools and spirits (although most people who answered Spirit just said Spirit). Any thoughts? I'm sorry guys, I'm just curious and it's something to do. :D
-
I would say a Charge is one model, as is a Spirit, Swiss Tool etc.
The variations are subtle in most cases, so I'd lump 'em together I think.
-
generally yes i take charge as all of them, as with powerlocks, and "new rangers" i only do an exception with the charge AL that specific model is the one i found beautiful(or maybe the ALX too) :)
-
Yeah, the aesthetic category is totally different.
-
what single tool have the most mention in any category?... that spirit has been mentioned a lot...
-
How many times has the skeletool been on there?
-
@GraysonK said:
Ok, because I'm a complete goober I went through this thread and wrote everything down. I was curious what was winning what. But I have a question: do you count specific tools or the series? For instance, some people put down Charge for an answer to some questions and some people were specific saying Charge TTi...you count that as two different tools or just one tool? What do you all think? Same thing with Swisstools and spirits (although most people who answered Spirit just said Spirit). Any thoughts? I'm sorry guys, I'm just curious and it's something to do. :DPfft. It's not about what's mentioned most.
Some tools have big followings. Others less.
For me, I look for new insights about tools. For example, the Buck Xtract was never a tool I'd think about. Now, I've gotta itchin' to take a look at one...
-
-
**Utility: **Original SOG powerlock, all function, zero comfort lol.
-
Aesthetically Pleasing: Vic spirit
-
Ease of carry: Leatherman Skeletool
-
Innovation: Leatherman PST, the one that started it all.
-
X-Factor: Leatherman Wave, while doesn't excel in one field it's the most balanced tool of them all. If I had to choose one this would be it.
-
-
@GraysonK said:
Ok, because I'm a complete goober I went through this thread and wrote everything down. I was curious what was winning what. But I have a question: do you count specific tools or the series? For instance, some people put down Charge for an answer to some questions and some people were specific saying Charge TTi...you count that as two different tools or just one tool? What do you all think? Same thing with Swisstools and spirits (although most people who answered Spirit just said Spirit). Any thoughts? I'm sorry guys, I'm just curious and it's something to do. :DI would go with series, as its easier to group. Charges are Charges the different models are just minor details. However with the Vics, a Spirit is a Spirit whereas Swisstool could be RS or CS models and there are some differences there - size, ergonomics etc. Likewise alot of people metioned different models of SAKs for "ease of carry" , I'd consider them all SAKs otherwise theres alot of writing for you.
Just making it easier for you ;) -
Hi all!
Here's some preliminary numbers (i'm not a professional just a bored gadget geek with too much time on her hands right now) Numbers are as of JZ's post yesterday.
**Utility: ** Surge and Powerlock are tied with 5 so far. Surge is a Surge but in the Powerlock category (and correct me if I did this wrong) there were 3 votes for powerlock, 1 for original powerlock, and 1 for Paladin Powerplay with I think is kind of the same thing. Close seconds were Spirit and Charge with 4 each. Third place so far is the SwisstoolAesthetically Pleasing: Gee I wonder?
The Spirit is winning this one, hands down with 13 so far. Juices are second with 8 (Yellow KF4 mentioned most with 3). A very distant third is the Skeletool.Ease of Carry: Skeletool is winning this with 7. Charge and Wave are tied for second with 5 each. And the Vic Farmer and Sideclip are tied for third with 3 each.
Innovation: This category is very close. The Crunch is barely winning this with 5. Second is the Surge with 4. And third with 3 is the SOG Power series (2 for the Power Plier and 1 for the Powerlock).
**X-Factor: ** SOG is winning this one. :) SOG Power series has 8 votes in this one (Powerlock-3, Power Plier-2, Power Assist-2, and 1 for J-Sews Power Cut...I didn't know exactly where to put this one so I put it here). Second place so far is the Spirit with 5. And the Wave and Charge are tied for third with 4 each. *If you count the "Super Surge" that Speedracer suggested then Surge would be tied with Wave and Charge for third.
Okay so that's it for now. I can't wait to see how this will all pan out. I already want to try a Buck X-tract and one of the SOG's as a result of this thread. Have fun! :) :D

-
Nice work there Gray
Glad to see some people appreciate the Surge! :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

i like how the powerlock gets some love too :)