Farmer love
-
- Utilitarian - Alox SAKs are a big step backward because they all lack Phillips drivers,
In case you haven't heard, the can opener on the Farmer(in fact all Vics) works very well as a Phillips. I won't carry a tool that doesn't have one and it works good enough for me that I'll gladly carry it.
I've heard people make that claim, but it isn't true in my experience.
In exigent circumstances the can opener is better than nothing to turn a Phillips, but in my experience it's also fairly likely to bugger up a screw that requires much torque.
Glad it works well enough for you though.
.
-
Here I was all nervous about it being FARMER LOVE and this being a family forum and all :ahhh
Then I realized you were talking about the alox farmer ::)

-
Wheew! I'm glad I wasn't the only one to think that... :ahhh :ahhh

-
another Farmer fan here. The silver alox scales improve with age IMO
-
Not such a fan myself. I don't feel any extra benefit from the beefier tools and a SAK isn't a SAK without a corkscrew (in my head anyway). I also notice them sitting in my pocket far to much. Eventually they look good with the worn scales but in the mean time they look terrible. I'm happy that others like them, but they're just not my cup of Darjeeling.
I find the Cellidor a far warmer and friendlier material to hold, you can clean the scales up or replace them entirely if they become scratched up. You get a far better selection of tools in the Cellidor range as well.
Just my 2p worth. :)
-
You get a far better selection of tools in the Cellidor range as well.
But Cellidors don't have the mighty Awl of the Pioneer/Farmer!
True enough, and a mighty awl it is
, but I don't need it every day. I'm happy to have one sitting at home waiting to be used, but an awl really isn't part of my EDC needs. -
Y'all must have some cheap screws where you live. I've rarely had a problem.
-
I use the screwdriver on the can opener often with out any problems. I prefer it to the Philips on the bottom of a SAK.
Mike -
True... ;)

-
Look, I'm happy for all of you that love your Alox SAKs. They're not my cup of tea, but so what?
However, some of the rationalizations offered in support of Alox SAKs are just silly:
-Alox SAKs lack some of the handiest implements, but those Phillips drivers, scissors, tweezers, etc. aren't really necessary. Yeah, right.
-Although they don't have a Phillips, the can opener is just as good or even BETTER than a real Phillips driver. Yeah, right.
Maybe it'd be better to just admit the obvious:
ALOX SAKs give up some functionality for the sake of appearance. Some people value their appearance enough to sacrifice some functionality - some people don't.
.
-
It's the utter robustness that win's me over :)
The fact that it's stunning is a happy coincidence :)
-
@ringzero said:
ALOX SAKs give up some functionality for the sake of appearance. Some people value their appearance enough to sacrifice some functionality - some people don't.Riiiight... That's why Model 61 soldier was a standard military issue for almost 50 years... appearance...
I carry a Rambler for all my T&T, scissor, and nail filing needs. I use my Wenger SI for most everything else, from safely cutting heavy duty cable ties with the awl, to opening gallon paint cans with the bottle opener. 91mm cellidor doesn't work for me in those tasks. I do carry CT41 in my laptop bag, and use it frequently, but Alox is a workhorse, and my "farmer love" is not just due to the farmer's good looks. -
I like the hand feel of the alox SAK's . I only wish there wee more of them , preferably with scissors !
Chris
-
ALOX SAKs give up some functionality for the sake of appearance. Some people value their appearance enough to sacrifice some functionality - some people don't.
Riiiight... That's why Model 61 soldier was a standard military issue for almost 50 years... appearance...
Nothing wrong with choosing a knife based on appearance.
Some people carry a multi blade Case Stockman with fancy scales rather than a plain old SAK because it is a more attractive knife. But unless you actually work with livestock, the Case Stockman offers less utility than the typical SAK.
The decision is easy for me, because I don't even like appearance of the ALOX SAKs.
To each his own.
.
-
i'm not a big fan of plain ole silver alox. Bring on the colours!

-
As much as I love the Alox, I think the whole idea of the SAK is to find the one (or more) that meet your needs. I think of the Alox knives as more on the minamalist side, but as it has more than proven its self in the service of soldiers for several decades I know that it's a very capable tool. Sometime I'm lazy though and I want scissors, which is why I carry a modified Alox.
We all love SAKs here, but this is a Farmer thread. Maybe we need an Explorer Love thread for balance.
:sak:
-
I love my farmer.... great alox finish, over sized main blade.... together with the saw and other bit and pieces it's a cracking all round knife.
10 outta 10 : :sak:
-
No need to get snippy ringzero. But when you post in a thread called "FARMER LOVE" and you say you don't like it it seems pretty obvious that other people are going to disagree with you.
I love the Farmer because it is robust, if I drop it the scales aren't going to fall off. I love the beefy tools. I love the looks. With it's looks and robustness it's equally at home at a white tie dinner or a battlefield. And if the tweezers and toothpick are that important then no, you're not gonna like the Farmer.
However, I will not carry a knife that does not give me an option for Phillips screws and for the the Vic can opener works well enough to satisfy me, and obviously a LOT of other people too. Will it grab a Phillips screw head like a Snap-On screwdriver? Of course not but it's a SAK. They're meant for emergencies. If I know I'm going to need a Phillips screwdriver I will grab a dedicated tool, but that's the case for ANY tool on a SAK. Even the blade.
So, if you don't like the Farmer, or any alox knife that's fine. I don't care. That's why Victorinox makes several models. But I don't know why you're getting pissy. It's like you're taking it personal that we don't share your views.
So I guess I'm sorry but for what I don't know. I just love my Farmer and thought I would talk about it.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


