Show your slip joint's thread!
-
I'm going to mail out the knife to GEC tomorrow. It would probably be faster to just drive it to them as I only live a couple of hours away, but I'm lazy :-\
I've had bummer knives from many companies. It's how the company handles the customers concerns that matters. If the knife comes back with a decent user edge and they can fix the spring issues then I'll be happy. As far as the knife goes though, I love the design. It's a great size with really useful blade shapes. I think for a hunter this model is the tops. If they can get me straight I'm sure the knife will see many a field dressing. It's a shame as I'm going bow hunting this weekend. Looks like the Case stockman gets the job again. I'll be sure to post here when I get the knife back.
This thread has been derailed. Nothing new here at MT.org. We now say goodbye to the whiner and his slipjoint problems. Feel free to carry on with your regularly scheduled posting. Show your slippies!
-
Just a quick update in case anybody still cares.
The good news - Superfast turnaround over at GEC. I think it took 3 days total to get my knife back from the day I mailed it.
The bad news - I guess that nobody over at GEC can get an edge on my knife either. It was returned to me with a note saying "blades have been sharpened". I was unable to cut paper or my thumb with either blade and believe me I was really trying to see if it could cut my thumb.
So I guess if you don't mind sharpening your brand new knife GEC would be fine. For me it's not acceptable. There are too many quality knife manufacturers who will ship me a sharp knife to be hassled with buying dull ones. I'll post this knife for trade on a couple knife forums and see if I can't find a Boker Copperhead or Case Saddlehorn which are next on my list.
-
It's a shame to hear that. For me the very least a knife can do is be able to cut things, otherwise can you really call it a knife?
-
What are your thoughts on Hen and Rooster ? I ask because I really like this one :drool: :drool: :drool: :drool:
Dunc
-
They are meant to be very good and have a good rep. I would have been all over that one when I was in the market for one, but it is just soooooo expensive. Picked up a Fight'n Rooster off of BB instead.
-
@GMArthur said:
Just a quick update in case anybody still cares.The good news - Superfast turnaround over at GEC. I think it took 3 days total to get my knife back from the day I mailed it.
The bad news - I guess that nobody over at GEC can get an edge on my knife either. It was returned to me with a note saying "blades have been sharpened". I was unable to cut paper or my thumb with either blade and believe me I was really trying to see if it could cut my thumb.
So I guess if you don't mind sharpening your brand new knife GEC would be fine. For me it's not acceptable. There are too many quality knife manufacturers who will ship me a sharp knife to be hassled with buying dull ones. I'll post this knife for trade on a couple knife forums and see if I can't find a Boker Copperhead or Case Saddlehorn which are next on my list.
That is poor :-\
-
@GMArthur said:
Just a quick update in case anybody still cares.The good news - Superfast turnaround over at GEC. I think it took 3 days total to get my knife back from the day I mailed it.
The bad news - I guess that nobody over at GEC can get an edge on my knife either. It was returned to me with a note saying "blades have been sharpened". I was unable to cut paper or my thumb with either blade and believe me I was really trying to see if it could cut my thumb.
So I guess if you don't mind sharpening your brand new knife GEC would be fine. For me it's not acceptable. There are too many quality knife manufacturers who will ship me a sharp knife to be hassled with buying dull ones. I'll post this knife for trade on a couple knife forums and see if I can't find a Boker Copperhead or Case Saddlehorn which are next on my list.
Well that sucks. I agree, it shouldn't be that way. As I said none of my GEC's came with a scary edge.....or at least an edge to my own standards but they did come usable. My most recent one which arrived yesterday I have to admit came a bit duller than my others. This one would need some sharpening if it was to be a user. It'll cut paper, just not as effortlessly as some of my others.

I'm wondering if some of these are built by one of their employees, edge grinds anyway, that just does it different. As my others, and many more owned by people I know, have come with usefully sharp edges.
2xTap
-
My latest from GEC has arrived and it is sweet!



These new ones for 2009 are excellent, and I do much prefer the end-cap bolster on this pattern over the barehead. When these showed up it was a given that I was getting one. GEC is calling this version which is a single Spey blade end-capped #23 the Farmer. These are available in either backspring only or with Linerlock.....I got the backspring only version. These are a "1 of 50" run done in 440-C stainless. Mine is serial #22.
These are 4.5" closed and as mentioned the blades are 440-C. Bolsters and shield are nickle/silver, and the liners & pins are brass. The scales on this one are Smooth Ivory Bone, and they are extremely nice. I really like the color, looks like some polished Mastadon Ivory I have seen before.....good looking stuff!

Overall the Fit & Finish is what I have come to expect from GEC.....damn near perfect. There is not a gap to be found, zero blade play, stout backspring, polished throughout (though the blades have a slight hazy look to them), clean and even blade grinds, Scale to bolster fit is seamless as are they to the liners, just superb in fit all around.

I ordered mine from Mike over at CollectorKnives.net from his "Early Bird Bonus" section. This included a GEC knife pick with my order. As seen in my pics this one is a non-scaled version. These would go well on a keychain.
One thing I have noticed is the stoutness of the backspring on this one is not as heavy as that of my other 23's. It's stout but not nail-busting. And nowhere near the level of my SARPNT which is also a single Spey Blade #23.
But......while this one is as clean and solid as any GEC I own it does have a fault, the edge! This is the dullest GEC I own and one of the dullest slipjoints in my whole collection. GEC's ain't known for laser-sharp edges but at least my others came fairly usable and at least sharp enough to remove arm hair with some effort. This one doesn't remove arm hair well at all and can barely cut through paper without tearing it. Matter of fact this one is about as close to a "butter knife" as I have gotten in a knife in a long time.
Considering these are priced near $100.00 this is unacceptable. As good as the F&F on these are they should still come with a usable edge......they are a knife after all. A tool specifically designed to cut things! It'd be like getting a screwdriver that won't turn screws or a car that won't drive. Kind defeats the whole purpose of their existance.
I've been hearing about this lately of GEC's coming dull out of the box, like the one GMArthur recently got. I haven't really had one up until now. This is one area GEC really needs to get their act together. In my case I ain't sweating it too much as this is going into the collection and won't be a user. But for those that get these to be used.....you shouldn't have to put an edge on a knife right from the get go when they cost as much as these do.
That aside, the knife is still a beautiful piece and well constructed. I hope that these dull ones are just random flukes and not becoming the standard from them. But regardless of edge, you'd be hard pressed to find a better build on another production knife.
2xTap
-
That's a fine looking knife. Whilst I personally wouldn't be too concerned about receiving a blade with a poor edge, I do agree that on a premium folder like these not having it sharp is just plain strange :-\
-
Neil,
Most users I know generally are never satified with most factory edges, many I know wind up putting their own edge on a knife that they are going to use and carry. One of the exceptions being Bark Rivers.......they come so damn sharp!
That being said the least a company can do is put a usable edge on their knives so at least it can do it's job out of the box. Seldom have I had a knife come not this way. Even more so the fact of a premium folder with such an awesome build. Quality like this you'd think a hair-popping edge would be standard......they have the technology!
My other GEC's all came with usable edges, not quite hair-poppers but sharp enough. But this one is odd in that it's not even really usable. I can't say enough about their quality as I have been utterly impressed with their level of fit and finish on their knives. But it is a little disheartening to get one with an edge like this.
2xTap
-
That is one handsome knife mate.

-
This one came in today. A couple of passes on a piece of leather and this thing is extremely sharp. Excellent fit and finish with everything nice and flush in every position. If you don't own any knives is Case's excellent CV steel hurry and pick one up.
Yella handled CV Trapper




-
Very nice 8)
-
GMArthur,
Nice grab bud!

Yellow delrin and the #54 pattern are two classics in their lines, done together with their Chrome Vanadium blade steel and you have a very popular piece.
2xTap
-
Yum

Hopefully get some Buck 301 pics up tomorrow.

-
Nice grab bud!

Yellow delrin and the #54 pattern are two classics in their lines, done together with their Chrome Vanadium blade steel and you have a very popular piece.
2xTap
Thanks. I'll be picking up a yella peanut in CV for my oldest boys birthday next month. He'll be 8 and in need of a nice Case for his pocket.
-
Hopefully get some Buck 301 pics up tomorrow.

Benner,
Oh yeah, let's see it. Which did you get, likely one of the new ones in either Black Delrin or Dymondwood? I have only one Buck 301 in my collection at the moment......This one an earlier model back when they were being made by Camillus for Buck:


I also got one of the asian import versions, the Buck 371...........

......these are real good stockmans as well, these are being built over in China by the same people that make the Rough Riders.
2xTap
-
GMArthur,
Nice grab bud!

Yellow delrin and the #54 pattern are two classics in their lines, done together with their Chrome Vanadium blade steel and you have a very popular piece.
2xTap
Thanks. I'll be picking up a yella peanut in CV for my oldest boys birthday next month. He'll be 8 and in need of a nice Case for his pocket.
GMArthur,
I'm sure your son is going to love that!

Just curious......on your CV knives that you use and carry, do you force patina or do you let it develope naturally?
2xTap
-
2xTap, it is the Dymondwood version. Lovely, easy to open knife. Came with a cracking sheath as well.
Did a quick pic the other day, but will do more;

-
Benner,
Nice pics bud, and nice knife as well! I totally forgot the new ones came with the pocket sheath. A great little addition.

2xTap
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



