Annoying thread
-
On another forum I recently saw a poll asking the members which of the following 2 knives would they take to a tropical island and have to survive with for a period of time.
-
was a Swiss Champ.
-
was a Chris Reeve Sebenza.
And the annoying part ???, a lot of people voted for the Sebenza! >:(
Now don't get me wrong I'm sure the Sebenza's a very fine knife, but better than a swiss champion in a survival situation ??? I don't think so!
I've been wracking my limited supply of brains to think of a reason why I'd take a Sebby over almost any sak and all I can come up with is as follow's
a) The sebby will hold it's edge longer (but be close to impossible to sharpen using natural materials)
b) You could in theory batton wood with it (but if you broke the liner lock the knife will become very dangerous to use)
c) You could use it as a weapon more effectively than you could the champ (But again you could use the sak to construct a bow, spear or a club)
So try as I might I can't think of a WORTHWHILE reason to take the sebbie or any tactical folder over a humble Sak in a survival situation ???
I think it's just a typical case of Sak/multi prejudiece again >:(
-
-
Ok... before I answer. What benefits would you have by having a SwissChamp while trying to survive on a tropical island?
-
@665ae said:
Ok... before I answer. What benefits would you have by having a SwissChamp while trying to survive on a tropical island?The means to collect and split fire wood.
The ability to make trap's of varieing size's.
Possibly even starting the fire with the magnifying glass.
Personal hygene tool's with the scissors, tooth pick and tweezers.
Possible kit repairs with the pliers and file.
Cleaning game with one of the blade's while eating with other. Also can use the fish descaler for fish (obviously ::))
Manufacture of clothing and equipment with the awl and again the plier's.
Should you be lucky enough to find tin good's you have the means to open them (same with bottle's)
Theres a few of the top of my head, the list is as long as you imagination :)
-
O.K. I understand that the Sebenza and the swisschamp are great tools both of which are capable of making the survival situation easier than no tools at all. The Sebenza would be better suited to baton wood. Contrary to popular belief, an edge can be put on a sebenza with a sandstone if need be. The swisschamp can also do many tasks that a sebenza could not. Id give my vote to the swisschamp only because of the utility of the tools implements. As far as blades go the sebenza is far superior. As for the island argument. Stone age people managed to survive with only stone tools (mostly blades of various shapes and sizes) so a blade is definately the base of a survival situation.
-
I think people disregard the SwissChamp because they believe the SAK to be antiquated mixed in with the belief that if you put the word "tactical" in front of anything it is instantly becomes versatile and durable, i.e.: tactical knife, tactical flashlight, tactical spoon, etc.
-Tactical Papacat.
-
@micky d said:
The means to collect and split fire wood.You can do that with a Sebenza
The ability to make trap's of varieing size's.
Again, you could do that with the Sebenza
Possibly even starting the fire with the magnifying glass.
True, but depending on the weather... I would probably want my camp/fire to be sheltered. It would probably be useful for a signal fire on the beach though :) I'm curious though, has anyone here done this with a SAK magnifying glass?
Personal hygene tool's with the scissors, tooth pick and tweezers.
True... but I could use the knife blade in place of scissors (I admit, the cuts probably won't be as precise) and I could make a toothpick by shaving down small twigs or small animal bones. The tweezers are a bonus though.
Possible kit repairs with the pliers and file.
I'm assuming that if you're "stranded" on a tropical island, you probably don't have much of a kit with you. Just going by what I normally EDC, I don't see much need for a pair of pliers. The file could be useful though.
Cleaning game with one of the blade's while eating with other. Also can use the fish descaler for fish (obviously ::))
The two blades would be nice, but you can wash/heat the blade to disinfect it. I don't see much need for the descaler, but I think that has more to do with how I would cook the fish.
Manufacture of clothing and equipment with the awl and again the plier's.
How long are you planning on being there? :P I normally think of "survival" situations lasting about 72 hours max... after that, you'll need some primitive living skills, and you'll probably make most of your tools :)
Should you be lucky enough to find tin good's you have the means to open them (same with bottle's)
I can open a can with a blade, it just doesn't look real pretty. I'd be more interested in why I'm finding canned goods and bottles on a "deserted" tropical island :P
I don't really know which one I would prefer. I'd probably go with the SwissChamp because of the implements, but a large part of me is screaming to take the dedicated blade :)
-
I'm not saying you can't survive with a sebenza, you could, but it would be a hell of a lot easier with the Sak in my opinion, and if you were given the choice of either tool, surely you'd be better served by something versitile like a champ :)
-
@micky d said:
I'm not saying you can't survive with a sebenza, you could, but it would be a hell of a lot easier with the Sak in my opinion, and if you were given the choice of either tool, surely you'd be better served by something versitile like a champ :)The sebenza looks more macho so must be better?
It costs more so maybe it comes with it own Man friday? ;)
More serious-
If it comes to a survival situation it is unlikely you will have time to pick and choose what you will have to survive, if it is on a tropical island you will not have anything sharp with you if you arrived by air, by sea you might be lucky and get by any checks carrying something less aggressive such as a SAK.Dave
-
@micky d said:
I'm not saying you can't survive with a sebenza, you could, but it would be a hell of a lot easier with the Sak in my opinion, and if you were given the choice of either tool, surely you'd be better served by something versitile like a champ :)
The sebenza looks more macho so must be better?
It costs more so maybe it comes with it own Man friday? ;)
More serious-
If it comes to a survival situation it is unlikely you will have time to pick and choose what you will have to survive, if it is on a tropical island you will not have anything sharp with you if you arrived by air, by sea you might be lucky and get by any checks carrying something less aggressive such as a SAK.Dave
I agree every sebenza should come with your very own jeeves, pimms anyone? ;D
I'm just saying what the original poll on the other forum said, what would you rather find in you pocket on said survival situation?
I just struggled with the logic of those who said Sebenza ???
-
"The best tool is the one between you ears.."
but personally, I'd go with the SAK... ;D
OR, I could apply the multitool.org rule....BOTH!

-
Hmm... I'd actually have to say that's a tough one for me. If there was the choice of a fixed-blade knife I'd probably take that over either one. To me the biggest plus of the SAK would be if you could start fires with the magnying glass (I'm also interested to know if it can be done!). I could also see the awl and saw as being useful for survival. The Sebenza on the other hand is much closer to a fixed-blade knife, which IMO would seem like the most basic survival tool of all. I'm not sure which I would choose, but then again, I'll never have to... :D
-
That sounds familiar... honestly, I would take the Sebenza too because I could sell it to the natives in exchange for everlasting support, while the SwissTool would probably only buy me a few years worth of slaves!
Def
-
@Sparkey said:
"The best tool is the one between you ears.."but personally, I'd go with the SAK... ;D
OR, I could apply the multitool.org rule....BOTH!

That's very true :)
-
@NeitherExtreme said:
Hmm... I'd actually have to say that's a tough one for me. If there was the choice of a fixed-blade knife I'd probably take that over either one. To me the biggest plus of the SAK would be if you could start fires with the magnying glass (I'm also interested to know if it can be done!). I could also see the awl and saw as being useful for survival. The Sebenza on the other hand is much closer to a fixed-blade knife, which IMO would seem like the most basic survival tool of all. I'm not sure which I would choose, but then again, I'll never have to... :DWell I'm sure most of us would take a fixed blade if the option was there :), but sadly the original thread was specifically sebbie or champ :-\
-
@Defender said:
That sounds familiar... honestly, I would take the Sebenza too because I could sell it to the natives in exchange for everlasting support, while the SwissTool would probably only buy me a few years worth of slaves!Def
Hmm If it was a slave for ''every'' need I could come round to the idea of a sebenza after all ;)
-
You could take out the magnifying glass and burn one of the natives and then you may be considered a god.
"Ray, the next time that someone asks you if youre a god you say YES!"
-Bill Murray, Ghostbusters -
I love that movie...
Given the choice between a SwissChamp and a Sebbie, I would take the Champ, and not just because I'm a SAK nut. The Champ (and other SAKs) are better suited to many of the more mundane tasks you'd find in a survival situation, like pulling splinters. In some parts of the world, the infection resulting from a simple splinter can kill you. Also, as Dunc pointed out, the saw could be used to open tougher foods like coconuts.
Of course if I had a Sebbie and was washed up on an island, I'll bet I get washed up with a bunch of imported beer without twist offs, and several crates of canned food!
Def
-
Swisschamp, definitely, for the previously cited reasons, except one. Although there have been reports of it being done, I have so far (30 years) been unsuccessful in starting a fire with a Vic magnifier. The best I could so far manage is burning tiny holes in darkened (to tone down reflectivity) paper, making brief wisps in charred cloth and having no effect at all on wood shavings. If my life depended on it, maybe I could work it out, but would prefer a fully charged Zippo lighter (I'm an older person). The magnifier is just too small. Recently, however, Vic has been fitting current production with a revised version that's a little larger; maybe enough to do the trick, but I doubt it.
Also, the fish scaler is NG for its intended purpose, although I use mine lots for a probe or olive fork (not before cleaning thoroughly ;D). The large knife blade works much better for scaling, but cleanup is a bitch.
Although you might think there are implements on a Swisschamp that would be useless, the only certainty in a survival situation is that you'll never know what might come in handy.
BTW, who's annoyed?
-
@znapschatz said:
Swisschamp, definitely, for the previously cited reasons, except one. Although there have been reports of it being done, I have so far (30 years) been unsuccessful in starting a fire with a Vic magnifier. The best I could so far manage is burning tiny holes in darkened (to tone down reflectivity) paper, making brief wisps in charred cloth and having no effect at all on wood shavings. If my life depended on it, maybe I could work it out, but would prefer a fully charged Zippo lighter (I'm an older person). The magnifier is just too small. Recently, however, Vic has been fitting current production with a revised version that's a little larger; maybe enough to do the trick, but I doubt it.Also, the fish scaler is NG for its intended purpose, although I use mine lots for a probe or olive fork (not before cleaning thoroughly ;D). The large knife blade works much better for scaling, but cleanup is a bitch.
Although you might think there are implements on a Swisschamp that would be useless, the only certainty in a survival situation is that you'll never know what might come in handy.
BTW, who's annoyed?
I was a little annoyed at the people who voted against the champ purely because it was a sak and not some high end tactical folder. ::)
It rally gets my goat when people look down there noses at saks/multis >:(
As for the magnifiying lens, well like you i've got things to smoulder but never hot enough to start a fire, but if it was your only means of making fire I'd probably try a lot harder ;D
Although I did burn the crap out of my best mate's neck with my champ once :D
-
It rally gets my goat when people look down there noses at saks/multis
As a relative newcomer to knife forums in general, I also see a lot of SAK people that look "down their noses" at just about any fixed blade or folder... I think the bias goes both ways.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login