Annoying thread
-
@Sparkey said:
"The best tool is the one between you ears.."but personally, I'd go with the SAK... ;D
OR, I could apply the multitool.org rule....BOTH!

That's very true :)
-
@NeitherExtreme said:
Hmm... I'd actually have to say that's a tough one for me. If there was the choice of a fixed-blade knife I'd probably take that over either one. To me the biggest plus of the SAK would be if you could start fires with the magnying glass (I'm also interested to know if it can be done!). I could also see the awl and saw as being useful for survival. The Sebenza on the other hand is much closer to a fixed-blade knife, which IMO would seem like the most basic survival tool of all. I'm not sure which I would choose, but then again, I'll never have to... :DWell I'm sure most of us would take a fixed blade if the option was there :), but sadly the original thread was specifically sebbie or champ :-\
-
@Defender said:
That sounds familiar... honestly, I would take the Sebenza too because I could sell it to the natives in exchange for everlasting support, while the SwissTool would probably only buy me a few years worth of slaves!Def
Hmm If it was a slave for ''every'' need I could come round to the idea of a sebenza after all ;)
-
You could take out the magnifying glass and burn one of the natives and then you may be considered a god.
"Ray, the next time that someone asks you if youre a god you say YES!"
-Bill Murray, Ghostbusters -
I love that movie...
Given the choice between a SwissChamp and a Sebbie, I would take the Champ, and not just because I'm a SAK nut. The Champ (and other SAKs) are better suited to many of the more mundane tasks you'd find in a survival situation, like pulling splinters. In some parts of the world, the infection resulting from a simple splinter can kill you. Also, as Dunc pointed out, the saw could be used to open tougher foods like coconuts.
Of course if I had a Sebbie and was washed up on an island, I'll bet I get washed up with a bunch of imported beer without twist offs, and several crates of canned food!
Def
-
Swisschamp, definitely, for the previously cited reasons, except one. Although there have been reports of it being done, I have so far (30 years) been unsuccessful in starting a fire with a Vic magnifier. The best I could so far manage is burning tiny holes in darkened (to tone down reflectivity) paper, making brief wisps in charred cloth and having no effect at all on wood shavings. If my life depended on it, maybe I could work it out, but would prefer a fully charged Zippo lighter (I'm an older person). The magnifier is just too small. Recently, however, Vic has been fitting current production with a revised version that's a little larger; maybe enough to do the trick, but I doubt it.
Also, the fish scaler is NG for its intended purpose, although I use mine lots for a probe or olive fork (not before cleaning thoroughly ;D). The large knife blade works much better for scaling, but cleanup is a bitch.
Although you might think there are implements on a Swisschamp that would be useless, the only certainty in a survival situation is that you'll never know what might come in handy.
BTW, who's annoyed?
-
@znapschatz said:
Swisschamp, definitely, for the previously cited reasons, except one. Although there have been reports of it being done, I have so far (30 years) been unsuccessful in starting a fire with a Vic magnifier. The best I could so far manage is burning tiny holes in darkened (to tone down reflectivity) paper, making brief wisps in charred cloth and having no effect at all on wood shavings. If my life depended on it, maybe I could work it out, but would prefer a fully charged Zippo lighter (I'm an older person). The magnifier is just too small. Recently, however, Vic has been fitting current production with a revised version that's a little larger; maybe enough to do the trick, but I doubt it.Also, the fish scaler is NG for its intended purpose, although I use mine lots for a probe or olive fork (not before cleaning thoroughly ;D). The large knife blade works much better for scaling, but cleanup is a bitch.
Although you might think there are implements on a Swisschamp that would be useless, the only certainty in a survival situation is that you'll never know what might come in handy.
BTW, who's annoyed?
I was a little annoyed at the people who voted against the champ purely because it was a sak and not some high end tactical folder. ::)
It rally gets my goat when people look down there noses at saks/multis >:(
As for the magnifiying lens, well like you i've got things to smoulder but never hot enough to start a fire, but if it was your only means of making fire I'd probably try a lot harder ;D
Although I did burn the crap out of my best mate's neck with my champ once :D
-
It rally gets my goat when people look down there noses at saks/multis
As a relative newcomer to knife forums in general, I also see a lot of SAK people that look "down their noses" at just about any fixed blade or folder... I think the bias goes both ways.
-
We tend to look down on them because they have much higher price tags and less versatility. It's kind of like a group of off roaders in beat up Jeeps looking at a guy who wants to join with his brand new Lincoln Navigator, but then gets upset because he gets some scratches and mud.
The reason SOSAK was so successful in the beginning was because all the tactical knife people secretly carried a SAK to do their dirty work!
Def
-
It rally gets my goat when people look down there noses at saks/multis
As a relative newcomer to knife forums in general, I also see a lot of SAK people that look "down their noses" at just about any fixed blade or folder... I think the bias goes both ways.
Maybe the bias does work both way's but I like to think that's not the case with me (although I'm not the world's greatest tacticle knife fan :-[) I've got and continue to use lot's of fixed blades and love them to bit's, especially now that a lot of companies are offering really good real world knives in the line ups
If the choice was between say an Falkie F1 and a Champ then I'd have gone for the F1 :)
-
It rally gets my goat when people look down there noses at saks/multis
As a relative newcomer to knife forums in general, I also see a lot of SAK people that look "down their noses" at just about any fixed blade or folder... I think the bias goes both ways.
Maybe, but I don't find SAK enthusiasts to be as stuck up and snobbish as many of the "tactical" knife enthusiasts.
Many of those people will tell you - in all seriousness - that the minimum threshold for a decent knife is 100 bucks. Any knife less than 100 bucks is garbage, not even worthy of consideration.
Another thing about these people that really bugs me is their constant repetition of the phrase "You get what you pay for." They'll use that phrase over and over to justify spending $200, $300, $500, or even more on a three-inch "tactical" folder.
Another thing I get fed up with real quick is their enthusiasm for - and snobbishness about - "super steels." Many of these people are ignorant of even basic metallurgy, but will go on and on about the superiority of the steel in their latest stainless "tactical" folder.
Underlying all of this hype and fantasy about "super steel" and "tactical" features is the biggest fallacy of all: that a $500 "tactical" folding knife in your pocket means you are well-prepared for self defense.
(Modified to fix bad grammar in original post.)
.
-
Of course if you spent $40 on an OHT, you'd be much more prepared, and still have $360 for more gear for the B.O.B., P.S.K. or other acronyms!
Def
-
@ringzero said:
Maybe, but I don't find SAK enthusiasts to be as stuck up and snobbish as many of the "tactical" knife enthusiasts.Many of those people will tell you - in all seriousness - that the minimum threshold for a decent knife is 100 bucks. Anything knife less than 100 bucks is garbage, not even worthy of consideration.
Another thing about these people that really bugs me is their constant repetition of the phrase "You get what you pay for." They'll use that phrase over and over to justify spending $200, $300, $500, or even more on a three-inch "tactical" folder.
Another thing I get fed up with real quick is their enthusiasm for - and snobbishness about - "super steels." Many of these people are ignorant of even basic metallurgy, but will go on and on about the superiority of the steel in their latest stainless "tactical" folder.
Underlying all of this hype and fantasy about "super steel" and "tactical" features is the biggest fallacy of all: that a $500 "tactical" folding knife in your pocket means you are well-prepared for self defense.
.The original question appears to be more of a way to question those two opposing views than be a serious survival question.
I know that if something happened were I had to survive I <u>would</u> be using a Spyderco UK knife and my Cybertool because I am never without them. (The Cybertool through laziness, it is clipped to my small Gerber LED light.)
If the town was being attacked by those pesky Zombies or Martians or whatever and I had to travel to a safe area I would pick a Becker, RAT or something like that! Not going to happen, so I would make do with a cheap fixed blade about 3.5 - 4 inches long (both illegal in the UK unless you have cause to use them in your work or you can get away with using them for field craft (camping?). I certainly would not be looking for some expensive custom knife that I know I would be shy to use knowing it might break (you would not be able to send it back under guarantee) or get lost.Dave
-
I have $200 folders. I have $5 SAKs (tinker on special at Wal-Mart). I have to say that I have had no advantage with a $200 folder over a SAK or multitool. That is why I have converted to multitools and Saks. I collect folding knives I can buy many more SAKs than I can Striders. If I get pulled over and an officer likes my 4" strider, he can take it and I am out $300. If I am carrying a SAK he looks the other way. Multitools and SAKs are every bit as useful and finely crafted as a production folder and they cost a lot less so you are not afraid to use them.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login