Spyderco UKPK v Urban
-
Whichever I go for, it won't be that gopping orange colour!
Foliage seems nice, and would match my man-bag :D
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
Well regardless of there apparent legality, I know which one would go down better at work, so I'd stick with the UrbanI don't get that tbh. If it's legal, what does it matter?
@nuphoria said:
I love my UKPK and feel naked without it - I didn't want the smaller urban and although I can't compare the two, I'm very happy with my choice.Cheers Nuphoria

-
@DaveK said:
Whichever I go for, it won't be that gopping orange colour!Foliage seems nice, and would match my man-bag :D
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
Well regardless of there apparent legality, I know which one would go down better at work, so I'd stick with the Urban
I don't get that tbh. If it's legal, what does it matter?
@nuphoria said:
I love my UKPK and feel naked without it - I didn't want the smaller urban and although I can't compare the two, I'm very happy with my choice.Cheers Nuphoria

What about me

-
You too!
I did reply, but my post got lost in the melee.....
Much appreciated mate

-
@Flash (some know him as WAR) said:
You can still be arrested though
but lets not go down that route again.Yes, they are priced the same and I'd still go with the Urban. The orange one looks pretty sweet.
If he is arrested he can charge the police £1100 per hour for false arrest.......
So he can't be arrested under the offensive weapons act (a hard one to prove I know) and they can't escort him to a police station to test the knife then? How comes I have heard such stories then?
There must be some loaded BB members now. :D -
You feeling neglected officer? :D
Come and arrest me - I could do with the money ;)
-
I knew this would end up into a legality debate :D, always does.
-
I don't think there's any debate to be had, for all intents and purposes, the two knives are the same!
-
I think perception is almost as important as legality, especially where sharp's are concerned :)
If I'm cutting something at work with a sak at work, there's less likelihood of a parent putting in a complaint or calling the cop's than there would be if I was doing the self same thing with a UKPK :-\
Yes there both legal, but one's going to raise eyebrows a lot bloody higher than the other, and i really can't be doing with that sort of bother tbh
-
Just to throw it out there, but what about one of these...
/topic/14756
It's much more ninjarish than the other two
-
@DaveK said:
I don't think there's any debate to be had, for all intents and purposes, the two knives are the same!As in technically they are both legal yes. But one is cute and comes in a lovely orange flavour with a diddy blade, and one is much bigger and comes in ninja black. :D Like Mike says (and clearly many of you disagree with so maybe it's a location thing) perception of a knife is an equal as legality IMO.
-
@Flash (some know him as WAR) said:
You can still be arrested though
but lets not go down that route again.Yes, they are priced the same and I'd still go with the Urban. The orange one looks pretty sweet.
If he is arrested he can charge the police £1100 per hour for false arrest.......
So he can't be arrested under the offensive weapons act (a hard one to prove I know) and they can't escort him to a police station to test the knife then? How comes I have heard such stories then?
There must be some loaded BB members now. :DYou have heard "stories". In 11 years I have yet to hear of anyone under these circumstances to get arrested.
The blade is LEGAL, and as per the offensive weapons act the only thing they could possibly have on him is "Intended" to be used as a weapon.
Now if any cop worth their salt were to look at our venerable, aged, old, funny looking Dave they would probably help him to cross the road rather than arrest him for intended weapon carrying.
So....if he were to "intend" it to be used then theoretically Yes he could be....but realistically???? No he wouldn't be.
Most cops I know would ask where he got it from and how much ;)
-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
I think perception is almost as important as legality, especially where sharp's are concerned :)If I'm cutting something at work with a sak at work, there's less likelihood of a parent putting in a complaint or calling the cop's than there would be if I was doing the self same thing with a UKPK :-\
Yes there both legal, but one's going to raise eyebrows a lot bloody higher than the other, and i really can't be doing with that sort of bother tbh
Does 1/2" make THAT much difference

-
@Flash (some know him as WAR) said:
@Flash (some know him as WAR) said:
You can still be arrested though
but lets not go down that route again.Yes, they are priced the same and I'd still go with the Urban. The orange one looks pretty sweet.
If he is arrested he can charge the police £1100 per hour for false arrest.......
So he can't be arrested under the offensive weapons act (a hard one to prove I know) and they can't escort him to a police station to test the knife then? How comes I have heard such stories then?
There must be some loaded BB members now. :DYou have heard "stories". In 11 years I have yet to hear of anyone under these circumstances to get arrested.
The blade is LEGAL, and as per the offensive weapons act the only thing they could possibly have on him is "Intended" to be used as a weapon.
Now if any cop worth their salt were to look at our venerable, aged, old, funny looking Dave they would probably help him to cross the road rather than arrest him for intended weapon carrying.
So....if he were to "intend" it to be used then theoretically Yes he could be....but realistically???? No he wouldn't be.
Most cops I know would ask where he got it from and how much ;)
....and in fairness this part of the legislation could theoretically be applied to ANY inanimate object......for example a BANANA

-
The day I'm worried about getting arrested for things that aren't illegal - it's time to emigrate!
I don't think that's where we are though.
@Flash (some know him as WAR) said:
Now if any cop worth their salt were to look at our venerable, aged, old, funny looking Dave they would probably help him to cross the road rather than arrest him for intended weapon carrying.Cheeky git. ;)
-
@Flash (some know him as WAR) said:
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
I think perception is almost as important as legality, especially where sharp's are concerned :)
If I'm cutting something at work with a sak at work, there's less likelihood of a parent putting in a complaint or calling the cop's than there would be if I was doing the self same thing with a UKPK :-\
Yes there both legal, but one's going to raise eyebrows a lot bloody higher than the other, and i really can't be doing with that sort of bother tbh
Does 1/2" make THAT much difference

But with the shorter blade, different scale colour and even a different profile if you want, The Urban does look less intimidating :)
-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
@Flash (some know him as WAR) said:
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
I think perception is almost as important as legality, especially where sharp's are concerned :)
If I'm cutting something at work with a sak at work, there's less likelihood of a parent putting in a complaint or calling the cop's than there would be if I was doing the self same thing with a UKPK :-\
Yes there both legal, but one's going to raise eyebrows a lot bloody higher than the other, and i really can't be doing with that sort of bother tbh
Does 1/2" make THAT much difference

But with the shorter blade, different scale colour and even a different profile if you want, The Urban does look less intimidating :)
....in that case Dave get a SAK Pocket pal ;)
-
It's that word "theoretically" that I am on about.
All I am saying is that if you are going to blow over £100 (I know Dave actually isn't) on a knife that is specifically UK legal, why not get the one that is even more copper/sheeple friendly. I am sure most police officers are great guys and would show interest, but sadly not all of them are as at the end of the day they are normal people just doing a job and that's why public perception plays it's part IMO.
But, saying all that, Nick is right, Dave does look like an old git and I am sure if he kept it in his shopping trolley he'd have no grief at all. :D
-
@Benner said:
It's that word "theoretically" that I am on about.All I am saying is that if you are going to blow over £100 (I know Dave actually isn't) on a knife that is specifically UK legal, why not get the one that is even more copper/sheeple friendly. I am sure most police officers are great guys and would show interest, but sadly not all of them are as at the end of the day they are normal people just doing a job and that's why public perception plays it's part IMO.
But, saying all that, Nick is right, Dave does look like an old git and I am sure if he kept it in his shopping trolley he'd have no grief at all. :D

Perhaps the question that need to be asked is
"Which one is better for cleaning werthers originals from dentures?"
-
Mike, make the most of it mate. The age jokes will soon be comming back to you. :D
-
@Benner said:
All I am saying is that if you are going to blow over £100 (I know Dave actually isn't) on a knife that is specifically UK legal, why not get the one that is even more copper/sheeple friendly.Because it's a better blade? And, why should I, for the benefit of people you recognise are ill-informed?
@Benner said:
But, saying all that, Nick is right, Dave does look like an old git and I am sure if he kept it in his shopping trolley he'd have no grief at all. :DLook. There's so much I can take before I start shaking my walking stick at you :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login