Juice= junk?
-
Well, my Juice S2 haven't let me down yet.. :D :D
-
It just seems a shame to write off a whole line of tools, call them junk after 1 bad experience. I think they are good myself, they just don't fit my EDC.
-
To be fair, I said as close to junk as you can get :D again, I'm only refering to the xe-6, but it does share the same implements with lesser layer models.
The drivers are decent, albeit quite sharp and verging on slicing your fingers while opening. The pliers are decent, but rather thin, but no more so than the skeletool. Aside from that its an underwhelming multi.
-
You clearly have a very personal definition of "junk" then Blackbeard. Each to their own I suppose, but I doubt you'll find many people agreeing with you tbh.
@Blackbeard said:
Its as if the designers at leatherman said "Lets make a multi with implements that dont snap back into place correctly, make one side bigger than the other and throw in poor stock metal and ultra thin implements that dont lock and can be easily bent, and see if we can beat Victorinox"
-
These are observations made based on my xe-6 and compared with my other multis, not a subjective opinion. Simply put, it is not on a par with other leatherman, Victorinox, Sog and Gerber multis in the same price range.
-
I guess we'll have to agree to disagree there BB

I could understand that the pliers are too small, you didn't like the tools etc - and I think many would agree. It is a mid-sized tool, and not comparable to the Wave IMO. (I already agreed about the price being high).
I can't agree that it's junk though, the materials, performance and quality are top notch. I've heard rare stories about snapped backsprings etc, and the awl takes a bit of a kicking on here quite a lot, but that's pretty rare I think.
The most common "flaw" I've heard about (and have actually seen myself) is that the flat-head drivers can be a bitch to get out, but a bit of lube and some use has always taken care of that for me. I have a few, and none of them are junk.
EDIT: You mentioned non-locking blades. Don't forget that in some countries, that makes the Juice legal to carry, whereas a Wave isn't - so I would call that a huge plus

-
-
It's funny how we all make judgements on a tool line based on a single specimen, I know I do it. True quality control should mean that each widget is built the same way, but sadly it isn't always that way.
Overall, with regard to this thread I think the Leatherman Juice line are good tools, they certainly are for a different demographic than the full sized Multi crowd but they fill a niche in a valuable way for lots of people.
-
I do see the value in the non locking tools for european countries. And I guess the juices' other main selling point is the pliers which can handle more abuse than the SAK ones.
I think the main problem is quality control with leatherman. I've already returned a charge that was was poorly made, and I really dont use the juice. Maybe Leatherman got too big too fast?
Either way, I'm sticking with my wave as my edc, surge as a backup. I keep a core in my car and a blast in one of my travel backpacks. All fine tools imo, its just some of their products that get under my skin.
-
I think that maybe with the Juice line being made out of a whole bunch of little parts there's more of a chance of things in there being a little too tight. That's probably the issue I see most of the time. The drivers can be terrible to get out. That was the main issue with both of mine. I even took one back and exchanged it. The 2nd one I bought wasn't as bad but it was still way too tight. I bent the handles and it helped a lot.
As for the can opener, a little Dremel work got them to where they'd at least open cans w/o bending.
-
I definitely would NOT dismiss the entire Leatherman line base off one model.
I have an original supertool that has given faithful service since the 1990s. I had Core (and I thought it was a solid tool), but replaced it with a Swisstool RS that better suited my needs. The new Supertool 300 looks very promising.
-
I got a chance to check out a juice the other day. It was built pretty solid. The can opener and awl were blunt (but that can be fixed). All-in-all a neat little tool. "Little" being the optimum word. For me the tools were a too small for my taste, but it definitely serves a nitch. :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login