Getting a multitool: Leatherman or Gerber?
-
Well, considering all the technicians I know, the most common tool I see is the Leatherman Wave, however the Core seems to be the current "it" tool among road crews.
If its fast pliers you want - Gerber
Myself, my #1 is drivers, so I choose Leatherman.
-
I chose the Victorinox Spirit over my LM Wave because the level of quality is significantly higher than the Wave.
Well, that's your opinion of course, and you're obviously entitled to it.......
It ain't mine.
Yes, that is just my opinion. Nothing more. But it is based on the particular LM Wave and Vic Spirit that I have. Fit & finish is IMO is higher in my Spirit than my Wave. Open/close action of the MT to the pliers is smoother on my Spirit than my Wave. My Wave actually sticks open and gouges are forming on the outside of the pivot. Secondary tool opening/closing is smoother on my Spirit than my Wave plus my Spirit doesn't clump when I try to open one of the secondary tools. And judging by my other LM MT's and the ones of my friends and family, I fully expect it to rust much sooner than my Spirit. I've had my Swisstools RS for longer than my LM's and it has seen more ues and still no rust.
It is my opinion but it is also opinion based on my experiences with the MT's. I do not think the Wave is of poor quality but I do acknowledge when one MT is or appears of higher quality.
The sticking and gouging of my Wave pivot. That's not oil or dirt. It is metal shaved and worn off.
The lockup on my Wave saw is poor. It barely catches and almost closed on my finger when sawing a branch and the tip caught on the push stroke.
Lockup on the file goes all the way to the outside. When this wears over time, it will develop play. Same thing happens on cheap folding knives.
Machining is rough causing a gritty feel when opening the tools.
Rough machining is evident on the blade and the edge looks like a hacksaw. Chips out of the opening hole edges.
Other peoples examples may not match mine and I am aware of that. I have seen other Wave examples which have excellent lockup and are looser around the pivot. All I am saying is that based on my experience, the Wave is not at the same quality level as my Spirit.
Hope that clarifies things.
-
Thats why I consider the WAVE crude. Its still an effective tool though.
-
Me too!

Also, I can never seem to find the Wave at as nearly a decent price as the Spirit so... hands down, Spirit. :D
-
Why is the WAVE so expensive it uses a ton of imported parts shouldn't the cost be lower than it is?
-
The locks on my Wave nearly put me off liner locks for good (and I commented on such on here before) - they were that bad. Luckily I took this as a one off, and liner locks on knives are probably my most favourite now.
-
@american lockpicker said:
Why is the WAVE so expensive it uses a ton of imported parts shouldn't the cost be lower than it is?Here's the reason:
At that price point, LM makes the profits it wants, runs production at levels that are optimal, with a level of quality that they deem necessary.
Lower the price and the profits drop, production goes up (presumably)--possibly incurring more operating costs. Lower the quality to improve profits and the tool has more failures or loses eye/hand appeal.
These things are pretty closely titrated.
-
@TangoDown said:
Rough machining is evident on the blade and the edge looks like a hacksaw. Chips out of the opening hole edges.
Actually the rough edges are intentional. On the thumb hole they are a result of the stamping process, and are left there to add to ease of opening with less thumb pressure. On the edge the rough grind is to create micro serrations, for two reasons. 1. Long term edge sustainability, and 2. Increases the ability to cut through fibrous material.
-
Hmmm, sorry but I don't believe the whole leaving rough edges on the opening hole to "add to ease of opening with less thumb pressure" bit. You don't get roughness on tac folders with opening holes even at low prices. That is done totally to reduce costs IMO.
-
@Benner said:
Hmmm, sorry but I don't believe the whole leaving rough edges on the opening hole to "add to ease of opening with less thumb pressure" bit. You don't get roughness on tac folders with opening holes even at low prices. That is done totally to reduce costs IMO.It's like "two birds with one stone". In the processing of the blade production the manufacturer could grind the edges of the hole, and then use a process to modify the surface to increase friction. This would add to production costs though, so yes a goal in the design is to save money. But then this is a goal in each step of the process with any manufacturer producing in mass quantities. With the end goals being: Meeting the customer's need; staying in business; and not the least of importance, paying employees.
-
I wasn't saying it was a problem, just wasn't agreeing with the there to make it easier to open thing. That is there for one reason only, to reduce cost and that is fine as the customer gets a cheaper product.
-
@Benner said:
I wasn't saying it was a problem, just wasn't agreeing with the there to make it easier to open thing. That is there for one reason only, to reduce cost and that is fine as the customer gets a cheaper product.My point was that it not only cuts cost, but makes the tool easier to use. Kind of like achieving a goal "on the cheap".
And besides, I have always felt that it makes the Wave rugged and manly. :D
-
"The Leatherman Wave...the Rugged and Manly Charge" :D
-
@turnsouth said:
Actually the rough edges are intentional. On the thumb hole they are a result of the stamping process, and are left there to add to ease of opening with less thumb pressure. On the edge the rough grind is to create micro serrations, for two reasons. 1. Long term edge sustainability, and 2. Increases the ability to cut through fibrous material.Sorry, but I don't buy that reasoning. The rough edges are there because LM didnt' want to pony up the cost to "finish" it. It's expensive enough as it is so I'm actually glad they didn't. I buy plenty of folding knives to know good opening hole machining when I see it. Also, I'd rather have my knife edge cut rather than saw or tear through whatever I am cutting.
While we're at the knife edge, what the hell is that edge angle sharpened to? It's 420HC! put 20deg on each side. That edge will roll at the first tough material it encounters. I'll be re-profiling mine.
It may seem I hate my Wave. Couldn't be further from the truth. I actually really like it. Just wish it was better. ;)
-
I didn't mean to start a debate! :D
I'm still thinking LM Wave, though I'll let you all know once the final decision's been made! :)
In the mean time, don't let me interupt! Carry on! :)
P.S. Every Wave I've seen seems to be decent quality and some have seem some serious use!
-
The day that "Fit and Finish", or "Slippy and Shiny" becomes more important than utility to me, I may agree.
However, I find the "precision" snap on the Spirit pointless and in fact, a hinderance, the high-gloss finish detrimental to the use of the drivers etc....
I enjoy the Spirit as a toy and a pretty thing, but when I need a tool, I'll go for something that deploys easily, performs better and is generally more versatile. What it looks like and the audible click are simply irrelevant when I'm driving a screw, or need a blade whilst holding onto a ladder.
I don't suppose we'll get any closer to solving this debate tonight than any other of the million or so times it crops up, but I'll repeat my oft repeated point of view that you can't consider "quality" without considering how "fit for purpose" and efficient a tool design is.
A hypothetical question:
If you took two high grade pieces of steel, fastened them together with incredible skill and precision, polished the whole thing up to a mirrored finish and then encrusted it in diamonds, then tried to pass it off as, I dunno, a washing machine - would you consider it to be a high quality item?
:P -
Dunno about a washing machine... It would make for quite a blink prybar though. :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

