Need help picking a multi-tool
-
Yea, I gotta say, I didn't think of the One Handed Trekker (OHT). If pliers aren't needed, it is an awesome tool. One handed opening, large saw, ergo handle and seriously beefy pry tool. I think mine is moving over to the camping stuff this year.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Yea, I gotta say, I didn't think of the One Handed Trekker (OHT). If pliers aren't needed, it is an awesome tool. One handed opening, large saw, ergo handle and seriously beefy pry tool. I think mine is moving over to the camping stuff this year.Why not the best of both worlds? Spirit in the rucksack, and a OHT on the belt or in a easy-to-reach pocket would be quite a combination. Completely redundant, yes, but good for if you walk away from your camp for a moment and end up having to rely upon just what you actually have on you. :)
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Yea, I gotta say, I didn't think of the One Handed Trekker (OHT). If pliers aren't needed, it is an awesome tool. One handed opening, large saw, ergo handle and seriously beefy pry tool. I think mine is moving over to the camping stuff this year.
Why not the best of both worlds? Spirit in the rucksack, and a OHT on the belt or in a easy-to-reach pocket would be quite a combination. Completely redundant, yes, but good for if you walk away from your camp for a moment and end up having to rely upon just what you actually have on you. :)
Well, for a backpacker, it's all about weight and every ounce counts. I'd rather just have one or the other and toss in a GPS or Camera for the same net weight... :-\
-
I'm going with everyone else and calling out the OHT. Perfect woods knife. :D

Well, unless you're going to be doing camp chores... bring a fixed blade then. =(
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
@Mr. Whippy said:
Yea, I gotta say, I didn't think of the One Handed Trekker (OHT). If pliers aren't needed, it is an awesome tool. One handed opening, large saw, ergo handle and seriously beefy pry tool. I think mine is moving over to the camping stuff this year.
Why not the best of both worlds? Spirit in the rucksack, and a OHT on the belt or in a easy-to-reach pocket would be quite a combination. Completely redundant, yes, but good for if you walk away from your camp for a moment and end up having to rely upon just what you actually have on you. :)
Well, for a backpacker, it's all about weight and every ounce counts. I'd rather just have one or the other and toss in a GPS or Camera for the same net weight... :-\
Whoops, I did miss the backpacking part. Hmm, yeah, either the SwissTool Spirit S or the OHT; I agree entirely, Mr. W. :)
-
WOWSERS! That is a lot to digest :o
Thanks for the replies! Honestly, and I hope I don't make any enemies :D, I've got some sort of natural disinclination towards SAKs. I know there is no "Master Multi-Tool!" (though it'd make for a good movie title), but I don't have the money to buy a MT for every occasion (hiking/tinkering/heavy repairs/odd jobs/etc). So I really want something with pliers. The Spirit sure looks swell! Thanks for the suggestions!
-
Why the disinclination towards SAK's , they have great utility , fit and finish , and about the highest price to performance ratio out there . A Wave or a Charge would serve you well as would a Spirit . A multi in the bag , and a SAK on the belt or in the pocket is a great approach .
Chris
-
I'm going to suggest you get a Leatherman Wave or Charge, with these tools not only are the blades outside opening but they are one hand opening. This makes this tool a standout for those who want to deploy their main blades with limited fuss, or in situation where you may have something else in one hand such as a flashlight or a walking stick.
The SOG Powerlock has the advantage of having pliers that can be deployed with only one hand, but you are more likely to need a blade than a pair of pliers in a field situation in my opinion. The single hand plier deployment could be more useful in a shop/work situation.
The SOG powerAssist also has one hand opening blades, but I have one and I just can't get used to the blade deployment mechanism. I also feel that the trade off in loss of other implements that was made to accommodate the power assist mechanism isn't worth it, especially in a field situation where weight and space are at a premium.
The Charge is slightly lighter than the Wave and it also has a better tactile feel. The charge has a great saw, a good file (good for trimming fingernails), a can/bottle opener (camping necessities), and it also has philips and flathead drivers which you may need for equipment repairs.
Overall I think it's a great all around solution to the average mans camping needs. Of course you should also carry a machete or fixed blade knife as well depending on the terrain and your needs. -
@Treker22 said:
WOWSERS! That is a lot to digest :oThanks for the replies! Honestly, and I hope I don't make any enemies :D, I've got some sort of natural disinclination towards SAKs. I know there is no "Master Multi-Tool!" (though it'd make for a good movie title), but I don't have the money to buy a MT for every occasion (hiking/tinkering/heavy repairs/odd jobs/etc). So I really want something with pliers. The Spirit sure looks swell! Thanks for the suggestions!
Ohhhhhhhh SNAP............that is close to blasphemy in here.
I think most of us are SAK & Leatherman junkies. I have to agree with Sazabi about weight though, every ounce counts. That said, a MT or SAK needs to be an addition to a good fixed blade. The LM Surge and Vic SwissTool are a large heavy MT's, you may want to focus on the Spirit, Wave or Charge. -
I have to admit, I don't think the spring-powered, split-second opening abilities of the SOG PA are worth losing 2-3 components. I do like that the PA pliers can be opened butterfly-knife style. I'll most likely go with the LM charge (black oxide finish of course). My beef with SAKs is simply aesthetics; nothing to do with performance or quality. As for a good fixed-blade, I've already got my heart set on a SOG Seal Pup Elite (black TiNi finish).
Thanks again for the replies and advice!
-
@Treker22 said:
I have to admit, I don't think the spring-powered, split-second opening abilities of the SOG PA are worth losing 2-3 components. I do like that the PA pliers can be opened butterfly-knife style. I'll most likely go with the LM charge (black oxide finish of course). My beef with SAKs is simply aesthetics; nothing to do with performance or quality. As for a good fixed-blade, I've already got my heart set on a SOG Seal Pup Elite (black TiNi finish).Thanks again for the replies and advice!
I'm not really worried about weight so I have a KaBar Becker BK2 for a fixed blade. It's not sexy, it's not expensive, it's not flashy, it just works like the tank it is. The SOG Seal Pup is more of a fighting type knife. I don't know if it is something I would want for backpacking/camping. You want a thick blade that is hollow ground so it has a wedge shape. It works better for splitting and batoning wood. I've been looking at Entrek knives lately. I told my wife to get me one for Christmas, the Badger. It's not a large knife but looked interesting. I will most likely stick with my Becker BK2 for camping.
-
@Treker22 said:
WOWSERS! That is a lot to digest :oThanks for the replies! Honestly, and I hope I don't make any enemies :D, I've got some sort of natural disinclination towards SAKs. I know there is no "Master Multi-Tool!" (though it'd make for a good movie title), but I don't have the money to buy a MT for every occasion (hiking/tinkering/heavy repairs/odd jobs/etc). So I really want something with pliers. The Spirit sure looks swell! Thanks for the suggestions!
If you only were to use it for backpacking I'd say skeletool, but for all round use I'd go Swiss. maybe complete the kit with the pluss version of the selected Swiss tool with bit's and wrench / ratchet.
If OHO blade is important, wave style leatherman. -
I have to admit, I don't think the spring-powered, split-second opening abilities of the SOG PA are worth losing 2-3 components. I do like that the PA pliers can be opened butterfly-knife style. I'll most likely go with the LM charge (black oxide finish of course). My beef with SAKs is simply aesthetics; nothing to do with performance or quality. As for a good fixed-blade, I've already got my heart set on a SOG Seal Pup Elite (black TiNi finish).
Thanks again for the replies and advice!
I'm not really worried about weight so I have a KaBar Becker BK2 for a fixed blade. It's not sexy, it's not expensive, it's not flashy, it just works like the tank it is. The SOG Seal Pup is more of a fighting type knife. I don't know if it is something I would want for backpacking/camping. You want a thick blade that is hollow ground so it has a wedge shape. It works better for splitting and batoning wood. I've been looking at Entrek knives lately. I told my wife to get me one for Christmas, the Badger. It's not a large knife but looked interesting. I will most likely stick with my Becker BK2 for camping.
I'd go for an Carbon steel Mora knife. Cheap, good quality, usable knife.
-
I'd take a look at a Swisstool Spirit or regular Swisstool
-
I've been looking over the LM Charge and I am a little befuddled. What is the difference between the Charge AL and Charge ALX? Is the only difference that the scissors have been replaced by a v-cutterish blade for the ALX? If so, why is the ALX advertised as having 18 tools while the AL only 17? Lastly, I thought the Charge TTi was a sort of gimmicky (titanium handle scales) half brother of the Charge AL, but it's listed as having 19 tools. WTF mate?
-
@Treker22 said:
I've been looking over the LM Charge and I am a little befuddled. What is the difference between the Charge AL and Charge ALX? Is the only difference that the scissors have been replaced by a v-cutterish blade for the ALX? If so, why is the ALX advertised as having 18 tools while the AL only 17? Lastly, I thought the Charge TTi was a sort of gimmicky (titanium handle scales) half brother of the Charge AL, but it's listed as having 19 tools. WTF mate?Have you tried comparing them here? Click. :)
-
Sweet! I didn't notice that on LM's web site.
So it seems that compared to the AL, the ALX gains a wire crimper, a hook on the serrated blade, a large bit driver, and a lot of bits, but loses a large screwdriver and scissors.
The TTi gains a wire crimper, a hook on the serrated blade, changes the steel of the smooth blade, and is lighter due to the titanium.
Does this seem accurate?
-
@Treker22 said:
Sweet! I didn't notice that on LM's web site.So it seems that compared to the AL, the ALX gains a wire crimper, a hook on the serrated blade, a large bit driver, and a lot of bits, but loses a large screwdriver and scissors.
The TTi gains a wire crimper, a hook on the serrated blade, changes the steel of the smooth blade, and is lighter due to the titanium.
Does this seem accurate?
Sounds just about right.. ;)

-
I think for backpacking/camping you have two good options: One Hand Trekker and LM Charge TTi. As you really want pliers and don't like SAK, go with Charge TTi. IMO this LM is better for camping than Vic Spirit just because Charge has more blades, two of then one hand opening. BUT, as an EDC multi tool, I would prefer Vic Spirit with no doubt!
-
Sweet! I didn't notice that on LM's web site.
So it seems that compared to the AL, the ALX gains a wire crimper, a hook on the serrated blade, a large bit driver, and a lot of bits, but loses a large screwdriver and scissors.
The TTi gains a wire crimper, a hook on the serrated blade, changes the steel of the smooth blade, and is lighter due to the titanium.
Does this seem accurate?
Sounds just about right.. ;)

... except the Titanium isn't really any lighter than the AL.
Also, technically, the ALX and the TTi have a cap crimper in the pliers, not wire crimpers.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login