Springs
-
I picked up a Winchester multitool tonight for $5, just on a whim. However, I noticed it's got a spring that lets you squeeze and release the pliers. I've got a couple of other cheapies like that, a Sheffield tool and a small, Squirt-sized "Tool Choice" tool. Plus, I know there's at least one Gerber like that, and the Squirt has a spring.
Do springs make for weaker tools?
I ask because I'd love to get a Leatherman, like the Blast, with a spring, but I don't think Leatherman makes any full-sized tools besides the Crunch with them. Has Leatherman ever worked on a tool like that?
-
I believe it's just too much of a hassle for them to back a product with a part prone to breakage.
Springs do break. Often.
I'm assuming they just don't wanna deal with it. ::)
Other than that there's a bit of extra reasoning where spring-loaded pliers wouldn't be an advantage on the job.
-
I'd imagine it's the case that by adding more pieces you therefore have more to go wrong. Having said that, the Gerber MP800 has a spring I believe and I haven't read any reports of that breaking that I can remember.
-
@Freudian Frog said:
I believe it's just too much of a hassle for them to back a product with a part prone to breakage.Springs do break. Often.
@Benner said:
I'd imagine it's the case that by adding more pieces you therefore have more to go wrong.That's kind of what I was thinking too. It's a shame, but for the sake of a better tool, neither surprising nor problematic.
-
Springs have a tendency of popping out too so maybe you can drop some epoxy on the ends to ensure that doesn't happen.
-
CRKT do MTs with springs as well. I've not personally heard of any issues with them.
-
Springs come in many different styles. Those in the Leatherman Squirt P4, for instance, are not likely to become either lost or broken. :)

-
Good point

-
The 'A'nuf i picked up had a spring, i removed it as not needed as my wave hasnt got one and works fine, it just popped out,
paul

-
I don't think springs make for a weaker tool but they are generally characteristic of lower quality tools. It'd be nice to see some full-size tools with an internal pivot spring like the Gerber 800 but it's not really something I feel is missing from most tools.
Here's what the spring looks like inside the Zilla-Tool:


I'm still working on doing a Crossgrip type spring mod for one of my tools, maybe over my holiday break.

-
Cheers for those pics Spoonrobot - I always wondered how those things were sprung.
@turbov21 said:
Plus, I know there's at least one Gerber like that, .....I have some decent quality tools with springs:
I have 5 Gerbers with sprung pliers, the Clutch, the Suspension, the Recoil, the Radius and the Legend 800. None of them have the external visible spring that I find a bit off putting.
The SOG Switchplier is sprung somehow, as are the Paul Chen Multitasker and the Bear Gardener (although they are shears rather than pliers).
The only big Leathermans I can think of with springs are the pruners (of which I only have the Hybrid).
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login