Vic quality slipping?
-
I think it would be hard to make a case for a loss of quality control on just one knife.
-
send it to Vic and get another one.... I would.
-
@NutSAK said:
I think it would be hard to make a case for a loss of quality control on just one knife.You're right about that. Every company will have slip ups in QC - it's inevitable. I've encountered QC issues with most brands: Gerber, Leatherman, Case, Buck, and others.
Guess I was especially shocked to see QC issues in a Victorinox product simply because I've never encountered a serious QC issue with a brand new Vic product.
.
-
I've seen a few issues, but never anything that seems to indicate a "string" of problems.
One that sticks out in my mind is an OHT that Scibeer modded for me. It's a good thing he pulled it apart to mod--when he removed the scales he discovered that one of the main pins had not been peined and was completely missing a bushing! :o
-
Ooops - forgot to update this until now.
My defective Vic Classic was exchanged the next time I made the trip into Lowes. New one is fine, no issues whatsoever.
This incident hasn't really changed my high opinion of Victorinox.
I was just shocked to get a Vic with QC issues similar to those that might be encountered in cheap Chinese or Pakistani knives.
That defective Classic was the first brand new Vic with issues that I've encountered in over 25 years of buying them.
.
-
Any chance it was a couterfeit? (I've heard they are out there) :(
-
I have a Vic that is of questionable quality also its still in the package theres all kinds of scrap red plastic on the scales.
-
It's sad, but I think there has been more QC issues at Vic lately. We've seen some awefully good prices, but there have been more reports of issues. I think they still have remarkable quality, but before they were simply the best (they set the standard). It appears that economic conditions (hopefully not philosophy or desire) has put a small kink in their manufacturing and QC. I think the knives are just no longer the revenue generator they once were and now they have to spend their time and money on so many other segments of their business.
-
@ICanFixThat said:
It's sad, but I think there has been more QC issues at Vic lately. We've seen some awefully good prices, but there have been more reports of issues. I think they still have remarkable quality, but before they were simply the best (they set the standard). It appears that economic conditions (hopefully not philosophy or desire) has put a small kink in their manufacturing and QC. I think the knives are just no longer the revenue generator they once were and now they have to spend their time and money on so many other segments of their business.Anyone noticed Wengers are getting nicer(except the swiss cross...)
-
Maybe you got a lemon there Mark

I just got a cheap Rally and fit and finish is perfect no clumping or rubbing of blades + a distinct snap when opening blades

If I were you I'd email Victorinox and explain that way they can me made aware if indeed quality is slipping

-
Come to think of it the rally I had was perfect quality but my Spirit had a slight defect on the pliers and the plating on the locks is peeling.
-
Sounds like you lot need Leatherman's. :D
-
@american lockpicker said:
@Mr. Whippy said:
@american lockpicker said:
Sounds like you lot need Leatherman's. :D
Or better yet Wengers. :)
Just as long as you don't need to use the corkscrew... :D
Why? The ones on the Evo S10s work fine.
Just mailed off my S557 because the corkscrew is torqued out of shape from opening several bottles of wine at Thanksgiving. It won't go in a pocket because the corkscrew sticks out. The Vic and LM corkscrews faired much better.
-
I would be very dissapointed if Vic's quality was slipping . I don't see any evidence of this based on recent purchases . I hope they hang in there , we need a few bastions of quality in a world full of schlock .
Chris
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

