Vic quality slipping?
-
Come to think of it the rally I had was perfect quality but my Spirit had a slight defect on the pliers and the plating on the locks is peeling.
-
Sounds like you lot need Leatherman's. :D
-
@american lockpicker said:
@Mr. Whippy said:
@american lockpicker said:
Sounds like you lot need Leatherman's. :D
Or better yet Wengers. :)
Just as long as you don't need to use the corkscrew... :D
Why? The ones on the Evo S10s work fine.
Just mailed off my S557 because the corkscrew is torqued out of shape from opening several bottles of wine at Thanksgiving. It won't go in a pocket because the corkscrew sticks out. The Vic and LM corkscrews faired much better.
-
I would be very dissapointed if Vic's quality was slipping . I don't see any evidence of this based on recent purchases . I hope they hang in there , we need a few bastions of quality in a world full of schlock .
Chris
-
Isn't this ironic that it happens after Vic decides to become a luxury brand.
-
We've all had issues with Victorinox products once in a while, whether it's the infamous misaligned awl to my Spirit's handles being misaligned - every company has at least a couple items make it through QC. My guess is that maybe they ramp up production even more in preparation for Christmas, Hanukkah, Eid ul-Fitr (yeah, I know it was in September this year, but work with me), Festivus, etc, and therefore are more prone to QC issues during late year months? :/
-
After reading Syph's brilliant review of the Outdoorsman, it got me thinking about the quality of Vic SAK's. I have seen many companys cut tool quality in order to stay in a market, or simply to make more of a profit. I wonder this about the 91mm large blade being made with a smaller tang. The dimpled outer liner makes no sense to accommodate the small tang, it even (seen at the right angle) dimples the scale slightly, this unbalances the whole knife IMHO. Also going to a less complicated magnifier, although arguments could be made for that being an improvement. This seems like a quality downgrade to me, as there is really no serious market competition for the 91mm. As for the country of origin issues, Vic appears to have branded and marketed some very high quality items besides SAK's. I hope this is not a trend and that we haven't seen the apex of the Vic SAK. In the past, it seems to me that all the 91mm evolutions until recently have been to make the product better, not cheaper. I dearly enjoy my Climber Lite, but can't help thinking about this when I deploy the large blade.
-
@twiliter said:
After reading Syph's brilliant review of the Outdoorsman, it got me thinking about the quality of Vic SAK's. I have seen many companys cut tool quality in order to stay in a market, or simply to make more of a profit. I wonder this about the 91mm large blade being made with a smaller tang. The dimpled outer liner makes no sense to accommodate the small tang, it even (seen at the right angle) dimples the scale slightly, this unbalances the whole knife IMHO. Also going to a less complicated magnifier, although arguments could be made for that being an improvement. This seems like a quality downgrade to me, as there is really no serious market competition for the 91mm. As for the country of origin issues, Vic appears to have branded and marketed some very high quality items besides SAK's. I hope this is not a trend and that we haven't seen the apex of the Vic SAK. In the past, it seems to me that all the 91mm evolutions until recently have been to make the product better, not cheaper. I dearly enjoy my Climber Lite, but can't help thinking about this when I deploy the large blade.I hope Victorinox maintain their exemplary (for me, at least) high standards. I have four Classics. The one stamped Switzerland is far better than the other three (blade and nailfile not scrubying eachother every bloody time I open them, better snap and overall heftiness I think). I've encountered many flaws when choosing Vic goodies and I don't know if this is a QC thing or a choice. I've had a Ranger with main blade rubbing on the liner when closed, awls scrubying the main blade on Pioneers, squeaky handles on 2008 Soldier after some use, even a rattly Spirit, now this new lockback -I haven't tried that but I'm convinced it isn't up to Vic quality. I hope that's just a passing phase :-\
-
In the last 6 years, I have picked up somewhere in the neighborhood of fifty SAKs. About 7 or 8 of those are Wenger; all of the rest are Victorinox. Of those 42, I have experienced no blems, defects, QC issues, or even inconsistencies. Not only have the fit, finish, and functionality on each been peerless, Vic has consistently put out this kind of quality for years.
-
I forgot to mention an unfinished can opener on a DD Forester, I'll try and get some pics tonight. This was shocking, that thing isn't sharpened at all. I still have it, as a collectors item :D or until I get enough faulty Vics to send them back and hope for something extra compensating for all the mess. How low is that?
Honestly, I'm starting to believe they are sending lots of good but not flawless products over here. I have a total on nine 91mm Vics with scissors out of which four sing (asked in this thread </post/677514>). I realise that's not really a flaw but such inconsistency is noteworthy and alarming for me.
I admit I like grumbling more as I get older day after day but that's not the case here
I honestly fear that Victorinox has somewhat lowered their quality standards; I have a bad feeling in my bones I tell you 
-
Since I started SAK modding I routinely buy 20-30 SAKS or so a month. Not one quality issue ever on any of these. The only issue I had was with the new lockback knife.
-
My experience tells otherwise:
-
Lateral blade play: check (58 mm, 91 mm, 93 mm included).
-
Dulled blade tip from slapping the backpring/spacer, from factory, with mark on the hit metal part: check (91 mm and 93 mm).
-
Wood saw closing on (and damaging) liner: check (84 mm, 111 mm).
-
Orange peeler/scraper MiniChamp blade closing on liner: check (new Cellidor MiniChamps).
-
Space between scales and exterior liners, scales not flush: check (84 mm, 91 mm, 111 mm).
-
Longitudinal blade play when locked: check (111 mm, both liner and side locking).
-
Large blade scrapping on awl/awl scrapping on blade on 93 mm: check.
-
Nailfile scrapping on blade on Cadet: check.
-
Electrician blade scrapping on main blade: check.
-
Wrong tools mounted: yes! Example: MiniChamp with two emergency blades (at least good not with two cuticle pushers).
-
Bent blades from factory: check (58 mm, 91 mm, 93 mm).
-
Dull blades from factory: check.
-
Scratched Cellidor handles and scratched anodizing on colored alox: plenty of...
etc
Fortunately there are still plenty nicely done to forget the duds. Unfortunately defects like these tend to be more and more frequent as production costs are lowered.
I am still a fan though and enjoy collecting despite the flaws sometimes found.

-
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

