Petzl
-
@ringzero said:
Given Petzl's areas of expertise, I'd imagine this knife is highly specialized - designed for durability and reliability in adverse conditions.-No locking mechanism to jam up when coated with a thick layer of cave mud and gritty sand.
-Probably some sort of rust proof steel to survive long term in a constantly wet cave environment.
-Primary function would be to cut nylon rope and webbing.
-One hand accessible blade.
Doesn't look to be a great general purpose knife, but as a caving knife it might be very good.
.
Yea, I don't know about the whole caving thing. Tight spaces to wriggle through, can't always get a hand free, restrict ability to breathe--makes me a little claustrophobic. :ahhh
Ok, maybe a LOT claustophobic. :ahhh :ahhh
Canyoneering? That looks fun, but caving? Don't think I'd enjoy that. :-\
-
Is that knife made in France.
-
I know probably 5 guys that climb with these knives clipped to harnesses, and I agree with what Mr. Whippy says. The pivot is really, really hit or miss, 2 hits and 3 misses in my group. It has lots of play in theirs, and does not seem like something sturdy at all. As for cave mud, I highly doubt it, since we climbed on a windy day a while back on a crag with a sand scree slope under it, and the dust that blew around almost completely jammed a pivot, on one of the good ones. Well oiled and looked after as well. The steel they use, not sure what it is, is pretty rustproof, as no one had any rust on theirs, but I don't know about how well it will handle constant wetness in a cave... No one I know caves. The OHO, really tricky, and from my attempts, hard to actually accomplish. And while I'm not trying to bash Petzl at all (I'm a bit of a BD guy) I don't know how well I would want to trust that if my life was in the balance :-\
And on the topic of caving... I don't know if I will ever do it :ahhh
A friend of a friend got nearly killed a couple months back on a trip I was invited on but couldn't attend. The lead on the way out places a cam behind a big flake, and as the cam released tension and pushed against it, it busted off... all 500+ pound of it, landing square on one of the people below. Lucky he was over 6'5", since it only caught him in the chest, and didn't get higher. :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
-
Youch! That sounds scary as heck. :o
-
@Shane769 said:
And on the topic of caving... I don't know if I will ever do it :ahhh
A friend of a friend got nearly killed a couple months back on a trip I was invited on but couldn't attend. The lead on the way out** places a cam behind a big flake, and as the cam released tension and pushed against it, it busted off... all 500+ pound of it, landing square on one of the people below.** Lucky he was over 6'5", since it only caught him in the chest, and didn't get higher. :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
Worst nightmare alert! :ahhh
Actually, worse than that is the one where the flake comes off, lead falls and is seriously injured and then I have to riggle through some gawdawful tight slot on lead :ahhh

Caves?

-
@Mr. Whippy said:
And on the topic of caving... I don't know if I will ever do it :ahhh
A friend of a friend got nearly killed a couple months back on a trip I was invited on but couldn't attend. The lead on the way out** places a cam behind a big flake, and as the cam released tension and pushed against it, it busted off... all 500+ pound of it, landing square on one of the people below.** Lucky he was over 6'5", since it only caught him in the chest, and didn't get higher. :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
Worst nightmare alert! :ahhh
Actually, worse than that is the one where the flake comes off, lead falls and is seriously injured and then I have to riggle through some gawdawful tight slot on lead :ahhh

Caves?

Amen to that. Multipitchs can be hard enough... but being in a hole doing one.... :ahhh

Not my bag at all -
Thanks for the real world reports, guys.
Sorry to hear about the pivot problems. I figured the reason for the unusual pivot design was to make it resisitant to jamming up due to mud and grit. Maybe that was the intention, but looks like it didn't work out so well.
Petzl gear is usually well thought out and executed, in my experience.
Sounds like they should have done a little more R and D before bringing out the Spatha.
About caving.
While there are technically challenging vertical caves with very unpleasant conditions, there are plenty of caves that require no climbing or ropework at all.
There are claustrophobic caves with tight squeezes, but also caves with no crawling at all. Caves that require wetsuits and caves that are completely dry.
Caves for everyone, from the total newb, to the hard core vertical caver and cave diver.
.
-
I know there are a lot of different kind of caves, and I have been in the really big open ones, mostly a couple around North and South Dakota on a trip once. But I think me and Whippy are more
towards the vertical technical climbing, crawling caves. But yeah, the only reason that Petzl made the pivot how it is, that I can tell, is so that you can throw in on a racking 'biner and keep it one you at all times.So you cave eh? Got any good pics?
:D -
@Shane769 said:
I know there are a lot of different kind of caves, and I have been in the really big open ones, mostly a couple around North and South Dakota on a trip once. But I think me and Whippy are more
towards the vertical technical climbing, crawling caves. But yeah, the only reason that Petzl made the pivot how it is, that I can tell, is so that you can throw in on a racking 'biner and keep it one you at all times.So you cave eh? Got any good pics?
:DGot lots of cave pics, but none in digital format - they're mostly slides.
As far as vertical caving, rock climbing, and mountaineering, I miss them all. The spirit is still willing, but alas, the flesh has grown weak. Enjoy it while you can.
I still enjoy caves, but nowdays the caves are of the less challenging, walk through variety. ;>
.
-
@ Ben: Yes Sir, they are French made.
The 12C27 INOX used is GREAT. it is made by Sandvik and used on some famous MORA models, Laguiole knives and even some older Bark River knives. That´s a hell of a steel!
But, to be honest, I do not like the Spatha. Yes, it is lightweight, offers great steel and is cheap. But it feels cheap too, I do not like the opening mechanism and I do not think it is very ergonomic. After all, it is designed to be a climbing knife, not much more than an emergency tool. Guess it is good for that, but not for EDC duty, imho.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login