Combo-edges?
-
I couldn't agree more. :)
I have quite a number of knives that are combo's. I really find them
very useful. Serrations work ever so well on cardboard, it's quite amazing actually.
Plain edge's do as well but start to bind and tear where as my serrations will keep going
for considerably longer. When they start going dull I just start sawing. :D
I don't mind sharpening them with the Sharpmaker and it works well.
Anyhow, they'd be not so good if you were whittling wood but working in the kitchen or for
most tasks I find either the combo edge or full serrations to be quite useful for my applications. -
Here's my 2 problems with them.
-
They aren't really 2 knives in one. They really are a lesser version of a serrated blade. That is, they won't cut clean sharp edges like a PE effectively.
-
Sharpening often means 2 different angles for different sections of the blade. PLUS, the PE is usually a standard 2 sided edge while the SE part is often just one side.
To me, they're more hassle than either one alone, with no real PE usefulness.
-
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Here's my 2 problems with them.-
They aren't really 2 knives in one. They really are a lesser version of a serrated blade. That is, they won't cut clean sharp edges like a PE effectively.
-
Sharpening often means 2 different angles for different sections of the blade. PLUS, the PE is usually a standard 2 sided edge while the SE part is often just one side.
To me, they're more hassle than either one alone, with no real PE usefulness.
I agree. I'd rather have a FS or PE, depending on what I'm doing. I never have like the CE. Sharpening them really sucks. And, maybe it's just me, but almost every time I've tried to use on when I've needed a clean cut, I end up missing the PE section of the blade and catching the SE. Not a huge deal, but still a pain. Plus, and this is just a personal preference, I just like the uniformity of the blade, all SE or all PE. Looks better to me.
-
-
I'm all for PE knives,but for cutting bread I'll take a serrated knife every time.
& 
-
I'm in the depends camp. As a separate blade I'm not much in to them but on a multi I think they are a great idea just for the more tools in a smaller space concept. This is more an occasional use thing for me rather than a primary blade though.
-
I find serrations no more difficult to sharpen than a PE. If you have a Sharpmaker it's quite simple.
-
I hate them really. I own quite a few combo edge knives but only because I got them so cheap or because they were in designs/patterns I really like but have no other blade option. I do not intentionally look for combo edge knives. I am not a big fan of serrations either. Haven't had a cutting task yet that a real sharp plain edge couldn't do it, or one that a serrated blade would of been better.
Combo edge knives do neither job really well as you don't have enough "plain edge" or enough "serrations" for any serious work. How or why anyone would think these are "The best of both worlds" is beyond me.
"Give me Plain Edge, or give me Death!".......it's what Patrick Henry said! Words to live by. :D
2xTap
-
Not a fan of serrations here myself. I can see the applications in some specific circumstances, but as a day-to-day knife? Not for me.
If you have a knife/tool with two blade then I have no problem with one of them being serrated, but if you only have one blade then I'd have a PE all the way.
-
Ooh a Poll...
Hate 'em >:(
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
I find serrations no more difficult to sharpen than a PE. If you have a Sharpmaker it's quite simple.
But takes more time and a little more care.
Also, often sharpened at a different angle than a PE (even on the same blade :ahhh)
Actually I'd say they were quicker as you only have the one side.
-

Guys, check out this Boker combo edge.
This looks to be a great design for a combo edge - mid serrations instead of back serrations.
The 'sweet spot' near the base of the blade is PE for precision cutting.
The tip is PE for delicate cutting tasks.
But you still have all that Serrated Goodness if/when it is needed.
Very little downside to adding the serrations to this knife.
This is another Chad Los Banos design for Boker - love this guy's innovative designs.
.
-
that is a really cool, functional looking blade. never seen one before. thanks for posting it.
-
If your going to have serrations, that's the right place to put them

-
I hate them, I like serrated blade (Spyderedge) or - in most cases - plain blades. The only use for comboedges is on MT hat have only one blade. For I guess there is a chance that I might cut rope, cardboard or fibrous material when working so for someone who just carries a MT and no extra knive the CE might be fine. I like the blade on the Spirit, for it has very fine serrations and is good for most tasks, and I accept the blade on my Spyderench even if I´d prefer it to be full serrated or plain. But on a folder, I will not carry a CE.
-
@Sean said:
that is a really cool, functional looking blade. never seen one before. thanks for posting it.Yeah, it looks quite functional as a general utility blade to me too.
But, it is marketed by Boker and designed by CLB primarily as a fighting knife.
The large flipper and the sub-hilt are for maintaining a secure grip during a stab and subsequent withdrawal of the blade from an opponent.
.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

