SHOT 2010- Gerber Booth
-
@SlackOne said:
I'd love to see how the Strata compares to a Skeletool size-wise. I do not like the Skeletool in the slightest, but it is kind of the defacto minimalist knifeplier right now. I do love how the Strata's bottle opener doesn't waste a tool slot!
I think you mean the Octane? The Strata is a larger tool, while the Octane is the minimalist one.
Compared to the Skeletool, I'd say the Octane is slightly smaller and wider. The sliding head design means that it's a broader, flatter but shorter tool than the Skeletool's butterfly style. The Octane is a great homage to the older Multiplier series and I think follows the MP600/400 design flawlessly, while still managing to update the design- similar to all the new Retro type cars everyone is producing these days, and yet done really, really well.
Def
-
Sorry yeah, the Octane. How does the plier head compare to the Skeletool, or the MP400 Compact Sport for that matter? And do those grip cut outs help with the traditional Gerber palm pinch when using the pliers?
My main gripe with the Skeletool/Freestyle is that both the knife and plier head were too puny (IMHO) for a tool dedicated to having a knife and plier head :P I'm kind of hoping the Octane manages to get a better balance.
-
Well, it really is a matter of "To Each His Own" but I do really think that the Octane balances things better. When I get one to play with I'll be able to take more detailed photos and give a head to head review, but tragically they get a little upset when I ask if I can take their brand new tool to another booth! :D
The plier head is similar in size to the MP400- it really does seem like an updated, minimalist version of the MP400, but I didn't get any pics side by side. If we get another chance to visit Gerber I'll see if I can get pics of them together.
Still, the Octane is quite affordable, so I think there's lots of room to try one out if you see it and not have a huge investment to worry about.
Def
-
Could it be?!?.... YES! Drivers that reach further than a quarter inch!

VERY interested now

-
Actually of these three tools it's the Octane that most interests me. It's a good looking tool that.

-
how does the grappler open?
sorry if its been asked
-
Well I am glad Gerber is makin more solid looking tools again :D All the tools above look great can't wait to see 1 in the flesh and blood so to speak

-
The Grappler and the Octane looks really good to me and I especially want to try the Octane for minimalistic EDC duty. Bravo Gerber, well done indeed!

-
I think the "clam shell packaging opener" will come in real handy for some folks.
I have a Vic, Mate that has the orange peeler. A similar tool that I find works well on clam shell packaging and other things where penetrating too deep can be a problem.
I wonder how the Gerber too peels an orange?
-
@ratslash7 said:
I think the "clam shell packaging opener" will come in real handy for some folks.Unfortunately I think it's a complete waste of a perfectly good tool slot. How many clam pack does one open per day, plus knife blade works just fine.
-
I think the "clam shell packaging opener" will come in real handy for some folks.
Unfortunately I think it's a complete waste of a perfectly good tool slot. How many clam pack does one open per day, plus knife blade works just fine.
while in general I agree, I find that a specialized tool can prevent accidents that can happen with an open blade and clam packs... they are crafty creatures and have a way of attacking you when you least expect it. I'm assuming it also doubles to open boxes... something a shipper/receiver would find mighty useful!
-
I think the "clam shell packaging opener" will come in real handy for some folks.
Unfortunately I think it's a complete waste of a perfectly good tool slot. How many clam pack does one open per day, plus knife blade works just fine.
while in general I agree, I find that a specialized tool can prevent accidents that can happen with an open blade and clam packs... they are crafty creatures and have a way of attacking you when you least expect it. I'm assuming it also doubles to open boxes... something a shipper/receiver would find mighty useful!
...ala the Raker Ring Tool.
Cuts cord, baling twine, packing tape, plastic packaging (bags) like potato chips etc.
Yes, you can use a knife, but this is cleaner and neater with the cut. Plus, who wants to cut into a hay bale with a good knife? It's like cutting into a bunch of raw paper (cellulose).
-
@Whoey said:
while in general I agree, I find that a specialized tool can prevent accidents that can happen with an open blade and clam packs... they are crafty creatures and have a way of attacking you when you least expect it. I'm assuming it also doubles to open boxes... something a shipper/receiver would find mighty useful!It's all in the way of how to open clam pack with a knife. You don't cut them open like cutting cardboard box, the correct way is perfectly safe.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
I think the "clam shell packaging opener" will come in real handy for some folks.
Unfortunately I think it's a complete waste of a perfectly good tool slot. How many clam pack does one open per day, plus knife blade works just fine.
while in general I agree, I find that a specialized tool can prevent accidents that can happen with an open blade and clam packs... they are crafty creatures and have a way of attacking you when you least expect it. I'm assuming it also doubles to open boxes... something a shipper/receiver would find mighty useful!
...ala the Raker Ring Tool.
Cuts cord, baling twine, packing tape, plastic packaging (bags) like potato chips etc.
Yes, you can use a knife, but this is cleaner and neater with the cut. Plus, who wants to cut into a hay bale with a good knife? It's like cutting into a bunch of raw paper (cellulose).
Let me add, after unloading a half dozen pallets of mortar and porcelain tiles, an open blade would have made removing the stretch plastic wrap around the bags of mortar a real hassle. Thank god for the Raker Ring tool. Less of an issue with the tiles, although I guess I could have scratched them if I went at them hamfisted with a knife.
-
@SlackOne said:
Sorry yeah, the Octane. How does the plier head compare to the Skeletool, or the MP400 Compact Sport for that matter? And do those grip cut outs help with the traditional Gerber palm pinch when using the pliers?My main gripe with the Skeletool/Freestyle is that both the knife and plier head were too puny (IMHO) for a tool dedicated to having a knife and plier head :P I'm kind of hoping the Octane manages to get a better balance.
I went to the booth and tried out the Grappler. I agree on the wimpiness of the look of the jaw, but i think it does look way cooler. I forgot to check how far it opens. Normally being a LM guy, it took me a minute to figure out how to stow the jaw. So if the jaws can handle big crap like the Crunch, my only concern then would be the tiny parts up inside of cavity between the jaw and the frame. There are several very tiny pieces/springs that look like if you loose even one of them, it will poop out on you. The other concern was getting it adjusted. Even though the Crunch takes a second longer to get ready, the Crunch is way easier to adjust. that tiny knurled nut in between the handles is just too small.
I do however like the looks of the whole tool much better than the older stuff. The style has some obvious LM hints to it. Notice the way the frames are folded down at the tip of the pocket where the blades fold in. That a direct copy of the fold on the LM handle where the skeletool knife blade folds in.
-
Sorry yeah, the Octane. How does the plier head compare to the Skeletool, or the MP400 Compact Sport for that matter? And do those grip cut outs help with the traditional Gerber palm pinch when using the pliers?
My main gripe with the Skeletool/Freestyle is that both the knife and plier head were too puny (IMHO) for a tool dedicated to having a knife and plier head :P I'm kind of hoping the Octane manages to get a better balance.
I went to the booth and tried out the Grappler. I agree on the wimpiness of the look of the jaw, but i think it does look way cooler. I forgot to check how far it opens. Normally being a LM guy, it took me a minute to figure out how to stow the jaw. So if the jaws can handle big crap like the Crunch, my only concern then would be the tiny parts up inside of cavity between the jaw and the frame. There are several very tiny pieces/springs that look like if you loose even one of them, it will poop out on you. The other concern was getting it adjusted. Even though the Crunch takes a second longer to get ready, the Crunch is way easier to adjust. that tiny knurled nut in between the handles is just too small.
I do however like the looks of the whole tool much better than the older stuff. The style has some obvious LM hints to it. Notice the way the frames are folded down at the tip of the pocket where the blades fold in. That a direct copy of the fold on the LM handle where the skeletool knife blade folds in.
Some good observations there TK.
I mostly agree.But as regards the folded metal out near the tip thing, according to my notes, the Gerber Freehand came out a year before the Leatherman Skeletool.....

Grappler pic, courtesy of Grant
Freehand pic, courtesy of DuncSo just who was copying who?
:D -
Plus Leatherman copied the replaceable cutter inserts from Gerber! :D
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Plus Leatherman copied the replaceable cutter inserts from Gerber! :DDef
Aye Aye Bob
You guys really need to make a smiley that actually says "neener neener". It would save a lot of typing.Once again I must bow to the Bob and Grant alter and beg forgiveness for my ignorance of multi-tools. :'( :ahhh Maybe I should study a little more before I open my big mouth.
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Plus Leatherman copied the replaceable cutter inserts from Gerber! :D
Def
Aye Aye Bob
You guys really need to make a smiley that actually says "neener neener". It would save a lot of typing.Once again I must bow to the Bob and Grant alter and beg forgiveness for my ignorance of multi-tools. :'( :ahhh Maybe I should study a little more before I open my big mouth.
Well I do hope that doesn't discourage you from opening your big mouth TK. :D I enjoy saying neener neener. :D :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login